Key takeaways
- One cubic metre of soil weighing two tonnes suffocates a buried person in a few seconds.
- Vertical depth without shoring or battering is strictly limited to one point five metres.
- Battering is inclined according to the ground, from forty-five to sixty degrees for stable soils.
- An exit ladder must project by one metre and remain accessible every twenty metres.
Understanding earth pressure and applying the vertical excavation limit
On an external works construction site, when laying a buried irrigation network, a surface stormwater collector or the foundations of a low boundary wall, the trench often seems minor due to its narrow width. This linear configuration creates a deadly trap: when a wall gives way, the mass of soil does not simply slide towards the bottom, it topples as a single block. Half a cubic metre of wet soil represents a mass of one tonne which strikes the worker, pins them against the opposite wall and immediately compresses their ribcage. Mechanical asphyxiation occurs in a few minutes without giving the victim time to free their limbs or colleagues time to intervene with a shovel.
This maximum level of 1.50 m constitutes a regulatory ceiling valid only in ground offering sufficient natural cohesion and free from external constraints. As soon as a trench exceeds 1.50 m in depth, the team leader must compulsorily choose between two securing methods: excavating the walls in slopes according to the gradient authorized by ground cohesion, or implementing a certified shoring system. In loose, unstable or rain-soaked soils, maintaining a vertical wall is dangerous even below one metre in depth.
| Aggravating factor | Direct effect on the wall | Mandatory site arrangement |
|---|---|---|
| Movement of a mini excavator or dumper | Continuous vibrations and dynamic surcharge breaking cohesion | Keep plant traffic more than 1 m away from the edge |
| Deposit of excavated earth at the edge of the excavation | Static surcharge causing a vertical shear plane | Minimum clear strip of 50 cm to 1 m without any material |
| Rainwater infiltration or runoff | Instantaneous loss of internal friction and local liquefaction | Stoppage of work at the bottom of the excavation and immediate pumping |
| Previously backfilled trench nearby | Absence of mechanical cohesion along the old excavation | Mandatory shoring with no vertical wall tolerance |
Management of the surroundings of the trench is inseparable from the stability of the walls. According to the Construction Work Ordinance, a horizontal clear strip must be permanently maintained along the crest. This berm measures at least fifty centimeters for an excavation supported by shoring, and at least one metre when the wall is battered. Any deposit of rubble, pallets of paving stones, concrete pipes or excavated earth in this buffer zone increases lateral pressure and triggers sudden failure of the bank.
Defining slope angles, installing shoring and guaranteeing escape routes
When the private plot footprint allows it, battering constitutes the most economical solution for external works. The cutting angle of the mechanical excavator must be adapted to the exact geotechnical nature of the subsoil crossed. One never relies on the dry appearance of soil at the surface: a clayey silt may appear rigid when the bucket opens, then suddenly collapse an hour later due to the release of internal stresses or seepage water ingress.
| Geological nature of encountered soil | Vertical / horizontal ratio | Permissible slope angle |
|---|---|---|
| Compact and sound rock not fractured | Subvertical wall | Up to 80° |
| Very compact loose soil (sound moraine) | 2:1 ratio | Up to 63° (approx. 60°) |
| Ordinary cohesive loose soil (clayey gravel) | 1:1 ratio | Up to 45° |
| Inconsistent loose soil (sand, clean gravel) | 1:2 ratio | Up to 30° to 35° |
| Recent backfill soil or swampy area | 1:2 ratio or less | Required shoring or specialized study |
As soon as available space at the property boundary or the proximity of an existing hedge forbids battering, resorting to shoring becomes the only compliant option. In landscaping and private roadworks, light aluminum or steel trench boxes maneuverable by mini excavator are mainly used, as well as hydraulic struts combined with prefabricated panels. Shoring must imperatively be installed from the surface: no worker descends into the trench to place a panel or adjust a strut if the area is not previously protected by a trench box or safety cage lowered to the bottom.
- Secure preliminary excavationOpen the trench with a backhoe to the required depth without personnel descending to the bottom, systematically dumping spoil more than one metre from the edge.
- Descent and guidance of modular shoringSlip the light box or aluminum panel guided from the surface by the excavation plant, then spread the struts to press the shoring firmly against the earth.
- Installation of standardized access ladderInstall the evacuation ladder within the perimeter protected by the box. The stiles must project by at least one metre above the upper ground level and the foot must rest on a stable bottom.
- Visual inspection and pipe-layers' accessCheck for the absence of seeps beneath the panels before authorizing descent for pipe laying or sand bed grading.
The evacuation of a trench tolerates no obstacles. It is strictly forbidden to use scree slopes or piles of sand as a provisional exit ramp. The metal ladder must be equipped with anti-slip pads, wedged to prevent any lateral sliding and kept free from any routing of ducts, pumping hoses or power tool cables which might hinder emergency ascent.
Organization of surroundings, spoil setback and movement of excavation plant
On an external works construction site, carrying out trenches for automatic irrigation, landscape lighting supply or stormwater collectors exposes personnel to sudden burial risks. The apparent compactness of clayey or silty soil is deceptive. Wall failure gives no warning: an unstable mass of several hundred kilos detaches in a fraction of a second under the effect of the soil's own weight and external loads. When excavation exceeds the depth allowed without shoring set at 1.50 m in compact loose soil, no intervention at the bottom of the excavation can be tolerated without suitable protection or a compliant batter angle.
The layout of haul roads for plant and the storage of excavated materials constitute the main causes of surcharges on banks. The Construction Work Ordinance prescribes maintaining a rigorous clearance zone at the excavation crest. This berm guarantees that no dynamic or static pressure increases earth pressure on vertical or battered walls. The accumulation of spoil right against the trench edge transfers a critical triangular load that cancels the natural soil cohesion, even in weathered rock terrain or compact moraine.
| Trench configuration | Minimum clear strip at crest | Spoil stop distance | Plant passage distance (excavators, dumpers) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shored or supported walls | 50 cm free of any deposit | Beyond 50 cm from the crest | At least 1 m from the edge (depending on load) |
| Battered walls without shoring | 1 m free of any obstacle | Beyond 1 m from the slope edge | At least 1.50 m from the slope break |
| Remoulded or sandy soil | Immediate mandatory shoring | Beyond 1.50 m from the crest | Prohibition of traffic without heavy shoring |
Swiss romandie weather imposes permanent monitoring of the excavation face. A trench opened in the morning in dry weather can turn into a rockfall corridor in the afternoon due to a summer thunderstorm or spring thaw. Water acts in two destructive ways: it saturates the soil by increasing its density, whilst exerting pore hydrostatic pressure that destroys internal ground friction. As soon as water inflow appears at the bottom of the excavation or torrential rain soaks the walls, evacuation of the trench is required by the Construction Work Ordinance to reassess slope angles or install suitable casing.
Light retaining devices and emergency retreat routes
For landscaped roadworks and garden utility networks, light aluminum or steel shoring boxes maneuverable by a 3 to 5-tonne mini excavator offer the best operational profitability. These modular elements are sunk by driving or progressive pre-excavation. When space is restricted against a party fence or existing kerb and battering according to soil nature is geometrically impossible, continuous timbering remains the only permissible technical solution. Struts must be sized to withstand loads from landscaping vehicles delivering gravel or paving stones at the platform edge.
- Visual geotechnical inspectionIdentify soil stratification before any descent: topsoil, moraine, alluvial sand or unstable backfill. Adapt the shoring method to the actual cohesion observed during mechanical excavation.
- Installation of shoring from the outsideAssemble trench boxes or struts outside the excavation. Lower them using the site crane or backhoe. Never enter the danger zone to manually wedge panels.
- Installation of access and egress ladderPlace a stable exit ladder, tied at the top and projecting 1 m above the upper ground level. Provide ladders distributed every few metres so that no worker is more than 20 m away from an immediate emergency exit.
- Arrangement of edges and guardrailsInstall rigid barriers or a warning net with toe board as soon as the fall height exceeds the limits set by the Construction Work Ordinance, in order to prevent falls of persons or materials.
Emergency retreat in case of cracking or sudden seepage depends solely on strict compliance with exit routes. The site ladder must never serve as a makeshift step stool slipped into the middle of the excavation. It must be locked at the foot by pins or rigid wedging on the blinding layer, and securely tied at the top to an external stake. When a crew is laying a run of agricultural drain or irrigation over several tens of metres, the advancement of the mobile shoring must be coordinated with the movement of the ladders. Getting stuck at the end of a narrow trench without direct access means turns the slightest wall incident into a fatal outcome.
Emergency procedure in case of incipient collapse and resumption of excavation
The appearance of a longitudinal crack at the trench crest or the detachment of soil lumps signals imminent failure. The absolute instruction on site remains immediate evacuation of the excavation bottom via the nearest ladder. One cubic metre of ground weighs nearly two tonnes: a worker buried up to the chest suffers asphyxiating chest compression in a few minutes, making any self-extraction impossible. Faced with a collapse with burial, the instinctive reaction of jumping into the trench to shovel must be formally banned. Dynamic surcharges applied to the edge of the opening almost systematically cause a second fatal flow.
- Alert emergency servicesImmediately notify the health dispatch centre and firefighters trained in trench rescue. Indicate the address of the external site, the nature of the ground, the depth of the excavation and the burial level of the victim.
- Secure the area and stop machineryStop all engines and excavation plant within a twenty-metre perimeter to eliminate destructive vibrations. Keep any worker away from the trench lips to prevent secondary slope detachment.
- Clear airways from the surfacePlace trench boards or spreader plates on the bank to approach without weighting down the crest. Try to free the head and ribcage with a handled tool, without ever jumping into the unstable zone.
After an incident or partial collapse, the resumption of roadworks or pipe laying requires a complete revision of the execution method. It is forbidden to send a worker back to the bottom without prior consolidation. If the land footprint allows it, the excavation is resumed by backhoe excavation to create regular battering respecting soil cohesion. In confined spaces or along a property boundary, the foreman enforces the installation of light aluminum shoring boxes, assembled outside the excavation then slid and strutted from natural ground. The spoil mound must imperatively be pushed back beyond the trench's zone of influence.
Frequently asked questions
What trench depth can be excavated vertically without installing shoring?
According to the Construction Work Ordinance, trenches and excavations can be executed with vertical walls without shoring up to a maximum depth of one point five metres, only if the ground exhibits good natural stability. In the presence of unconsolidated backfill, sandy soils, water inflows or plant passing nearby, this tolerance drops: regular battering or continuous shoring becomes mandatory from the first decimetres of excavation.
How to determine the regulatory batter slope according to the nature of the encountered ground?
Slope gradients must correspond to the mechanical resistance of the excavated soil. For sound and compact rocks, an almost vertical wall remains permissible. In loose but cohesive soil or firm marl, the common batter angle lies between two to one and one to one (i.e. forty-five degrees). For pulverulent soils, unstable gravels or waterlogged sands, the slope must be eased down to a one-in-two ratio.
What is the maximum permissible distance between exit ladders at the bottom of a trench?
In a pipeline or landscape irrigation network trench, emergency ladders must be installed so that a worker can reach an exit in a few steps, with a maximum spacing of twenty metres between two ladders. The stiles must project beyond the crest level by at least one metre to ensure a stable grip, and ladders must be solidly tied at the top so they do not slip during a hurried evacuation.
How to install a modular shoring box without exposing personnel to the risk of collapse?
Assembly of boxes and struts is always done flat on the external working platform. The mechanical excavator then lifts the pre-equipped shoring using certified slings and places it vertically into the excavated opening. Panels are then pushed at the base or jacked from the ground surface. No earthworker is authorized to descend into the excavation until the panels are solidly wedged against both earth walls.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConstSafety prescriptions for excavations, trenches, battering and shoring
