Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 411Machinery, safety and management of the outdoor siteChapter 10 of 10 in the section

The ramp is sagging: compaction diagnosis, excavation, removal of unstable soil and complete reconstruction

Faced with a deformed underground garage paved ramp a few months after the acceptance of the work, the site manager must technically classify the defect. You will know how to organise joint inspections, identify foundation bearing capacity defects, apply the warranty rules of standard SIA 118 and carry out the complete rebuilding of the bedding layers in accordance with standard SIA 318.

Key takeaways

  • The cross-sectional sounding precisely locates the failing layers beneath the bedding layer of the ramp.
  • Standard SIA 118 governs the notification of defects during the two-year liability period.
  • The complete removal of unstable material is mandatory prior to placing any well-compacted replacement aggregate.
  • Standard SIA 318 sets the bearing capacity criteria to permanently reconstruct the base of a trafficked roadway.

Identifying the defect at eight months and diagnosing the base via sounding

Eight months after the handover of a residential complex, the access ramp to the underground garage shows pronounced rutting under vehicle wheel tracks. The concrete pavers are coming loose, the joints are opening up and several elements are spalling due to shear forces. Puddles retain surface run-off water, which accelerates degradation under daily traffic.

Differential settlement of a ramp
Non-uniform settlement of the pavement structure caused by a failure of the supporting soil's bearing capacity or insufficient compaction of the bedding layers under the effect of repeated loads and infiltration water.

As the work is within the two-year period following joint acceptance, standard SIA 118 applies provided it has been integrated into the construction contract. The client formally notifies the defect in writing. The landscaping contractor is then required to eliminate the defect at their own expense, unless they can prove a cause completely unrelated to their work. To establish responsibilities without sterile disputes, the first step is to open a joint diagnostic trench.

  1. Methodical removal of a transverse stripLift the pavers by hand over a width of 1 metre across the entire width of the ramp to examine the condition of the bedding layer.
  2. Inspection of the bedding layerMeasure the thickness of the laying grit. A variable thickness exceeding 5 centimetres reveals that the bedding layer was used to compensate for poor levelling of the underlying layer.
  3. Exploratory excavation in the foundationExcavate the foundation gravel with a mini-excavator down to the natural ground or structural work backfill to check the particle size distribution and the presence of plastic fines.
  4. Bearing capacity and compaction measurementCarry out a dynamic cone penetrometer test or a plate load test on the formation level to quantify the deformation modulus in accordance with standard SIA 318.

In this textbook case, the diagnosis reveals a foundation contaminated by clayey soils from neighbouring slopes, combined with the absence of a separating geotextile on uncompacted backfill following civil engineering work. Water seeping down through the permeable joints turned the subgrade into mud under axle pressure.

Remove contaminated foundation material and rebuild the structure in accordance with standard SIA 318

The finding of faulty compaction requires a complete reconstruction. Retaining weakened marginal areas would compromise the future stability of the entire trafficked roadway. Remedial works require strict securing of access to the car park throughout the intervention, organised in agreement with the property management.

Reconstruction structure of a trafficked ramp in accordance with standard SIA 318
Structural elementRecommended materialMinimum thicknessExecution control
Excavated formation levelCompacted or stabilised natural soilSubgrade graded to slopePlate deformation modulus EV2
Separation and filtrationAnti-contaminant non-woven geotextileMinimum overlap of 30 cmMechanical continuity and wedging
Foundation layerUntreated mineral aggregate 0/4525 to 35 cm depending on loadCompaction by cross-passes with a roller
Permeable bedding layerClean crushed grit 2/4 or 2/5Constant 3 to 4 cm after tampingScreeding on rails without prior compaction
Paved surfacingInterlocking vehicular concrete pavers8 cm thicknessJoint alignment and sand compaction
  1. Removal and sorting of existing materialsRemove intact pavers for reuse after cleaning their edges. Dispose of broken elements and strip contaminated gravel to an appropriate sorting facility.
  2. Removal of soft pockets and compaction of the formation levelExcavate the bottom of the excavation down to stable and homogeneous soil. Compact the formation level with a vibratory roller and check the gravity drainage of deep water.
  3. Installation of geotextile and spreading of 0/45 aggregateUnroll the anti-contaminant non-woven fabric on the subgrade with a rigorous overlap of the sheets. Place the untreated aggregate in successive layers not exceeding 15 centimetres in thickness.
  4. Methodical compaction and levellingCompact each pass of aggregate with heavy equipment adapted to the slope. Check finishing levels to ensure a regular longitudinal slope without counter-slopes.
  5. Screeding the bedding layer and relaying paversSpread crushed 2/4 grit with a screed board on metal guides. Lay the pavers progressively with regular joints of 3 to 5 millimetres, brush in crushed silica sand and then compact with a plate vibrator equipped with a polyurethane pad.

Ramp earthworks, base replacement and methodical compaction

The repair of an underground car park access ramp requires rigorous construction site organisation due to the gradient, which is often between ten and fifteen percent. Once the pavers are removed and the bedding layer contaminated with fines is cleared away, the excavation goes down to the stable subgrade identified during preliminary soundings. The removal of contaminated or waterlogged soil is carried out with a tracked backhoe excavator positioned upstream to avoid any shear failure of the formation level. The sides of the excavation must be stabilised in accordance with the requirements of the construction work ordinance, ensuring a clear setback for material storage and plant movement.

  1. Preparation and levelling of the formation levelAfter extracting the unstable soil, the bottom of the excavation is graded according to the design slope to ensure gravity drainage of infiltration water. Superficial tamping with a heavy vibrating plate tightens the natural ground before visual acceptance of the subgrade.
  2. Installation of the separation and anti-contaminant geotextileA non-woven polypropylene geotextile of at least two hundred grams per square metre is unrolled from bottom to top. The sheets overlap by fifty centimetres to neutralise any upward migration of silts under the effect of dynamic pumping induced by vehicle traffic.
  3. Backfilling with frost-resistant 0/45 aggregateThe supply of clean quarry aggregate is carried out in successive layers of twenty to thirty centimetres compacted thickness. Each pass is uniformly moistened to approach the optimum moisture content of the modified Proctor test.
  4. Heavy compaction and upward progressionCompaction is carried out using a tandem vibratory roller or a reversible vibrating plate of at least four hundred kilos, always progressing from the low point towards the top of the ramp to prevent material displacement.
Bearing capacity checks and compaction requirements for a trafficked ramp
Structural levelMaterial usedControl methodRequired target value
Excavated formation levelReworked natural soil or well-graded materialCircular plate load testDeformation modulus greater than 30 MPa
Lower foundationRecycled aggregate or quarry aggregate 0/45Deflection measurement or plate testDeformation modulus greater than 80 MPa
Upper base layerCrushed frost-resistant aggregate 0/22 or 0/32Plate load test (ME2/ME1 ratio)ME2 modulus greater than 120 MPa, ratio less than 2.2

Relaying of paving, acceptance of the work and contractual warranties

On the accepted base layer, the repair continues with the installation of a bedding layer of crushed 2/4 or 2/5 grit with a constant thickness of three to four centimetres after tamping. On steep slopes, the use of a fine-free draining mortar or dry-stabilised grit prevents the bedding layer from creeping under repeated acceleration and braking. Concrete pavers at least eight centimetres thick, equipped with side spacers promoting three-dimensional interlocking, are laid to refusal against solidly anchored concrete edge restraints.

Joint filling is carried out immediately after aligning using a hard crushed sand 0/2 or 1/3 free of clay particles. Cross-sweeping precedes general tamping using a plate vibrator equipped with a polyurethane or elastomer mat so as not to chip the edges of the concrete blocks. A second sanding fills the voids created by mechanical vibration. No vehicle must cross the ramp before the gaps are completely sealed, under penalty of causing immediate transverse micro-displacements.

  • Verification of flatness using a four-metre straightedge, with the deviation not exceeding eight millimetres across the entire deck.
  • Check of the exact altimetric connection between the repaired surfacing and the channel grating located at the bottom of the ramp.
  • Check of the anchorage of the edge kerbs and proper lateral drainage to the surface gullies.
  • Drawing up of the joint acceptance inspection record in accordance with the clauses of standard SIA 118 and formal closure of the notice of defects.

Dispute management, liabilities and rectification of structural defects

When a paved ramp sags eight months after completion, visual inspection is no longer enough. Signs of pronounced rutting in turning areas and the shearing of pavers reveal underlying instability. Facing the client, the contractor must act methodically. The framework of standard SIA 118 structures the exercise of defect rights during the notification period. The notice of defects received by the site management requires a joint on-site inspection to determine technical and contractual liabilities.

  1. 1. Joint inspection record and destructive soundingOpen a mechanical exploratory trench perpendicular to the ramp alignment. The sounding makes it possible to record the actual thicknesses of the bedding layers, check for the presence or absence of a separation geotextile and visually observe the contamination of the base layer by fines from the supporting soil.
  2. 2. Geotechnical measurements and layer characterisationHave plate load tests carried out at at least two strategic points by a third-party laboratory. If the Ev2 deformation modulus of the foundation does not reach the requirements prescribed by standard SIA 318, execution failure of the compaction is formally established, ruling out the theory of simple surface wear.
  3. 3. Total removal of unstable soil and subgrade rehabilitationReject any superficial patching by adding laying sand. Excavate all the paving, remove all contaminated or poorly densified foundation material down to soft soil, then re-profile the subgrade while respecting water drainage slopes.
  4. 4. Methodical reconstruction and staged controlsLay a heavy non-woven anti-contaminant geotextile on the formation level. Backfill with frost-resistant 0/32 aggregates in successive passes not exceeding 20 cm, compacted with a vibratory roller with systematic control of the compaction rate before laying the crushed 2/4 or 2/5 grit bedding layer.

Rigorous management of such a claim protects the company's reputation. By taking responsibility without delay for complete excavation and re-profiling of the work in accordance with recognized technical rules, the builder demonstrates professionalism and avoids escalation into costly expert legal proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a garage ramp often sag after only a few months?

The main cause lies in insufficient compaction of the bedding layers or the use of aggregate contaminated with fines. Under the repeated action of residual heavy site traffic or daily car braking, the foundation settles, especially if infiltration water is not quickly removed by an adequate cross-fall.

How to justify a total reconstruction rather than localized repair of ruts?

Destructive sounding diagnosis almost always reveals that the decompression of the granular material extends well beyond the sagging area. Localized repairs create bearing capacity discontinuities that lead to further differential settlement. Standard SIA 318 prescribes a homogeneous foundation to support rolling loads.

What role does the geotextile placed on the formation level play during reconstruction?

The non-woven geotextile felt mechanically separates the natural ground from the foundation layer made of recycled or natural aggregate. It prevents fine particles from migrating upwards under the pressure of loads, while allowing free water to pass through. Without this barrier, the aggregate loses its internal cohesion and sinks into the soft soil.

What compaction control should be required before relaying the bedding layer and pavers?

Dynamic or static plate bearing tests should be required on the completed foundation layer. These measurements make it possible to validate that the minimum bearing capacity required by technical directives is achieved across the entire ramp. These test reports are included in the final reconstruction file.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, governing acceptance, notification of defects and the exercise of contractual warranties.
  • SIA 318Directives and technical requirements for soil preparation, foundation dimensioning and the installation of paved and slab surfacings in external works.

In the same section