Key takeaways
- The municipality imposes a maximum permissible discharge rate without directly fixing the required retention volume.
- The effective volume compensates for the difference between the incoming stormwater flow and the continuous discharge through the calibrated orifice.
- The overflow weir directs exceptional flows to a secure outlet, preventing any scouring of the roadway.
- Regular inspection of the trash basket and sludge removal guarantee the long-term operation of the device.
Determine the retention volume from the municipal discharge rate
In external works projects, the municipal authority never prescribes a pre-established earthworks volume for a retention structure. It sets a ceiling discharge value, referred to as the permissible discharge rate, often expressed in litres per second for the entire plot or linked to the impermeable surface area. The objective is to protect the public stormwater sewer or the receiving watercourse against flood peaks following storms. The landscape contractor intervenes to shape the topography of the basin, whether it is an open landscape swale or a sealed depression integrated into the green spaces.
- Permissible discharge rate
- Maximum volume of water authorised by the municipal technical authority to leave the private plot per unit of time, regulated before its discharge into the public network or the natural environment.
The sizing calculation stems from the design storm hydrograph adopted by the guidelines of the Swiss Association of Water Protection Professionals. The effective volume corresponds to the maximum cumulative difference between the volume of water collected from roads, car parks and roofs, and the volume simultaneously released by the flow limiter during the critical rain event. If the municipality authorises a very low discharge rate, temporary storage must increase in direct proportion. On site, this volume translates into precise excavation, rigorous management of slope gradients and a maximum water level set to the millimetre on the execution plans.
| Input data | Origin of the value | Impact on the landscape structure |
|---|---|---|
| Imposed discharge rate | Municipal wastewater drainage regulations | Determines the flow cross-section of the orifice plate and directly conditions the storage volume. |
| Runoff coefficient | Nature of road surfacings and paving | Increases the gross volume of water directed towards the retention installation during intense rainfall. |
| Storm return period | Canton or municipal regulations | Defines the maximum filling height before the overflow line engages. |
Secure the overflow water path and organise component maintenance
Any retention structure inherently carries a risk of saturation, either by exceeding the rainfall occurrence taken into account in the calculation, or by partial clogging of the regulating orifice. Integrating an overflow device constitutes an absolute technical obligation to protect the immediate surroundings. This overflow must not be improvised: it requires an evacuation threshold set altimetrically above the maximum retention level and a secure outlet that channels the water to a non-damaging infiltration zone or to the municipal network without eroding the foundations of private roads.
- Altimetric setting of the overflow crestSet out the spilling threshold with a site builder's level or laser level at the exact elevation defined by the plans, maintaining a minimum freeboard of fifteen centimetres below the crest of the surrounding slopes.
- Mechanical protection of the discharge channelLine the water descent downstream of the spillway using a heavy anti-puncture geotextile covered with calibrated riprap to prevent regressive soil erosion during an overflow.
- Installation of the flow control chamberPosition the prefabricated chamber at the foot of the structure, seal the stainless steel orifice limiter or vortex regulator according to the manufacturer's instructions and check the tightness of the connections.
- Installation of the debris screenFix a removable fine-mesh screen upstream of the calibrated orifice to retain leaves, twigs and floating matter before they clog the discharge nozzle.
The sustainability of the installation relies on methodical maintenance operations entrusted to road or green space teams. Twice a year and after each significant storm event, it is imperative to lift and clean the trash basket, remove accumulated plant debris and scrape fine sediments settled at the bottom of the swale. In the inspection chamber, the restriction orifice must be inspected to verify the absence of clogging by organic matter or grit washed in from neighbouring parking areas.
Open or buried structures: construction execution and regulator setting
On site, the realisation of the calculated retention volume depends closely on the morphology of the plot and the layout of the networks. While the municipal technical service sets a maximum permissible discharge rate to protect the downstream public collector, the landscape contractor must materialise the corresponding storage capacity without disrupting the general topography. Two options prevail in external works: the open landscaped basin in a grassy depression or underground storage using ultra-light cellular crates. In the case of an open-air depression, slope gradients must not exceed a ratio of one to three to ensure the mechanical stability of the earth and allow easy mowing without specialised machinery.
To scrupulously respect the authorised discharge rate, the pre-fabricated concrete or polyethylene control chamber constitutes the neuralgic organ of the installation. Its altimetric setting with a theodolite or laser level requires absolute precision. The drainage orifice must coincide rigorously with the bottom invert of the effective retention volume, under penalty of creating permanent stagnant dead water or, conversely, of amputating the theoretical effective volume validated during the building permit application. The hydraulic head acting on the orifice varies proportionally with the height of water accumulated during the storm, which dictates the technological choice of the limiter.
| Technical device | Hydraulic principle | Sensitivity to clogging | Landscape installation constraint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calibrated stainless steel orifice plate | Restriction by calibrated orifice creating a singular head loss | High in case of plant debris; leaf screen essential | Direct access via inspection chamber with a minimum diameter of 800 mm |
| Hydrodynamic vortex regulator | Creation of a centrifugal force braking the water without narrow section reduction | Low; larger free passage than a conventional diaphragm | Requires sufficient drop between the incoming and outgoing water line |
| Mechanical float valve | Progressive closure by float maintaining a rigorously constant flow | Medium; moving parts sensitive to silt and fine deposits | Requires a dry compartment or one protected from coarse sediments |
Immediately upstream of the restriction device, the implementation of a settling pit with a removable stainless steel trash basket is essential. This compartment retains dead leaves, bark debris and mineral particles torn from mineralised or vegetated surfaces before they clog the nozzle. Without this accessible primary filter, the slightest autumn storm risks blocking the regulated evacuation, causing premature surcharging of the structure even though the rain event remains below the design return period.
Overflow path, execution tolerances and maintenance protocol
When precipitation intensity exceeds the reference rain event used for the retention calculation, the basin reaches saturation. Human safety and the integrity of neighbouring buildings then rely entirely on the design of the overflow. The latter must never be connected to the throttled discharge pipe: it is a totally independent emergency evacuation, sized to discharge the raw peak flow of the shed surface without retention. On open basins, the most sustainable solution lies in a masonry spillway or a concrete-grouted riprap weir with a berm, positioned above the calculated maximum water line.
- Visual inspection of thresholds and retention geometryCheck with an optical level that the excavation bottom or inverts comply with the elevations of the execution plan. The altimetric tolerance on the edge of the overflow weir must not exceed plus or minus 10 millimetres to ensure the planned nappe without premature stressing.
- Flow test and tightness of the discharge chamberFill the control chamber with clean water before backfilling to check the tightness of the pipe connections. Ensure that the flow limiter drains the chamber without parasitic leaks under the fixing flange or the gasket.
- Installation of anti-erosion protectionLay a heavy non-woven geotextile under the overflow dissipation riprap to prevent scouring of the natural ground during high-power overflows. Immediately vegetate the slopes by hydroseeding or turf laying to stabilise the soil.
- Preparation of the maintenance manual for the clientDraft an operating manual recording the dates of sediment removal, the frequency of inspection of the debris screen (at least twice a year and after each major storm) and access routes for the suction excavator.
The maintenance of a retention basin is the guarantor of its long-term efficiency. In underground structures in the form of cellular crates, the regular passage of a video inspection and jetting nozzle through the integrated distribution channels is required to extract settled sands. For landscape depressions, the removal of fine sediments accumulated at the low point is carried out every three to five years by superficial scraping of the clogged layer, followed by reseeding. This operation restores the entire effective height and guarantees the continuous compliance of the installation against inspections by cantonal environmental services.
Hydraulic non-conformities and refusal of acceptance: correction protocols
On external works construction sites, disputes during the acceptance of a retention structure almost always stem from an altimetric discrepancy on the overflow threshold or a measured discharge rate not in conformity with the value fixed by the municipal water regulations. When the local authority refuses to issue the drainage certificate or site management blocks the final account, the landscape contractor must refuse any uncontrolled surcharging and record the state of the structure contradictorily in accordance with SIA 118.
The first frequent malfunction comes from premature sedimentation resulting from neighbouring earthworks phases. Runoff mud clogs the trash basket and reduces the effective section of the nozzle or regulating valve. Before engaging any contradictory hydraulic verification, the foreman requires careful pumping, hydro-jetting of the settling chamber and brushing of the nozzle. If the measured débit still does not match the values imposed by the building permit, no artisanal retouching is permitted: the adjustment of the discharge size imperatively requires a revised sizing note drawn up by the civil engineer responsible for the drainage concept.
The second critical defect lies in the levelling error of the overflow threshold. An altimetric drift of a few centimetres above the theoretical line neutralises the safety reserve and backs up floods towards riparian plots or the public roadway. Conversely, a crest that is too low prematurely empties the basin without exploiting the calculated effective volume. The team leader checks the elevations at the site level, rectifies the overflow crown by sawing or masonry build-up, and repositions the protective riprap to prevent regressive erosion of the slope during discharge.
To prevent complaints after the end of the works, the as-built documentation file must contain the survey of actual elevations, the regulator calibration sheet and the maintenance protocol. The handover of these documents during formal acceptance attests to the perfect delivery of the system. It definitively transfers the obligation of semi-annual cleaning and clearance of strainers to the property owner, thus releasing the contractor from failures linked to subsequent lack of maintenance.
Frequently asked questions
What to do if the municipality refuses acceptance due to a measured discharge rate that is too high?
The contractor checks as a priority for the absence of abnormal turbulence and ensures that the regulator is not blocked in the open position by construction rubble. After complete cleaning, a volumetric counter-measurement is carried out with a stopwatch using a calibrated tank under the supervision of the representative. If the flow still exceeds the municipal setpoint, the builder asks the engineer to reduce the orifice opening or install an approved restriction without modifying the basin geometry.
How to correct an elevation error on the overflow threshold of a swale or basin?
If the spillway crest has been executed too low, the effective retention volume is truncated and no longer complies with the initial hydraulic calculation. The landscaper raises the crest by means of a sealed metal profile or concrete edge casting with reinforcement continuity. If the overflow is too high, water threatens to flood unintended surfaces; mechanical planing or clean sawing makes it possible to precisely restore the projected overflow level.
Why is it forbidden to connect the overflow directly to the wastewater collector?
In Switzerland, municipal and cantonal regulations strictly apply the principle of network separation. Connecting a rainwater overflow to the wastewater system causes immediate overloading of wastewater treatment plants during heavy storms and generates upstream faecal backflows. The overflow must imperatively discharge either into the public stormwater collector, or into a receiving watercourse, or infiltrate onto a secured surface infiltration zone.
Who is responsible for the first cleaning of the retention basin before the handover of the structure?
Complete cleaning before acceptance remains the exclusive responsibility of the executing company. During external works, the sedimentation of topsoil and cutting dust inevitably clogs the excavation bottoms and trash screens. The team leader arranges for emptying, sludge scraping and wall rinsing before signing the acceptance report, delivering a clean and immediately functional structure to the owner.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works
