Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 201 / 211.0SIA 414 tolerances, tests and substrate acceptanceChapter 10 of 10 in the section

Excavation base approval by geotechnical engineer: hold point

This chapter provides the method for organising the approval of the excavation base with the geotechnical engineer and the site management. You will know how to plan the call-in notice period, prepare bearing capacity suitability checks on the earthworks subgrade and prevent the major contractual consequences of concreting without formal clearance of the hold point.

Key takeaways

  • The hold point blocks any blinding concrete pour without written approval from the geotechnical engineer.
  • Formal notice must be sent to the site management at least forty-eight hours in advance.
  • The geotechnical engineer validates the bearing level, absence of disturbance and ground bearing capacity.
  • Concreting without approval transfers full liability for geotechnical defects to the masonry contractor.

Organising the convening and process of the hold point

On a building construction site in Switzerland, clearance of the excavation base is not a mere earthworks formality, but a genuine contractual hold point. In accordance with standard SIA 118, the masonry or earthworks contractor cannot proceed to the next step — laying the geotextile, blinding concrete or raft foundation — without the explicit, recorded agreement of the site management and specialist consultants. This milestone establishes liabilities between the initial state of the subsoil and the execution of the structural work.

  1. Planning and notice periodThe site manager issues written notice to the site management and the geotechnical engineer at least 48 working hours before reaching the theoretical excavation level. This lead time allows the inspection visit to be integrated directly into the specialists' daily schedule.
  2. Maintaining the ground conditionThe formation level must be excavated using a smooth, toothless bucket, without heavy plant tracking over the bearing stratum. The contractor ensures the pumping of infiltration water to prevent any softening of silts or mechanical degradation prior to the inspection visit.
  3. Joint site inspectionThe site foreman meets the geotechnical engineer and the civil engineer to inspect the entire footprint. Observations focus on the correspondence between the actual strata and the preliminary geotechnical soil investigation report.
  4. Signing the clearance approvalThe meeting concludes immediately on site with an approval record or an explicit entry in the site journal, authorising the pouring of the blinding concrete.
Visual checks and measurements carried out during geotechnical approval
Inspected itemVerification methodAcceptance criterionImmediate corrective action
Nature of the bearing layerVisual examination and comparison with borehole logsConsistency with expected geological formationLocalised dig-out of soft clay pockets
Density and consistencyDynamic light penetrometer or driving rodRefusal or values compliant with calculation notesContinuation of excavation down to competent ground
Moisture condition of the formation levelTactile and visual surface inspectionAbsence of free water table, non-muddy groundSump pumping and surface scraping
Levelling and geometryRotating laser tied to surveyor benchmarksTolerances compliant with engineer drawingsFine grading without uncompacted backfilling

Ground suitability assessment and risks of unapproved pouring

The suitability assessment aims to confirm that the bearing capacity assumptions used to design the strip footings or raft foundation are indeed met in actual ground conditions. The heterogeneity of soft soils requires expert interpretation: compressible lenses, the presence of old pipework or localised water ingress must be detected before being concealed by building materials. Art. 365 CO also reminds that if the ground designated by the client is recognised as defective, the contractor must inform the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences.

Concreting an excavation base without having cleared the hold point exposes the structural work to direct penalties. The site management is entitled to demand, at the exclusive expense of the contractor, the complete breaking out and removal of the concrete already placed in order to uncover the ground for examination. If core drilling or destructive probe drilling through the slab is ordered to verify bearing capacity retrospectively, its costs and the associated schedule delays remain entirely payable by the builder.

  • Immediate forfeiture of the right to claim defective ground against the client.
  • Obligation to demolish concrete poured without prior written agreement from the site management.
  • Full liability for costs of supplementary investigation programmes using heavy core drilling.
  • Transfer of civil liability and ten-year liability onto the contractor in the event of future differential settlement of the building.

Excavation base formal recording and clearance chain

On structural work construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland, the intervention of the geotechnical engineer at the excavation base is not a mere informal discussion. It is a formal contractual hold point that secures the transition between earthworks and masonry. The site foreman or site manager must ensure that site observations and mechanical measurements are immediately recorded in an excavation opening record before the arrival of concrete mixer trucks for the blinding concrete.

In situ checks and supporting documents prior to hold point clearance
Examined itemMeans of verificationAcceptance criterionResponsible party
Subgrade bearing capacityDynamic or static plate load testsDeformation modulus compliant with soil reportGeotechnical consultant
Nature of surrounding groundVisual examination and pocket penetrometerGeological layer matching initial boreholesGeotechnical engineer / site management
Excavation levelOptical or laser levelling referenced to fixed benchmarkSetting-out elevation tolerance respectedMasonry site manager
Surface conditionInspection for moisture and alterationAbsence of disturbance, mud or decompressed zonesEarthworks site foreman
Water managementLow point pumping or perimeter drainage trenchDry base, groundwater table lowered below bearing levelEarthworks site foreman

Hold point clearance requires the joint signature of the geotechnical engineer, the site management and the masonry contractor's representative. If localised dig-outs or material replacement prove necessary due to a silty lens or a decompressed pocket, the additional earthworks quantities and the volume of lean packing concrete must be recorded in a joint inspection record on the spot to avoid any dispute over execution quantities.

Management of geotechnical discrepancies and pouring liability

When a discrepancy appears between the design assumptions of the civil engineer and the geology actually revealed at design level, the hold point fulfils its role of technical protection. Art. 365 CO recalls the applicable rule: if the material provided by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).

If the mason makes the unilateral decision to pour blinding concrete or the raft slab without holding this hold point, he assumes major technical and financial risks. By concealing the ground with concrete, the contractor prevents any joint inspection record of density and lithology beneath the footings. If the civil engineer or client refuses to approve the bearing stratum retrospectively, the site management is entitled to require additional destructive investigations or the outright demolition of the poured element.

  1. Discovery of non-compliant groundImmediate stopping of the excavator 10 to 20 centimetres above final level to protect the underlying ground, and written notification to the site management.
  2. Joint inspectionSite visit by the appointed geotechnical engineer to redefine the allowable bearing pressure or prescribe deepening to competent ground.
  3. Dig-out and replacementExcavation of unsuitable materials and rapid backfilling using compacted non-frost-susceptible gravel or mass concrete to prevent degradation from rain.
  4. Execution approvalSigning of the clearance document authorising formwork, reinforcement placement and structural pouring.

Dispute over ground suitability and unapproved pouring: managing legal recourses

When visual examination or dynamic penetrometer testing reveals a bearing capacity lower than the assumptions of the soil report, the excavation base cannot be cleared for concreting. If the site management refuses to record geotechnical reservations or demands the immediate pouring of blinding concrete to adhere to the overall schedule, the site foreman or site manager must immediately formalise a written notice. The contractor then applies his duty to notify pursuant to art. 365 CO.

If the client persists in demanding the continuation of works on a bearing stratum deemed unsuitable by the ground specialist, the contractor applies art. 369 CO. This notice of defects discharges the contractor from the client's rights in respect of defects in the works, provided the reservations were stated with precision, citing the risk of ground bearing failure or cracking of the raft foundation.

  1. Suspension of concreting operationsImmediately halt the fresh concrete delivery schedule and record the moisture condition and nature of compressible pockets in the site journal.
  2. Notification of the unsuitability recordIssue the record of unsuitability prepared by the geotechnical engineer to the civil engineering firm and to the site management within 24 hours.
  3. Protective measures and remediationImplement the measures decided by the consultants: mechanical excavation of unsuitable soils, replacement with lean concrete or installation of an anti-contamination geotextile.

In the event of a pour carried out without prior clearance of the hold point, the site management may reject the work and order the complete removal of the concrete at the contractor's expense. If a technical compromise is sought, through-core drilling and additional destructive geotechnical investigations remain mandatory to prove the density of the bearing stratum retrospectively.

Frequently asked questions

Who must convene the geotechnical engineer to the construction site to validate the excavation base?

Convening is the responsibility of the site manager of the earthworks or masonry contractor. Under the terms of the works contract and recognized good practice, the customary notice period is 24 to 48 working hours before reaching theoretical formation level. This advance planning prevents unnecessary downtime of site teams and ensures the joint presence of the site management to sign the clearance approval record for the contractual hold point.

Can blinding concrete be placed without waiting for the geotechnical engineer's visit?

No. Blinding concrete permanently conceals the lithology and moisture condition of the natural ground. Placing this material without a formal inspection constitutes a unilateral breach of the hold point. If the civil engineer or geotechnical engineer subsequently disputes the bearing capacity of the foundation strata, the site management can demand the complete demolition of the poured concrete or impose destructive additional investigations at the sole expense of the contractor that took this construction site initiative.

What immediate checks does the geotechnical engineer perform during excavation approval?

On site, the geotechnical engineer compares the actual geological formation with the preliminary boreholes. He checks for the absence of unmanaged water ingress, the absence of heterogeneous fill, the cohesion of fine-grained soils or the density of gravels. He frequently uses rapid tests with a dynamic light penetrometer or plate load test. These observations enable him to grant or refuse immediate approval for pouring the blinding concrete.

How should one react if the geotechnical engineer prescribes an unforeseen excavation overdepth?

The contractor must immediately have this decision recorded in the site journal and submit a notice of additional works to the site management. Excavating soft soil and replacing it with lean concrete or compacted granular material alters the contractual quantities. No replacement material may be placed before receiving written agreement from the consultant on the revised excavation levels.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 118General conditions for construction work, management of hold points, notices of defects, and orders from the site management.
  • CO art. 365Materials and ground: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of materials supplied; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he shall immediately inform the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).
  • CO art. 369Exclusion of client rights in respect of defects in the work when the defective execution is personally attributable to him (orders given contrary to the contractor's formal advice or any other cause).

In the same section