Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 201 / 211.0SIA 414 tolerances, tests and substrate acceptanceChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Reporting a non-compliant substrate before laying masonry: format, recipient and notice period

In masonry and special works, building on a non-compliant substrate directly engages the company's liability. This chapter details the exact procedure for drafting the interruption notice, notifying the client or their representative, suspending laying operations, and recording the event in the site journal to avoid any shift of liability.

Key takeaways

  • The mason must inspect the substrate and immediately report any defect observed prior to execution.
  • The notice of defect must be sent in writing to the client or site management.
  • Suspending works protects the contractor against the consequences of executing work on a non-compliant substrate.
  • Each observation and notification must be entered in the site journal on the very same day.

Procedures for preparing and issuing the notice of defect

Before starting to lay masonry units, the site foreman or the site manager carries out the acceptance inspection of the substrate. If the substrate exhibits deviations beyond permissible tolerances (offset elevations, out-of-plumb underlying structure, insufficient cleanliness, misplaced starter bars, or degraded concrete), the contractor must not proceed without reservation. The Code of Obligations (CO) (art. 365 CO) and standard SIA 118 formally define the contractor's duty to notify. If the mason neglects to report the defect and carries out the work, they assume the financial and technical consequences of subsequent remedial work.

The notice cannot be a mere oral remark made in the field. To take legal effect, the report must take the form of a written, dated and signed document. It is addressed directly to the client or to the site management (mandated representative). The document specifies the exact nature of the defect identified, its precise location on the drawings (gridlines, levels, axes), as well as the measured deviations relative to the applicable tolerances of standard SIA 414.

  1. Joint measurement survey of deviationsMeasure deviations (levels using a spirit/laser level, out-of-plumb, setting-out dimensions) and take dated photographs.
  2. Drafting the formal documentPrepare a written notice stating the affected substrate, the exceeded tolerances, and the impossibility of executing the masonry in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade.
  3. Transmission to the qualified recipientSend the notice by registered post or hand-deliver it against formal receipt to the site management.

Suspension of works, traceability and handling management silence

As soon as the notice of defect is issued, the masonry crew suspends operations in the affected area. Continuing to build a wall on a floor slab that is outside tolerances or on defective waterproofing shifts liability for future defects onto the masonry contractor. The suspension remains in force until a remedial decision has been formally approved or a written instruction to execute despite reservations has been served by the site management.

If the client or site management fails to reply to the notice within a reasonable timeframe or demands that the construction site proceed without correcting the substrate, the mason must demand a written site work order. If this order confirms laying despite the reported defect, the client then assumes liability for technical consequences, provided personal safety is not compromised.

Traceability on the construction site relies on the site journal. The site supervisor must enter the date and time the defective substrate was discovered, the stoppage of works in the area, the reference of the notice issued, and any redeployment of personnel to other tasks. These entries constitute admissible evidence to substantiate an extension of time or a claim for compensation for involuntary construction site interruption.

  • Mandatory entries in the journal: blocked area, affected workforce, bad weather, or redeployment hours.
  • Archiving: attach the inspection report, photos, and a copy of the interruption notice to the site journal.
  • Follow-up: send a written reminder after 48 hours without instructions from the site management.

Format and technical content of the substrate defect notice

In masonry and special works, identifying a non-compliant substrate (shifted foundation slab, concrete wall outside verticality tolerances under standard SIA 414, poorly cropped pile head, or contaminated/unstable bearing soil) requires the site foreman or site manager to formalise reservations immediately. Under standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), the contractor is bound by a strict duty to notify as soon as an anomaly in the ground or preceding works jeopardises the proper execution of the masonry.

To ensure technical and legal validity, the notice must specify the exact location of the non-compliant zone, the measured deviation relative to applicable tolerances (for instance, an out-of-plumb of 25 mm instead of the permitted 10 mm), the direct technical consequences for the masonry to be laid, as well as the corrective measures requested before the masons resume work.

Key components of the defect notification file
Document sectionTechnical data to recordTraceability objective
Identification and locationProject gridline, profile elevation, structural element designation (e.g. basement 1 foundation slab).Define the precise scope of the defective work.
Joint measurement surveyDeviation recorded using an optical level or gauge against standard SIA 414.Provide physical proof of the tolerance breach.
Impact on subsequent worksImpossibility of ensuring block seating, buckling risk, or cover defect.Justify technical suspension of the work item.

Recipient, deadline management and site journal traceability

The notice of defect is addressed directly to the site management (mandated architect or civil engineer) with a copy to the client. The document must set a specific deadline for response to obtain execution instructions (remedial orders, scabbling of defective concrete, or levelling screed borne by the preceding trade package).

  1. Drafting and sending the notificationDraw up the dated written notice with photographic records and measured quantities. Send via registered post or official electronic mail to the site management.
  2. Zone shutdown and journal loggingSuspend masonry assembly on the defective section. Log the work stoppage in the affected area, the number of workers impacted, and the crew's temporary redeployment in the site journal on the same day.
  3. Action in case of no response or instruction to proceed regardlessIf the site management remains silent or demands that work proceed without correcting the substrate, the mason confirms in writing that they are executing the instruction under express reservation of liability exemption, in accordance with the duty to warn under standard SIA 118.

Managing deadlocks and liabilities when site management fails to respond

When a defective substrate (slab exhibiting excessive deflection, concrete wall outside SIA 414 flatness tolerances, or uneven course bed) is subject to an interruption notice, masonry enters a critical holding phase. The Code of Obligations (CO) (art. 365 CO) and standard SIA 118 require the contractor to inform the client or site management immediately. If site management remains silent or orally demands that walling continue without issuing written corrective instructions, the site foreman or site manager must not give in to schedule pressures under any circumstances without protecting the company.

  1. Notifying the suspension of masonry worksUpon discovering the defect on the substrate, send written notice of work suspension (A-Post with signature or confirmed email) to the site management. Specify the exact area and declare the immediate stoppage of wall-building tasks in the affected zone.
  2. Logging the stoppage in the site journalRecord the impact of the standstill in the site journal on a daily basis: mason workforce idle or redeployed, impossibility of erecting scaffolding or setting up formwork, and delays generated on the overall schedule.
  3. Dealing with silence or an oral instruction to proceed regardlessIn the absence of a written response within 24 to 48 hours, send a formal reminder. If the site management gives oral instructions to execute the work on the defective substrate, immediately send written order confirmation under express reservation. State that work resumes solely on the project manager's explicit instruction, which transfers liability for future defects (cracking, waterproofing failure) to the client.

Erecting masonry on an unreported substrate that exceeds SIA 414 tolerances makes the mason fully liable for remedial works. Thorough written traceability constitutes the only technical and legal shield guaranteeing coverage of extra costs and extensions of contractual deadlines.

Frequently asked questions

To whom should the notice of non-compliance be sent if the site management is absent from the construction site?

The notice of non-compliance must be sent directly to the official office address of the site management, with a formal copy to the client. Even if the clerk of works or architect is absent from the construction site, sending via official email combined with a registered letter or notification on the construction site's collaborative platform is legally binding. Setting out or laying the first bricks on the affected zone must strictly be halted.

Can masonry be laid on a defective foundation slab if site management refuses to sign the site journal?

No. Refusal by site management to initial the site journal does not validate the substrate. The site manager must send the notice-of-defect report by A-Post registered mail to the architect's office and suspend vertical masonry. If site management issues a written order to lay masonry despite refusing to initial the inspection record, the mason issues a formal reservation that releases them from warranty liability for future defects.

What deadline should be granted to site management to respond to a non-compliant substrate notice?

Standard SIA 118 and art. 365 CO require immediate notice, but do not set a fixed response period for site management. A precise deadline should be stipulated in the written notice (generally 24 to 48 working hours depending on schedule urgency), stating that upon expiry without technical directives, masonry works in the area remain suspended and generate a delay attributable to the client.

What should be done if site management orders wall flatness to be made up with masonry mortar?

Masonry jointing mortar is not a structural build-up or thick levelling material. A technical data sheet and a written site work order specifying the approved reprofiling product to apply must be demanded. If the thickness exceeds SIA 414 tolerances, applying inappropriate mortar will lead to surface stepping and cracks for which the mason will be held liable if no reservation was issued.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for construction works and contractor's duty to notify
  • SIA 414Tolerances in building construction
  • Code des obligations art. art. 365 COImmediate notice to the client in the event of defective materials or ground

In the same section