Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 201 / 211.0SUVA safety, health and workstation requirementsChapter 10 of 10 in the section

SUVA work stoppage on a non-compliant excavation: procedure, consequences and resumption

Faced with a work stoppage order issued by SUVA in a trench, the site manager must react without improvising. You will learn how to handle the notification in the field, steer the required technical safety measures, obtain the formal lifting of the order and document the contractual extension of time request.

Key takeaways

  • The SUVA inspector orders an immediate stoppage if the trench poses a serious risk of collapse.
  • Resumption requires technical compliance confirmed in writing by the competent authority.
  • The stoppage generates machine standby costs and disrupts the sequence of trade contractors.
  • An extension under standard SIA 118 depends directly on the initial cause of the earthworks.

Notification of the SUVA stoppage, securing the site and reopening procedure

During a construction site inspection, the SUVA inspector who identifies an unstable excavation enforces an emergency stoppage measure. Personnel present at the bottom must evacuate the excavation immediately. The officer drafts an inspection report and delivers a formal decision to suspend work to the foreman or gang leader. This order prohibits any activity within the designated perimeter, with the strict exception of operations necessary to secure the premises.

Upon notification, the contractor must block physical access using rigid barriers and prohibition signs. Technical supervisors must immediately contact the site management and the geotechnical engineering consultancy. Work cannot resume based on an internal assessment by the contractor: only the authority that ordered the stoppage or the mandated official department is empowered to certify the compliance of corrective measures and issue a written lifting of the prohibition.

  1. Evacuation and cordoning offImmediate exit of bricklayers/masons and installation of safety barriers at ground level with a strict ban on entering the excavation.
  2. Technical adaptation of ground supportInstallation of a modular trench box, battering back the faces to the permissible slope, or resuming excavation from the surface.
  3. Inspection and submission of the fileSubmission of the geotechnical adjustment report, trench shoring technical data sheets and photos demonstrating compliance to SUVA.
  4. Notification of the lifting of the measureReceipt of the formal resumption authorisation issued by the inspector prior to any redeployment of personnel to the bottom of the excavation.

Management of schedule delays, consequential costs and procedures under standard SIA 118

A work stoppage immediately disrupts the critical path of the project. Hired mechanical excavators remain idle, spoil truck turnarounds are suspended and the masonry gang dedicated to the foundation slab or pipe laying must be reassigned to other tasks as a matter of urgency. The idling of a complete excavation team and equipment along with temporary demobilisation generates operating costs of several thousand francs per lost day, an amount varying according to the plant size and the stranded workforce.

Additional cost items and disruptions generated by an excavation stoppage
Item affectedDirect consequence on the construction siteRequired mitigation action
Earthmoving plantFixed hire costs and excavator downtimeNegotiating standby rates or machine transfer
OperativesIdle hours or dispersion of the gangRedeployment to areas outside the excavation zone
Subsequent trade contractorsPostponement of blinding concrete and foundation slab poursFormal readjustment of the intervention schedule
Trench shoring equipmentExpress delivery of trench boxes or hydraulic strutsVerification of ground support calculation notes

On the contractual level, the contractor must immediately notify the site management of the situation. Applying the provisions of standard SIA 118 relating to deadlines and their extension requires a scrupulous examination of the origin of the failure. If the non-compliant excavation stems from a deliberate failure to comply with or negligence regarding the provisions of the construction work ordinance by the contractor, the latter bears full responsibility for the delay and contractual penalties.

The extension of time request submitted to the site management must include a copy of the SUVA report, the site daily log detailing the hours of stoppage, the comparative soil analysis and the revised target programme. Any late submission prevents the site management from taking necessary organisational measures and exposes the contractor to a formal rejection of the delivery date revision.

Technical requirements for excavation compliance

When an inspector halts activity at the bottom of a trench, the prohibition to work remains effective as long as the risk of collapse persists. Resuming earthworks or pipe laying requires complete remediation of the excavation profile according to the recognised trade practices.

Pursuant to art. 68 OTConst, as soon as an excavation exceeds 1 m 50 in depth, unsupported vertical faces are prohibited. The site manager must then order either appropriate battering determined by the soil cohesion, or the installation of a continuous or discontinuous mechanical ground support system.

  • Immediate clearance of excavated material stockpiled less than one metre from unstabilised slope crests.
  • Installation of prefabricated steel trench boxes lowered progressively by the backhoe from the surface.
  • Installation of hydraulic struts or mechanical spreaders torqued to the manufacturer's specified values.
  • Provision of safe access to the trench bottom using anchored ladder towers, excluding any unsecured single ladders.

The inspector from the supervisory body or the enforcement authority requires submission of a precise photographic record and, where applicable, the technical instructions for the trench box used before formally issuing the reopening authorisation.

Contractual impact, financial implications and SIA 118 claims

Halting work in an excavation does not merely hold up the earthworks gang; it freezes the progress of bricklayers/masons, pipe layers and the installation of utility networks. The contractual management of this financial contingency must be handled rigorously to limit the contractor's exposure to the client.

Additional cost items resulting from a work suspension
Expense itemSource of lossSite cost accounting treatment
Plant downtimeExcavator and dumper stranded on the working platformStandby costs according to internal inventory scales
Idle hoursPipe-laying gang redeployed on an emergency basisLogged as logistical redeployment hours
Specialist equipment hireExtension of heavy trench box hire periodHire company addendum and extended custody period
Schedule penaltiesRisk of missing milestone datesNotice of hindrance under standard SIA 118

Where the stoppage order stems from an error in judgement by the contractor, the contractor bears all resulting costs and cannot claim financial compensation. However, if the deterioration of the excavation face results from erroneous instructions from the site management or geotechnical constraints not identified in the call for tenders documents, an extension of time request under standard SIA 118 becomes admissible.

  1. Immediate record and formal noticeSend a formal notice of interruption within twenty-four hours to the site management by registered post or signed protocol, detailing the unforeseen geotechnical situation.
  2. Joint inspection record of idle resourcesLog daily in the site log the idle hours of workers, immobilised plant and emergency shoring measures installed.
  3. Submission of the extension requestCalculate the net impact on the critical path of the project and submit the revised schedule to the client in accordance with the contractual rules of standard SIA 118.

Mobilising shoring not foreseen in the initial quote represents an unexpected expenditure in the region of several thousand francs per week of hire; these costs must be subject to an advance joint inspection record if a variation order is to be processed.

Impasse on resumption and management of schedule disputes

When the inspector refuses to lift the stoppage order or the site management disputes the impact on the critical path, the situation shifts from a technical issue to contractual grounds. If the excavation remains closed for lack of certified shoring or sufficient setback space, the site manager must formalise the hindrances in writing to prevent a formal notice.

  1. Joint inspection record of reasons for refusalDemand a detailed inspection report from the supervisory authority specifying residual non-compliances. Check the design calculations of the trench box or batter slope point by point with the geotechnical engineer prior to any further action.
  2. Immediate notice under standard SIA 118Notify the site management without delay by registered letter or an entry in the site log. Formally record that the access prohibition constitutes an obstacle to proper execution and halts progress for the structural work teams.
  3. Submission of the extension of time requestSubmit a costed claim incorporating the schedule impact analysis. If the earthworks were not included in the main contract or if unforeseen ground conditions necessitated the stoppage, claim an adjustment of contractual dates in accordance with the works contract rules.
  4. Precautionary reorganisation of personnelTemporarily redeploy gangs to workstations outside the exclusion zone to mitigate daily financial losses, while recording the standby hours of immobilised earthmoving plant.

Granting a time extension depends on the initial allocation of ground risks. If the masonry contractor excavated without complying with earthworks profiles or shoring regulations, the delay remains its sole responsibility. Conversely, if the geometry resulted from erroneous formal instructions from the site management, the client must bear the consequences of the schedule adjustment.

Frequently asked questions

Who has the legal authority to lift a work stoppage on an excavation?

Only the body that ordered the measure, namely the labour inspector or the SUVA safety engineer, has the authority to lift the access prohibition. The site management or the client may under no circumstances authorise resumption. The lifting is confirmed in writing following an on-site inspection of the installed shoring or verification of the slope stability calculation note.

Does a construction site stoppage entitle the contractor to an extension of time under standard SIA 118?

An extension of time under standard SIA 118 is accepted only if the stoppage is not the result of negligence by the contractor. If the non-compliant excavation breaches safety regulations due to a lack of propping attributable to the contractor, the delay falls entirely on the contractor. If the situation arises from incorrect ground data provided by the site management, the contractor is entitled to claim an extension of contractual deadlines.

How should a schedule extension claim be formulated following a safety stoppage?

Notice must be given in writing to the site management immediately upon notification of the building control measure. The application must state the cause of the stoppage, append the inspection report, and quantify the delay on the critical path. The contractor details the direct impacts on pipe laying and the foundation slab, requesting a formal adjustment of the overall works programme.

What are the residual costs of an excavation stoppage that cannot be claimed from the client?

Where the non-compliance stems from an execution failure by the contractor, the contractor bears all resulting costs. These costs include excavator downtime, idle time of masonry personnel, emergency shoring hire fees, and fees for the engineer tasked with the design calculation note. No financial compensation may be claimed from the client to cover these shortcomings.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118Management of deadlines, site delays and contractual extension requests
  • CPBreach of the rules of the art of construction: whoever, when directing or carrying out a construction or demolition project, intentionally breaches the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons shall be liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; in cases of negligence, to a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty

In the same section