Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 201 / 211.0SIA 414 tolerances, tests and substrate acceptanceChapter 4 of 10 in the section

Substrate acceptance report: mandatory details and wording of reservations

On structural work construction sites, accepting a substrate without dimensional checks directly engages your liability. This chapter teaches you how to structure an irrefutable acceptance report, how to formulate precise and quantified technical reservations, and how to have the parties sign jointly on site in order to legally and technically secure your masonry interfaces.

Key takeaways

  • A report without quantified measurements or precise referencing does not discharge any liability on the construction site.
  • Joint acceptance requires the presence and signature of authorised representatives in accordance with standard SIA 118.
  • Each technical reservation must state the measured deviation, the exceeded tolerance and a clearance deadline.
  • The formal notice of defects protects the contractor against unjustified remediation work attributable to the upstream trade.

Structuring the acceptance report to secure construction site interfaces

Acceptance of a substrate constitutes the contractual turning point between two trades. In masonry and reinforced concrete, accepting the work performed by the upstream trade, whether bulk excavation, blinding concrete or a basement raft foundation, transfers custody of the setting-out surface to the subsequent contractor. Without a written joint document drawn up on the spot, defects in levelness, elevation or setting out are presumed accepted without reservation, making any technical or financial compensation impossible in subsequent phases.

To hold probative value against the site management, the report must include strict identification details. Vague descriptions such as "basement" or "east area" weaken the case in the event of a dispute. Each report must record the weather conditions at the time of survey, the exact date, the names and roles of the signatories, as well as the calibrated measuring instruments used for the inspection.

  • Project identification: designation of the structure, precise location by formwork gridline, datum level and slab number.
  • Parties present: name of the site manager, the masonry trade foreman and the authorised representative of the site management.
  • Inspection equipment: optical level or rotating laser with calibration reference, 2 m bevelled aluminium straightedge, stepped measuring wedge.
  • Clear substrate status: accepted without reservation, accepted subject to implementation of corrective measures, or rejected for major non-conformity.

Pursuant to art. 365 CO, if the client or the upstream trade delivers land or a substrate with obvious defects that jeopardise the proper execution of subsequent work, the contractor must give immediate notice to the client, failing which they shall bear the consequences of future defects themselves.

Formulating enforceable reservations, obtaining the signature and setting the deadline

A reservation formulated in terms such as "irregular substrate" or "poorly finished concrete" has no technical weight. An unchallengeable formulation imperatively combines gridline referencing, the physical quantity measured, the permissible value according to standard SIA 414 and the operational impact on subsequent masonry work. Without this data, the site management may dismiss the reservation for lack of precision.

Comparative examples of reservation wording on concrete substrates
Observed anomalyContestable formulationCompliant enforceable formulation
Levelness defect on raft foundationRaft not straight near the wall14 mm dip under the 2 m straightedge at gridline C-4, maximum permissible tolerance of 8 mm according to standard SIA 414 exceeded by 6 mm.
Bearing elevation errorBlinding concrete too highTop level of blinding concrete at level +432.18 m instead of +432.15 m according to engineer drawing no. 102, 30 mm excess thickness preventing reinforcement placement.
Displaced starter barsRebar poorly positioned on the wallDiameter 14 mm starter bars shifted 45 mm inwards between gridlines 2 and 3, preventing compliance with nominal cover of 35 mm.
  1. Joint measurement on the substratePlace the 2 m straightedge on critical areas, insert the measuring wedge graduated in millimetres and have the direct reading witnessed by the site management present on the structure.
  2. Immediate drafting of reservationsRecord the raw measured value, the deviation from the approved working drawing and the exact nature of the essential preparatory works on the acceptance form.
  3. Setting the clearance deadlineAgree mutually on a mandatory cut-off date for defect remediation, scheduled so as not to interrupt the critical path of the formwork or masonry programme.
  4. Joint signature on siteObtain original signatures from both parties at the bottom of the report before leaving the construction site, and provide a hard copy or certified digital duplicate without delay.

Clearance of reservations follows the same formal procedure as initial acceptance. As soon as the upstream contractor or appointed third party has carried out the required planning, scabbing or patch repair, a second joint inspection must be performed at the same geometric points. The final sign-off confirms that the substrate now meets the tolerances of standard SIA 414 and authorises the start of masonry work without transfer of prior defects.

Joint inspection record of the substrate and metric survey

Before starting masonry, underpinning or concreting work on a foundation executed by a third party, the site manager and the foreman must draw up an objective physical survey. Taking over a substrate without a joint inspection record automatically transfers liability for underlying defects to the downstream contractor. According to standard SIA 118, verifying the preceding work and reporting anomalies immediately constitutes an unavoidable operational obligation to prevent any dispute regarding geometric tolerances or load-bearing capacity.

To establish an unchallengeable report, a narrative description is not enough. Each deviation found during the acceptance of excavations, blinding concrete or an existing slab must be backed by a dimension chain referenced to the overall construction site control points. Setting-out, plumb or levelness tolerances must be measured with an optical site level, rotating laser or two-metre straightedge fitted with a steel rule or graduated wedge, and then compared against permissible limit values.

Joint survey grid and qualification of deviations on bare substrates
Inspected elementMeasuring instrumentObserved deviation vs referenceDirect impact on the masonry trade
Excavation base / blinding concreteSite level and aluminium staffElevation at -45 mm below specified datum lineExtra consumption of foundation concrete or cracking risk due to thickness variation
Strip footing for masonry2 m straightedge and measuring wedgeLocal levelness sag of 18 mm under the straightedgeImpossibility of levelling the first course of masonry with standard mortar
Pile head / soil-nailed wallTheodolite or 3D laser65 mm encroachment onto the wall alignment axisReduction of reinforcement cover or formwork thickening
Substrate slab before wall constructionCarbide moisture meter and laserPresence of standing water and unpurged laitanceAdhesion failure of levelling mortar and onset of segregation

When the condition of the ground or preliminary structure presents an obvious technical risk, the duty to notify is required without delay. Pursuant to art. 365 CO, the contractor is bound to notify the client immediately of any defect in the designated ground or substrate provided, failing which they run the risk of bearing the consequences of these defects during subsequent execution stages.

Clearance protocol for reservations, signatures and handling refusals

The substrate acceptance report is not a mere informal release: it binds the site management, the main contractor for the preliminary trade and the receiving contractor. To achieve its full probative effect on the construction site, the document must contain closed technical sections, prohibiting any subsequent unilateral modification.

  1. Rigorous geometric locationIdentify the element by its structural gridlines (for example: gridlines C-D / 4-5), its datum level or official Swiss level, as well as the exact date and time of the joint inspection.
  2. Technical qualification of non-conformityExplicitly identify the nature of the defect (concrete segregation, residual water puddle, axis offset, starter bar out of tolerance) with reference to the approved construction drawing.
  3. Specification of corrective actionDefine the action required from the delivering party: structural patch repair, concrete scabbing, slurry removal, pile cropping or mechanical surface preparation before any work by the following team.
  4. Setting a firm clearance deadlineEnter a precise calendar deadline with a cut-off time for the re-inspection. State the impact on the masonry work schedule to prevent any unjustified formal notice.

If the representative of the handover contractor or the site management refuses to sign the report on the construction site, the foreman or site manager must record this refusal directly on the form with the explicit remark "refusal to sign after joint visual inspection". The document, accompanied by time-stamped photographs with a steel rule, is sent the same day by email and confirmed by registered post, which constitutes notice of defects and suspends the start of subsequent phases without incurring liability.

Managing acceptance disputes and deadlocks on the construction site

When the condition of the substrate jeopardises the work or the site management refuses to sign the acceptance report, the site manager must neutralise the transfer of risk. Accepting an out-of-tolerance substrate without a written document directly engages the contractor's liability for future defects in the cladding or masonry assembly.

  1. Immediate record of refusal on the formIn the event of disagreement on the survey, record on the spot the remark "refusal to sign by the site management" or detail the direct counter-proposals of the representatives.
  2. Formal notice to the clientSend the report by registered post within 24 hours pursuant to art. 365 CO para. 3, in order to notify the defective substrate that jeopardises the proper execution of the work.
  3. Formal determination of the clearance deadlineServe notice of temporary work stoppage on the non-compliant element and set a clear deadline for remediation by the preceding trade, in accordance with the specifications of standard SIA 118.

As long as the substrate is not rectified or approved by a remedial solution expressly agreed by the engineer, the downstream team must not start any installation work. Schedule postponement and idle-time additional costs must be notified without delay to preserve the application of CO on default of the debtor.

Frequently asked questions

What should be done if the site management refuses to sign the acceptance report?

Immediately add a handwritten note of this refusal to the document, accompanied by the joint measurements taken on site. Then send this report by registered post with delivery receipt within 24 hours to the client, making formal reference to the rules of standard SIA 118. Without immediate written notification, subsequent installation amounts to tacit acceptance of the substrate with all its geometric defects.

How should an elevation reservation be worded to make it legally enforceable?

Avoid vague notes such as "slab not flat". Draft: "Basement raft foundation Sector B, between gridlines 4 and 5: measured sag of 18 mm under the 2 m straightedge, exceeding the permissible tolerance of standard SIA 414". Set a specific remediation deadline for the masonry trade before any resumption of work. This dimensional rigour prevents any dispute during the clearance procedure.

Who has legal authority to sign the report on the construction site?

The report must be signed by persons holding contractual representative authority: the site manager or the authorised foreman for the executing contractor, and the supervising architect or authorised inspector for the site management. The signature of a regular worker or a third-party installer does not legally bind the site management and renders the record ineffective in any subsequent dispute before an expert.

Can work commence if reservations have not yet been cleared?

Starting finishing work or installation is strictly prohibited if reservations affect structural functions or waterproofing. If the site management nevertheless insists on progressing, it must issue a signed written service order assuming full liability for future defects. Without this formal order, your start completely releases the preceding structural work trade and engages your five-year warranty.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for construction works and acceptance of the work
  • norme SIA 414Dimensional tolerances in building construction
  • COdefault of the debtor: a debtor is placed in default by a formal notice from the creditor; simply by the expiration of the day where the date for performance was established by mutual agreement or fixed by regular warning.
  • CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of materials supplied; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is recognised as defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the regular or punctual execution of the work, the contractor shall immediately inform the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).

In the same section