Key takeaways
- Any unauthorised removal of an anchor immediately degrades overall stability and requires the suspension of use.
- The joint inspection record requires contextualised photographs, zone identification and precise timestamps.
- The physical closure of the structure is accompanied by formal signage prohibiting all access to users.
- Immediate written notification to the site management provides the basis for full rebilling of repairs.
Record the tampering on the spot and lock out access to the scaffolding
On construction sites with overlapping activities, the unauthorised removal of facade anchors, diagonal braces or toeboards is a common malpractice. Facade installers, blind fitters or painters often remove these components to clear a work area, without realising that the overall stability of the structure depends on the continuity of the tying pattern. As soon as such tampering is spotted, the scaffolding crew applies a strict emergency procedure to neutralise the risk of collapse or falls from height.
- Immediate physical closure of access pointsLock out immediately the construction site stair flights and access ladders leading to the compromised levels. Erect a rigid physical barrier, supplemented by a sign formally prohibiting access, stating that the structure has been taken out of service for structural reasons.
- Joint inspection survey and localisationPinpoint each compromised point on the scaffolding layout plan: bay number, deck level and standard number. Identify the exact nature of the removed components, such as unscrewed eyebolts, removed couplers, missing tie tubes or unhooked toeboards.
- Compilation of the photographic fileTake general photographs showing the facade and the affected bay, followed by close-up views of the neutralised tying points. The photographs must clearly show empty drill holes, tubes left dangling or equipment dumped by the trade working in the modified zone.
The access prohibition must not remain theoretical. The foreman locks out the initial green inspection notice and replaces it with explicit red signage. No site operative may bypass this barrier. The scaffolding ceases to be under the erector's compliance liability until vital components have been reinstalled and inspected by qualified personnel.
Notify the suspension of use and allocate reinstatement costs
Unauthorised tampering directly compromises the safety of third parties and alters the contractual execution framework. The scaffolding erector must formally notify the site management to release its liability in the event of an accident occurring on a structure manipulated by third parties, while setting out the financial terms for the remedial work.
If the material supplied by the client or the site designated by them is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or prompt execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences.
art. 365 CO
The notice of suspension and damage is sent by email with delivery confirmation or entered in the construction site daily log the very same day. This document specifies the missing components, the date and time of closure, as well as the name of the company suspected of having moved the anchors for its own rendering application or joinery installation needs.
| Technical service | Resources deployed | Supporting document for the account |
|---|---|---|
| Diagnosis and emergency securing | Workshop vehicle and foreman | Dated inspection report with photographs |
| Installation of new anchors or ties | Qualified erectors, drilling and new rawlplugs | Tightening torque check sheets |
| Replacement of damaged guard rails and toeboards | Supply of scaffold timber or metal | Replaced material delivery note |
| New compliance acceptance | Site supervisor and technical inspector | Reopening record and notice display |
Travel expenses, partial dismantling labour, new drilling into the concrete substrate and consumable anchoring components are not covered by the initial fixed erection lump sum. Under the rules of standard SIA 118, these operations constitute extra work made necessary by circumstances to remedy the act of a third party. Their cost, which frequently represents an amount in the region of 400 to 1,200 CHF depending on the extent of the detached facade, is detailed in a daywork report submitted to the site management for full rebilling to the defaulting trade.
Technical reinstatement protocol following unauthorised removal
Once the lockout of the structure is implemented on site, the reinstatement work requires a rigorous methodology. A structure deprived of its anchor points or guard rails exhibits potentially compromised static equilibrium. The scaffolding erector cannot merely put a component back in place hastily: the area must be treated like a structure under erection, subject to full structural checks before any reopening.
- Diagnosis of overall facade plane deformationCheck the plumb line and horizontal alignment of the affected bay and adjacent bays using a level or laser. Any buckling or twisting of the tubular standards indicates an abnormal redistribution of wind or operational loads.
- Clearing and recreating wall anchor pointsDrill new anchor points into the load-bearing concrete or solid masonry substrate if the original plugs were sheared, deformed or filled with insulation material. Install new eyebolts and check their resistance with a representative pull-out test.
- Connecting tie tubes and couplersPosition short or long tie tubes using compliant right-angle couplers, tightened to the specified torque using a torque wrench or calibrated ratchet wrench, in the immediate vicinity of the frame nodes.
- Restoring collective deck protectionReinstall timber or aluminium toeboards removed by users. Ensure their proper seating at the base of the frame and the complete continuity of the perimeter guard rail to eliminate any gap through which tools could fall.
The presence of toeboards is not merely a matter of user comfort: OTConst art. 22 sets the requirements for perimeter guard rails, comprising a top rail whose upper edge is at least 100 cm above the working surface, at least one intermediate rail, a toeboard of at least 15 cm and a maximum spacing of 47 cm between elements. The removal of a toeboard by a secondary trade to facilitate inserting boards or pipes constitutes a direct technical breach of these regulatory dimensions.
Removal of lockout, traceability and billing of services
The completion of scaffolding reinstatement works does not allow an immediate resumption of use by the other trades. The scaffolding contractor has the obligation to update its visual inspection system on site and formalise the transfer of risks to the site management.
| Altered component | Nature of induced risk | Required technical operation | Contractual claim basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wall anchor dismantled or unscrewed | Loss of wind stability, onset of scaffolding overturning | New plugging, installation of a new eyebolt, tie tube and couplers | Daywork voucher for re-anchoring including travel time and materials |
| Deck toeboard removed or broken | Fall of tools, rubble or materials to lower levels | Installation of a 15 cm replacement toeboard and latch locking | Supply of damaged component and daywork installation labour |
| Diagonal brace unhooked | Parallelogram deformation under dynamic load | Correction of verticality, refitting of diagonal brace and pinning | Geometric check of the bay and specific intervention time |
| Internal or external guard rail removed | Direct risk of falls from height greater than two metres | Reinstallation of top rails and intermediate rails with anti-lift locking | Urgent safety reinstatement invoiced to the offender or main contractor |
Removing the physical closure must strictly be accompanied by replacing the red prohibition sign with a green compliance sign, supplemented with the recommissioning date, the name of the qualified erector and their signature. The updated inspection report is sent immediately by electronic means to the site management and filed in the construction site safety file.
Financially, interventions caused by third-party damage cannot be absorbed into the initial lump sum for scaffolding hire or maintenance. Standard SIA 118 regulates the execution of daywork when services not provided for in the original contract become essential due to the act of a third party. The contractor submits its daywork vouchers detailing crane hours, any cherry picker use, qualified labour and non-reusable supplies (plugs, eyebolts). The site management then proceeds with set-off or rebilling against the payment claims of the defaulting trade, thereby preserving the economic balance of the scaffolding package.
Handling billing disputes and repeated offences on site
On a building construction site, discovering unbolted anchors or toeboards removed without permission triggers immediate friction. When the party responsible for the tampering refuses to accept liability or the site management disputes the daywork sheet, the scaffolding erector must maintain absolute documentary rigour to protect their rights and release their technical liability.
- Administrative record and formal evidenceCompile the initial record without delay: close-up photographs with bay references, overview of the cordoned-off sector, digital timestamp and a copy of the prohibition sign posted on the access hatch. This file establishes the condition of the structure prior to any remedial works.
- Submission of the joint daywork reportDraw up the daywork voucher specifying the labour used for securing the structure, and the couplers, tubes or anchors replaced. Have the document endorsed by the site manager on site or send it by registered post with recorded delivery in accordance with the rules of standard SIA 118.
- Handling repeated offences or refusal to arbitrateIf unauthorised dismantling occurs again despite warnings, apply a total suspension of use across the affected facade. Art. 229 CP punishes anyone who intentionally or through negligence breaches the recognised rules of construction and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons.
Faced with a refusal of direct charging to the offending trade — often a facade contractor or blind installer —, invoicing is contractually addressed to the site management, as the representative of the client. For complex repairs involving temporary offset ties or additional pull-out tests, the costs incurred regularly reach several thousand francs; refer to the unit prices series under /tenders/ to support your final account.
Frequently asked questions
Who must pay for reinstatement if the offending trade denies having removed the anchors?
The invoice is addressed to the site management, signatory to the main contract under standard SIA 118. The scaffolder does not manage site policing: they provide a safe structure for all trades. It is up to the site management to arbitrate the dispute during construction site coordination and charge the cost of the reinstatement work to the shared site account or to the defaulting work package.
Can access to the entire scaffolding be prohibited because of only two removed toeboards?
Yes, on the affected level and the areas plumb below. A missing toeboard directly exposes workers below to falling tools or materials, which is prohibited by the construction work ordinance. The erector must physically lock out the access ladders leading to that platform until the timber or aluminium component is fully reinstalled, to ensure the integrity of the workstation.
How do you effectively lock out scaffolding on which anchors have been unscrewed?
Lockout is carried out by physically closing the access ladder hatches using padlocks or chains, accompanied by standard access prohibition signs. Barrier tape is strung out at ground level to prevent approach beneath unstable bays. The erector immediately writes a formal notification, sent by instant messaging and then by formal email to the site management and the site safety officer.
What is the legal value of a photographic record without a joint counter-signature?
Timestamped digital photographs with geolocation and contextual views provide robust evidence within the framework of a contract for work governed by the Code of Obligations (CO). Accompanied by immediate written notification to the site management, they demonstrate the scaffolder's due diligence and reverse the presumption of structural defect. The absence of an immediate counter-signature in the field does not invalidate the probative value of the record of tampering.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365material and site: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the material supplied; if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by them is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or prompt execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3)
- CPbreach of the recognised rules of construction: whoever, in directing or executing a construction or demolition project, intentionally breaches the recognised rules of construction and thereby knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons shall be liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; if committed through negligence, the penalty shall be a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty
- norme SIA 118General conditions for construction
