Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 411Earthworks, foundation and compactionChapter 9 of 10 in the section

The tree to keep: root zone, manual trenching, and the tree that dies three years later

This chapter details the essential technical measures for preserving existing trees during earthwork operations. You will learn how to define the root protection zone according to JardinSuisse recommendations, prohibit any compaction under the canopy, and choose between manual trenching and directional drilling to cross the root system without causing delayed dieback of the plant.

Key takeaways

  • The root protection zone encompasses the entire vertical projection of the canopy plus at least one and a half metres.
  • Soil compaction under the canopy irremediably suffocates the shallow root system of trees.
  • Any infrastructure excavation within the root zone must be carried out manually or by directional drilling without destabilisation.
  • Roots cleanly cut and protected from drying out prevent fungal necroses that are fatal in the medium term.

Delimit the root protection zone and prohibit loads under the canopy

On external works construction sites, mature trees frequently suffer invisible damage whose consequences only become apparent three to five years later. The repeated passage of a mini-excavator, the temporary storage of run-of-material or the uncontrolled stripping of topsoil destroy the porous structure of the soil. A tree injured at the base of its trunk or deprived of its absorbing root hairs continues to draw on its starch reserves for two or three seasons, giving the illusion of normal survival, before a sudden drying out of the crown or a parasitic attack makes its felling inevitable.

Root Protection Zone (RPZ)
Soil surface excluded from any construction site footprint, corresponding at a minimum to the vertical projection of the tree canopy onto the ground, increased by a peripheral strip of at least one and a half metres in width according to JardinSuisse professional guidelines.

The majority of absorbing roots are concentrated in the top sixty centimetres of the soil, where aeration and microbial life are most active. When construction machinery travels under the canopy, mechanical settling drastically reduces soil porosity. Water no longer infiltrates properly, oxygen no longer diffuses towards the rootlets and carbon dioxide accumulates, causing the suffocation and rotting of the roots. Similarly, even a temporary fill of twenty centimetres of compacted crushed gravel is enough to condemn vital gas exchanges.

  1. Pegging out the footprintMeasure the maximum radius of the tree canopy, add one and a half metres, then mark out this circular or polygonal perimeter on the natural ground before any earthwork intervention.
  2. Installation of the fixed fenceInstall a solid hoarding or construction site mesh barriers at least two metres high, securely anchored on concrete bases, to prevent any physical access by machinery.
  3. Signage and displayFix explanatory signs to the barriers mentioning the prohibition of storage, traffic and dumping of polluting products within the protected perimeter.

Open infrastructure trenches by gentle earthworks or underground boring

The installation of kerbs, paving or the routing of secondary drainage and watering pipes sometimes requires approaching the tree. The toothed bucket of a mechanical excavator tears structural roots longitudinally, creating internal tears that travel up to the collar. These injuries pave the way for wood-decaying fungi that degrade the heartwood, ultimately compromising the mechanical stability of the tree. For any unavoidable intervention under the canopy, the use of the mechanical excavator must be formally banned in favour of non-destructive methods.

Comparison of root zone crossing techniques
Execution methodTools requiredBenefits for the treeImplementation constraints
Careful manual trenchingSharp spade, round shovel, arboricultural prunerImmediate visual exposure of roots and clean cutsSlow pace and high labour cost
Excavation by air lanceMobile compressor, pneumatic lance, suction excavatorRoots totally preserved without any mechanical stressRequires specialised equipment and generates dust
Directional drilling / pipe rammingPneumatic mole or horizontal directional drilling rigNo surface excavation opening, soil integrityRequires start and arrival pits outside the footprint

During manual opening, as soon as a root with a diameter of less than three centimetres is exposed and hinders the installation of a duct or paving, it must never be broken by twisting or torn out with the bucket. The cut must be made perpendicularly to the axis using a well-sharpened pruning saw or lopper, achieving a smooth section without fraying the bark. Exposed roots that remain in place must be protected without delay from sunlight and wind by a jute fabric kept constantly moist.

For backfilling the trench under the canopy, exclusively original topsoil or a draining soil-stone substrate not mechanically compacted must be used. Settling is done by light manual tamping or by abundant watering in order to compact the soil without breaking the preserved root axes. For deep passages of technical utilities, driving via pneumatic mole below the level of the main root hair system, generally beyond one metre in depth, constitutes the safest technique to preserve the plant in the long term.

Surgical treatment of uncovered roots and closing of excavations

When a manual trench or suction excavation exposes woody axes in the root protection zone, exposure to the open air triggers cellular desiccation within a few hours. The absorbing root hairs die first, depriving the tree of its superficial water supply. The technical recommendations of the umbrella association JardinSuisse require immediate handling of any denuded root system before continuing roadworks or network installation.

  1. Trimming and clean cutting of damaged sectionsAny root torn, crushed or frayed by a bucket tooth must be reworked manually. The team leader uses a sharpened arborist saw or heavy-duty pruner previously disinfected. The cut is made perpendicularly to the axis of the root, clean, without tearing the residual bark or cambium. For diameters exceeding 20 millimetres, the application of healing balm is prohibited in favour of strict maintenance under continuous humidity.
  2. Temporary thermal and hydric protectionAs long as the excavation remains open, the exposed walls and root systems must be lined with natural jute felt or rot-proof non-woven geotextile cloths kept constantly moist by spraying with clean water. In summer or during dry wind, this humidification is carried out twice per working day. The use of watertight black plastic tarpaulins is excluded to prevent any overheating of the root hair system.
  3. Targeted backfilling with fertile structural materialsBackfilling is carried out with a draining soil-stone mixture or screened topsoil enriched with mature compost, avoiding alkaline or polluted recycled run-of-material. The material is placed in successive layers of 15 to 20 centimetres, tamped manually by foot or hand tamper. Any passage of vibrating machinery or heavy plate remains prohibited so as not to destructure the rootlets.
Required interventions according to the diameter of roots encountered during earthworks
Root diameterPhysiological and mechanical roleCutting toleranceTechnical execution protocol
Less than 20 mmWater and mineral nutrition (root hair system)Tolerated if limited to less than 25% of the volumeStraight cut with pruner, misting, light organic backfill without mechanical compaction.
Between 20 and 50 mmSap conduction and secondary anchorageExceptional, upon approval by the managerMeticulous manual trenching, clean cut with arborist saw, maintenance under damp jute cloths.
Greater than 50 mmStructural element for mechanical stability and reservesFormally prohibited without prior expertiseStopping of earthworks, complete preservation, redirection of the utility line or directional drilling under the root.

The three-year delayed dieback syndrome and surface handover

A mature woody specimen has significant reserves of carbohydrates stored in its trunk and large roots. When an earthmover cuts master roots or a loader compacts the soil inside the root protection zone, the tree does not react instantly. It draws on its internal stocks to maintain its foliage during the current season and the next. Vegetative dieback only appears visibly two to four years later, in the form of crown dieback, generalized microphylly, and then the sudden death of the specimen.

To protect the landscaping company against late disputes linked to prior interventions by third parties on the plot, the foreman draws up a joint inspection record of the arboricultural condition before starting the landscaped civil engineering construction site. This record lists the initial health status of the canopies, previous injuries, the presence of pre-existing trenches and the precise layout of rigid barriers prohibiting the passage of heavy machinery. If the earthwork plan requires a pipeline passage crossing the root ball, the landscaper ensures that the mandatory use of directional drilling or pneumatic gentle earthworks is recorded under the responsibility of the site management.

  • Weekly visual inspection of the condition of fixed peripheral protections around the root protection zone.
  • Verification of the total absence of temporary storage of excavated earth, pallets or skips under the canopy.
  • Installation of a root ventilation system and perforated aeration pipes in the event of an unavoidable modification of the finished ground level.
  • Canopy thinning pruning carried out by a qualified arborist if more than 20% of the root hair system has undergone unavoidable mechanical stress.

Dispute management, joint inspection record and emergency rescue measures

On the construction site, the accidental breakage of an underground structural root or the intrusion of a loader under the canopy constitutes a serious non-conformity during earthworks. When the bucket of a mechanical excavator tears master roots or the soil undergoes heavy rolling in the root protection zone, the landscaping team must freeze the sector to contain the biological damage. Trying to hastily backfill an excavation with shredded roots condemns the tree to suffocation and exposes the contractor to a dispute during delayed dieback.

  1. Stopping of earthworks and sanctuaryisation of the zoneInterrupt machinery throughout the entire canopy perimeter. Install an impassable rigid barrier to banish any residual compaction on the vulnerable root system.
  2. Surgical purging of torn stumpsClear the excavation face by hand or by gentle soil suction. Recut each root with a diameter greater than two centimetres using a sharpened and disinfected arborist saw, with a clean cut oriented downwards.
  3. Thermal protection and permeable backfillingPlace a jute fabric kept moist to prevent rootlet desiccation. Backfill without any mechanical compaction with living topsoil enriched with organic matter according to JardinSuisse recommendations.
  4. Joint inspection record and logbook instructionRecord the incident with supporting photos in the daily report. Summon the site management and the client to draw up a joint inspection record detailing the cut calibres and the compensatory watering plan.

Since the tree can languish three to five years after earthworks due to the exhaustion of its carbohydrate reserves, subsequent expertise will systematically look for bucket marks or soil clogging. In accordance with SIA 118 standard, a joint inspection record protects the landscape constructor if mechanical damage existed before their intervention. If the damage stems from an execution fault, the tree valuation method according to the Swiss Union of Parks and Promenades will serve as the calculation basis to quantify the replacement compensation.

Frequently asked questions

A root of more than five centimetres is torn out by the bucket: how to intervene?

It is necessary to immediately stop the machine and clear the area by hand. Never leave a frayed stump in the soil. Recut the root cleanly with a well-sharpened pruning saw to obtain a smooth surface facilitating healing. Wrap the wound in a geotextile or jute cloth kept continuously moist until backfilling. Notify the injury on the construction site report with photographs and precise measurement of the cut diameter.

Why is compaction under the canopy completely excluded for light roads?

Even for a simple pedestrian paving or a non-load-bearing gravel layer, the vibrating plate packs the upper horizon over thirty centimetres. This crushing compacts the soil macropores, eliminates oxygen and suffocates the absorbing rootlets located at the surface. Deprived of respiration and water infiltration, the root system slowly declines. In the root protection zone, the installation structure must rest on a self-compacting draining material, without resorting to heavy vibrating machinery.

Manual trenching or directional drilling: how to decide according to the project configuration?

The choice depends on the number of networks and the installation depth. Manual or suction trenching is required for short, superficial crossings perpendicular to visible roots, allowing ducts to be threaded under large diameters without breakage. On the other hand, to cross the entire canopy over a long distance or install a deep drainage pipe, deep subterranean directional drilling avoids any destructive earthworks in the root volume.

Why does a tree whose roots have been cut take three years to die?

A woody specimen has carbohydrate reserves stored in its trunk and large roots to survive aggressions. After the mechanical sectioning of its nourishing or anchoring roots, the tree draws on its stocks without showing visible symptoms during the first season. As reserves run out and wood-decaying fungi colonise unhealed wounds, the canopy begins to dry out. Total dieback thus commonly manifests three years after the works.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works and management of notices of defects
  • Directives JardinSuisseSwiss professional regulations for the protection of vegetation and trees on construction sites

In the same section