Key takeaways
- The in-situ geometric volume never corresponds to the volume actually loaded into the lorries.
- Each ground type imposes a distinct initial bulking factor and residual bulking factor.
- On-site reuse requires calculating compaction to prevent a shortage of soil during backfilling.
- The transport consignment note and weigh tickets remain the only valid evidence against the client.
Distinguishing between in-situ volume and bulked volume to size logistics
Measurement by excavation void corresponds to the theoretical geometric volume calculated from original ground level profiles. During extraction with an excavator, the soil structure is disrupted: air enters between the particles, immediately increasing the apparent volume of the material. A misconception about this fundamental difference leads directly to transport ordering errors, risks of congestion on the construction site, and disputes during final account sign-off.
- Initial bulking
- Immediate volumetric increase of ground excavated from its natural state, expressed as a multiplying factor applied to the in-situ volume.
To calculate the bulked volume to be removed ($V_f$), the initial bulking factor ($C_i$) is applied to the geometric volume measured in situ ($V_p$) using the exact formula: $V_f = V_p \times C_i$. This result determines the theoretical number of skips or 5-axle lorries to schedule for the construction site. Failing to factor in this value inevitably leads to underestimating the vehicle fleet or halting earthworks progress.
| Ground type | In-situ bulk density (t/m³) | Initial bulking (Ci) | Residual bulking (Cr) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Topsoil and silt | 1.4 - 1.6 | 1.20 - 1.25 | 1.02 - 1.05 |
| Clay and marl | 1.8 - 2.0 | 1.30 - 1.40 | 1.05 - 1.10 |
| Gravel and sand | 1.7 - 1.9 | 1.10 - 1.15 | 1.00 - 1.02 |
| Fractured rock / Soft sandstone (molière) | 2.2 - 2.5 | 1.45 - 1.60 | 1.15 - 1.25 |
Organising waste removal traceability and managing on-site reuse
The theoretical calculation must be checked daily against the reality of the landfill and the construction site. Precise monitoring relies on the transport consignment note and the weighbridge tickets printed at the landfill or sorting centre. In accordance with the provisions of the Waste Prevention and Disposal Ordinance (OLED), sorting of excavated material must be carried out rigorously to separate topsoil, non-polluted excavated material, and polluted material.
- Calculate theoretical in-situ volumeExtract exact quantities from earthworks drawings or topographical surveys carried out by the surveyor.
- Apply appropriate factorMultiply in-situ volume by the factor $C_i$ corresponding to the actual soil type identified during trial pits.
- Check weights and transport notesCompare actual tonnage removed (converted to volume based on the bulk density of bulked soil) with theoretical calculations to adjust invoicing.
- Anticipate reuse volumesCalculate on-site stockpile requirements by applying residual bulking $C_r$ to ensure the required volume for perimeter backfilling.
When reusing material on site to backfill voids around basement retaining walls, the site manager must retain a sufficient stockpile. If excavated soil is reused, the volume required in temporary stockpiles is calculated using the residual factor. Care must be taken to ensure stripped topsoil is stored separately and reclaimed in accordance with the Waste Ordinance to preserve its biological and geotechnical properties.
Practical calculation of bulking and logistical impact
In earthworks, confusing the volume measured in the excavation (in-situ volume or m³ of excavation) with the volume once the material has been excavated (bulked volume or m³ of transport) constitutes a major organizational error. As soon as the excavator bucket breaks up the natural ground, air voids form between rock or soil particles. Apparent bulk density drops and overall volume immediately increases.
Theoretical calculations rely on the fundamental formula: Bulked volume = In-situ volume × Bulking factor (C<sub>f</sub>). This factor varies considerably depending on soil particle size distribution, plasticity, and moisture content. To schedule lorry turnarounds or skip capacities, the foreman must apply the specific ratios observed on Swiss construction sites.
| Ground type | In-situ bulk density (t/m³) | Initial bulking factor (C<sub>f</sub>) | Bulked bulk density (t/m³) | Residual bulking after compaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Topsoil / Humus | 1.2 - 1.4 | 1.20 - 1.25 | 1.0 - 1.1 | 5% to 10% |
| Plastic clay and marl | 1.8 - 2.0 | 1.30 - 1.40 | 1.3 - 1.5 | 10% to 15% |
| Sandy gravel / Alluvium | 1.9 - 2.1 | 1.15 - 1.20 | 1.6 - 1.8 | 0% to 5% |
| Molasse / Weathered rock | 2.2 - 2.4 | 1.40 - 1.50 | 1.5 - 1.7 | 15% to 20% |
| Solid rock (blasting/hydraulic breaker) | 2.5 - 2.7 | 1.50 - 1.70 | 1.6 - 1.8 | 20% to 30% |
Managing on-site reuse and checking against consignment notes
When excavated materials are reused on site for structural backfill or filling perimeters, a second phenomenon occurs: residual bulking. Mechanical compaction (tracked plant, vibrating roller, vibrating plate) reduces the voids introduced during extraction, but the reinstalled ground never fully recovers its initial density without considerable energy input. In accordance with the rules of the Construction Works Ordinance, backfills and slopes must be stabilised to prevent slippage.
- Calculation of in-situ backfilling requirementDetermine the geometric volume to backfill (V<sub>remblai</sub>) from the construction design profile.
- Application of residual compaction factorMultiply this volume by the residual bulking factor. For compacted gravel, allow approximately 1.05 × V<sub>remblai</sub> of bulked material to be installed.
- Balancing volumes to remove (earthwork balance)Subtract the bulked volume reserved on site from the total bulked volume extracted. Only the exact remaining balance must be covered by transport dockets and sent to off-site disposal.
From an administrative and accounting standpoint, verifying removed volumes is based on strictly comparing joint excavation measurements against the summary of transport consignment notes. Structural work and masonry custom and practice demands absolute rigour when checking weighings and volumes.
The site manager must ensure drivers and the chargehand understand how to fill skips optimally. A 5-axle lorry carrying a capped statutory payload must balance the apparent volume of the bulked soil with the maximum allowable gross vehicle weight on public roads, avoiding the dual traps of overload at the weighbridge and transporting air.
Managing volume variances, logistical claims, and measurement disputes
On an earthworks construction site, discrepancies between theoretical volumes excavated on the drawing and volumes tipped at a licensed landfill represent one of the primary drivers of cost overruns. When the volume of soil removed exceeds the quote's forecasts, the site manager's responsibility is to determine the cause of the excess immediately: unexpected changes in ground conditions, underestimation of the initial bulking factor, or inaccuracies in on-site measurements.
- Notification of supplementary quote or duty to notifyAs soon as a change in ground conditions is identified (such as switching from compact marl to plastic clay, increasing bulking from 20% to 35%), the site management immediately notifies the client in writing. In accordance with the Code of Obligations (CO), the contractor must report any circumstance that jeopardises the proper execution of the works, failing which they will bear the additional costs.
- Carrying out a joint measurement of the excavation profileBefore disputing any lorry turnarounds, carry out a topographical survey of the excavation (excavation base and slopes). This survey establishes the in-situ volume ($V_p$) definitively. Comparing this with the bulked volume ($V_f$) recorded on the transport consignment note allows the actual bulking factor to be verified scientifically ($C_f = V_f / V_p$).
- Handling excess during reuse or off-site removalIf the bulked volume exceeds the temporary storage capacity allocated for on-site reuse, the foreman must reorganise the rotation of skips. Recoverable materials must be segregated in accordance with the Waste Prevention and Disposal Ordinance to avoid landfill penalties for improper mixing.
In the event of a financial dispute over the final account for waste removal, only construction site records duly signed by the site management are authoritative. Strict traceability between loading with the bucket and delivery to the landfill protects the contractor against unilateral budget cuts during measurement accounting.
Frequently asked questions
How do you justify an excess in tonnage to the client if the geometric profile of the excavation has not changed?
The excess is explained by the difference between theoretical in-situ volume and the bulked volume actually loaded into the lorries. To obtain approval for additional transport costs, present the weighbridge dockets alongside a geotechnical report demonstrating a bulking factor higher than the indicative tender value. Measurement must always link tonnage to the actual soil factor.
Who bears the additional transport cost if soil reused on site occupies more space than planned?
If the temporary stockpile area becomes inadequate due to bulking, unforeseen internal earthmoving or removal of the surplus is at the client's expense, provided the foreman issued a notification of interruption or variation as soon as storage limits were reached. Without prior notice, the contractor risks having to bear the additional logistical costs.
What is the evidentiary value of a transport consignment note not signed by the site management?
A transport consignment note lacking a signature or sign-off by the site management lacks joint evidentiary value. To prevent the rejection of these volumes in the monthly valuation, the site manager must attach weighbridge tickets from the licensed landfill and cross-reference these against the driver's log and site diary.
Can soil removal be invoiced by bulked volume instead of excavated in-situ volume?
The measurement method depends on the terms of the works contract and the Standard Item Catalogue (CAN) classifications. Earthworks are generally measured by in-situ volume ($m^3$ within profile). If the tender provides for payment by transported volume ($m^3$ bulked) or tonnage, the contractor must strictly apply the bulk density agreed upon and approved on the consignment note.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365Immediate notice to the client if the ground or other circumstances jeopardise the proper execution of the works.
- OLEDRequirements relating to sorting and recovery of soil and excavated materials.
