Key takeaways
- The continuous particle size distribution of a gravel ensures optimal mechanical interlocking of the mineral skeleton under load.
- Exceeding the maximum permissible thickness produces surface crusting without compactness at the core of the bed.
- Adapting the equipment to the loose thicknesses directly determines whether the required load-bearing capacity for roads is achieved.
- Controlled moistening of the material prior to compaction ensures that the optimum dry density is achieved.
Particle size distribution of gravel according to VSS and SIA 318 standards
For the construction of subgrades and foundation layers in external works, the selection of mineral all-in aggregate cannot be improvised. According to Swiss trade practice, jointly defined by standard SIA 318 for external works and the body of VSS standards for transport infrastructure, foundation gravel must have a continuous particle size distribution curve. This continuity allows fine grains to fill the voids formed by coarser elements, thereby creating a self-locking skeleton with high mechanical strength.
- Unbound gravel (UGM / GNT)
- Reconstituted or natural granular mixture, unbound with cement or hydrocarbon binders, comprising a sandy and gravelly fraction spread from 0 to a maximum diameter D, intended to constitute the load-bearing foundation of a structure.
| Particle size designation | Recommended main use | Tolerated fines content | Behaviour under water |
|---|---|---|---|
| Non-frost-susceptible 0/32 gravel | Foundation layer under trafficable paving | Low (fines less than 5% to 7%) | Free-draining, frost-resistant |
| Raw or recycled 0/45 gravel | Thick foundation layer under heavy traffic roads | Moderate (fines according to VSS standards) | Good load-bearing capacity if well compacted |
| 0/16 or 0/20 gravel | Levelling layer under slabs or pavers | Very low (fines less than 3%) | Permeable, prevents capillary rise |
The management of very fine elements (less than 0.063 mm) is the critical point in acceptance testing. Excessive fines make the gravel sensitive to water, promoting bleeding or frost-heave instability, which compromises the underlying stability of the paving. Conversely, a gravel poor in fines will never achieve the necessary internal cohesion during rolling, leaving the material loose and unstable under the tyres of earthmoving machinery.
Layer thickness and compaction energy: the mistake of bulk backfilling
One of the most widespread execution defects on external works construction sites is the attempt to compact a thirty-centimetre raw layer in a single operation. Physically, the shock wave and vibration emitted by light or medium construction plant are rapidly damped through the mass of aggregate. Repeated passes over an excessive thickness only compact the top ten centimetres, creating a hard-appearing crust resting on a spongy and unstable lower cushion.
- Spreading and bulkingSpread the gravel using a bucket or blade in regular layers not exceeding 20 cm in the loose state. Ensure the transverse water drainage slope is maintained right from the earthworks stage.
- Moisture controlCheck the moisture content of the material. Dry gravel crumbles without agglomerating; waterlogged gravel flows under the roller. Carry out fine spray watering via a boom if necessary to achieve the optimum Proctor moisture content.
- First locking passPerform a static pass or low-amplitude pass to stabilize the gravel blanket without disrupting the upper edges of the material.
- Crossed dynamic passesCarry out 4 to 6 complete passes with vibration, overlapping the compaction lanes by at least 15 cm. Cross the trajectories between the longitudinal and diagonal directions.
- Surface sealingFinish with a static pass to seal the surface profile, eliminate ridges left by the edges of the plate, and prepare the seat for the next layer.
The landscape contractor must adapt the weight and technology of their equipment to the target thickness. A vibratory rammer transmits very deep point energy but easily disrupts spread gravel; it is used for narrow trench bottoms. For large areas of pathways or car parks, the tandem vibrating roller or heavy reversible vibrating plate (over 400 kg) are the reference equipment. For a total foundation layer of 30 cm required by detail sections, execution is systematically carried out in two distinct 15 cm lifts compacted separately.
Determining the number of passes and equipment suitability on thin layers
Compacting unbound gravel does not follow a logic of brute crushing, but rather a methodical rearrangement of grains by vibration and pressure. The most common mistake is to dump a subgrade 30 or 40 centimetres thick and attempt to tighten it by multiplying the passes of a heavy vibrating plate. The shock waves emitted by medium-tonnage machinery are rapidly damped in the interstitial air of the loose material: the top ten centimetres undergo overcompaction that breaks the edges of the surface aggregates, while the lower third retains its initial bulking. Under future vehicle loads or repeated pedestrian traffic, this unstable subgrade inevitably subsides, leading to the deformation of the asphalt or the opening of paving joints.
To guarantee the homogeneity required by standard SIA 318 and VSS standard recommendations, execution must imperatively be carried out in crossed passes on regular lifts. A pass corresponds to a complete return trip or total overlap of the previous lane by at least one-third of the width of the shoe or roller. Below an optimum moisture content determined by the Proctor test, internal friction prevents tightening; above it, pore water pressure rises and creates a lateral displacement phenomenon.
| Equipment category | Operating mass | Max. compacted thickness | Recommended number of passes | Recommended use in private road construction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vibratory rammer | 60 to 80 kg | 10 to 15 cm | 4 to 6 passes | Narrow excavations, channel bottoms, surrounds of planted areas |
| Unidirectional vibrating plate | 80 to 130 kg | 10 cm | 4 to 6 passes | Pedestrian paths, garden paths, light stabilized areas |
| Reversible vibrating plate | 200 to 450 kg | 15 to 20 cm | 6 to 8 passes | Garage entrances, terraces on natural soil, trafficable roads |
| Heavy reversible plate | 500 to 750 kg | 25 to 30 cm | 6 to 8 passes | Heavy parking areas, foundations for permeable paving |
| Tandem vibrating roller | 1.5 to 3.0 tonnes | 20 to 25 cm | 6 to 8 passes | Large delivery courtyards, trafficable access roads |
- Visually check the flatness of the spreading using a levelling staff or laser before starting the first pass of the machine.
- Linear progression at constant speed: never allow a vibrating plate to idle on the spot, as this creates an unwanted local depression.
- Systematic overlap of roller tracks by at least 15 to 20 centimetres to prevent under-compacted longitudinal strips.
- Immediate cessation of rolling if a pumping effect occurs, which is a sign of excessive moisture in the subgrade or an inadequate supporting soil.
In situ load-bearing capacity testing and foundation layer acceptance
Visual inspection of the surface alone after the passage of machinery is not sufficient to certify compaction at depth. Compliance of the foundation bed must be supported by physical load-bearing tests, as described within the framework of VSS standards and standard SIA 318. In external works subject to regular traffic from delivery vans, refuse collection vehicles, or private cars, the stability of the base directly dictates the performance of the overlying layers. Poorly tightened gravel decompresses under the effect of French-speaking Switzerland's freeze-thaw cycles, which causes paving edges to break out and the ground to punch through beneath the bedding layer.
- Checking the moisture content on the heapTake a handful of 0/32 gravel and squeeze it in your hand: the clump must keep its shape without running between your fingers or crumbling under light thumb pressure.
- Levelling the first bulked layerSpread the gravel in regular layers not exceeding the permissible thickness of the selected equipment, taking into account an average bulking coefficient of 20 to 25 percent.
- Execution of the compaction test stripCarry out two slow passes without vibration to seat the material, then follow up with crossed vibrating passes until the plate or roller no longer causes any visible residual settlement.
- Deformability control measurementCarry out the light dynamic plate test or static plate test according to project specifications to check the required modulus of elasticity and deflection ratio prior to laying the bedding layer.
Course of action in the event of a load-bearing failure and remedial work on a non-compliant foundation
When static or light plate load-bearing tests reveal abnormal deflection or insufficient deformation modulus, the reflex of multiplying machine passes worsens the situation. If a thirty-centimetre layer was spread in one go, the lower third retains too high a void ratio and deficient density. The energy transmitted by a vibrating plate or tandem roller decreases exponentially with depth. Continuing compaction on gravel whose base remains loose produces only surface crushing of the edges of the 0/32 or 0/45 granular mixture. This surface overcompaction generates friable lamination while masking residual settlement that will cause subsidence as soon as the road is put into service.
- Methodical stripping of the defective stratumThe backhoe loader removes the improperly laid gravel to uncover the clean earthworks formation level or undamaged separation geotextile membrane.
- Adjustment of moisture content and reduced spreadingThe temporarily stored material is moistened by spraying or aerated depending on its water state relative to the Proctor optimum. The gravel is then relaid in regular passes with a maximum thickness of fifteen centimetres after bulking.
- Methodical compaction and acceptance according to standardsEach pass receives the complete compaction cycle with guided machinery whose linear mass or centrifugal force corresponds to the material used. Final load-bearing capacity is measured in accordance with VSS standards and the rules of standard SIA 318 before any authorization to lay surface layers.
On landscaping and private road construction sites, this substructure repair constitutes the only recognized technical solution in the face of structural non-compliance. Any attempt to adjust the level by adding fines or dusting with cement destroys the drainage behaviour of the foundation and accelerates the frost susceptibility of the base assembly. Rigorous execution of layers of controlled thickness guarantees the durability of the structure without additional remedial costs.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done when the subgrade exhibits elasticity during gravel compaction?
If the gravel layer undulates or sinks under the roller with a cushioning effect, the problem originates from the waterlogged or clayey subgrade. Continuing compaction is useless because the gravel sinks and becomes contaminated with silt. The laid gravel must be stripped immediately, the unstable supporting soil excavated over twenty to forty centimetres, a high-strength anti-contaminant geotextile laid, and the foundation then reconstituted in thin layers methodically compacted.
Can excessive gravel thickness be compensated for by increasing the tonnage of the compaction roller?
No, using too heavy a roller on a thick layer crushes the surface aggregates without transmitting the necessary energy to the bottom of the layer. Standard SIA 318 and VSS standards dictate limiting the single compacted thickness to between fifteen and twenty centimetres. Disproportionate machinery crushes the 0/32 mixture, increases the proportion of frost-susceptible fines, and permanently weakens the structure instead of providing it with the required load-bearing capacity and stability.
Why does gravel segregate during unloading and how can this be remedied on site?
Brutal unloading by direct tipping in heaps encourages large stones to roll towards the periphery while fine elements remain in the centre. This granular segregation ruins the homogeneity of the mixture. To avoid this phenomenon, the machine operator must spread the gravel with the blade or bucket without pushing it over long distances. Prior light mixing with the bucket allows the granular grading envelope to be redistributed before starting compaction.
What are the criteria for choosing between a vibrating plate and a tandem roller?
The choice depends directly on the working area and the target layer thickness. A vibrating plate weighing two hundred to five hundred kilos is perfectly suited for narrow paths, edgings, and small courtyards for layers not exceeding fifteen centimetres. The tandem vibrating roller weighing one to three tonnes is essential on larger circulation lanes and car parks, allowing layers of up to twenty centimetres to be compacted while guaranteeing flawless evenness.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 318External works: execution requirements for foundation gravels, execution tolerances and acceptance rules
- normes VSSSwiss road construction standards: gravel particle size distribution, compaction criteria and in situ load-bearing tests
