Key takeaways
- The diagonal transforms rectangular frames into non-deformable triangles to absorb horizontal thrust.
- Any unilateral removal of bracing without technical compensation jeopardises the temporary structure.
- Standard SN EN 12811 mandates a continuous longitudinal layout transferring loads down to the ground.
- Access openings require manufacturer-approved bridging beams or reinforcements.
Mechanical function of the diagonal and requirements of standard SN EN 12811
On a building construction site, the façade diagonal is regularly seen as an obstacle by finishing trades. Painters, plasterers or window installers frequently try to unhook these steel tube bars on the grounds that they block access to an opening or hinder the handling of staging platforms. For the scaffolding erector (CFC 212), however, the longitudinal diagonal is not an optional accessory, but the fundamental stiffening element that prevents the structure from racking into a parallelogram under the action of horizontal forces.
- Longitudinal bracing
- A triangulated structural system connecting successive standards on the outer face of the scaffolding. It ensures rigidity in the plane parallel to the façade and transmits wind loads or dynamic impacts to the anchors and base plates.
Standard SN EN 12811 sets the performance and design requirements for façade scaffolding. According to this technical benchmark, the connections between standards and ledgers function as pinned joints and not as fully rigid connections. Without an oblique element creating a rigid triangulation, the structure has no inherent resistance to longitudinal shear. Stresses from wind on the façade, but also winch braking or worker movements, cause progressive deformation that overloads the anchor ties to the point of pull-out.
| Configuration | Façade plane rigidity | Load on neighbouring anchors | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compliant triangulated bay | Maximum via triangulation | Evenly distributed axial forces | None under normal conditions of use |
| Diagonal removed (open bay) | Zero (functions as a deformable frame) | Massive shear transfer onto anchor ties | Buckling of standards and total collapse |
The bracing layout specified in the manufacturer's technical instructions must be strictly followed from the very first lift. In most frame systems approved in Switzerland, this layout requires a diagonal at least every four to five bays, running continuously from the base to the top, or a continuous zigzag arrangement (bracing tower). The diagonal must be locked to the standard in the immediate vicinity of the node by a wedge coupler or a tilting pin.
Approved technical solutions to clear construction site access
When a building entrance door, a pedestrian walkway under a covered gallery or a supply opening coincides with the position of a diagonal, the erector must never simply omit the component. The accepted rules of the art require immediate compensation for the loss of rigidity by transferring the load to adjacent bays. Art. 229 CP provides for a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty for anyone who intentionally departs from the rules of the art when directing or carrying out a building structure, knowingly endangering the life or physical integrity of persons.
- Shifting the braced bayIf the pattern of façade openings permits, the diagonal is shifted to the immediately adjacent bay, provided that the overall triangulation scheme remains balanced and complies with the manufacturer's instructions.
- Installation of a bridging beamTo open a wide opening without ground support, a steel or aluminium lattice girder 30 cm to 50 cm deep is installed, secured with heavy-duty right-angle couplers to re-establish a non-deformable belt.
- Triangulation using tie rods and bridging transomsIn a pedestrian access bay, short corner frame diagonals or dedicated portal frames are implemented to prevent buckling at ground level.
- Reinforcing anchor densityThe standards adjoining the modified bay systematically receive double anchor points using eye bolts and mechanical expansion anchors, installed at every platform level instead of every other level.
Every intervention on the bracing must be validated by the erector foreman before handover to other trades. If the request comes from the site management during use, the work constitutes a structural modification subject to a specific measurement. Installing a compensatory lattice girder generally represents an additional cost of around 180 to 350 CHF per span depending on the span length and the required connection components. Access can only be opened after the replacement solution is fully installed.
Bracing layout and structural integrity
In façade scaffolding, longitudinal diagonals are not shimming accessories to be placed at will during erection. They form a non-deformable vertical truss system that absorbs horizontal forces parallel to the façade, caused by wind thrust or dynamic operational loads, and transfers them to the base jacks and anchor points. Removing a single component breaks the kinematic continuity of the bay: the rectangle formed by the standards and ledgers then deforms into a parallelogram under even a modest lateral load.
Erection must strictly comply with the layout defined by the manufacturer's technical instructions, generally configured as a bracing tower every four or five bays, or as diagonals distributed continuously from the bottom to the top of the structure. Standard ties in no way compensate for the absence of triangulation: an eye-bolt and plug anchor functions essentially in tension and compression perpendicular to the wall, but provides only negligible residual resistance to longitudinal shear.
Procedure and structural compensation for access openings
When a clear passage on the ground floor or an intermediate level proves essential for structural work or logistics, the modification must be carried out exclusively by qualified scaffolding erectors. No change may take place without a compensatory system taking up the load path prior to loosening couplers or pins.
| Required configuration | Structural impact | Approved technical compensation | Associated ties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pedestrian passage or ground floor entrance | Removal of the lower diagonal in the first bay | Enclosed steel portal frame or bridging lattice girder spanning two bays | Doubling of short ties on adjacent standards |
| Opening for material hoist | Removal of bay diagonal over several lifts | Transfer of triangulation to the two neighbouring bays (V-bracing) | Reinforced V-ties (V-anchors) at upper node points |
| Opening a glazed bay for heavy glass installation | Temporary removal of the intermediate diagonal | Temporary tubular propping or Ø 48.3 mm steel tube with reinforcing right-angle couplers | Kept under the supervision of an erector foreman until reinstallation |
- Inspection and analysis of the requested openingThe scaffolding contractor's foreman examines the bay on site, checks the load paths and identifies the position of existing ties on the concrete or masonry façade.
- Installation of the diversion structureThe erectors fit the intended compensatory components: bridging girders, reinforced portal frames or diagonals shifted to adjacent bays according to approved assembly drawings.
- Reinforcement of connections to the structural workInstallation of additional ties required by the modified structural scheme, torqued to specification, with plug holding capacity verified using a pull-out tester.
- Removal of the obstructing component and signage updateSafe dismantling of the initial diagonal, verification of overall rigidity and immediate update of the inspection report on the scaffolding access board.
In accordance with the Construction Work Ordinance, all scaffolding must remain stable during all phases of work. OTConst art. 5 stipulates that the employer must appoint a competent person on each construction site responsible for occupational health and safety, who is authorised to issue instructions to workers. This competent person immediately records any unauthorised modification and prohibits access to the deck until the structure's original integrity has been restored.
Discovery of unauthorised dismantling: emergency securing and restoration
On a construction site in Romandy, finding a diagonal disconnected by a third trade to pass a skip or deliver pallets represents an immediate breach in the stability chain. The scaffolding chargehand's response admits no makeshift repairs: the structure has become an unstable mechanism under the action of wind or service loads.
- Cordoning off and closure of the sectorLock out access to the upper levels located in line with the compromised bay and the two adjacent bays. Use of these platforms is suspended until full compliance is restored.
- Checking verticality and anchor tiesCheck the standards for plumb over their entire height using a plumb line or level. Verify that there is no play in surrounding couplers, spigots or anchor rods that may have experienced abnormal shear.
- Installation of approved structural compensationIf the clear opening must be maintained, install a two-support aluminium or steel lattice girder with vertical load transfer and upper triangulation recovery according to the manufacturer's assembly instructions.
- Inspection and reopening reportCheck the torque of right-angle and swivel couplers. Draw up an intervention report countersigned by the site management before lifting the prohibition notice.
In accordance with CP, departing from the accepted rules of the art of building and thereby endangering the life or physical integrity of persons exposes the offender to criminal penalties. This rule applies to any operative who alters the scaffolding. Pursuant to CO, the contractor must immediately notify the client of circumstances that compromise the proper execution of the work.
Frequently asked questions
Can a bricklayer remove a ground floor diagonal to bring in pallets?
No. Dismantling a bracing component without prior compensatory measures is strictly prohibited. This operation alters the dynamic behaviour of the scaffolding and can lead to buckling of the standards or collapse through racking. Only a qualified scaffolding company is authorised to modify the layout, by first installing an approved bridging structure such as a load-transfer lattice girder designed according to technical specifications.
What solution should be installed to create a permanent van access under the structure?
To clear one or two ground-level bays, the erector removes the intermediate standards and diagonals, replacing them with reinforced bridging lattice girders. These components transfer dead and live loads to the adjacent doubled standards. The neighbouring bays must without exception receive full vertical and horizontal bracing, completed by reinforced anchoring to the façade in line with the girder supports.
What should be done if the façade does not allow anchoring for the diagonal compensation?
When the substrate precludes heavy-duty anchoring in line with the opening, loads must be transferred using steel tubes connected with right-angle couplers to sound reinforced concrete anchoring zones. Another solution is to install a continuous horizontal plan brace below the bridging deck, in order to transfer the wind shear force to soundly anchored and triangulated adjacent bays.
How should a scaffolding with compromised bracing be locked out?
The chargehand installs a rigid prohibition barrier physically preventing ascent via the ladders or stair towers serving the area. They attach the standardised red sign indicating that the structure must not be used. Next, they record the event in the site diary, immediately notify the site management and block all access authorisation until the layout is fully restored and the verticality of the standards has been verified.
Texts and standards cited
- CPviolation of the rules of the art of building: anyone who, when directing or carrying out a building structure or demolition, intentionally departs from the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons is liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; in cases of negligence, to a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty.
- COmaterials and site: the contractor is liable for the good quality of the materials supplied; if the materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or punctual execution of the work, the contractor must notify the client immediately, failing which the contractor shall bear the consequences (para. 3).
