Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 212Handover, periodic inspections and documentsChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Pre-assembly façade condition survey: photographic record and reservations

At the end of this chapter, you will know how to carry out a methodical joint condition survey of a façade before the initial scaffolding erection. You will identify critical pre-existing defects, draft formal reservations enforceable against site management, and legally protect your company against subsequent claims of damage caused during fixings or handling.

Key takeaways

  • Any damage not recorded before assembly will systematically be attributed to the scaffolder.
  • The joint photographic record must include overview shots and time-stamped close-ups.
  • Defects on rendering, cornices, sills, and glazing require immediate written reservations.
  • The signed report binds site management and protects the company in disputes.

Methodically survey sensitive points and produce the photographic record

Upon arrival on the construction site, before unloading the first steel frames or tubes, the team leader or site supervisor must walk the entire perimeter of the building. On renovation or conversion construction sites, façades often have structural weaknesses or degraded finishes. During assembly, handling decks, tightening couplers, or drilling anchor holes generate vibrations and impacts in close proximity to the walls. If these degradations are not formally recorded beforehand, site management or the client will systematically attribute them to the scaffolding crews.

Joint photographic record
Exhaustive survey of the physical condition of a structure, carried out jointly by the contractor and site management before operations commence, recording existing deteriorations with indexed and dated photographs.

Certain façade components are particularly exposed and require meticulous, millimetre-accurate examination. The visual inventory must follow a logical path, bay by bay and level by level, so that nothing is overlooked before the space becomes congested with tube structures.

  • Window sills made of folded sheet metal, natural stone, or concrete, which are often already scratched, warped, or cracked at corner joints.
  • External joinery glazing, glass balustrades, and stacked Venetian blinds, which are vulnerable to stone chips or blows from components.
  • Mineral rendering, external thermal insulation composite systems, or historic mouldings showing hairline cracks, crazing, or detached hollow areas.
  • Copper or zinc rainwater downpipes, gutters, as well as roof soffit ornaments or cornices.
  • Door thresholds, resin balcony coatings, and waterproofing elements located immediately below the future first platform level.

To ensure the evidential weight of the record, each shot must combine a context photograph showing its precise location on the façade, and a close-up photograph featuring a graduated scale, a folding rule, or a crack gauge. Raw digital files must retain their full EXIF metadata with native time-stamping. Every captured image must be sorted by cardinal orientation, scaffolding gridline, and storey level.

Formalising written reservations and asserting the record in the event of a dispute

A visual inspection only protects the company if it is immediately recorded in formal writing. In accordance with art. 365 CO, if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance arises which compromises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under penalty of bearing the consequences. For the scaffolder, the anchor base represented by the façade falls fully within this duty of notification.

  1. On-site summonsArrange the joint visit with the site management supervisor before bringing in heavy equipment.
  2. Drafting the condition survey sheetList each observed defect, linking it to the photograph number, the exact location, and the nature of the reservation.
  3. Joint signature of the documentHave the condition survey record initialled by the site management representative directly on the construction site.
  4. Immediate electronic notificationSend the complete report in PDF format by email with read receipt before starting assembly of the structure.
Templates of written reservations based on identified defects
Identified defectTypical locationWording of the technical reservation
Through-crack or gaping fissureSpandrels, masonry lintels, opening cornersExpress reservations: pre-existing cracks identified. Full discharge of liability for any widening caused by the installation of anchors or operational vibrations.
Blown or hollow-sounding renderingHistoric façades, slab edges, cornicesFriable, unstable base: refusal of any direct anchoring to this area without prior purging by the bricklayer. No liability in the event of detachment.
Impacts, scuffs, and scratchesAluminium joinery, glazing, copper sillsPre-existing material damage recorded in photo report no. X. No remedial painting or metalwork may be charged to the scaffolder.
Fragile components not dismantledFabric awnings, signs, outdoor light fittingsPresence of obstacles in the scaffolding bay. Risk of interference during handling: written warning and request for removal by the client.

The legal value of a properly maintained condition survey is decisive during final acceptance of the work according to standard SIA 118. When a retention of payment is considered at dismantling for surface damage, producing the initial dated, countersigned, and documented survey record immediately neutralises improper claims. This document defeats the reversal of the burden of proof and demonstrates the scaffolding company's strict compliance with recognised trade practices.

Protocols for locating and surveying critical wall points

Setting out a façade scaffolding requires a methodical analysis of the substrate bases before the assembly materials arrive. Every square metre of vertical surface, every opening reveal, and every architectural projection exhibits an initial state of preservation that must be recorded without ambiguity. In the absence of an exhaustive prior survey, any damage noted upon dismantling or during work by other trades — such as plasterer-painters or tinsmiths — is systematically attributed to the scaffolder's assembly and anchoring operations.

The team leader or site supervisor conducts a visual and tactile inspection along the alignment of future standard columns. Historic or renovated façades frequently conceal hidden structural or aesthetic defects. The inspection focuses primarily on the cohesion of mineral coatings, the integrity of dressed stone elements, the flatness of thresholds, and the fixings of external secondary works.

Inspection matrix for specific points prior to scaffolding erection
Area examinedCommon defectsMeans of inspectionScaffolder preventive measure
Façade rendering and plastersDetachment sounding hollow, crazing, shrinkage hairline cracksManual tapping with a light hammer, optical crack gaugeExclusion of base jacks or pads bearing against this area
Cornices, string courses, and mouldingsConcrete spalling, unbonded natural stone, chippingManual stability check, macro-photo surveyOffsetting anchors and protection using spreader planks
Shutters, blinds, and ironworkDistorted hinges, scratched slats, deformed blind boxesManual test operation, visual alignment checkLocking in closed position or reservation for dismantling
Thresholds, window sills, and ledge platesBends in sheet metal, cracked granite corners2-metre straightedge, depth gaugesProhibit use as a walkway or bearing point

To lend technical rigour to the survey, each photograph must be systematically paired with a millimetric scale and a cardinal orientation reference. Overview shots of each façade allow the scaffolding bays to be located, whilst close-up shots document the exact opening width of existing cracks, measured with a crack gauge graduated to tenths of a millimetre.

Notification of reservations, duty to notify, and legal enforceability

A visual inspection only holds value if it is immediately converted into an enforceable contractual document. As soon as a weakness in the substrate base or a defect likely to worsen is identified, the scaffolding company must formalise written reservations. This document summarises the defects found, identifies areas where the load-bearing capacity of the wall does not permit standard horizontal anchor loads to be taken up, and sets out the required technical adjustments.

This approach strictly complies with the statutory framework of the contract for work and services. Art. 365 CO provides that if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance arises which compromises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3). Regarding scaffolding, the façade represents the direct physical base of the temporary structure provided; neglecting to alert site management to visible deterioration transfers liability for the damage onto the scaffolder.

Art. 367 CO specifies the rules on inspection and notice of defects: after delivery, the client examines the condition of the work as soon as feasible and notifies the contractor of defects; for an immovable structure, he has 60 days to report them, and a shorter contractual period is void (para. 1bis). In order to neutralise any late claims during this phase, the incoming condition survey file must imperatively be sent by registered post or by email with formal read receipt to site management and to the client before erecting the first level of frames.

  1. Joint on-site inspectionComplete walk-through of the surroundings and base of the façade with the site management representative, reservation log and camera in hand.
  2. Drafting the condition survey sheetNumbering of the structural bays and exact recording of observed defects, referenced to time-stamped photo numbers.
  3. Joint signature of the documentImmediate validation by the client's site supervisor; in the event of refusal to countersign, official notification within 24 hours.
  4. Adapting the anchoring patternJoint definition of alternative fixing points (rakers, through-wall anchors via windows) to bypass unstable materials.

Dispute management and implementation of condition survey evidence

During scaffolding dismantling, the discovery of cracked rendering, a chipped window sill, or a crushed rainwater downpipe almost systematically triggers a retention of payment by site management. Without initial precautions, the scaffolder is presumed liable for this damage that occurred while the structure was used by other trades.

Art. 365 CO specifies that if any circumstance arises which compromises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under penalty of bearing the consequences. To make the photographic record fully enforceable, the initial shots must include verifiable time metadata as well as a metric scale reference. Prior written notification of a joint condition survey is the key piece of evidence to reject unjustified claims.

  1. Submitting the evidence fileRespond to the notice of defects by enclosing the excerpt from the initial survey showing the pre-existing defect with its precise location on the setting-out plan.
  2. Joint on-site counter-inspectionSummon site management and the client to compare the current condition visually with the dated pre-assembly photographs.
  3. Drawing up the closing survey recordFormally record that the damage pre-existed in order to obtain the immediate lifting of reservations and the full release of financial retentions.

Art. 97 CO states that the debtor is obliged to make good the damage unless he proves that no fault is attributable to him. If the client disputes the validity of a unilateral survey, the company must immediately request a joint expert assessment pursuant to standard SIA 118. The involvement of an independent expert makes it possible to distinguish structural settlement microcracks from mechanical spalling caused by tightening base jacks or anchor ties.

Frequently asked questions

How should one respond if site management refuses to sign the joint condition survey?

Immediately send the complete photographic file by registered post or secure electronic transmission with read receipt before starting assembly. Specify in writing that the absence of documented contestation within 24 to 48 hours constitutes formal acknowledgment of the defects noted. This time-stamped notification allows the company to prove it fulfilled its duty of notification and eliminates any presumption of fault in the event of subsequent claims concerning the identified areas.

Does a simple folder of smartphone photos suffice in court proceedings?

Photographs must imperatively contain usable EXIF metadata, including precise time-stamping and ideally the geolocation of the structure. Each shot must combine an overview locating the bay and a close-up fitted with a millimetric gauge or crack rule. Without these rigorous framing elements and their formal prior transmission to the client, a court or expert may deem isolated photographs to lack sufficient probative value.

Which façade elements require a systematic photographic survey before anchor installation?

Examine projecting and fragile components first: natural stone thresholds, metal window sills, blind boxes, rainwater downpipes, and glass balustrades. Also inspect masonry corners and external thermal rendering, which are particularly susceptible to impacts from decks or the tightening of anchors. The survey must inventory every existing chip, scratch, or flaking to separate prior defects from any damage attributable to scaffolders.

Who bears the repair costs if a crack appears directly under an anchor?

Remediation is the responsibility of the scaffolder if drilling caused the substrate base to spall or if anchors were tightened beyond admissible tolerances without prior recording of fragility. Conversely, if the crack was explicitly listed in the initial reservations notified to site management, or if the wall structure had an intrinsic defect reported in writing, the scaffolding company's liability is discharged as of right against opposing claims.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365material and site: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the material he provides; if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance arises which compromises the regular or punctual execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).
  • COnon-performance of the obligation: the debtor is obliged to make good the damage, unless he proves that no fault is attributable to him.
  • SIA 118General conditions for construction works.

In the same section