Key takeaways
- Destructive coring is only carried out after proven failure of compliance tests on test specimens.
- Drilling locations require prior Ferroscan scanning to spare main load-bearing reinforcement.
- Characteristic strength on cores incorporates a conversion factor relative to standard test specimens.
- Hole filling requires non-shrink grout applied to cleaned and pre-wetted core-hole walls.
Define the joint coring programme and locate the drill holes
When a series of 28-day control cylinders or cubes fails statistical compliance criteria, doubts arise regarding the load-bearing capacity of the cast component. The civil engineer or the site management may then reject the component or demand additional investigations. Coring cannot be improvised: it must be governed by a joint expert assessment protocol cosigned by the contractor, the civil engineer, and the appointed testing laboratory. This joint approach prevents any subsequent dispute over sampling validity, the representativeness of tested areas, or core dimensions.
Selecting locations involves a strict compromise between concrete representativeness and preserving the structural static integrity. Areas of maximum stress, such as compression flanges of heavily loaded beams or frame nodes, are prohibited. To pinpoint longitudinal and transverse reinforcement, systematically using an electromagnetic rebar detector (Ferroscan or structural GPR) is mandatory prior to any drilling. Severing a stirrup or continuous bar would exacerbate the technical dispute by degrading local load-bearing capacity.
| Extent of questionable area | Minimum number of cores | Recommended nominal diameter | Targeted assessment accuracy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isolated component (slab, shear wall, pillar) | 3 valid cores | 100 mm (slenderness 1:1 or 2:1) | Local strength assessment |
| Large batch (multiple pours) | 6 to 12 cores | 100 mm (50 mm tolerated under conditions) | Statistical approach to homogeneity |
| Confined area or very congested reinforcement | 3 cores minimum | 50 mm (aggregates D ≤ 16 mm) | Cautious interpretation with increased scatter |
Interpret mechanical strengths and durably seal drill holes
A classic error on the construction site consists of directly comparing the raw compressive strength of a crushed core with the strength class specified for moulded test specimens (e.g. C25/30 or C30/37). Hardened in situ concrete in a shear wall or slab experiences hydration, poker vibration, and thermal curing conditions that differ greatly from those of a standard specimen stored in a curing room at 20 °C. According to the state of the art in structural concrete, the required characteristic in situ strength is generally deemed satisfactory once it reaches 85% of the strength required on standard test cylinders.
- End preparation and geometric rectificationCore ends are trimmed using diamond sawing or capped with sulphur mortar to achieve flat bearing faces strictly perpendicular to the core axis.
- Slenderness correctionMeasured strength is corrected based on the length-to-diameter ratio of the specimen (optimal ratio of 1.0 for cube equivalent or 2.0 for cylinder equivalent).
- Moisture weightingMoisture content at the time of testing affects mechanical failure: a water-saturated core exhibits a 10 to 15% lower strength than an air-dried core.
- Comparison with allowable thresholdsThe civil engineer compares the mean of results and the lowest individual value against structural safety criteria.
Once the investigation is concluded, the contractor must immediately carry out the structural backfilling of the created core holes. Filling these openings with leftover masonry concrete or hand-mixed standard mortar is strictly prohibited, as volumetric shrinkage would produce an annular gap, preventing load transfer and creating a water infiltration path.
- Light mechanical scabbing and thorough dust removal from the cylindrical hole surface using dry compressed air.
- Saturate the concrete surfaces with clean water without leaving standing water prior to application.
- Installation of mechanically fastened watertight formwork for through-drilled slabs or shear walls.
- Pouring or dry-packing ready-to-use, high-strength, shrinkage-compensated non-shrink grout or micro-concrete.
- Protection against drying out for at least 72 hours using tightly sealed polyethylene sheeting.
Sampling strategy and joint qualification of the disputed area
When compressive test results on cube specimens prepared at the batching plant or on the construction site fail to achieve the specified characteristic class, coring provides the decisive technical method to resolve the dispute. The test cannot be improvised: it must be governed by a joint expert assessment protocol cosigned by the civil engineer, site management, and the contractor before setting up the core drill. This document defines the structurally contested scope, the wet coring method, the accredited testing laboratory, and the apportionment of investigation costs based on the outcome of the inspection, in accordance with the works contract rules.
Selecting the location and number of cores is not left to chance. Taking a single core carries no statistical validity and risks rejecting a sound structure due to a localised air void. To reliably characterise a disputed volume of concrete (for instance a slab pour or a set of shear walls on the same raft foundation), a minimum sampling group is required: three usable cores represent the technical threshold to validate a local mean, while a series of six to nine cores is required whenever evaluating the overall batch scatter.
| Structural component | Minimum number of cores | Recommended diameter | Positioning constraint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Formwork-cast shear wall (thk. ≥ 20 cm) | 3 cores per homogeneous zone | 100 mm (50 mm tolerated) | Middle third of height, away from construction joints and bottom honeycombing |
| Solid slab or bridge deck | 3 to 6 cores depending on area | 100 mm | Zone of minimum bending moment, rebar detection with Ferroscan mandatory |
| Column or compressed member | 3 cores (or combined method) | 50 mm (L/D ratio = 1.0) | Avoid main longitudinal reinforcement; engineer's prior approval |
| Watertight raft (white tank) | 3 cores minimum | 100 mm | Blind drilling if possible or special sealing watertight against pressurised water |
Prior reinforcement detection using a covermeter or high-frequency GPR avoids cutting load-bearing steel. If transverse rebar is exceptionally present in the core, it must lie perpendicular to the compression axis, and its diameter must not exceed one quarter of the specimen diameter, failing which the compression test result is invalidated.
Interpreting deviations and structural remediation of drill holes
A classic error on the construction site is to directly compare core strength with the strength required from standard test specimens (150 mm cured in water at 20 °C). In situ strength in a structural member is naturally lower than that of compliance test specimens. Actual compaction, construction site curing, mass effects, and mechanical damage from coring induce a normal reduction. In practice, the structural in situ strength requirement is deemed met when the estimated characteristic value reaches at least 85% of the project-specified cylinder strength, or when the lowest individual value does not fall below 75% of this same figure.
- Sawing and end rectificationCore ends are trimmed to achieve a height-to-diameter slenderness ratio between 1.0 and 2.0 (the normative ideal being 1.0 for short cylinders or 2.0 for standard cylinder equivalence). Bearing faces are dressed by sulphur mortar capping or mechanical surface grinding.
- Conditioning and mechanical testingStabilisation of moisture state (storage in laboratory ambient air or saturation depending on the test scope) prior to continuous loading to failure in a compression machine conforming to Swiss metrological standards.
- Geometric conversionApplication of shape correction factors to convert raw measured strength to that of a reference standard cylinder (150 mm diameter, 300 mm height).
- Serviceability verificationThe civil engineer recalculates the actual load-bearing capacity using the in situ value. If the 85% criterion is validated, the concrete is accepted without price reduction or structural remediation.
Plugging core holes affects the durability and watertightness of the structural work. The inner walls of the drilled hole must be high-pressure water washed or mechanically wire-brushed to eliminate drilling slurry, then saturated with water with no standing film. For infrastructure components or those under heavy loads, the method requires pressure injection or firm dry-packing of a non-shrink grout or micro-concrete based on polymer-modified hydraulic binders, achieving a final strength at least equal to the surrounding concrete. In basement slabs and retaining walls in contact with ground (watertight concrete, white tank), sealing strictly requires an epoxy bonding agent or a compressible sealing plug resistant to pressurised water.
Crisis management: conflicting expert findings and structural remediation
When mechanical strength testing on cores confirms a structural deficit or testing laboratory results conflict with witness specimens, the construction site enters a technical dispute phase. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the contractor or site management may request an examination by experts pursuant to art. 367 CO to formalise findings via a joint inspection record prior to any destructive intervention or strengthening measures.
- Joint inspection record and securing the siteDraw up an expert inspection record signed by the civil engineer, the site foreman, and the client's representative. If the safety of load-bearing components is jeopardised by the strength deficit or by weakening caused by the coring itself, immediately record the installation of heavy-duty props beneath the affected slab or beam.
- Strength arbitrationReconcile characteristic in situ strength from coring with the strength required on standard cylinders. Concrete in a shear wall or pillar undergoes actual curing and compaction that differ from specimens stored in a curing room. The engineer must recalculate actual ultimate margins before requiring partial demolition.
- Immediate structural hole fillingTreat cylindrical holes to restore monolithic integrity. Clean drilled hole walls with high-pressure water jets to remove coring slurry, saturate the substrate with water, then pour non-shrink grout or fibre-reinforced thixotropic micro-concrete behind watertight formwork.
In the event of persistent disagreement over the interpretation of crushing values or the impact of severed reinforcement, the client may invoke rights regarding defective execution under art. 368 CO. Definitive technical appraisal will always favour an engineer-approved strengthening solution, such as bonded carbon-fibre plates or concrete jacketing, before considering demolition of the structure.
Frequently asked questions
How are core locations selected to avoid weakening the component?
The location must be approved by the civil engineer following covermeter or GPR scanning. Maximum compression zones, column heads, beam supports, and the immediate vicinity of prestressing tendons must be strictly avoided. Sampling is preferably carried out at the geometric centre of slabs in low bending moment areas, ensuring complete clearance from main load-bearing bars to maintain residual component capacity.
How many cores must be taken to qualify a disputed concrete batch?
For a homogeneous testing area, Swiss practice requires a minimum sample of three valid cores, free of longitudinal reinforcement, to establish a representative mean. If the batch covers an extensive area or volume, such as a raft slab of several hundred cubic metres, the campaign typically extends to six to nine drill holes to apply reliable statistical corrections and isolate any non-compliant batch without condemning the entire structure.
Why does in situ strength differ from control specimen strength?
Cube or cylinder specimens benefit from ideal laboratory compaction and standard curing under water or at 95% relative humidity. In situ concrete on the construction site undergoes temperature fluctuations, surface drying out, variable bleeding, and actual vibration conditions. It is normal and structurally accepted that mechanical strength on in situ drilled cores is 10 to 15% lower than specimen values.
What is the proper method for filling a core hole?
The hole must be rough-cored or scabbed to promote mechanical keying, then thoroughly cleaned of dust and drilling slurry. After saturating the surrounding concrete for several hours, a clamped, watertight bottom formwork is installed. The hole is then filled by gravity or injection using high-strength non-shrink grout or mortar, compacted without air pockets, guaranteeing watertightness and the transfer of compressive loads.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 367examination of the work after delivery, notice of defects, and inspection by experts
- CO art. 368client's rights in case of defects in the work (rejection, price reduction, repair, damages)
