Key takeaways
- A one-centimetre gap under the door leaf dramatically degrades the overall sound insulation of the installed door.
- SIA 181 sets in-situ requirements that immediately penalise the slightest air passage under the leaf.
- Mechanical air sweeping must never pass through an open gap under a door with acoustic requirements.
- Recessed automatic door bottoms and Swiss-type thresholds ensure the continuity of the sound barrier at floor level.
Acoustic leakage under the leaf destroys the performance of the installed element
On an interior joinery construction site, the acoustic behaviour of a door unit does not depend solely on the surface mass of its leaf. In the laboratory, a solid leaf or one with an acoustic sandwich core shows impressive sound reduction indices. However, at handover in the building, the check measurements carried out in accordance with the guidelines of SIA 181 assess the raw sound insulation between two finished rooms. It is the installed element as a whole that is judged, including the frame, the perimeter seals and, above all, the junction with the finished floor.
Sound waves systematically take the path of least mechanical resistance. Air is the preferred vector for the propagation of airborne noise. As soon as a gap remains under the bottom of the door, acoustic energy rushes in through diffraction. A free gap of ten millimetres under a leaf one metre wide represents a gaping opening of one hundred square centimetres. Even if the door panel is certified for very high attenuation, this direct coupling with the neighbouring room brings the overall measured value down to that of a basic hollow-core door.
| Index of sealed closed solid leaf | Free gap at the bottom observed | Resulting overall in-situ performance | SIA 181 compliance finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| 32 dB | 10 mm | Approximately 18 to 20 dB | Non-compliant for separating living spaces |
| 37 dB | 10 mm | Approximately 20 to 22 dB | Major defect on an apartment entrance door or confidential office |
| 42 dB | 6 mm | Approximately 25 to 27 dB | Complete failure of the high-requirement acoustic assembly |
| 37 dB | 0 mm (threshold with compressed seal) | 34 to 36 dB (depending on masonry) | Compliant with requirements for the installed element |
Resolving the conflict between controlled mechanical ventilation and acoustic requirements
In contemporary buildings meeting high energy-performance standards, the controlled mechanical ventilation concept traditionally relies on air being transferred from dry rooms to wet rooms. HVAC engineers commonly specify undercutting interior doors by eight to twelve millimetres to allow this passage. This instruction is in direct and violent contradiction with SIA 181, which sets the limit values for protection against noise between sleeping areas, work areas and living rooms.
- Undercut
- Trimming or mechanical clearance left under the bottom of a door leaf to allow a defined air flow to pass between two adjoining rooms.
The joiner must never accept an undercut on a door that is contractually subject to a sound insulation requirement. The two functions are technically incompatible on the same open gap. To resolve this conflict without blocking air circulation or sacrificing quiet, the air must be diverted through devices independent of the bottom of the door. Ventilation must pass through wall-mounted transfer silencers built into the party partition or through bypass ducts in the suspended ceiling fitted with sound absorbers.
- Identifying contradictory requirementsIdentify on the tender drawings the doors that combine a sound-sealing requirement under SIA 181 with a thermal note requiring an undercut for air transfer.
- Formal refusal of the acoustic undercutNotify site management in writing that it is physically impossible to achieve the acoustic values of an installed element if an air passage remains under the bottom of the leaf.
- Fitting a sealed automatic door bottomInstall an automatic drop-seal door bottom recessed into the groove in the bottom of the leaf, adjusted to press its elastomer lip firmly against the hard floor when the door closes.
- Fitting a Swiss-type threshold or a flat barWhere the floor has thick carpets or hollow joints, fix a perfectly levelled mechanical threshold to the floor on which the sealing gasket provides continuous compression.
Bottom sealing devices: automatic door bottom and Swiss-type threshold
To maintain the sound insulation required by SIA 181 on a demanding entrance or interior door without blocking the air transfers provided for in the ventilation design, the joiner must use active sealing systems at floor level. The mechanically triggered automatic door bottom, often called a drop seal, is the standard solution when the continuity of the floor covering rules out fitting a raised physical stop. Recessed in a groove cut in the underside of the bottom rail of the leaf, this fitting comprises an aluminium profile guiding a flexible extruded elastomer lip.
The recurring pitfall on construction sites is the flatness of the finished floor. If the screed or parquet has a dip or a bump of two millimetres under the door opening, the elastomer lip cannot compress uniformly. The residual gap lets sound waves pass through by direct airborne transmission, immediately degrading the overall sound reduction index of the installed element. The side plunger must be calibrated with an adjusting key so that it triggers the drop only during the last five degrees of the leaf's swing, thereby limiting the destructive rubbing of the seal against the floor.
Where requirements are severe, the surface-mounted or recessed Swiss-type threshold remains the essential mechanical reference. This rigid metal profile incorporates a stop against which a continuous sealing gasket mounted on the door panel strikes, thus creating a durable, tight mechanical barrier without relying solely on the vertical pressure of a spring mechanism.
| Bottom closing device | Average sound reduction provided | Impact on mechanical ventilation | Sensitivity to finished floor flatness |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard automatic door bottom (single elastomer lip) | Moderate: compensates for an air gap of up to 8 to 12 mm | Total sealing: prevents direct air transfer under the leaf | Very high: localised acoustic leak at the slightest dip in the floor |
| High-performance acoustic automatic door bottom (double hollow lip and brush seal) | High: ensures the continuity of a certified leaf | Total sealing of the bottom air passage | High: requires a levelling strip or a flat floor bar |
| Metal Swiss-type threshold with striking lip seal | Very high: sealing by compression on the low rebate | Total sealing: air flows must be rerouted | Low: the profile compensates for minor floor covering defects |
| Acoustic transfer channel in the bottom rail of the leaf | Low to moderate: sound attenuation by absorbent baffles | Allows a controlled air flow for ventilation | None: the channel is built into the body of the leaf |
Technical coordination and verification of in-situ performance
The sound insulation of the installed element does not depend solely on the factory data sheet certified in the laboratory on a rigid test frame. During the final acceptance measurement carried out according to SIA 181, the acoustics expert records the real sound reduction between two rooms, which includes flanking transmission through the wall connections, sealing defects of the frame and the fitting of the leaf. Where the building's ventilation plan prescribes air sweeping from one room to another without a secondary duct network, the joiner must under no circumstances agree to undercut an acoustic leaf on site without a written release from site management.
In practical terms, fitting the door begins by checking the floor level before installing the frame. If a textile covering or tiling has pronounced hollow joints under the path of the automatic door bottom, the joiner fits a flat bar in stainless steel or brushed brass, two millimetres thick, glued onto the finished floor. This bearing piece provides a continuous ground surface ensuring perfect compression of the elastomer across the full width of the opening.
The seal check is carried out simply on site using a sheet of paper inserted under the closed leaf: the clamping exerted by the lowered automatic door bottom must hold the sheet firmly along its whole length without it slipping freely. At the same time, the contact on the perimeter seal of the frame must be perfectly uniform from the top to the bottom of the jambs to prevent the pressure at the bottom of the leaf from pushing the leaf out of its rebate.
Non-compliant measurements and disputes: remedial method at the bottom of the leaf
When an in-situ acceptance acoustic measurement reveals an insulation shortfall against the requirements of SIA 181, the bottom of the leaf is the joiner's first point of investigation. A drop in the overall performance of the installed element almost invariably comes from an air-tightness defect at the finished floor, a poor adjustment of the automatic door bottom or an unresolved conflict with the ventilation system.
- Compression check of the automatic door bottomCheck that the plunger on the hinge side triggers when the leaf is fully closed. The elastomer lip must drop parallel to the floor and compress uniformly without bowing. The test with a sheet of paper trapped under the seal immediately locates the air leakage zones along the profile.
- Checking floor covering tolerancesMeasure the dips under the straightedge at the door swing. If the tiling or parquet has a deflection greater than the useful travel of the moving mechanism, the door bottom cannot guarantee sound sealing. Fitting a flat aluminium strip or a flat Swiss-type threshold under the door stop then becomes essential to restore a straight contact surface.
- Treating frame junctions and lower cornersInspect the junction between the striking seal of the jamb and the end of the recessed door bottom. A gap in the lower corners creates a direct sound bridge. Applying a corner sealing pad in closed-cell foam corrects this break in the perimeter seal.
- Formal resolution of the air-sweeping conflictIf the leaf has been undercut to compensate for the absence of a ventilation passage, immediately issue a written notice of anomaly to site management in accordance with SIA 118. The joiner must never cut the bottom of an acoustically certified door to create a ventilation undercut, as this would destroy the test certificate of the installed element. The ventilation engineer must specify an independent wall-mounted transfer silencer.
Frequently asked questions
Can an automatic door bottom make up for the hollow joints of rustic tiling?
No. The flexible silicone or EPDM lip does not penetrate deep tile joint hollows. Air seeps under the profile and degrades the sound insulation index. On an uneven floor, a perfectly flat metal Swiss-type threshold profile must be recessed or glued in to provide a continuous striking zone for the leaf's automatic door bottom.
Why do we refuse to undercut an acoustic door for dwelling ventilation?
Undercutting the leaf by ten millimetres creates a through opening that makes the real sound insulation fall below the thresholds set by SIA 181. To reconcile air renewal and sound comfort, the air transfer must take place through an acoustic transfer duct built into the transom or through a baffle silencer housed in the adjacent separating partition.
What difference in sound insulation is measured between a Swiss-type threshold and an automatic door bottom?
A Swiss-type threshold with a striking seal on a double rebate generally offers a gain of two to four decibels over a mobile automatic door bottom. However, the threshold creates a raised step at floor level that is often rejected by barrier-free accessibility standards, whereas the mechanical door bottom keeps a free, level passage while still meeting the contractual requirements.
How do you adjust an automatic door bottom that rubs before the door is fully closed?
The threaded mechanical plunger must be unscrewed or screwed in to adjust the moment of triggering precisely. The door bottom should drop only over the last millimetres of travel, just before the latch bolt engages in the strike plate. If the lip rubs too early, it wears prematurely, slows the leaf and compromises the final compression essential for acoustic sealing.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 181Protection against noise in buildings (in-situ sound insulation requirements)
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work (notice of anomaly and duties to inform)
