Key takeaways
- Simply adding up the raw flow rates systematically leads to oversizing that is costly and hazardous for hygiene.
- Converting the loading units using the simultaneity curve determines the actual volumetric flow rate.
- The flow velocity must comply with the standard limits to avoid erosion, noise and water hammer.
- A diameter sized as tightly as possible reduces the volume of stagnant water and the risk of bacterial growth.
Calculating the actual peak flow rate from the loading units
On a construction site for collective housing or an administrative building, the sanitary installer faces a reflex that is still too widespread: adding up the nominal flow rates of each appliance to choose the cross-sections of the main pipes. This raw addition method produces oversized pipes. An excessive cross-section results in too low a water velocity in normal use, a prolonged residence time in the pipes and an increased risk of bacterial biofilm development, while needlessly increasing the cost of materials and thermal insulation.
- Loading unit (LU)
- Dimensionless conventional value (Loading Unit) defined in Swiss practice, where 1 LU corresponds to a reference flow rate of 0.1 litre per second (6 litres per minute) at a given dynamic pressure.
Sizing according to Swiss rules is based on the SIA 385/1 standard and the industry guidelines for drinking water. Each draw-off point is assigned a value in loading units (LU). Surveying the appliances installed on a section gives the total sum of loading units (sum of LU), which does not reflect the actual service flow rate but the draw-off potential of the branch concerned.
| Sanitary appliance | LU cold water | LU hot water | Rated flow rate (l/s) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Washbasin or hand basin | 1 | 1 | 0.10 |
| Bidet | 1 | 1 | 0.10 |
| Shower with mixer | 2 | 2 | 0.20 |
| Bathtub with mixer | 4 | 4 | 0.40 |
| Kitchen sink | 2 | 2 | 0.20 |
| WC flush (cistern) | 1 | 0 | 0.10 |
| Washing machine (domestic) | 2 | 0 | 0.20 |
Once the sum of LU has been established for a given section (riser, basement collector or apartment distribution), a mathematical simultaneity function is applied to derive the design peak flow rate. In a building of twenty dwellings, it is statistically impossible for all the WC flushes, showers and sinks to operate at full opening in the same second. The simultaneity curve flattens the flow curve as the number of cumulated appliances increases.
Determining the internal diameter according to permissible velocity and pressure loss
Once the peak flow rate of the section is known, the choice of the nominal diameter depends directly on two physical constraints: the maximum flow velocity of the fluid and the residual pressure available at the most unfavourable draw-off point. Excessive velocity causes acoustic noise transmitted to the building structure, accelerates internal erosion of the fittings and generates violent water hammer when timed taps or single-lever mixers are closed abruptly.
| Type of pipe | Maximum permissible velocity (m/s) | Determining criterion |
|---|---|---|
| Floor pipe and terminal branch | 2.0 | Acoustics and flexibility |
| Vertical riser | 2.0 | Pressure loss and noise level |
| Main collector and basement | 1.5 to 2.0 | Flow regularity and wear |
| Booster pump suction pipe | 1.0 to 1.2 | Risk of cavitation |
- 1. Add up the loading units of the sectionCount all the appliances served downstream of the section under study and calculate the total sum of LU, separately for cold water and for hot water.
- 2. Determine the design flow rate using simultaneityConvert the sum of LU into a peak volumetric flow rate (l/s) using the Swiss simultaneity charts or formulas specific to the building's type of use.
- 3. Assess the theoretical velocityUsing the continuity formula Q = v × A, calculate the minimum theoretical internal diameter so as not to exceed the maximum permissible velocity adopted.
- 4. Check the linear and local pressure lossesConsult the pressure loss table provided by the pipe manufacturer (multilayer, stainless steel or copper). Determine the linear losses in millibars per metre and add an allowance for bends, tees and reducers.
- 5. Check the pressure at the highest pointMake sure that, after deducting the geometric height and the sum of the total pressure losses of the network, the prescribed minimum service pressure is still guaranteed at the most unfavourable terminal tap.
Impact of simultaneity on water volume and stagnation risk
Sizing a drinking water network by naively adding up the nominal flow rates of each draw-off point leads to a critical error on the construction site: systematic oversizing of the distribution pipes. In a residential or administrative building, the probability that all taps, showers and WC flushes operate at the same moment is practically zero. Applying the simultaneity curves from the SSIGE guidelines and the SIA 385/1 standard makes it possible to extract the actual peak flow rate from the cumulated loading units. Reducing the cross-section to the technically necessary minimum is not a cut-price saving on material, but the first line of defence against bacteriological degradation of the water.
The simultaneous use factor varies considerably depending on the building's use. In a rental residential building, draw-offs are spread over time, which produces a very damped simultaneity curve as soon as the number of loading units exceeds fifty. Conversely, in sports hall changing rooms, barracks or school workshops, simultaneity becomes total or semi-total at the end of classes or shifts. The sanitary installer must therefore check the intended use of the premises before fixing the diameters of risers and branches.
| Building use | Consumption profile | Simultaneity factor | Main risk to control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collective housing | Short draw-offs spread over the day | Low (standard logarithmic curve) | Stagnation in service shafts and warming |
| Hotels and accommodation | Concentrated morning and evening peaks | Medium to high depending on standard | Pressure drop during grouped draw-off |
| Sports facilities and barracks | Massive, immediate draw-off at the showers | Very high (simultaneity close to 100%) | Critical under-flow and sudden low pressure |
| Offices and administration | Use concentrated at floor sanitary facilities at midday | Low for showers, medium for WCs | Prolonged stagnation during weekends |
Trade-off between permissible limit velocities and flow noise
Once the simultaneous flow rate has been established for each section, the choice of the final internal diameter runs up against two opposing physical limits: the maximum permissible velocity and the minimum flushing velocity. Excessive velocity generates significant linear pressure losses, flow noise transmitted to the building structure through the fixing clamps, and a marked risk of erosion-corrosion on metal pipes and press fittings. Conversely, too low a velocity favours the sedimentation of suspended particles and the anchoring of biofilm on the inner walls.
According to SSIGE guideline W3 and the acoustic requirements of the SIA 181 standard, flow velocities at peak flow must not exceed strict thresholds defined according to the function of the pipe. In floor distribution and individual connection pipes, the permitted velocity is generally kept between 1.5 and 2.0 m/s. On main risers and basement collectors, a velocity of 1.2 to 1.5 m/s avoids exciting resonance in the service shafts and guarantees comfortable residual pressure at the most unfavourable draw-off points without requiring an oversized booster pump.
| Type of section | Recommended velocity (m/s) | Absolute maximum velocity (m/s) | Direct consequence of exceeding it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main collector in basement | 1.0 to 1.5 | 2.0 | Massive pressure losses, whistling noise |
| Riser in service shaft | 1.2 to 1.8 | 2.0 | Acoustic transmission to living rooms |
| Floor pipe to apartment collector | 1.5 to 2.0 | 2.5 | Water hammer when solenoid valves close |
| Individual appliance connection (DN 10 to 15) | 1.5 to 2.0 | 3.0 | Local cavitation and deterioration of the angle valve |
- Survey and conversionList all the appliances supplied by the section and convert each draw-off point into standardised loading units according to SSIGE guideline W3.
- Peak flow rate calculationApply the simultaneity curve or formula specific to the building's use to obtain the design volumetric flow rate in litres per second.
- Screening the diameter by velocityDetermine the theoretical flow cross-section by setting a target velocity of 1.5 to 2.0 m/s, then select the standardised internal diameter immediately available in the chosen pipe range.
- Pressure loss checkAdd up the linear and local pressure losses of the section to ensure that the flow pressure at the highest and furthest point remains sufficient without causing noise nuisance.
Hydraulic non-conformities: how to act on sizing errors
On the construction site, a discrepancy between the plans and the hydraulic reality shows up as two opposite symptoms: a sudden pressure drop on the upper floors during simultaneous draw-offs, or whistling noises and water hammer caused by excessive velocity. When static and dynamic pressure readings diverge from the initial calculation notes based on SSIGE guideline W3 and the SIA 385/1 standard, the site manager must immediately suspend the final connections and carry out a methodical diagnosis section by section.
- Checking dynamic pressures at the critical pointInstall a calibrated pressure gauge on the most unfavourable draw-off tap of the sanitary network. Measure the residual pressure while simulating the peak flow rate calculated with the actual loading units of the landing. If the dynamic pressure drops below the bar required for the mixers to work properly, check the local pressure loss of the meters and main filters.
- Audit of velocities and pipe diameter alignmentCheck the match between the distribution plan and the pipes actually installed in the basement and service shafts. Localised undersizing leads to velocities above two metres per second, causing premature wear through erosion and noise nuisance. Replace badly positioned conical reducers or sharp bends that choke the flow.
- Remedying oversized areasIf the calculation reveals an oversize diameter that favours stagnation and a drop in domestic hot water temperature, recalculate the layout with the exact simultaneity of the appliances. Reduce the pipe cross-section to guarantee complete volumetric renewal of the section, or install a mixed-water loop with controlled flow in accordance with the sanitary requirements.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the pressure drops excessively during simultaneous draw-off in an attic?
First measure the dynamic pressure available at the building entry. If the network pressure is compliant, the drop comes from undersizing of the riser or from excessive pressure loss on upstream components (filter, water softener, non-return valve). If resizing the main layout is impossible, installing a sanitary booster set dedicated to the top levels is the usual corrective technical solution.
How should one react to oversizing found after the pipes have been installed?
An overly wide pipe reduces the flow velocity and dangerously increases the volume of water contained, causing stagnation. On a terminal hot or mixed water section without a circulation loop, the pipe must be removed and replaced by a section adapted to the actual loading units. If there is a major constructional impossibility, it is imperative to incorporate automated flushing devices programmed according to the use of the premises.
Can the permissible velocity be increased in order to keep a compact pipe?
No. Exceeding the maximum velocities prescribed by the professional guidelines generates whistling that is audible in living rooms adjacent to the shafts and prematurely wears copper or multilayer pipe through cavitation. The velocity must be kept within the permitted limits, either by adapting the space taken by the layout or by distributing the hydraulic loads over two separate risers connected to the floor manifolds.
Why are certain continuous consumers excluded from the standard simultaneity calculation?
The simultaneity coefficient is based on the probability of brief, discontinuous draw-off by domestic appliances such as washbasins or sinks. Equipment with prolonged or continuous flow, such as automatic sprinklers, swimming pool filling or certain industrial processes, must be added directly at full flow to the peak flow rate obtained from the simultaneity curve to avoid a complete collapse of the network.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 385/1Domestic hot water installations in buildings - General principles and requirements for sizing and distribution
- Directive SSIGE W3Guideline for drinking water installations - Rules for calculating peak flow rates, maximum velocities and loading units
