Key takeaways
- Any cut made after manufacture voids AEAI conformity and destroys the fire-resisting properties of the work.
- Vision panels and ventilation grilles must be fitted at the factory in accordance with recognised test reports.
- The joiner must refuse in writing any late request for cutting made on the construction site.
- Only complete replacement of the leaf guarantees that the prescribed level of fire protection is maintained.
AEAI approval prohibits any subsequent cutting into the leaf
A certified EI30 or EI60 fire door assembly is not a simple wooden panel that can be notched at will. It is an inseparable construction system, subjected to strict thermal tests in an accredited laboratory in order to obtain a certificate of use issued by the Association of Cantonal Fire Insurance Institutions (AEAI). The integrity of the complex core, the boring frames, the arrangement of the perimeter reinforcements and the layers of intumescent products react together when the temperature rises. As soon as a circular saw or jigsaw cut passes through the facing of a finished leaf on the construction site, the internal structure is broken, the fire behaviour becomes unpredictable and the approval plate fixed on the rebate instantly loses all legal value.
| Technical criterion | Industrial execution under licence | Makeshift cutting on the construction site |
|---|---|---|
| Inner frame | Bore in hardwood or bonded fire-resistant mineral material | Core exposed, friable and without supporting reinforcement |
| Intumescent seals | Calibrated heat-expanding strips glued in a groove | No gas-tight containment against hot gases |
| Glazing system | Specific fire-resistant glass with glazing beads screwed at an angle | Ordinary or poorly wedged glass causing flashover |
| Administrative status | Valid AEAI plate and declaration of conformity | Loss of approval and complete downgrading of the door |
Incorporating a glazed vision panel or a ventilation grille requires design in the factory. For glazing, the manufacturer integrates an internal frame surrounding the opening with non-combustible fire-resistant profiles, high-expansion intumescent seals and precise thickness wedging to receive a fire-resistant laminated glass. For a pressure relief or air transfer grille, the assembly incorporates an element with heat-fusible slats that expand at a defined temperature to seal the void. The slightest perforation for a cat flap, a serving hatch or a letter slot not documented in the manufacturer's certificate constitutes a direct thermal bridge, accelerating the passage of flames and toxic smoke.
Handling the request for on-site modification and formalising the written refusal
Site managers and clients frequently misunderstand the strict constraints of fire-resisting closures. Faced with an omission in the plans, an unforeseen fitting-out of a room or the need to light a windowless corridor, the request to open a glazed aperture in a leaf that has already been delivered is a recurring one. The joiner must never give in to this oral instruction, even under the promise of a signed discharge of liability from the site management. In matters of fire safety, a simple private discharge does not prevail over the requirements of the fire police directives and does not remove the consequences of work that does not comply with the rules of the art.
- Establish the incompatibility with the approvalCheck the AEAI certificate number shown on the metal plate of the leaf. Consult the manufacturer's data sheet to point out that no through machining is permitted outside the certified workshop.
- Notify the formal refusal in writingImmediately send a formal notice of defects to the site management. Draft an unambiguous document stating that the requested cutting voids the certification of the work and contravenes the fire protection directives.
- Propose replacement with a factory-machined leafSubmit a supplementary offer for the removal of the solid leaf and the supply of a new leaf machined in the factory with approved vision panel or grille, accompanied by their complete declaration of conformity.
Workshop manufacture: certified integration of glazing and openings
The integration of a glazed vision panel or a grille can never be improvised on an existing fire door. Any opening made in a certified leaf changes the distribution of mass and the thermal inertia when exposed to flames. For a door to retain its EI 30 or EI 60 resistance class according to the AEAI fire protection directory, each cut-out must imperatively be made in the factory during initial assembly. The manufacturer machines the cut-out in the solid fire-resistant core, made of high-density fireproofed particleboard or calcium silicate, before the decorative facings are fitted. The inner edges receive a frame in hardwood or non-combustible mineral material. This reinforcement stabilises the structure, ensures the hold of the fixings and limits the transmission of heat to the unexposed face.
Thermal insulation and smoke tightness depend on an assembly tested as an inseparable whole. Fire-resistant glazing based on intumescent gel requires a rebate bottom lined with foaming strips and supports made of refractory ceramic fibres. The glazing beads, in dense wood or profiled steel, must be screwed at a spacing strictly in accordance with the manufacturer's test report. Likewise, original fire-resistant ventilation grilles incorporate intumescent slats that expand to seal the air passage hermetically. Their box must be sealed into the core of the door with intumescent sealants and fixings tested in an accredited laboratory.
| Equipment item | Approved factory integration | On-site intervention prohibited | Consequence for safety |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glazed vision panel | Digitally controlled cut-out in the core, perimeter frame reinforcement, certified glazing beads and glazing. | Manual cutting with a plunge saw in the solid leaf once installed. | Breach of EI insulation, immediate escape of smoke, loss of AEAI conformity. |
| Air transfer grille | Certified box with intumescent slats sealed with calibrated heat-expanding seals. | Direct recessing of a standard or fire-resistant grille without core reinforcement. | Thermal collapse under the action of hot gases, spread of the fire. |
| Motorised cable passage | Original longitudinal axial drilling with fire-resistant sleeve integrated in the mass. | Transverse drilling or core drilling on site to fit a lock or strike plate. | Structural weakening of the leaf, perforation of the core and a through hot spot. |
| Cat flap or low hatch | No approval possible in the AEAI directory for these devices. | Free cutting in the lower part for the passage of animals or ducts. | Irreparable destruction of the fire compartmentation, categorical refusal of acceptance. |
Technical passages intended for home automation, evacuation control or access control are subject to the same laboratory requirements. Incorporating an electric strike, a motorised bolt or an articulated cable transfer requires a longitudinal axial drilling carried out in the workshop on a stationary machine. Any attempt to run conductors through a finished leaf by makeshift drilling destroys the insulating core, creates a dangerous thermal bridge and compromises the stability of the door in a real fire.
Change requests on site: refusal procedure and replacement solutions
During the works, the joiner faces unforeseen requests from the site management or an operator. Whether it is a matter of creating a view onto a corridor, inserting a transfer grille or fitting a cat flap, the refusal must be categorical. Machining an approved element on site destroys its compartmentation function and breaches the rules of the art. Under the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118, the contractor has a strict duty to notify when faced with non-compliant orders. Agreeing to alter a panel directly engages his civil and professional liability. In the event of an inspection by the fire authority, the client may require the complete replacement of the door assembly at the installer's sole expense.
- Immediate notification of the technical refusalInform the requester on the spot that any manual perforation on the construction site results in the cancellation of the approval certificate of the work.
- Sending a formal notice of stoppageSend a written notice without delay to the site management citing the AEAI regulations and the impossibility of carrying out the requested cutting.
- Proposal of compliant alternativesSubmit an offer for the factory manufacture of a new leaf with a certified cut-out, or relocate the grille to a partition with a dedicated damper.
- Recording in the site minutesRequire the refusal to be entered in the works log in order to prevent any unauthorised or clandestine intervention later by an uninformed third party.
Conflict on the construction site and damage by a third party: safeguarding procedure
On the construction site, schedule pressure sometimes leads the site management or an agent to demand the direct cutting of a fire door leaf in order to insert a vision panel or a transfer grille omitted from the order. Faced with a verbal or written instruction, the joiner's position remains unchanged: mechanical intervention on the core of a certified door instantly destroys its conformity with the AEAI fire protection regulations. Yielding to urgency directly engages the liability of the installation company in the event of a fire.
When the order to carry out a cut is maintained despite the technical explanations, the foreman drafts a formal notice of refusal in accordance with standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO). This document states that the door delivered corresponds to the approved plans and that any perforation on site voids the manufacturer's declaration of conformity and results in the withdrawal of the approval plate. The letter invites the client to order a new element manufactured in the factory with certified cut-outs.
- Immediate record: photograph the door, the unauthorised cut and the AEAI plate of the leaf.
- Written notification: send a damage report to the site management releasing the joiner from liability.
- Making safe: report the altered element to those responsible for fire safety in the building.
- Replacement order: draw up a quote for the supply and installation of a factory-approved door.
If the client refuses replacement and insists on keeping the altered door, the joiner must remove the identification label fixed on the edge. He records this removal in the site minutes in order to avoid any ambiguity at acceptance by the cantonal fire protection authority.
Frequently asked questions
Can a circular vision panel be cut with a router in an installed EI30 leaf?
No. No vision panel cutting is tolerated on the construction site. Integrating fire-resistant glazing requires specific bores, a dimensioned perimeter intumescent strip, certified glazing with its original glazing bead system and internal reinforcements integrated during factory pressing. Machining on site destroys the fire-resistant core, voids the AEAI approval and makes the door non-compliant at the acceptance inspection by the fire authority.
The site management demands a low ventilation grille: how do I formalise the refusal?
The refusal is made in writing on the same day by means of a detailed notice sent to the site management. State that manually cutting into a fire door breaches the AEAI fire protection regulations and removes the validity of the approval. Specify that the supply of a fire-resistant grille added on site is not covered by the manufacturer's certificate and propose ordering a leaf produced in the factory.
What should be done if a technical installer cuts into a fire door to run a cable?
The joiner must immediately notify the alteration in writing to the site management, supported by photographs. The element has lost its certified fire-resistant and smoke-tight properties. No makeshift sealing can restore the certification of a moving leaf. The only compliant measure is to order a new replacement leaf manufactured in the workshop, with the costs chargeable to the company responsible for the damage.
Is there any tolerance for fitting a cat flap in an EI30 apartment entrance door?
There is no tolerance. Apartment entrance doors must guarantee strict fire separation and smoke tightness in accordance with the AEAI. Fitting a cat flap creates a direct opening through which hot gases and toxic smoke pass instantly in the event of a fire in the stairwell. There is no standard cat flap component approved for on-site cutting; such a modification must be categorically refused.
Texts and standards cited
- Norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and handling of the contractor's formal notices.
- Prescriptions de protection incendie AEAIDirectives on the use and maintenance of conformity of approved fire-resisting closures.
- Code des obligationsGeneral rules governing the contract for work and the contractor's duty to notify.
