Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 411Planting, irrigation and living soilsChapter 3 of 10 in the section

When to plant: favorable period, rootball or bare roots, and the survival guarantee

Planting a tree or shrub bed during a heatwave exposes the construction site to immediate plant failure and costly disputes. This chapter details the intervention schedule according to plant conditioning, the biological limits of each specimen, and the precise criteria set by the industry to grant, refuse, or qualify the survival guarantee with reservations.

Key takeaways

  • Bare-root plants must imperatively be planted during the dormant period, from November to March.
  • Rootballed plants tolerate spring and autumn planting, while container-grown plants offer regulated flexibility.
  • Planting between June and August imposes heavy watering constraints and justifies refusing the guarantee.
  • The survival guarantee according to JardinSuisse requires a maintenance contract or a validated watering protocol.

Technical schedule and conditioning: adapting earthwork to biological cycles

The success of landscaping works relies on the match between the physiological state of the plant and the local climatic conditions of the Swiss Plateau or alpine valleys. Forcing planting in the middle of summer, under the pretext of delivering a construction site before the award holidays, disrupts the water balance: foliage transpiration far exceeds the absorption capacity of roots not yet anchored. This results in the irreversible desiccation of conductive tissues, even with massive water applications that then risk asphyxiating the subsoil.

Recommended planting windows in French-speaking Switzerland according to conditioning
ConditioningOptimal intervention periodTechnical and climatic limitsSensitivity to desiccation
Bare roots (trees, shrubs, whips)Early November to late MarchFormal ban in frozen or waterlogged soil; stop as soon as bud burst occursMaximum: roots exposed to air during transfers
Wire-basketed or burlap-wrapped rootball (standard trees, conifers)Mid-October to late AprilTo be excluded during prolonged frost periods and during advanced vegetative awakeningMedium: rootball sensitive to dehydration before planting
Container / growing pot (all specimens)September to May (possible in summer under strict conditions)In summer: mandatory management of thermal stress and timed daily wateringLow if the root network remains intact and watered

Bare-root plants remain the most economical solution for hedge rows, reforestation, or forest shrub beds, but their execution window remains extremely narrow. As soon as the buds swell in early spring, planting becomes critical. Immediate mud-puddling (pralinage) of the rootlets and hydraulic tamping of the loam are essential to remove air pockets.

Wire-basketed rootballs mainly concern large-calibre trees and conifers. Autumn remains the prime season: the soil retains the heat accumulated during summer, which stimulates autumn root growth before the first severe frosts. In spring, installing a watering basin sized to the volume of the rootball, combined with mechanical anchoring via tripod staking or underground guy-wiring, supports the tree until full leafing without root tearing caused by wind.

Survival guarantee according to JardinSuisse: attribution criteria, exclusions, and duties of the site foreman

According to trade practices applied by JardinSuisse and formalised in landscaping contracts, the survival guarantee is not an automatic insurance against all weather hazards. It is a contractual guarantee certifying that the supplied plant was healthy, compliant with quality specifications, free from quarantine pests, and planted in accordance with trade practices. This guarantee generally extends over a complete vegetative period, i.e., until the autumn following planting.

  • Compliant execution of earthworks: pit loosened to at least two to three times the width of the rootball.
  • Installation of support devices: staking or rootball anchoring intact throughout the entire first season.
  • Mandatory creation of a stable watering basin at least 15 cm high at the edge of the pit.
  • Formal proof of continuous watering: recorded regular visits or functional automated network.

According to recognised practices of the professional association JardinSuisse, the survival guarantee becomes void if the maintenance following planting is not entrusted to the executing company. If the client or a third party takes charge of watering, the contractor cannot be held responsible for summer desiccation or, conversely, for root rot due to prolonged immersion in non-drained clay soil.

To maintain a survival guarantee on late spring plantings, the contractor must submit an addendum to the client including a reinforced watering protocol, organic mulching of the basin to a depth of 8 to 10 cm to limit evaporation, and, on large specimens, the application of a protective white wash on trunks to prevent sunscald cracks. Without these validated and remunerated provisions, free replacement of dead plants cannot be demanded from the company.

Summer deadlocks and schedule forcing: arbitrating between technical refusal and safeguarding measures

Forcing the planting of trees or shrubs between June and August almost always responds to administrative end-of-project constraints rather than agronomic requirements. In the middle of summer, the evapotranspirational demand of the foliage far exceeds the absorption capacity of a root system disrupted by lifting, handling, or the tightness of a root spiral. For the site manager and team leader, yielding to schedule pressure without issuing technical reservations directly engages the landscaping company's liability for massive mortalities foreseeable from the first heatwaves.

Conditioning behaviour and acceptability of plantings during high heat episodes
Plant conditioningSummer feasibilityMain physiological riskMandatory conservatory measures
Bare rootsTotal banRapid desiccation of rootlets, immediate gas embolismMandatory postponement to autumn dormancy; no admissible derogation
Wire-basketed rootball / burlapStrongly discouragedWater loss through reverse capillarity toward dry backfill soilFormal refusal or heel-in in shaded trench with misting
Container / potTolerated under strict reservationsThermal shock of off-soil substrate and asphyxiation from excessive wateringPrior soaking by immersion, rootball opening, 10 cm protective mulch

When the client contractually requires the installation of plants during pronounced water stress, the professional position defined by JardinSuisse directives is clear: the company must issue a written notice of reservations motivated by adverse climatic conditions. If the order to execute is maintained despite the signalled risks, the Code of Obligations discharges the contractor from defects attributable to the client's instructions, provided that the notification was recorded before the first bucket stroke. The survival guarantee must then be expressly suspended by addendum or refused outright.

Conditions for applying the guarantee: watering protocol and maintenance handover

The validity of a survival guarantee, established over a full vegetative cycle according to JardinSuisse practices and the association's landscaping standards prescriptions, relies on a rigorously documented execution chain. The decisive initial action remains the anchoring watering, commonly called settling. This is not simply about moistening the substrate, but about removing air trapped between the rootball and loose backfill soil through hydraulic saturation. Creating a stable retention basin, whose diameter matches at least that of the planting pit and whose bund height reaches 15 to 20 centimetres, is an essential prerequisite for directing water volumes straight to the active root system.

  • Immediate construction of a compacted soil bund at the periphery of the pit, watertight and dimensioned to contain massive watering without spilling outside.
  • Application of clean organic mulch free of pathogens to a thickness of 8 to 10 centimetres to curb evaporation and limit surface soil overheating.
  • Control of mechanical anchoring: monopode staking, bipode staking, or underground guy-wiring must show no play likely to shear emerging rootlets.
  • Formal verification of root collar position: excessive burying under topsoil causes asphyxiation and cancels the supplier's or installer's liability without exception.

The survival guarantee cannot be assimilated to an all-risks insurance granted to the client. According to the practice accepted by the French-speaking branch, the supply of plants with a guarantee contractually requires the external works company to take charge of consolidation maintenance during the twelve months following the acceptance of the work. If the client or property management reserves watering and cultural care for its own staff, the guarantee expires immediately upon provisional acceptance of the work, barring any special agreement including a joint watering log and regular tensiometric measurements.

Managing survival failures: joint inspection record, disputes, and replacement

When spring bud burst fails or sudden desiccation occurs in mid-summer, the team leader or site manager must immediately trigger a joint inspection record on site. Facing claims from site management, the cambium test must be carried out immediately using a grafting knife on the trunk and scaffold branches to check sap flow. Inspection does not stop at the foliage: it is essential to probe the rootball and pit bottom using a soil auger to distinguish acute water stress from root asphyxiation caused by compacted soil or stagnant excess water at the bottom of the excavation.

If dieback engages the landscaper's liability under the contractual guarantee regime, replacing the specimen must imperatively comply with trade practices and vegetative cycles. There is no question of replanting in the middle of July to settle an administrative list of reservations. The intervention is the subject of a technical addendum scheduling the substitution during the appropriate biological period: in autumn for a rootballed or bare-root specimen, or at the very beginning of spring. The protocol requires the complete extraction of the withered rootball, removal of soil saturated with root pathogens, de-compacting of the pit walls, addition of fresh substrate, and careful anchoring of the new specimen.

Frequently asked questions

What to do if site management demands the replanting of a dead tree in the middle of July?

The site manager must formally refuse this operation via a detailed written notice. Planting a new specimen during a heatwave period exposes the plant to lethal water stress and reproduces the exact conditions of the initial failure. Non-survival must be recorded in the site meeting minutes and the uprooting and replanting planned from November onwards, when vegetation dormancy resumes.

How to distinguish a lack of water from root rot during a survival dispute?

Joint expert assessment requires immediate probing of the planting pit with a gouge or auger. A crumbly rootball and a mat of dried rootlets indicate irrigation failure attributable to watering. Conversely, a smell of hydrogen sulphide, blackened roots, and waterlogged soil at the bottom of the excavation demonstrate asphyxiation due to lack of drainage, ruling out any watering failure on the client's part.

Which contractual documents allow excluding the survival guarantee during forced planting?

When the schedule requires planting outside periods recommended by JardinSuisse, the contractor must notify a written anomaly notice before any intervention. This document specifies thermal risks, expressly refuses granting the survival guarantee for the relevant season, and requires the client to sign a contractual disclaimer before plants are brought onto the construction site.

Does the survival guarantee apply automatically to a tree supplied by the client?

No. The landscaper is not liable for the intrinsic quality, nursery lifting freshness, or sizing of plants supplied directly by the client. The contractor remains solely responsible for the compliance of planting, adherence to planting levels, and initial watering. The survival guarantee must be formally excluded from the quote for any external supply.

Texts and standards cited

  • Norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and management of notices of defects upon acceptance of the work.
  • Directives et usages JardinSuisseSwiss professional prescriptions for plant quality, planting periods, and conditions for granting the survival guarantee.

In the same section