Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 201 / 211.0SIA 414 tolerances, tests and substrate acceptanceChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Masonry cracks: placing tell-tales, monitoring with crack gauges and preparing the expert report

Faced with cracked masonry, the contractor must characterise the phenomenon objectively. This chapter details the installation of tell-tales, the handling of calibrated crack gauges, the measurement frequency according to seasonal thermal cycles, and the procedure for compiling a rigorous monitoring file directly usable by the civil engineer or insurance expert.

Key takeaways

  • The plaster tell-tale signals a brittle failure, whilst the millimetre gauge measures displacement.
  • An active crack exhibits continuous deformation; a stabilised crack remains motionless after thermal movements.
  • Metric monitoring spans several seasons to rule out the direct impact of temperature fluctuations.
  • The expert file requires timestamped photographs paired with a methodical table of thermohygrometric readings.

Instrumenting the structure: installing tell-tales and selecting crack gauges

The appearance of a defect in load-bearing masonry—whether clay brickwork, sand-lime blocks or concrete—requires immediate characterisation before any remedial decision is made. The initial objective is to determine whether mechanical failure has ceased or if stresses continue to develop. The instinctive reaction of superficially filling the crack with mortar conceals the pathology without identifying its kinematics. Two families of instruments make it possible to evaluate substrate behaviour objectively: brittle failure tell-tales and continuous measurement gauges.

Moulding plaster tell-tale
A small strip of pure quick-setting plaster (fibrous plaster or moulding plaster 8 to 10 mm thick and 20 to 30 mm wide), bridged across the edges of the crack after stripping the render. Its clean break demonstrates structural movement without, however, quantifying the magnitude of displacement.

The plaster tell-tale remains an all-or-nothing warning tool. It is inexpensive and quick to install, but it has notable drawbacks: it is sensitive to ambient humidity, can blister outdoors, and provides no directional data. As soon as technical monitoring requires precision, a two-way or three-way calibrated crack gauge is essential. The transparent vernier gauge is the standard equipment on construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland. Comprising two overlapping sliding acrylic plates, it indicates opening, closing, and shear movements to within a tenth of a millimetre.

  1. Substrate preparationStrip the plaster or render over a minimum area of 100 x 50 mm on either side of the crack edge. The mineral substrate must be exposed, brushed and cleared of dust to remove any paint layer or friable material.
  2. Marking out and alignmentMark the centre line perpendicular to the fracture line. Position both plates of the calibrated crack gauge so that the zero mark of the sliding grid coincides perfectly with the reading reticle.
  3. Mechanical and chemical fasteningBond the plates with two-part epoxy resin onto sound masonry. In damp conditions or on porous hollow bricks, mechanically anchor without hammer action as an obligatory backup to avoid jolting the cracked zone.
  4. Commissioning and identificationRemove the temporary locking strips. Number the crack gauge with indelible ink and record the installation date and initial reading directly on the adjacent wall.

Measurement cycles, kinematic characterisation and expert file

Distinguishing an active (live) crack from a stabilised (dead) crack requires an incompressible time frame. Mineral components react reversibly to climatic variations. Masonry contracts in winter and expands in summer. A purely thermal crack opens by a few tenths of a millimetre in January only to return strictly to its baseline value in July. Conversely, deformation caused by differential foundation settlement, earth pressure or structural creep exhibits a cumulative, unilateral progression over the months.

Kinematic behaviour of cracks by cause
Observed typologyTrend in readingsProbable structural causeClassification
Sinusoidal variationOpening in winter, closing in summer, returning to zeroThermal expansion of materialsStabilised / cyclic crack
Continuous progressionConstant widening without returning to baselineFoundation settlement, landslipActive / progressive crack
Vertical shearPermanent unilateral edge displacementExcessive slab deflection, loss of bearingActive structural crack
Absence of movementIdentical reading over 12 full monthsCompleted hydraulic shrinkage of mortarsDormant stabilised crack

Monitoring must be organised according to a strict protocol. Readings must be taken at regular intervals: once a week during the first month of observation, then monthly for a minimum period of six to twelve months to cover the entire annual thermal cycle. Each reading must imperatively be paired with the sheltered outdoor temperature and the day's weather. Temperature shocks between sunny and shaded façades cause significant local deformations.

When a technical or judicial expert assessment takes place, particularly under art. 367 CO governing the examination of the work and notification of defects, the engineer cannot deduce anything from mere oral claims. The contractor or site foreman must provide an unassailable, timestamped file to clarify the liability of the parties involved.

  • A site layout plan and façade drawing locating each device accurately with its identification code (e.g. F1, F2, F3).
  • Timestamped photographs: overall view of the masonry wall, close-up of the crack path, and sharp macro shot of the vernier scale at each reading.
  • The chronological log recording the date, exact time, ambient temperature, horizontal reading (X-axis) and vertical reading (Y-axis).
  • The history of neighbouring works that could have disturbed the stability of the structure (open excavations, groundwater lowering, passage of heavy compactors).

Measurement protocols and kinematic interpretation of defects

Monitoring structural distress in load-bearing masonry requires a rigorous methodology to separate reversible dimensional variations from cumulative irreversible displacements. Distinguishing an active crack from a stabilised crack relies on joint analysis of absolute displacement and ambient thermohygrometric conditions during each reading.

Typology of kinematic behaviour according to instrumented observations
Observed behaviourTrend over an annual cycleDisplacement profileProbable structural diagnosis
Stabilised crackZero variation or below the instrument thresholdFlat curve after the initial loading phaseDifferential settlement completed, initial hydraulic shrinkage dissipated
Cyclic active crack (breathing)Periodic oscillation without drift in the median valueSinusoidal variation synchronised with surface temperatureDifferential thermal expansion, lack of movement joint
Progressive active crackIncreasing opening or shear irrespective of weatherContinuous positive slope on the cumulative crack opening axisOngoing geotechnical instability, impermissible surcharge, lateral thrust

To verify that a defect has stabilised, monitoring must cover the entire annual climatic cycle, representing twelve consecutive months. An isolated reading or a survey limited to a single warm quarter underestimates the winter contraction effects of clay units, concrete or sand-lime elements.

Compiling the adversarial file and submission to the expert

The technical or judicial assessment of cracked masonry relies on the traceability of physical evidence collected by the contracts manager and the site foreman. Any reading lacking context loses its evidential value in disputes regarding the origin of the damage or implications from adjacent works.

  1. Overall view and spatial layoutPhotograph the façade or load-bearing wall in its entirety with a visible scale bar (folding rule, 2 m straightedge) to locate the crack trace relative to openings, ring beams and bearings.
  2. Timestamped macro photograph of the deviceTake an orthogonal close-up photograph perpendicular to the crack gauge vernier or the tell-tale reference marks. Optical timestamping and positioning metadata must be preserved without digital alteration.
  3. Recording environmental physical parametersMeasure and note immediately the infrared surface temperature of the material, the ambient air temperature, and the relative humidity adjacent to the tell-tale.
  4. Entry in the site logbookTransfer the reading value into the monitoring register, noting any concurrent works capable of generating vibration or ground decompression (earthworks, groundwater dewatering, sheet piling).

As soon as abnormal movement threatens wall stability or the defect triggers the statutory defect warranty under art. 367 CO, the contractor submits the metrological register to site management to arrange an adversarial joint site inspection.

  • Copy of the setting-out plan showing all numbered tell-tales
  • Chronological reading sheets signed by all parties present
  • High-resolution photographic file with visible scale references
  • Synoptic chart plotting crack opening progression against adjacent construction site phases

Procedure in case of kinematic escalation or expert dispute

When a crack gauge reveals sudden opening or continuous acceleration of defects on load-bearing masonry, the site team must act without delay. If structural stability is threatened by unforeseen structural movements, evacuating the risk area and installing temporary propping are absolute construction site priorities, in accordance with the provisions of the Construction Works Ordinance (OTConst).

Legally and contractually, the discovery of an un-stabilised, progressive crack demands strict due diligence. Under art. 365 CO, if the ground provided by the client or any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the works, the contractor must inform the client immediately, under pain of bearing the consequences. This formal notice of suspension or reservation must imperatively include recent metrological readings.

  • Immediate entry of the event into the site logbook detailing the time, weather, and nearby ongoing earthworks or demolition.
  • Immediate written notice to site management and the client issuing a notice of defects within the meaning of the Code of Obligations (CO).
  • Locking the timestamped photo documentation showing initial baselines, vernier shifts, and general surface condition without digital modification.
  • Formal request for an adversarial site assessment under standard SIA 118 prior to any resumption of work likely to conceal or alter the crack.

The judicial or insurance expert expects tangible evidence, not subjective speculation. Do not carry out any skim coating, patching or resin injection prior to their inspection. Hasty concealment of an active crack obliterates the readable pattern of mechanical stresses and deprives the company of the means to establish the geotechnical or structural origin of the defect.

Frequently asked questions

Is the traditional plaster tell-tale still accepted in technical expert assessments?

The plaster tell-tale only reveals whether movement has occurred via a clean break, without quantifying the magnitude or direction of travel. For authoritative findings, appointed experts now require orthogonal calibrated crack gauges or dial gauge measurement points. Plaster remains acceptable purely as an immediate visual warning indicator for the site foreman on the construction site.

What should be done if a crack gauge debonds from the wall during the monitoring period?

Never attempt to glue it back approximately in its original spot. Photograph the detached unit immediately, record the incident in the site logbook and secure a new gauge alongside it, establishing a new zero baseline. Document this measurement jump in the summary log so that the civil engineer can correctly correlate the time series during analysis.

How long must readings be continued to declare a crack stabilised?

A crack can only be deemed stabilised after continuous monitoring across an entire thermal cycle, generally representing twelve months of regular measurements. This time frame makes it possible to separate reversible seasonal expansion from continuous structural movement due to differential settlement. Readings every two to four weeks are sufficient under standard conditions, supplemented by systematic recordings of outdoor temperatures.

Is a glued paper strip or tape tell-tale sufficient to prove the absence of movement?

No, a paper or fabric strip lacks rigidity and stretches or debonds under humidity without snapping cleanly. In court or before an insurer, this makeshift method holds no metrological value. Only calibrated measurement instruments, recorded under a strict protocol with sharp photographs of millimetre marks, constitute admissible evidence to release you from liability.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for construction works
  • CO art. 365Materials and ground: the contractor informs the client immediately if the materials, ground, or circumstances jeopardise the proper execution of the works

In the same section