Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 411Earthworks, foundation and compactionChapter 3 of 10 in the section

Proving compaction: plate loading test, target value and test report

In the event of paving or vehicular access subsidence, only a documented geotechnical check protects the company. This chapter details how to carry out the plate load-bearing test on unbound aggregate in accordance with standard SIA 318 and VSS standards. You will learn how to interpret deformation moduli, plan measurement points and lock down the acceptance test report.

Key takeaways

  • Vibration sound or the absence of a visual imprint do not constitute technical proof in the event of differential settlement.
  • The static plate loading test determines the ME2 modulus and the ratio of ME2 to ME1 in accordance with VSS standards.
  • Standard SIA 318 requires verified load-bearing capacity before authorizing the installation of the bedding layer and pavers.
  • A joint test report precisely locating each test point releases the company's liability vis-à-vis the client.

Measuring the actual load-bearing capacity of an aggregate without relying on visual impression

On an external works construction site, judging the compaction of an unbound 0/32 or 0/45 aggregate solely by the passage of the vibrating roller is a frequent mistake. Apparent refusal under the roller or the metallic sound of a heavy vibrating plate never guarantee deep compaction. Material that is too dry may present a perfectly rigid surface crust while masking a compressible lower layer. Conversely, aggregate that is too wet may bounce under the machine without ever achieving the required tightening. As soon as ruts or uneven joints appear after the passage of the first vehicles, the absence of objective measurement places the contractor in a position of technical weakness.

Foundation layers for external surface surfacings must exhibit the load-bearing capacity and frost resistance required by the intended use of the structure, attested by compliance tests prior to the installation of the upper layers.

norme SIA 318
Deformation modulus (ME)
Value expressed in meganewtons per square metre (MN/m²) characterising the rigidity of a granular layer. The plate loading test measures deformation under a first load cycle (ME1), then under a second cycle (ME2) after decompression. The ME2/ME1 ratio reflects the quality of the compaction achieved.

The reference method is based on the static plate test standardised according to VSS standards. A rigid disc 300 mm in diameter is pressurized against the aggregate using a hydraulic jack supported by a counterweight, generally an excavator or a truck loaded with at least 8 to 10 tonnes. An independent measuring arm equipped with a dial gauge accurate to a hundredth of a millimetre records the settlement at each pressure step. The ME2 value indicates the effective stabilized load-bearing capacity, while an ME2/ME1 ratio that is too high reveals material that was not sufficiently tightened during installation and continues to undergo plastic deformation.

Indicative load-bearing capacity values according to the use of external works
Surface designationTarget minimum ME2 modulusRequired maximum ME2 / ME1 ratio
Pedestrian terrace and garden path50 MN/m²2.5
Parking space and access for light vehicles80 MN/m²2.3
Private vehicular road and garbage truck passage100 to 120 MN/m²2.2

Set out test points and record results in a foolproof test report

To constitute irrefutable proof, load-bearing tests must follow a coordinated set-out strategy. There is no point in concentrating checks in the centre of an esplanade where the heavy compactor has manoeuvred without restriction. Sensitive areas are systematically located around the periphery: along concrete kerbs, near manhole heads, in feathered connections against stripped natural terrain, or along the alignments of recently backfilled secondary surface water drainage pipes. A representative grid generally provides for one check point every 200 to 300 m² for large surfaces, with a minimum of three points on any vehicular structure, even of modest size.

  1. Preparation of the test bedClear loose chippings from the surface of the foundation without de-compacting the base. Level a flat area to the diameter of the plate with a thin layer of fine bedding sand to eliminate voids under the steel disc.
  2. Installation of the measuring rigPosition the heavy machine serving as the reaction mass. Install the gauge support tripod outside the zone of influence of the tyres or tracks to avoid any mechanical interference during loading.
  3. Recording of load cyclesApply the increasing and then decreasing pressure steps prescribed by VSS standards. Record the stabilized deflections at each step to plot the two deformation curves required to calculate ME1 and ME2.
  4. Drawing up the joint test reportRecord on site the geo-referenced or dimensioned coordinates of each test point, the date, weather conditions and apparent moisture content of the material before joint signature with the site management.

The plate loading test report is the cornerstone of the handover documentation for earthworks and foundation work. Handed over to the site management before spreading the bedding layer for pavers or laying the bituminous asphalt, this document certifies that the provided subgrade meets the deformation tolerances of standard SIA 318. If subsidence occurs subsequently due to massive infiltration or traffic from convoys not provided for in the contract, the company provides material proof that the foundation layer was delivered with the required compaction and load-bearing capacity.

Interpretation of VSS moduli and acceptance criteria according to standard SIA 318

The interpretation of the static plate loading test is based on two fundamental values: the deformation modulus in the first loading cycle and the modulus obtained in the second cycle after complete unloading. Expressed in meganewtons per square metre, these indicators reflect the mechanical behaviour of the aggregate. The second modulus quantifies the rigidity acquired by the stonework under the action of the roller or vibrating plate, while the ratio between the second and first modulus indicates the capacity for residual rearrangement of the aggregates. A ratio that is too high signals a mineral skeleton that is still sinking in a plastic manner, revealing unfinished compaction despite flattering apparent rigidity.

Indicative target values for unbound aggregates in external works according to VSS standards and usual requirements of standard SIA 318
External surface designationControlled granular layerMinimum second-cycle modulusMaximum permissible ratio
Terraces, pedestrian pathways, private courtyardsUnbound foundation aggregate 0/32 or 0/4580 MN/m²2.5
Villa access, light vehicle parkingFrost-resistant foundation aggregate 0/45100 MN/m²2.2
Private heavy-duty roads, fire service access, delivery areasCrushed foundation aggregate 0/45120 MN/m²2.2
Support platform or earthworks sub-baseStripped in-situ soil or compacted backfill30 to 50 MN/m²2.5

Handling of non-conformities and probative force of the test report

When the measured values remain below the requirements set by the quote or VSS standards, persisting with the vibrating roller is often counterproductive. If the ratio exceeds the authorized threshold or if the second modulus stagnates, the problem generally lies in the excessive thickness of the spread layers, poor grading curves of the supplied aggregate, or the flexibility of the underlying subgrade. A foundation layer cannot compensate for compressible natural ground onto which no separation geotextile or improvement layer has been inserted.

  1. Analyze the obtained deformation valuesIdentify whether the refusal of acceptance stems from overall load-bearing capacity that is too low or an excessive deformation ratio indicating incomplete tightening of the grains.
  2. Check moisture and subgradeProbe the layer via a localized trench to check the water state of the aggregate and ensure that the sub-base soil does not punch under vibration forces.
  3. Implement the adapted corrective measureAerate and mix the aggregate if it is too wet, scarify and re-moisten if it is too dry, or excavate and replace the localized area then compact in reduced thickness passes.
  4. Carry out the joint check testHave the plate test repeated by the geotechnical laboratory at the same planimetric coordinates to formally validate the compliance of the remedy.

The load-bearing test report constitutes the landscaper-builder's absolute legal bulwark in the event of subsequent subsidence of paving or ruts under the passage of vehicles. Drawn up jointly with site management and filed in the handover documents in accordance with standard SIA 118, this document certifies that the delivered platform met the stresses foreseen by the contract. If defects occur two years later as a result of rainwater infiltration not controlled by the client or unauthorized heavy traffic on the private road, the test report demonstrates the perfect compliance of the work at the time of delivery and releases the external works company from liability.

Management of subsidence disputes and counter-expert assessment on aggregate

When differential settlement appears under paving or a vehicular access road, the client's reflex is often to blame the execution of the foundation. If the contractor has limited themselves to an empirical assessment, such as the reaction under the vibrating roller or the metallic tone of the compaction plate, their position becomes indefensible during expert appraisal. Only the presentation of a complete control file makes it possible to establish the initial compliance of the earthworks.

In the presence of defects observed after installation, the first step is to compare the subsided areas with the layout plan of the initial control points. If the subsidence coincides with a point validated during the handover of the subgrade or foundation layer, the dispute points towards external causes: failure of untreated underlying layers, modification of the groundwater regime, localized infiltration due to poor surface drainage, or abnormal traffic overload not foreseen by the external works project.

  1. Joint opening of a test windowCarefully remove the surfacing and its bedding layer without disturbing the base, then uncover the compacted aggregate in the incriminated area in the presence of the site management to visually observe the moisture state.
  2. Carrying out a joint load-bearing testCommission an independent geotechnical laboratory to carry out a new plate test in accordance with VSS standards, taking the chassis of an excavator or a heavy truck as a reaction.
  3. Comparative analysis of moduliCompare the deformation modulus and compaction ratio measured with the values recorded in the handover test report drawn up according to the criteria of standard SIA 318.
  4. Excavation and methodical repairIn the event of a proven drop in load-bearing capacity due to excess water or contamination, excavate the polluted aggregate, lay an anti-contamination geotextile and rebuild the layer using methodically compacted passes.

Frequently asked questions

Can the plate loading test be carried out directly on the sandy aggregate?

The test is carried out directly on the graded and compacted foundation layer. However, the contact surface under the steel plate must be rigorously flat and free of voids. The operator applies a millimeter-thick bedding layer made of dry fine sand to compensate for the asperities of the 0/32 or 0/45 aggregate, thus guaranteeing homogeneous pressure transmission without skewing the dial gauge readings.

What should be done if the weather has waterlogged the aggregate before handover?

A mineral aggregate saturated with water instantly loses its load-bearing capacity under the effect of pore pressures. Carrying out a plate test on water-logged material systematically leads to refusal. Operations should be suspended, the surface lightly scarified to facilitate evaporation, or, in the event of prolonged deep saturation, degraded materials removed to spread healthy aggregate.

Who must provide the reaction mass on the landscaping site?

The static load-bearing test requires a significant vertical support force to mobilize the plate. On external works construction sites, it is the landscaping company that provides the laboratory technician with a sufficiently heavy machine, generally a tracked backhoe loader of at least eight tonnes or a loaded dump truck, whose chassis serves as a fixed support point for the jack.

How should measurement points be recorded on winding access roads?

On pedestrian paths, garden walkways or curved access roads, classical chainage referencing is unsuitable. The company must report each test point on the dimensioned execution plan, taking perennial elements such as concrete kerbs, masonry angles or inspection chambers as fixed reference points, with a precise indication of the relevant cross-section.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 318Directives relating to external works, load-bearing requirements and foundation layer acceptance criteria
  • normes VSSSwiss technical road standards governing the plate test method and the calculation of deformation moduli

In the same section