Key takeaways
- Detecting a serious structural disorder requires the immediate physical decommissioning of the structure.
- The red prohibition sign and removal of ladders block access to all trades.
- Immediate written notice to the site management records the defect and clears the scaffolder.
- Technical repairs are carried out within an agreed deadline before any new access authorisation.
Physically block access as soon as a non-conformity is observed
On a building construction site, discovering a major anomaly on facade scaffolding tolerates no operational hesitation. Whether it involves anchors unbolted by a facade worker to run insulation, dislodged guardrails, or settlement of sole plates beneath an upright, the work instantly ceases to guarantee user safety. The chargehand or scaffolder foreman on site cannot settle for a verbal remark. Between the detection of the fault and the repair work, the structure must be declared inaccessible.
On each construction site, the employer designates a competent person responsible for occupational safety and health protection, who is able to give instructions to workers; any person who, through their conduct or condition, exposes themselves or endangers others must be removed from the construction site.
art. 5 OTConst
To make this exclusion of danger tangible, cordoning off must make access physically impossible. SUVA scaffolding inspection directives specify that a prohibition sign is not sufficient if it is not combined with a physical barrier. The first measure consists in removing or lifting and locking the first flight of access ladders on the access bay using a chain and padlock. The access trapdoors on the first level in aluminium or plywood decking are padlocked in the closed position.
- Removal of the green handover certificateImmediately remove the green handover sign located at the base of the scaffolding to eliminate the presumption of conformity.
- Installation of red signageFix the official SUVA access prohibition sign "No Entry - Non-compliant scaffolding" in plain view on each access standard.
- Mechanical barrierDismantle the first ladder or install a padlocked mesh gate with a chain around the base tubular standards.
- Closing off crossingsBar passages from openings, French doors, or flat roofs using tubes fixed with right-angle couplers.
Notify the stoppage of use in writing and schedule the technical repair
Physical action on the construction site does not protect the scaffolding contractor unless accompanied by immediate contractual formalisation. As soon as the locking mechanism is in place, the erection supervisor drafts an access prohibition notice sent without delay to the site management and the representatives of the user trades (plasterers, painters, tinsmiths, bricklayers). This notice specifies the exact time of the inspection, the precise nature of the damage, the area affected (north facade, bays 3 to 6, levels 2 and 3), as well as the strict prohibition against stepping onto the platforms.
| Document section | Required technical content | Legal and practical role |
|---|---|---|
| Identification of the work | Scaffolding number, facade, bays, and levels concerned | Demarcates the red zone if the shutdown is partial |
| Precise nature of the defect | Severed anchors, removed guardrails, overloaded pallets | Identifies the source of risk and any responsible party |
| Protective measures | Padlocked ladders, SUVA red sign displayed | Proves fulfilment of the duty of prevention |
| Remediation deadline | Date and time slot set for the team's repair work | Establishes unavailability for the trades |
The remediation deadline depends on the severity of the structural disorder and the resources of the scaffolding company. For a simple defect without overall structural impact, such as a detached bracket or a missing rail, action can be taken within 24 hours. Conversely, when a series of anchors has been removed over a large area exposed to wind, the structure presents an overturning hazard. Immediate intervention is required to secure the attachment points using new chemical or mechanical anchors with eye bolts and plugs adapted to the masonry substrate.
The contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied; if materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client, failing which the contractor shall bear the consequences (para. 3).
art. 365 CO
Physical prohibition methods and implementation of cordoning under SUVA directives
As soon as a defect compromising user safety is identified on facade scaffolding, the scaffolder responsible for the structure must implement physical prohibition measures without delay. A mere verbal remark protects no worker and holds no weight in the event of a SUVA inspection or an accident. Neutralising a defective structure requires an impassable mechanical obstacle combined with standardised signage.
- Removal or locking of the climbing systemRemove the ladder from the first access level or lock the access trapdoor to the lower deck with a construction site padlock to which only the scaffolder holds the key. On staircase access towers, bar the starting landing using a rigid padlocked gate.
- Installation of physical prohibition barriersErect a transverse rigid tubular component across ground-level accesses, reinforced with a steel tube rail fixed with right-angle couplers tightened with a ratchet wrench, preventing the passage of persons.
- Display of prohibition signageFirmly fix the official access prohibition sign (white circular symbol bordered in red with a crossed-out pedestrian pictogram or explicit text "Scaffolding closed to the public and users") to each neutralised access point. Immediately remove the handover sign or initial acceptance of the work certificate posted on site.
- Demarcation of exposed lower areasIf the structural disorder involves a risk of falling components (guardrail crudely dismantled, dislodged decking, anchors ripped out by the wind), establish a safety perimeter on the ground beneath the bay in question using freestanding security barriers to prevent traffic from other trades.
The employer is subject to the Swiss legal framework for the prevention of occupational hazards. Under LAA, the employer must take, to prevent occupational accidents and illnesses, all measures shown by experience to be necessary, which the state of the art allows to be applied, and which are adapted to the given conditions. Physically prohibiting the use of deteriorated temporary works is a direct reflection of this elementary technical diligence.
Written traceability to trades and setting remediation deadlines
The scaffolder's liability extends to the rigorous formalisation of the decommissioning. Notice cannot remain confined to a telephone exchange. A written notification must reach the site management and the user companies registered on the construction site (facade workers, plasterers-painters, tinsmiths, bricklayers) simultaneously.
| Defect severity | Technical manifestation | Immediate action by the scaffolder | Target response time |
|---|---|---|---|
| Critical defect with structural risk | Loosened or sheared anchors, ground sole plate settlement, buckling of tubular standards | Total shutdown of scaffolding, chain and padlock on all accesses, emergency written notice | Immediate or within 4 to 12 working hours |
| Localised fall protection defect | Top rail, intermediate rail, or toeboard removed by a trade, unstable cantilever bracket | Targeted closure of the affected bay or level, localised prohibition sign | Within 24 working hours |
| Secondary equipment defect | Torn debris netting, access trapdoor with distorted latch, missing flashing | Recorded in the site logbook, maintained with reservations without complete shutdown | Within 48 to 72 working hours |
The prohibition notice sent by email with acknowledgement of receipt or recorded in the site logbook must specify the exact area concerned (South facade, levels 3 and 4, bays 2 to 5), the nature of the observed structural disorder, the strict ban on entering the sector, and the scheduled date for the scaffolding team's intervention. The construction work ordinance also imposes strict safety organisation on every construction site.
As soon as the repair is completed by the scaffolder's teams, a meticulous inspection of the repaired area is carried out (coupler tightening torques, presence of safety pins, re-installation of anchor plugs). A new inspection certificate is signed, the prohibition sign is removed, and the site management receives a formal written lifting of the stoppage authorising the reopening of the workstations.
Managing usage conflicts and safe resumption during decommissioning
On the construction site, taking facade scaffolding out of service frequently clashes with the schedule constraints of the finishing work trades. When a worker crosses a cordon or tears down a prohibition sign to continue working, the situation escalates from a simple technical defect to a major accident risk. The scaffolder or the designated safety supervisor must respond methodically: priority remains user physical safety and traceability of decisions before the site management.
If a user company refuses to evacuate the cordoned-off area or deliberately damages the barrier device, the scaffolding chargehand immediately records the event. They take dated photographs of the forced access, note the name of the offending company, and immediately issue written notification to the site management and the safety coordinator. Concurrently, a copy of the decommissioning notice is forwarded to the delegates of the trades concerned.
| Observed situation | Immediate physical action | Formal communication | Contractual consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Crossing the tape or barrier | Verbal challenge and evacuation order | Immediate email to site management with photos | Work stoppage under the liability of the offending user |
| Unauthorised removal of an anchor or rail | Rigid mechanical closure of the bay | Non-conformity sheet indicating serious hazard | Repairs invoiced to the party responsible for the alteration |
| Refusal to comply by a trade | Complete physical locking of access ladders | Formal notice to the client and SUVA notification | Revocation of acceptance of the work for the temporary structure |
The lifting of the prohibition occurs only once repairs are completed by qualified scaffolders. Following visual inspection, verification of tightening torques, and restoration of collective protective equipment, the authorised access sign is reinstalled and countersigned. Under CP, whoever, when directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally breaches the recognised rules of the trade and thereby knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons shall be liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; if acting through negligence, to a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty. This rigorous approach legally protects the scaffolder.
Frequently asked questions
Can a user repair a defect themselves to continue working?
No. SUVA directives and professional rules strictly reserve any modification or repair for qualified scaffolders. If a painter or bricklayer refits an anchor or diagonal brace, they assume liability without ensuring the technical conformity of the assembly. The structure remains strictly off-limits until the responsible scaffolder has approved the repair and updated the inspection notice at the base of the structure.
What should be done if site management refuses to halt the construction site despite a defect?
The scaffolder must maintain physical decommissioning via rigid, padlocked barriers and record their refusal in writing. They must immediately send a notification of serious danger to the site management and the client, declining all liability for potential accidents. In the event of a persistent impasse creating an imminent risk of falls, they must request immediate arbitration from the competent SUVA inspectorate.
How can an effective access prohibition be established on an access ladder?
Simple two-tone barrier tape is inadequate as it is easily crossed. Physical prohibition requires removing the first flight of the ladder or fitting a padlocked trapdoor onto the access decking, supplemented by a rigid prohibition sign compliant with SUVA directives. The device must physically prevent workers from climbing and clearly state the reason for closure as well as the decommissioning date.
Who covers the cost of downtime caused by a scaffolding defect?
If the non-conformity results from faulty workmanship by the scaffolder, repairs are at their sole expense under their contractual obligations. If the defect stems from damage caused by a third party, an unauthorised overload, or the unapproved removal of an anchor by a trade, repair costs and resulting delays are recharged to the responsible company, following a joint inspection record documented by the site management.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConst art. 5organisation of occupational safety and health protection: on each construction site, the employer designates a competent person responsible for occupational safety and health protection, who is able to give instructions to workers (para. 1); any person who, through their conduct or condition, exposes themselves or endangers others must be removed from the construction site (para. 2).
- CPbreach of the recognised rules of the art of building: whoever, when directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally breaches the recognised rules of the trade and thereby knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons shall be liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; if acting through negligence, to a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty.
