Key takeaways
- The overall flatness and plumb of the carcasses determine all subsequent adjustments of the fronts.
- A finished fitted installation is judged visually by the millimetre-level regularity of the open gaps between panels.
- Hardware with three-dimensional adjustment corrects fine alignments but does not make up for poor shimming.
- The acceptance minutes under SIA 118 record the reservations together with a deadline for execution.
Geometric check: plumb of carcasses, flushness and tolerances of open gaps
The appearance of a high-end fitted installation depends on the rigour of its visible geometry. The eye immediately notices a break in a three-millimetre open gap or a front that is out of flush with its neighbour. During the preliminary check, however, verification does not start with the doors but with the load-bearing structure of the cabinet carcasses. If the carcasses are twisted or out of plumb, no hardware will give clean, lasting sight lines.
| Item checked | Measuring tool | Nominal value | Permissible tolerance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Verticality of carcasses and uprights | 200 cm spirit level or laser | 90° to the finished floor | ± 1 mm per metre of height |
| Horizontality of worktops and fascias | 200 cm aluminium straightedge and level | Zero reference level | ± 1 mm over 2 running metres |
| Width of gaps between adjacent fronts | Calibrated feeler gauges | 3 mm (according to detail drawing) | ± 0.5 mm deviation over the height |
| Flushness of two closed fronts | Steel rule or feeler gauge | Perfect plane (0 mm) | Maximum deviation below 0.5 mm |
Flushness is checked by running a finger over the adjoining edges of doors and drawers, then checking flatness with a straightedge placed diagonally. A misalignment visible in raking light frequently comes from carcass twist caused by over-tight wall fixings on an uneven masonry wall. The fitter must then loosen the anchors and make up the void with non-deformable fork shims before touching the fine-adjustment screws.
- Check the level of the independent plinths before the final fitting of the base units.
- Check the parallelism of the internal diagonals of the carcasses to confirm the factory squareness.
- Adjust the depth of the drawers to obtain a strictly flat alignment with the neighbouring doors.
- Test the soft-close damping to eliminate any rebound or rubbing on the edge of the unit.
Joint acceptance procedure, notification of defects and clearance of reservations
Acceptance of a joinery fitted installation takes place once fitting is fully complete, after sawdust has been cleaned up, protective films removed and the runners dusted. It is carried out jointly between the contractor and the site management or the client. Under the contractual framework governed by SIA 118, this step marks the transfer of risk and starts the warranty periods for defects.
- Functional and visual checkCareful examination of every moving element: opening all drawers, operating lift-up doors, testing push-to-open mechanisms and checking overall flatness under normal ambient light.
- Drawing up the joint minutesWritten record of the findings in a document signed on site by both parties. The work is either accepted without reservation, accepted with reservations for minor defects, or refused in the case of major defects preventing the agreed use.
- Precise description of the reservationsEach imperfection must be located exactly (for example: 'top drawer of base unit 03 offset 1.5 mm downwards; 2 cm scratch on upright of wall unit').
- Setting the rectification scheduleAllocation of a deadline for the fitting team's intervention, agreed between the joiner and the site management, generally set between ten and twenty working days.
- Clearance check and closureFinal inspection of the corrected points, endorsed by the site management, which releases the balance of the guarantee retentions or authorises the final invoice.
A well-worded technical reservation avoids fruitless disputes. Instead of stating 'fitted installation unsatisfactory', the minutes must state precisely the corrective action expected: 'redo the left lateral gap of the cladding panel' or 'replace the lacquered door of the sink unit showing a chip on the underside'. Once the finishes have been redone and the fronts realigned, signing the reservation clearance slip formally discharges the fitting team.
What can be adjusted on site: three-dimensional hardware, runners and fine adjustments
When inspecting a fitted installation visually, the reflex of the client or the architect is often to blame the panel or the carcass as soon as a misalignment or an uneven gap catches the eye. For the fitting foreman, the fundamental distinction lies between deviations that the kinematics of the hardware can absorb and structural defects requiring rework in the workshop. All current hardware for wall-hung units and base carcasses incorporates micrometric compensation screws on three axes.
| Mechanical component | Adjustment axis | Compensation range | Direct visual consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hinge mounting plate and arm | Height (vertical) | ± 2.0 mm to ± 3.0 mm | Alignment of the top edge of the doors with the filler line |
| Hinge overlay screw | Lateral (open gap) | - 1.5 mm to + 3.0 mm | Parallelism of the vertical gap between two adjacent doors |
| Depth eccentric | Depth (flushness) | - 1.0 mm to + 2.5 mm | Continuity of plane between two adjacent front faces |
| Drawer front fixing bracket | Height and lateral | ± 2.0 mm / ± 1.5 mm | Centring of the front in the opening and regularity of the open gaps |
| Drawer tilt adjuster | Tilt (vertical inclination) | ± 2.5 mm | Flushness of the upper front against the neighbouring carcasses |
Gaps are never adjusted front by front in isolation. A strict sequence is required, starting with levelling the plinth and carcasses to plumb, checked with a spirit level or precision laser. If the carcasses show diagonal twist due to a distorted rough wall, no hardware will restore a constant open gap. Mechanically fixing the end filler locks the final geometry of the run; only once the unit is clamped can the fine adjustment of the gaps be carried out.
What constitutes a defect: localised reservations, clearance and application of SIA 118
When the deviation cannot be compensated by the hardware, the work falls within the scope of defects in the contractual sense. Under Swiss construction rules, acceptance of a fitted installation is carried out according to SIA 118. The assessment of tolerances leaves no room for subjectivity: a cumulative out-of-plumb of more than 2 mm over the height of a two-metre column, or a warp of a solid-wood door exceeding the tolerances allowed for derived timber panels, constitutes a defect that must be the subject of a reservation entered in the joint acceptance minutes.
During the acceptance walk-round with the site management, the joinery foreman makes sure that each remark is recorded factually. Vague entries such as 'finishes to be redone' must be avoided. The minutes must specify the precise nature of the reservation, its exact location on the layout plan and the type of intervention expected: additional adjustment, adjustment of a sealing gasket, or outright replacement of a scratched or delaminated panel.
- Unambiguous designation of the disputed element: identification by unit number or front reference on the approved fitting plans.
- Technical classification of the anomaly: distinction between a minor aesthetic defect (micro-scratch visible under direct lighting), an assembly defect (non-parallel spacing exceeding the tolerance) and a functional defect (mechanical impact on the damper, jammed extraction).
- Joint setting of the clearance deadline: formal agreement on an intervention date taking account of any remanufacturing time for veneered or lacquered components.
- Organisation of the clearance inspection: spot check limited exclusively to the points recorded in the table of reservations, without reopening the whole work.
Handling disputes at acceptance: disagreement over gaps and contested reservations
When the three-dimensional adjustment of the hinges or runners reaches its mechanical stop without removing a misalignment or an uneven gap, the technical situation quickly turns into a contractual disagreement. This mainly occurs when a carcass has followed the twists of a rough masonry wall or an out-of-tolerance screed, forcing the unit without sufficient compensating shims. In front of the site management, invoking the quality of a veneer or the make of the hardware to justify a misalignment is ineffective. Only geometric regularity checked with a straightedge counts.
In the event of a proven technical reservation concerning uneven gaps or out-of-plumb, immediately agree on a precise schedule of work. SIA 118 provides for setting a reasonable period for execution of the remedial work on the defects reported. The operating procedure requires removing the fronts concerned, checking the flatness of the carcass with a precision spirit level, then unscrewing the links between carcasses to insert tapered shims or rip down a compensating filler. Once the gaps have been evened out to between three and four millimetres over the full height, arrange a limited follow-up visit restricted to the reserved points only.
If disagreement persists on the permissible limit of the gap, the parties may appoint a neutral expert from the joinery trade or request arbitration by the cantonal professional association. This technical finding fixes the situation before any disproportionate financial retention on the final invoice.
Frequently asked questions
How should you react if the architect refuses full acceptance because of a single warped unit door?
Under SIA 118, a minor defect does not justify refusing the work as a whole. You must require the acceptance minutes to be drawn up recording acceptance of the fitted installation with a localised reservation. This reservation expressly provides for replacement or straightening of the front concerned, without permitting a total blocking of payments already due.
What standard deadline should be set for clearing a front alignment reservation?
SIA 118 stipulates that the client grants the contractor a reasonable period. For a simple machining or hardware adjustment, intervention within ten to fifteen working days is common. If the reservation requires remanufacturing a lacquered or re-veneered door in the workshop, allow a realistic period of three to four weeks.
Who bears the cost of dismantling if the out-of-plumb comes from a distorted partition?
If the joiner failed to report the non-conformity of the substrate in writing before fitting, he bears technical responsibility. The shimming and adjustment rework is his responsibility. If, on the other hand, a formal notice concerning the structural work was given beforehand, the remedial work is an additional service paid for under the contract.
How should the final clearance of reservations be formalised after work on the construction site?
Draw up a reservation clearance slip listing each point of the initial minutes. Have the evened-out gaps and the corrected plumb confirmed jointly with the site management. The joint signature of this document definitively clears the apparent defects recorded and starts the warranties provided for by SIA 118.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: acceptance of the work, notice of defects, setting of rectification deadlines and warranty regime.
