Key takeaways
- The calculation note determines the geometry of the raking shores and the ballast mass according to wind exposure.
- Ground anchoring requires precisely sized reinforced concrete pads or ballast blocks.
- Continuous topographical monitoring measures horizontal deflections and settlements to the millimetre.
- A strict stoppage criterion sets the alert thresholds to suspend work on the construction site immediately.
Design of the temporary structure: raking shores, calculation note and ballast
Retaining a historic or heritage façade during the deconstruction of internal floors requires a load-bearing structure for wind loads and horizontal stability. In the absence of the floor slabs that provided the original bracing, the masonry or ashlar wall becomes vulnerable to overturning. The scaffolding contractor or installer of temporary works must rely on a detailed structural engineering study before any intervention on the construction site.
Three-dimensional raking shores, generally composed of heavy steel section towers or high-strength aluminium/steel props, are arranged on the external or internal façade. These diagonal elements absorb horizontal thrust to transfer it to the ground. The connection between the steel section and the masonry is achieved via wall distribution beams (horizontal walers) anchored through the wall or by threaded rods bonded with resin mortar to prevent punching shear.
| Structural element | Primary mechanical role | Critical assembly point |
|---|---|---|
| Horizontal walers (ledgers) | Distribute thrust across the masonry | Insertion of timber balks beneath the steel section |
| Diagonal raking shores | Transfer horizontal forces towards the base | Tightening splice bolts to the specified torque |
| Ballast blocks | Counteract overturning moment through gravity | Calculation of bearing surface and friction coefficient |
| Anchor tie rods | Prevent uplift of the rear base | Verification of pull-out resistance in the slab |
Base ballasting is a fundamental parameter. When raking shores operate in compression and tension under alternating wind action, the outer support point tends to lift. Precast reinforced concrete blocks or gravel-ballasted skips are positioned on the tower baseplates. The ballast mass must compensate for the overturning moment with a strict safety factor defined in the execution documentation.
Topographical monitoring and emergency stoppage procedure on the construction site
Once the shoring is loaded and internal demolition is underway, the façade enters a critical phase. Vibrations induced by the nibbling of interior structures and the removal of original ties can cause deformations imperceptible to the naked eye. High-frequency automated or manual topographical monitoring is mandatory throughout the temporary phase.
- Installation of targets and baseline surveyingOptical prisms or retro-reflective targets are fixed to the façade at each floor level and at the building corners before the first blow of a breaker.
- Measurement of the zero point (datum)A total station records the X, Y, Z coordinates of all targets over three consecutive days to incorporate the natural thermal movements of the wall.
- Monitoring surveys during deconstructionReadings are taken each morning prior to the start of demolition work, and then at the end of the day, with automated data transmission to site managers.
- Analysis of deformation trendsThe surveyor compares absolute deviations and rates of displacement against allowable thresholds set out in the safety plan.
- Work stoppage criterion
- Operational threshold measured in millimetres of horizontal displacement or rate of tilt (e.g. > 2 mm/day) requiring the immediate suspension of the demolition construction site and evacuation of the danger zone.
If the stoppage criterion is reached, the emergency procedure requires the immediate installation of supplementary propping or retightening the load-bearing screw jacks at the base of the raking shores. No resumption of demolition is permitted without written sign-off from the specialist engineer following a review of the control measurements.
Installation of anchors and load transfer onto retained masonry
Stabilising a historic or heritage façade whose interior structure is demolished requires direct transfer of wind and eccentric thrust loads to the ground via a rigid raking shore system. The connection between the temporary structure's steel section and the existing masonry is the critical assembly point. Inadequate anchoring risks shearing the stone or causing pull-out under alternating weather actions.
- Drilling and bonding through-tie rodsTo avoid pulling off the facing under wind suction, the horizontal members of the raking shores are anchored by threaded rods passing through the full thickness of the wall. Steel spreader plates distributed on the internal face distribute the load without punching into the heritage masonry.
- Installation of support brackets and packingVertical loads arising from the self-weight of the temporary structure and the rake of the shores are absorbed by chemically anchored metal brackets. Non-shrink bedding mortar is poured between the support section and the masonry to guarantee perfect surface contact.
- Concrete ballasting and ground anchoringThe bases of raking shores transfer substantial uplift and sliding forces to the ground. The reinforced concrete ballast blocks are placed on a compacted gravel platform and anchored by temporary piles or tied by anchor rods embedded in the perimeter foundation slab.
Interactions with demolition and strict construction site management criteria
During the deconstruction of interior slabs, the load transfer from the façade to the temporary structure must be gradual. The removal of original connections abruptly alters the buckling conditions of the external wall. The provision of temporary shoring bridges through window openings helps maintain masonry alignment prior to installing the permanent structural members.
| Topographical threshold | Observed movement | Action required on the construction site | Parties to notify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Green (Tolerance) | Displacement < 2.0 mm | Normal continuation of interior demolition works. | Site manager |
| Amber (Alert) | Displacement between 2.0 and 5.0 mm | Check raking shore tension, tighten anchors and hourly monitoring. | Specialist engineer, site foreman |
| Red (Stoppage) | Displacement > 5.0 mm or rate > 1.0 mm/h | Immediate stop of demolition, evacuation of the risk zone and installation of emergency wedging. | Site management, structural expert, Suva |
In addition to the basic safety measures required by art. 17 OTConst, which stipulates that measures must be taken at workstations and passageways so that workers are not endangered by the collapse of building components, the scaffolding contractor guarantees daily checks of bolted connections and the visual integrity of the steel structure. Any alteration in the condition of connections due to vibrations from plant on the construction site requires immediate retightening using a torque wrench.
Dismantling of the shoring structure is only carried out once the new internal framework (reinforced concrete or structural steel) has achieved its design nominal strength and permanent anchors between the retained masonry and the new structure are grouted and accepted. The reverse load transfer is performed by controlled de-jacking, stage by stage, while continuing total station monitoring until theoretical final stabilisation.
Managing anomalies and unforeseen deformations
During internal deconstruction operations with retention of the external shell, the temporary support structure undergoes complex load redistributions. The removal of existing floors abruptly modifies the buckling lengths of the masonry and transfers wind action solely onto the metal raking shores and the shoring tower. If topographical monitoring detects movement exceeding the pre-alert threshold established by the civil engineer, the foreman must immediately freeze demolition works in the affected zone and consolidate the anchoring system.
- Detection of threshold exceedanceThe surveyor transmits automated total station readings. As soon as the deflection exceeds 5 mm relative to the datum, the Level 1 alert is activated.
- Demolition freeze and securingDeconstruction plant (crushers, breakers) operating near the unstable wall must be shut down to stop the emission of vibrations.
- Visual inspection and torque checksThe gang leader inspects all bolted connections of the raking shores, the tension in the steel tie rods, and the seating of the concrete ballast.
- Strengthening under engineer directionInstallation of emergency struts or adding additional ballast to the base of the support structure in accordance with the calculation note's contingency plan.
According to standard SIA 260 and standard SIA 261, the safety of temporary works is based on the rigorous consideration of allowable deformations. Should through-cracks appear in the retained masonry, the foreman has glass tell-tales or electronic strain gauges installed. If the crack widens by more than 0.5 mm in 24 hours, the mandatory construction site stoppage criterion is triggered. The employer then enforces the general duty to prevent accidents by removing all personnel from the potential impact zone, as stipulated in LAA.
| Alert level | Measured displacement | Visual criterion | Operational action required |
|---|---|---|---|
| Threshold 1: Vigilance | 3 to 5 mm | Render microcracks (< 0.2 mm) | Retighten anchor bolts and check ballast |
| Threshold 2: Pre-alert | 5 to 10 mm | Active masonry cracking | Halt vibrating plant, double the frequency of topographical monitoring |
| Threshold 3: Critical stoppage | > 10 mm | Detachment of anchor points | Evacuate the area, install emergency steel raking struts |
Frequently asked questions
How is the ballast at the base of metal raking shores sized?
Ballast is sized in the calculation note prepared by the civil engineering practice. It takes into account the overturning moment caused by wind loads on the exposed façade, the self-weight of the retained masonry, and the friction coefficient on the ground. Precast concrete blocks equipped with standardised lifting anchors are used.
What is the recommended frequency for topographical monitoring of the façade?
During critical deconstruction phases of adjacent floors, measurements must be taken daily, or even continuously via an automated total station with SMS alarm dispatch. Once the demolition phase is complete and prior to the reconstruction of the new internal structures, a weekly reading is sufficient.
What should be done if a shoring anchor fails in degraded old masonry?
Loads on that raking shore must be relieved immediately. The engineer must specify core-drilling through the wall to install steel spreader plates with through-threaded rods, instead of simple expansion anchors that risk bursting the degraded historical stone or brick.
Who is responsible for signing off the shoring system before demolition begins?
The scaffolding or structural steel contractor installs the structure according to the drawings. The civil engineer who authored the calculation note and the temporary works undertakes technical acceptance and signs the commissioning record jointly with site management.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 260Basis of structural design
- SIA 261Actions on structures
- LAAGeneral rules for the prevention of occupational accidents and diseases
- CPBreach of the rules of the art of building during construction or demolition
