Key takeaways
- The joint inspection record prior to earthworks clears the risk of pre-existing cracks in the adjoining structure being attributed to the works.
- Plaster tell-tales and graduated crack gauges ensure objective monitoring of facade movements.
- The alert thresholds defined with the engineer require excavation to stop as soon as the first millimetre of deviation occurs.
- The timestamped and geolocated photographic file constitutes the key piece of evidence in the event of subsequent judicial expert assessment.
Preliminary joint inspection record and conclusive file before opening an excavation
Deploying an excavator against the facade of a neighbouring building without an exhaustive survey of the premises turns the masonry company into the presumed debtor of all deterioration across the neighbourhood. Soil decompression, plant vibrations or groundwater lowering can reactivate former differential settlements. Without a technical joint inspection record drawn up before the first bucket stroke, the causal link between opening the excavation and the defects observed by third parties becomes indefensible for the site agent.
The technical file is structured around a joint inspection carried out in the presence of the adjoining property owner, the professional representative, the civil engineer and the site foreman. The inspection is not limited to the external envelope: it must imperatively include basements, basement slabs, masonry cross-walls, lintels, window frames, and the operational clearance of joinery. If the ground designated by the client presents instabilities or endangers the adjoining structure, the contractor refers to the obligations of art. 365 CO by immediately notifying the client in writing.
- Survey of the general condition of renders, rubble stone, brick, or reinforced concrete masonry.
- Checking the plumbness of party walls and identifying out-of-level areas on floors.
- Checking functional clearances of doors, windows, and metal closures.
- Examination of buried drainage pipes, stormwater inspection chambers, and basement utility connections.
- Systematic photographic documentation comprising general views, medium shots, and close-ups with a millimetre gauge.
Each photograph must include a standardised visual marker, such as a graduated scale or a crack comparator, placed next to the defect. Raw files are archived without retouching, electronically timestamped, and integrated into a fully dimensioned, numbered report initialled by all parties during the survey meeting. Under standard SIA 118, this report also records weather conditions and already active damp issues.
Crack monitoring devices, alert thresholds and earthwork stoppages
As soon as the joint inspection record is signed, the team installs measuring instruments across all active fissures and critical structural joints. The choice of sensor depends on the required accuracy and the foreseeable kinematics of the defects. Rigid plaster or resin tell-tales serve as indicators of brittle failure, whilst two-dimensional or three-dimensional vernier crack gauges allow continuous metric recording of variations in width and slip.
| Device | Reading accuracy | Measured direction | Recommended construction site usage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fine plaster tell-tale or glass strip | Binary indication (broken or intact) | Global shear | Rapid visual alert on cross-wall zones |
| Plastic vernier strain gauge | 0.1 mm | 2 axes (opening and slip) | Facades, expansion joints, lintels |
| Measuring points for removable extensometer | 0.01 mm | 3 axes depending on installation | Retaining walls, underpinning works |
| Connected potentiometric sensor | 0.01 mm with teletransmission | Continuous multidirectional | Deep excavations close to sensitive structures |
- Initial zero readingInstallation of gauges using mechanical anchors or two-component adhesive prior to any earth movement. Recording of the reference measurement at a stabilised temperature.
- Monitoring during the earthworks phaseDaily readings by the site foreman during topsoil stripping and when approaching the neighbouring foundation level. Weekly readings while awaiting concrete placement.
- Warning level reachedUpon 0.5 mm of cumulative movement or cracking of the plaster tell-tale, immediate convening of the geotechnical engineer and reduction of excavation pass lengths.
- Critical threshold and site stoppageBeyond 1.0 mm to 1.5 mm according to the engineer's instructions, total stoppage of excavation plant and immediate partial backfilling or emergency propping.
Site safety management is based on precise criteria. Art. 68 OTConst requires that excavations be arranged so that falling materials or cave-ins do not endanger any workers. As soon as a deviation appears on the crack gauges, the excavation area along the party wall must be made safe. Work only resumes following written validation of the consolidation protocol by the civil engineer responsible for the earthworks and shoring.
Implementation of the monitoring network and setting of benchmarks
Setting out crack benchmarks and survey targets is carried out before the first bucket stroke for platform preparation or party wall excavation. The masonry and special geotechnical contractor must ensure that every critical point of the contiguous building is instrumented to reflect its mechanical behaviour under the effect of foundation ground stress relief.
- Surface reconnaissance and identificationIdentify existing fractures, expansion joints, and critical structural connections (masonry corners, underpinning returns, lintels). Clean the substrate with a wire brush without damaging the crack edges.
- Mechanical or chemical fixing of gaugesFix orthogonal measuring plates (millimetre vernier gauges or measuring studs for removable deformeters) using plugged screws or a two-component resin suitable for the type of masonry (clay brick, rubble stone, or concrete). Pure plaster tell-tales are reserved for qualitative indications of rapid failure and do not replace a quantified measurement.
- Installation of survey prisms and reference levellingMortar miniature optical prisms onto the adjoining facade at various heights, supplemented by levelling pins at the base of the wall. Take an initial zero measurement independent of construction site movements, tied to a fixed elevation benchmark outside the excavation zone of influence.
| Benchmark type | Reading accuracy | Measured quantity | Preferred use on adjoining properties |
|---|---|---|---|
| Biaxial vernier gauge | 0.1 mm | Opening and shear (X, Y) | Active cracks on rendered masonry or concrete facades |
| Tripod studs for removable deformeter | 0.01 mm | Relative distance between stainless steel balls | Historic buildings or structures sensitive to differential settlement |
| Optical monitoring prism | 0.5 mm | Three-dimensional displacement (X, Y, Z) | Overall monitoring of facade out-of-plumb and base-of-wall settlement |
| Gauged plaster tell-tale | Failure indicator | Clean tensile break | Immediate visual signal for site agents and site foremen |
Reading protocols, alert handling and file maintenance
Crack monitoring derives its full evidential value from regular data collection and rigorous archiving. The absence of a reading at a key stage of earthworks deprives the contractor of any defence against a claim by the neighbouring owner.
- General excavation phase: visual check and gauge readings at least twice a week.
- Excavation phase in hit-and-miss bays or underpinning: daily readings before and after each excavation pass.
- Pumping or dewatering phase: daily monitoring of settlements and the adjoining piezometric level.
- Site shutdown period or extended bank holiday weekends: systematic inspection prior to restarting excavation plant.
As soon as a vigilance threshold set by the civil engineer is reached, the site foreman submits the reading sheet to the site management. If the alarm threshold is exceeded, excavation works are stopped in the affected sector, the area is secured in accordance with the provisions of art. 68 OTConst to prevent any cave-in endangering personnel or the adjoining structure, and precautionary measures (propping, partial backfilling or grouting) are defined before reopening the excavation.
Each interim survey must include close-up photographs showing a visible millimetre scale, certified timestamp, and precise location of the benchmark on the phasing drawings. This file, updated weekly, is signed off by the site agent and made available to the client, in accordance with art. 365 CO which requires the contractor to report circumstances compromising the proper execution of the works.
Crisis management: emergence of defects and neighbour claims
The sudden appearance of a crack or a neighbour's claim during earthworks demands an immediate, methodical response. The common mistake is to deny the occurrence or undertake hasty repairs on one's own initiative. The absolute priority is to freeze the geotechnical situation and establish the contractual chain of liability before any plant restarts.
- Securing the area and targeted suspensionHalt excavator digging or driving operations in the affected sector. Stabilise the toe of the slope by partial backfilling or installing an earth bund if the excavation face threatens to slip beneath the neighbouring footing.
- Contractual notificationNotify the site management and the geotechnical engineer without delay. In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor notifies the client of any circumstance compromising the proper or timely execution of the works, failing which they bear the consequences.
- Crisis joint inspection recordConvene the civil engineer, the client's representative, and the neighbouring owner for an emergency on-site survey. Immediately record the readings on the crack gauges and shoring deformations.
- Adjustment of the retaining schemeHave an appropriate corrective design approved by the geotechnical engineer: hit-and-miss underpinning, emergency soil nailing, steel strutting, or modification of the excavation phasing.
All incident documentation — timestamped photographs with a graduated scale, inclinometer readings, vibration logs, and plant timesheets — must be compiled as an appendix to the site diary. Art. 364 CO subjects the contractor's liability to the same rules as that of the employee; the contractor demonstrates diligence through full traceability of their actions when faced with unforeseen risks.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if a neighbour refuses access to install crack gauges before excavation?
Record the refusal immediately in a registered letter sent to the owner and inform the site management. Arrange for a judicial bailiff's report or high-definition telephoto survey from the property boundary or the public domain. In the absence of internal joint measurements, you will have conclusive evidence documenting the visible condition of the facade and the physical impossibility of carrying out internal monitoring.
How should one respond when a millimetre gauge reaches the intervention threshold?
As soon as the limit value set by the engineer is exceeded, halt earthworks in the affected area. Notify the site agent and the geotechnical consultancy via a written report. Inspect the shoring, the slope, and the base-of-excavation drainage. No excavation must resume without written technical instructions from the engineer, who will prescribe strutting, temporary backfilling, or additional ground anchors.
What evidential value does a crack photo taken with a site smartphone have?
A simple digital photo remains contestable if the metadata is not certified. To constitute robust evidence, the shot must include a millimetre rule or graduated scale affixed against the masonry surface, a unique identification code for the crack, and a calibration target. The raw file with automatic timestamping must be filed on the same day in the project folder and validated by a signed joint inspection record.
Who appoints the expert and covers the cost of the pre-works survey?
Establishing the preliminary joint inspection record is in principle the responsibility of the client, often through an independent civil engineer or surveyor. The masonry contractor must imperatively require this full dossier before breaking ground with the excavator. If none exists, the contractor assumes their own liability and must notify the project management of the absence of a survey to suspend operations.
Texts and standards cited
- COobligations of the contractor: liability is subject to the same rules as that of the employee; they execute the works in person or under their personal supervision; unless customary or agreed otherwise, they procure the necessary equipment, plant, and tools at their own expense.
- CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is responsible for the sound quality of the materials they supply; if materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the works, the contractor immediately informs the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).
