Key takeaways
- Trimming a leaf invalidates the AEAI certification, with no possibility of later regularisation on the construction site.
- The inspector enters the defect in the official report and blocks the issue of the occupancy permit.
- No filler or added strip can restore the original fire resistance.
- The joiner bears the full cost of manufacture, removal and new installation.
Recording of the infringement at the AEAI inspection and entry of the rejection
The acceptance of a fire-resistant door set requires the joint attention of site management and the fire protection authority, represented by the municipal building authority or the cantonal inspector. During the visit preceding the issue of the occupancy or operating permit, the authority systematically examines the fire-resistant closures delimiting the fire compartments. The most frequent case of serious non-conformity comes from an unauthorised adjustment: faced with an apartment or landing screed that is ten millimetres too high, the fitter trimmed the bottom of the door with a portable circular saw to free up the operating clearance.
When the expert inspects, the finding is immediate. The inspector checks the perimeter clearances with a feeler gauge, verifies the presence of the metal identification plate fixed on the edge on the hinge side and examines the bottom edge of the leaf. An exposed core, a cut-off intumescent seal, a visible fixing of a drop seal or the absence of the original veneered edge constitute material evidence of a structural modification not in conformity with the official test report.
- Visual and dimensional examinationThe inspector measures the lower gap between the panel and the finished floor, then checks the finish of the bottom edge against the manufacturer's requirements.
- Documentary checkCross-checking of the plate riveted to the frame or the leaf against the AEAI use certificate supplied in the as-built file.
- Entry of the remarkDrafting of a blocking non-conformity in the inspection minutes, accompanied by a formal order to bring the work into conformity, notified to the client.
The remark entered in the official report of the building authority fixes the administrative status of the building. The element is no longer regarded as an admissible fire protection device but as a simple unclosed opening within the meaning of the AEAI fire protection requirements. The direct consequence for the client is the refusal to issue the occupancy permit for the area concerned, giving rise to an immediate contractual formal notice to the interior joinery company.
Irreversibility of the downgrading and full cost of replacement
A fire door is not an ordinary wooden panel that can be rehabilitated by improvised workshop operations. Faced with the inspector's rejection, the temptation to attach a strip glued to the underside, to apply an intumescent paste or to refix a screwed profile is technically ruled out. The validity of the AEAI certificate rests exclusively on the strict conformity of the finished product with the specimen tested in an accredited laboratory.
- Integrity of the AEAI approval
- Inseparable nature of a certified door set, whose components (frame, leaf, hardware, seals and fixings) have successfully undergone the thermal and mechanical tests according to the reference standards. Any physical alteration not provided for by the manufacturer cancels the certificate of conformity.
No cantonal fire protection authority, no safety engineer and no reputable manufacturer will issue a certificate of conformity for a leaf modified outside the normative framework. As repair on site is impossible, the only outcome accepted by the building authority is the complete removal of the non-conforming panel and its replacement by a new factory-made element to the actual dimensions of the construction site.
| Inspection criterion | Conforming factory execution | Unauthorised trimming on the construction site |
|---|---|---|
| AEAI status | Valid certificate maintained | Total lapse of the approval |
| Permitted corrective action | Adjustment by regulating the hinges | Full replacement mandatory |
| Impact on the occupancy permit | Issued without fire reservation | Blocked until the finding is lifted |
| Financial responsibility | Included in the initial offer | Full costs charged to the joiner |
In financial and contractual terms, under the rules of the contract for work and the SIA 118 standard, where the delivered work has an irreparable defect caused by an execution fault of the tradesperson, the remedial work is entirely at the joiner's expense. The company must bear the urgent manufacture of a new leaf, the removal of the rejected element, the transfer of the approved fittings, the new installation with adjustment of the seals and any re-inspection costs invoiced by the municipal or cantonal fire prevention services.
Protective measures and replacement logistics for a non-conforming door set
From the formal notification of the rejection by the fire protection authority or the building authority, keeping a downgraded element in place blocks the issue of the occupancy permit or the authorisation to operate the compartment. A leaf trimmed at the bottom to compensate for a screed level that is too high immediately loses its AEAI fire protection approval. The internal structure in solid wood or mineral composite panel is exposed, the lower intumescent binder is destroyed and the clearances prescribed by the manufacturer become non-conforming. The team leader must under no circumstances attempt filling, closing with an added strip or applying an intumescent paint in the hope of validating the element.
- Validation of actual dimensions before manufactureThe joinery foreman personally retakes the one-metre level mark on the floor landing and measures the masonry opening and the exact thickness of the finished floor build-up (anhydrite screed, tiles or glued parquet). The order for the new leaf must include the net clear passage height, without ever reworking the work at the bottom edge.
- Methodical removal of the invalidated elementUnscrewing the hardware, extracting the leaf from its frame and, if the frame itself has been damaged or built in without respecting the tolerances of the AEAI certificate, careful extraction of the metal frame or the timber lining without detaching the approved fixing system from the partition.
- Physical neutralisation of the cut doorTo avoid any later dispute or attempt at clandestine transfer to an annex room not subject to fire requirements, the residual AEAI label is removed in the presence of site management, and the leaf is split or indelibly marked before being placed in the skip for wood recycling.
- Installation and sealing of the factory-certified door setFitting of the new element to the corrected execution dimensions. Rigid wedging with rot-proof wedges, perimeter packing with rock wool at the density defined by the manufacturer, and fitting of the intact intumescent seal at the bottom of the door according to the manufacturer's installation instructions.
Allocation of costs, recourse and coordination of the floor-door interfaces
In contractual and financial terms, the interior joinery company bears in full the costs of removal, express factory manufacture, transport and reinstallation of the door set if its fitter sawed the panel on his own initiative. Even where the screed poured by the screeding contractor is clearly raised in relation to the execution drawings of site management, having planed or cut the door without giving prior notice transfers the entire responsibility for the defect to the joiner. Under the Code of Obligations (CO) and the customary rules of the SIA 118 standard, a tradesperson who modifies an approved product destroys the manufacturer's warranty and commits a characterised execution fault.
| Situation found | Error made on the construction site | Decision of the building authority | Financial responsibility |
|---|---|---|---|
| Screed 12 mm too high | Trimming of the bottom of the door with a portable circular saw | Immediate rejection, non-conformity report, refusal of the occupancy permit | Interior joiner 100% (new supply and labour) |
| Screed outside SIA tolerance | Written notice of defects sent to site management before installation | Formal order for floor adjustment issued by site management | Screeding company or client depending on coordination |
| Floor joint not fire-tight | Removal of the intumescent seal to ease the clear passage | Invalidation of the fire compartment | Interior joiner (full certified restoration of conformity) |
| Door set received from factory with wrong dimensions | Forced installation with friction without prior check of the clearance | Rejection at the automatic closing function test | Interior joiner or door supplier depending on the original order |
To protect the workshop against major outlays, the joinery site manager must introduce a strict operating rule: no cutting tool may be used to adjust the height of a certified fire door leaf. As soon as a level deviation is found in relation to the official level mark, the fitter must suspend the fixing of the element and draft a notice of substrate non-conformity. If the client nevertheless requires the floor level to be maintained without reworking the screed, ordering a special made-to-measure door with a specific approval remains the only legal route accepted by the fire inspectors.
Crisis management after official rejection: replacement protocol and arbitration of costs
The finding made during the conformity visit by the fire protection authority or the building authority is final: any fire door leaf whose lower strip has been cut on the construction site to make up for a screed that is too high immediately loses its AEAI approval. The remark entered in the expert report blocks the granting of the occupancy or operating permit. Faced with this major non-conformity, the joiner has no room for technical negotiation.
- Notification and joint inspection recordReceive the formal notification from the authority, check the reference of the door set in question and record the impossibility of documentary regularisation with the manufacturer.
- Express manufactureTake the actual execution dimensions including the finished level of the completed floor, then place the priority order for a leaf calibrated in the factory with its certificate of origin.
- Removal and substitutionDismantle the downgraded leaf, install the new approved element without any mechanical rework and affix the permanent identification plate on the edge.
- Lifting of the reservation and closureSend the updated declaration of conformity to the building authority to obtain the final lifting of the reservation before the handover of the keys.
In financial terms, the cost of the full replacement falls on the joiner if the trimming was carried out on his own initiative to conceal a third party's level error. In the absence of a formal notice of stoppage sent to site management reporting the incorrect floor level, the joinery company bears all the costs: urgent manufacture, transport, removal, reinstallation and restoration of the finishing paintwork.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a trimming tolerance on the bottom of a fire door?
Only trims expressly documented in the AEAI certificate and the manufacturer's installation instructions are permitted, generally limited to a few millimetres protected by a specific strip. If the tradesperson cuts into the fire-resistant core or removes the original fire-resistant strip to clear a badly wedged parquet floor, the door loses its technical approval. No building authority inspector issues a derogation for an empirical trim carried out on the construction site.
Can a trimmed leaf be re-approved on site by an accredited body?
No. No inspection institute issues a certificate case by case for a leaf modified on the construction site. Approvals rest on furnace tests standardised according to the AEAI directives. As soon as the intumescent barrier or the protective wood mass is compromised, the impossibility of repairing an altered element is legally binding. The only technical solution is to replace the leaf with a new element manufactured to the exact dimensions by the factory holding the approval.
Who pays for the replacement leaf if the screed was poured too high?
If the joiner trimmed the door without giving prior notice of the non-conforming level, he alone bears the replacement costs under the rules of the contract for work. To pass the cost on to the screed trade or the mason, the joiner had to record the level defect in writing before intervening and demand a formal instruction from site management. Without this step, his unauthorised modification engages his full financial liability.
Which document must be submitted to the building authority to lift the infringement?
The authority requires the installer's declaration of conformity signed by the installation company, accompanied by a copy of the valid AEAI certificate supplied by the manufacturer. At the re-inspection, the inspector physically checks the presence of the permanent metal plate riveted on the edge of the door, as well as strict compliance with the clearance under the leaf according to the test requirements. Once these elements are validated, the remark is officially struck from the register.
Texts and standards cited
- Directives de protection incendie AEAISwiss fire protection requirements on fire-resistant closures and their conformity
- Norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and management of defects in the work
