Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 273Fire doors: approval and integrityChapter 2 of 10 in the section

Trimming the bottom: the permitted limit, and the approval lost at the next millimetre

Fitting a fire door on a finished floor that is uneven or too high confronts the joiner with the trimming dilemma. This chapter explains how to identify the adjustment margin allowed by the approval, avoid invalidating the test report and deal with screed level deviations without risking rejection by the fire protection authority.

Key takeaways

  • Trimming the bottom rail depends exclusively on the AEAI approval specific to each manufacturer.
  • Exceeding the manufacturer's tolerance destroys the official approval and voids the conformity of the work.
  • The building control authority orders complete replacement as soon as a bottom edge sawn beyond tolerance is found.
  • Prior coordination of the screed levels avoids destructive sawing of the fire door.

The trimming margin allowed by the AEAI certificate and the impact on the bottom rail core

On a building construction site, fitting a door between an underground car park and a stairwell regularly causes level problems. The self-levelling screed or the tiling often stands proud of the one-metre level mark drawn on the formwork panels. When a leaf rubs or will not enter the rebate, the reflex of notching or sawing the bottom of the door with a plunge saw on a rail is a major technical error. A fire protection door is not an ordinary joinery panel but a fire-resisting element tested in a laboratory and certified.

AEAI certificate of use
Official Swiss document issued by the Association of Cantonal Fire Insurance Institutions (AEAI), certifying the fire-resistance performance of a building element according to standardised tests and setting the strict limits for modification in the workshop or on site.

The Association of Cantonal Fire Insurance Institutions records in the certificate of each model the geometric modifications that are permitted. Some manufacturers allow the underside to be trimmed by 5 mm, others up to 15 mm, while several systems prohibit any planing on pain of immediate downgrading. This restriction is explained by the internal composition of the leaf. The bottom rail core contains a rail of dense wood or calcium-silicate material that ensures rigidity, protects the insulating core against direct combustion and receives the groove for the automatic drop seal.

Typical limits for modifying the bottom of the leaf according to door structures
Type of panelPermissible bottom marginConsequence of exceeding itAdministrative penalty
Light tubular solid core0 to 5 mm according to data sheetExposure of the internal cellsImmediate rejection of the element
30-min fire-resisting composite panel10 to 15 mm with re-cutting of the bottom railWeakening of the bottom rail reinforcementLoss of the AEAI test report
Heavy 60-min fire-resisting panelStrictly 0 mm without approvalDestruction of the intumescent stripsComplete replacement of the door set
Acoustic and fire-resisting entrance doorTolerance tied to the hardwareFailure of sound and smoke sealingRefusal of the occupancy permit

The finding of non-conformity by the building control authority and the compulsory remedial work

At the final acceptance of the finishing work, the municipal fire safety officer or the representative of the building control authority systematically checks the integrity of the entrance doors. The check starts with the nameplate riveted to the edge of the leaf, showing the AEAI registration number and the resistance class. The inspector then measures the functional gap between the underside of the panel and the finished floor. A gap larger than the prescribed tolerance, often set at 6 or 8 mm depending on whether or not there is a metal threshold, immediately reveals unauthorised trimming.

Any modification made to a fire-resisting closure element that is not expressly authorised in the manufacturer's declaration of conformity or in the recognition certificate renders the certificate void for the element concerned.

AEAI fire protection directives

If the joiner has removed too much material to clear a bump in the screed, the test report loses all legal validity. The authority accepts no corrective improvisation on site: attaching a glued strip to the underside, screwing on a flat steel bar or injecting an intumescent sealant does not restore the fire resistance of an assembly proven in a furnace. The penalty is final. As the approval test report is null and void, the building control authority records the defect in the inspection report and blocks the issue of the occupancy permit for the building's stairwell.

  1. Survey of the actual levelMeasure the distance between the official level mark and the finished screed in front of each opening to the car park before fitting any frame.
  2. Reading the technical documentationConsult the AEAI certificate of use and the manufacturer's workshop data sheet to identify the maximum trimming dimension at the bottom rail.
  3. Formal notice to site managementReport immediately in writing any finished floor level outside tolerances so that the mason has the screed corrected before the leaf is touched.
  4. Fitting the replacement leafOrder a new door made to measure at the factory if non-conforming trimming has already damaged the certified structure of the element.

Invalidity of the AEAI test report and refusal of acceptance of the work

On a construction site for a collective underground car park or an administrative building, the entrance door to the airlock is a decisive fire boundary in the smoke and fire compartmentation. The fitting of these fire-resisting closures is tied to a certificate of use issued by the Association of Cantonal Fire Insurance Institutions. The element delivered to site forms an inseparable system, certified by a test report from an approved laboratory. As soon as trimming on site exceeds the tolerance specified in the manufacturer's technical notice, the element instantly loses its legal conformity.

Each fire-resisting leaf carries on its top edge or on the hinge side an indelible metal identification plate showing the manufacturer, the AEAI approval number, the fire-resistance class and the year of manufacture. By signing the declaration of conformity for the work, the joiner attests on his honour that the door set was fitted in strict compliance with the manufacturer's requirements and the AEAI fire protection directives. When the cantonal fire safety delegate or the building control inspector examines the bottom of the door with a feeler gauge, any excessive air gap to the finished floor or any bottom rail planed beyond the critical threshold voids the evidential value of this document.

Technical and administrative consequences of interventions on the bottom rail
Situation foundAEAI approval statusImpact on seals and hardwareDecision of the fire authority
Trimming within the limit of the manufacturer's notice (generally 3 to 5 mm)Test report fully validAutomatic drop seal groove and intumescent seals preservedAcceptance without reservation if the floor gap is respected
Trimming exceeding the manufacturer's limit (from 1 mm too much)Immediate loss of validity of the AEAI certificateWeakening or destruction of the bottom fixing railRefusal of conformity, formal notice to restore
Solid bottom rail trimmed, then a piece of wood glued on siteApproval void, aggravated non-conformityFire behaviour untested (glue failure under heat)Categorical rejection at the end-of-site inspection
Floor air gap above the smoke-sealing limit valueLoss of the combined sealing function (e.g. EI30-S200)Automatic drop seal outside its mechanical travelOccupancy permit blocked until certified correction

Forced removal, urgent order and handling of the site dispute

The finding of a car park entrance door trimmed too short triggers a cascade of organisational penalties. In this technical compartment, the door provides the thermal barrier against hot gases and toxic smoke generated by a vehicle fire. If the rebate depth or the finished floor height was not anticipated by site management when the screed was poured or the mastic asphalt laid, the joiner can on no account compensate for this level error by planing the element beyond the factory tolerances.

Once the building control authority has notified its refusal, the only way of regularisation accepted by the AEAI is to replace the non-conforming leaf entirely with a new leaf manufactured in the workshop under certified production control. The original hardware, in particular the fire-resisting multipoint lock and the standard-compliant slide-arm door closer, can be reused only if its integrity suffered no damage during the initial installation. Ordering a made-to-measure replacement leaf entails a factory manufacturing lead time that collides directly with the move-in dates of tenants or co-owners.

  1. Joint check of the floor levelsSurvey the actual level at the threshold with site management and the screed layer to determine the origin of the deviation from the official one-metre level mark.
  2. Careful removal of the downgraded panelDismantle the non-conforming leaf without damaging the sealed metal frame or the solid-wood frame, then recover the certified hardware that can be reused.
  3. Expedited manufacture of a suitable leafOrder from the licensed manufacturer a new factory-made leaf to the exact dimensions of the frame opening with the fire-resisting bottom rails intact.
  4. Fitting, adjusting the threshold seal and reissuing the certificateInstall the new leaf, adjust the drop of the automatic drop seal, check the perimeter gaps and sign a new AEAI certificate of conformity handed to the building control authority.

In contractual and financial terms, under the general rules of the contract for work in the Code of Obligations (CO), the tradesman bears the cost of the remade part if he carried out destructive cutting on his own initiative instead of suspending the fitting and notifying site management of a floor anomaly. To prevent a single cut with a portable circular saw from leading to the scrapping of an element worth several thousand francs, measuring the opening heights beforehand to the millimetre remains the only guarantee of the integrity of the work.

Intervention protocol in the event of refusal of approval at floor level

When an inspection by the building control authority or the cantonal fire protection authority finds an excessive gap under the door or trimming outside tolerance on an underground car park access, the conformity report is rejected immediately. Physically modifying the panel beyond the limits set by the manufacturer destroys the validity of the certificate of conformity issued under the AEAI regime. Any attempt at patching by adding material to the underside is excluded by the Swiss rules of building practice.

  1. Joint inspection record of the undercut dimensionThe foreman measures the air gap between the bottom of the leaf and the finished threshold at three distinct points: hinge side, centre and strike side. The manufacturer's data sheet and the AEAI certificate of conformity must be produced on the spot to check the minimum remaining thickness of the hardwood bottom rail and the maximum permitted gap.
  2. Examination of the AEAI test report and contact with the manufacturerThe joiner asks the technical department of the manufacturing plant whether a derogating floor-sealing variant is included in the original approval. If the manufacturer confirms that the scope of the approval has been exceeded, no improvisation can restore the fire-resistance class.
  3. Removal of the non-conforming leaf and urgent orderThe invalidated leaf is kept on the construction site as material evidence. A priority replacement order is placed, stating the exact finished clear opening dimension and taking into account any false levels in the screed or the car park resin to avoid any readjustment on site.

Replacement with a new element involves delivery of a new factory-made leaf fitted with its indelible metal nameplate riveted to the edge. The fitting supervisor then completes a new installation report for the fire safety file intended for the municipal authority.

Frequently asked questions

Is there a standard trimming tolerance for a fire-resisting leaf?

Each leaf has its own limits defined by its AEAI certificate. As a general rule, manufacturers allow planing of the bottom edge of between 5 and 10 millimetres, only on the solid-wood bottom rail. Some models strictly allow no trimming because of integrated tie rods or intumescent strips. It is imperative to consult the approval sheet before making any saw cut on the construction site.

Can a drop seal be fitted after the bottom of the leaf has been sawn too much?

No, this improvised modification is refused at acceptance of the work. Recessing an automatic drop seal requires specific machining carried out at the factory and validated in the official fire tests. Cutting a groove in an already weakened panel destroys the thermal barrier and voids the AEAI test report. The cantonal authority will require the complete removal and replacement with a new closure element.

How does the fire inspector check for over-trimming at the foot of a door?

The inspector checks the remaining gap between the bottom of the leaf and the floor with a calibrated gauge, the tolerated gap often being limited to a few millimetres. He also inspects the bottom edge with an inspection mirror to check for the presence and thickness of the protective hardwood bottom rail. If the insulating inner core is visible or if the floor gap exceeds the approval, the work is declared non-conforming.

Who bears the financial cost of the replacement leaf on the construction site?

Responsibility depends on the initial finding recorded in the site diary. If the joiner cut the panel on his own initiative to clear a screed that was too high without giving written notice, the cost of remanufacture and fitting remains his responsibility. If, on the other hand, site management ordered the trimming in writing, the expense falls to the client.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work

In the same section