Key takeaways
- Laying each rubble stone on its quarry bed guarantees stable transmission of vertical loads.
- Through-stones tie the wall faces together and prevent bulging or detachment of the wall.
- Hydraulic lime mortar preserves the flexibility and breathability of traditional masonry.
- Using rigid Portland cement on an old substrate causes cracking, spalling, and salt-induced damage.
Bonding and laying: quarry bed, headers, and corner quoins
The stability of a traditional load-bearing wall relies on the gravitational distribution of forces within the masonry. Unlike modern gauged blocks laid with thin-bed mortar joints, rubble stone requires an accurate geological reading before laying. Laying a stone off its natural bed (face-bedded), i.e. with its sedimentary strata running parallel to the vertical face, exposes the masonry to rapid spalling under the effect of frost and compression. The golden rule is to bed the stone on its natural quarry bed, either level or with a very slight inward fall.
- Through-stone (bonder)
- Ashlar or rubble stone whose longest dimension spans the full thickness of the wall, mechanically linking the external and internal faces to prevent any outward bulging of the rubble core.
In thick double-faced walls with a central rubble core, the recurring defect observed on alteration construction sites is a lack of transverse tie. Without through-stones distributed at a rate of at least one per square metre of wall face, the two faces work independently, creating a risk of buckling or bulging under axial load. At corners and opening reveals, toothed bond quoining alternates stretchers and headers to lock the right-angle returns without continuous vertical fault lines.
- Rough cutting and dressingRemove fragile edges using a lump hammer and stone axe. Rough out the bedding face to guarantee a flat bed without any central pivot point.
- Dry laying and shimmingOffer the stone up onto its bed; adjust with hard stone spalls (shims) to achieve direct mechanical balance before applying binder.
- Mortar fillingGenerously fill the bed and perpend joints by squeezing out mortar. No air voids must remain behind the bedding shims.
- Staggering vertical jointsPerpend joints must strictly be staggered by at least one-third of the length of the underlying stone to prevent straight joints.
Binders and junctions: preserving the old substrate against modern cement
The choice of binder determines the durability of the old wall. For decades, repair interventions used pure Portland cement to repoint or rebuild breaches in historic masonry. This practice represents a major technical error with destructive consequences: cement has an excessively high modulus of elasticity and a water vapour impermeability that traps moisture inside the adjacent stones.
| Technical criterion | Natural hydraulic lime mortar | Pure Portland cement mortar |
|---|---|---|
| Water vapour permeability | High, allows diffuse evaporation | Nil to very low, traps condensation |
| Modulus of elasticity | Low, accommodates flexible deformations | Rigid, concentrates mechanical stresses |
| Soluble salt content | Virtually nil | High, risk of efflorescence and honeycombing |
| Behaviour during frost | The mortar erodes before the stone | The stone freezes and spalls beneath the joint |
On a contractual level, when a site supervisor works on an existing structure showing defects or materials degraded by previous unsuitable mortars, the duty of notification applies immediately. According to art. 365 CO, if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which the contractor shall bear the consequences.
Forming a junction or toothing into a degraded historic wall requires careful raking out of old joints using a flat chisel without excessive percussion, clear-water dusting, and the application of natural hydraulic lime batched with well-graded local sands. Worker safety elements during local dismantling fall under the general requirements of the Construction Works Ordinance, requiring reliable shoring of the core before any removal of load-bearing rubble stones.
Dressing, bush-hammering, and rebating: matching the rubble stone to the existing face
On a rehabilitation or underpinning construction site in Romandy, incorporating a new rubble stone into a traditional bond requires cutting calibrated to the original texture and bed. Plateau molasse sandstones, Jura limestones, or Alpine granites do not behave the same way under the tool. The goal is not to achieve a polished face, but to ensure a strictly trued bed to prevent point load transfers that fracture underlying stones.
- Broaching
- Operation consisting of scoring regular grooves across the exposed face of a soft to semi-hard stone using a broaching chisel or axe-hammer, in order to blend the wall face with the surrounding historic masonry.
- Roughing out and blockingThe raw stone mass is split using a stone axe or sledgehammer to eliminate friable portions. The quarryman or mason defines the face arrises, leaving a safety overthickness for the finish dressing.
- Truing beds and jointsUsing a point chisel and straightedge, true the bottom bed and top bed over at least two-thirds of the stone's depth. The perpend joints are cut square to the face to prevent wedge-shaped joints that squeeze out mortar under pressure.
- Face dressing and rebatingDepending on the original structure, the exposed face receives a rusticated pointed finish, bush-hammered finish, or broached finish. The rear lateral faces undergo controlled rebating to create the necessary space for core filling mortar without weakening the bed.
- Purging and dustingRemoval of loose spalls and quarry dust with a stiff brush, followed by thorough pre-wetting to saturation before laying to prevent premature desiccation of the binder.
Diagnosis of defects and toothing/stitching methodology under load control
Work on a cracked or leaning historic wall begins with the careful removal of previous incompatible repairs. The most destructive mistake of recent decades is the injection or patching with pure Portland cement on masonry laid with air lime or natural hydraulic lime. Cement forms a rigid, impermeable shell that blocks water evaporation. Mineral salts then crystallise behind the render or in the core of the stone, causing limestone to spall or molasse sandstone to disintegrate rapidly.
| Technical characteristic | Air lime mortar / NHL 2 | Gauged mortar (lime/cement) | Portland cement mortar |
|---|---|---|---|
| Modulus of elasticity (E) | Low: accommodates slow building movements | Medium: moderate flexibility | Very high: rigid, thermal cracking |
| Water vapour permeability | Very high: natural moisture venting | Medium: partial condensation risk | Nil to very low: traps liquid water |
| Soluble salt content (sulphates) | Nil: zero risk of destructive efflorescence | Low to medium | High: development of ettringite and salts |
| Adhesion to damp substrates | Excellent through capillarity and carbonation | Adequate with preparation | Poor without a bonding primer |
Replacing a degraded rubble stone or repairing a breach requires a rigorous localised underpinning technique, executed in alternating sections not exceeding 80 cm in width. Workers must actively shore up the upper area to prevent any differential settlement. According to art. 17 OTConst, measures must be taken to ensure workers are not endangered by the collapse of building components during underpinning or partial demolition work. Laying replacement stones is carried out by ensuring thorough packing with a wooden or flat iron caulking tool, using a stiff mortar of NHL 2 or NHL 3.5 mixed with well-washed river sand, avoiding all-in aggregates rich in clay fines.
For the solidity of the finished structure, the contractor is the guarantor of technical choices and installed materials. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied; if the contractor notices that the substrate designated or the stone required by the client compromises the proper execution or durability of the wall, they must notify the client immediately, failing which they shall bear the consequences.
Managing failures and repairing historic masonry
On natural stone structures, workmanship failures stem primarily from three deviations: using overly rigid hydraulic binders, omitting through-stones, and careless quoin toothing at corners. When a defect appears during construction work — cracking of a stitched face, loosening under load, or surface spalling from stress concentration —, immediate intervention is required to stabilise the structure.
- Load relief and securingHalt works immediately in the affected area. Install heavy shoring under the floors or upstream vault. Position plaster tell-tales or millimetre fissure gauges to monitor the movement of the masonry bond.
- Contractual noticeRecord the defect in the site diary. In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor promptly notifies the client of any defect affecting the historic substrate or the material that compromises the regular execution of the works.
- Methodical removal and raking outDismantle the defective face in successive stages without heavy mechanical impact (prohibit pneumatic breakers). Rake out the unsuitable mortar in joints and inner rubble fill back to a sound bed.
- Traditional repair and toothingRebuild while strictly respecting horizontal bedding planes. Reinsert through-stones (at least one stone per square metre) and reconstruct corner quoin toothing with a low-binder air lime or natural hydraulic lime mortar.
For detailed pricing of underpinning or face redressing per square metre, costs generally fall within the range of 450 to 900 CHF per square metre depending on accessibility and rock hardness; contractual estimates must be verified against /soumissions/.
The contractor applies recognised good practice and promptly notifies the site management of any unforeseen circumstances regarding the stability of the existing structure.
norme SIA 118
Frequently asked questions
How should you respond to a bulge discovered on a rubble stone wall?
The formation of a bulge indicates a rupture of the tie between the wall face and the rubble core, often due to a lack of through-stones. The floor above must be immediately propped to relieve load on the wall. Once made safe, the deformed wall face must be dismantled in small sections, then restitched by inserting through-stones anchored into the core of the wall with natural lime mortar.
Can a historic wall be consolidated by injecting cement grout?
No, this method is prohibited on soft natural stone such as Swiss Plateau molasse. Cement blocks moisture migration, generates excessive stresses through differential rigidity, and produces harmful sulphates for the rock. Fluid injection grouts based exclusively on natural hydraulic lime, formulated to be non-shrink, are used, ensuring compatibility with the vapour permeability and flexibility of the historic building.
What should be done if reclaimed rubble stones split under load?
The splitting of a stone under load generally results from face-bedding (laying off the quarry bed) or stone-to-stone contact without an even mortar bed. The overlying masonry must be shored up, the fractured block carefully removed using a manual chisel, and its housing cleared. The replacement stone must be dressed strictly respecting its natural quarry bed before being re-bedded with lime mortar.
How do you treat vertical cracking at a quoin toothing junction?
A vertical crack at a corner indicates deficient bonding or differential settlement between two walls of unequal thickness. After stabilising the foundations if necessary, remove the fractured stones in alternating staggered blocks. Re-bonding requires dressing new corner stones and stretchers from hard stone to rebuild deep interlaced quoining, jointed with well-buttered natural hydraulic lime joints.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. art. 365 COmaterial and ground: contractor's liability for supplied material and duty to inform the client immediately if the material, the ground, or any other circumstance compromises the execution
- norme SIA 118General conditions for construction work
