Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 250Water hygiene: legionella, temperatures and stagnationChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Limescale: where it forms, what it costs, how to descale without causing damage

This chapter gives you the method for assessing limescale fouling in a domestic hot water calorifier or plate heat exchanger. You will learn how to schedule visual and thermal inspections according to local water hardness, how to select the acid suited to the metals in use, how to set the circulation time and how to carry out flushing without risking acidification of the drinking water network.

Key takeaways

  • A two-millimetre layer of scale reduces heat exchange efficiency by about ten per cent.
  • The rate of limescale precipitation increases sharply when the temperature exceeds sixty degrees.
  • Hydrochloric acid must not be used on stainless steel exchangers, to avoid perforation by pitting.
  • Flushing is complete only when the outlet pH equals that of the cold water network.

Water hardness, thermal precipitation and monitoring protocol

In French-speaking Switzerland, the mineralisation of distributed water varies according to catchment areas and aquifers, with values frequently ranging between 15 and more than 35 French degrees (°fH). Calcium carbonate and magnesium carbonate remain soluble as bicarbonates when cold. As soon as the temperature exceeds the threshold of 55 to 60 °C in a water heater or a domestic hot water exchanger, the calco-carbonic equilibrium shifts: the dissolved carbon dioxide escapes, causing rapid precipitation of calcium carbonate in the form of hard calcite on the hottest metal walls.

The rate of scaling depends jointly on the hardness of the make-up water and the daily volume drawn off. In a storage cylinder with an internal exchanger (coil) or on an instantaneous production module fitted with a brazed plate heat exchanger, the build-up of limescale forms an insulating crust. The thermal conductivity of scale is about thirty times lower than that of copper and fifteen times lower than that of stainless steel. This barrier forces the control system to raise the setpoint temperatures to compensate for the reduced heat exchange, which degrades overall efficiency and increases the risk of under-deposit corrosion through the confinement of chloride ions.

Indicative inspection intervals according to domestic water hardness
Hardness (°fH)Deposition rateVisual inspection intervalRecommended measure
Less than 15Very low to lowEvery 4 to 5 yearsVisual inspection through the manhole during maintenance
15 to 25MediumEvery 2 to 3 yearsReading of the primary/secondary delta T and opening of the flange
25 to 35HighEvery 12 to 18 monthsEndoscopic inspection or removal of the spool pieces
More than 35Very severeAnnuallyCheck of pressure losses and scheduled chemical cleaning

The periodic inspection of a domestic hot water exchanger is first carried out without heavy dismantling, by analysing the operating parameters. A growing temperature difference between the primary fluid and the secondary mixed water, at equal flow rate, indicates fouling of the exchange surface. Likewise, an abnormal increase in hydraulic pressure loss between the cold water inlet and the hot water outlet reveals a restriction of the flow section. On cylinders fitted with an inspection port or manhole, removing the flange allows direct examination of the surface condition of the tube bundle and the bottom of the tank, where limescale sludge detached spontaneously by thermal expansion accumulates.

Chemical descaling procedure, choice of acid and sanitary flushing

Curative descaling of an exchanger or cylinder must never destroy the constituent materials or impair the quality of the drinking water subsequently distributed. The use of hydrochloric acid is strictly prohibited on stainless steel plate exchangers or those brazed with copper or nickel: chlorides destroy the passive film of stainless steel and cause perforating pitting within a few hours. Solutions of citric acid, sulfamic acid or food-grade phosphoric acid are used, formulated with corrosion inhibitors suited to the metals of the domestic hot water calorifier.

  1. Isolation and draining of the applianceClose the upstream and downstream sanitary stop valves. Drain completely the water contained in the calorifier, or isolate the domestic water side of the plate heat exchanger using the dedicated isolating valves.
  2. Connection of the descaling pumpConnect a closed-circuit cleaning unit comprising a tank, an acid-resistant pump and a flow reversing valve. Connect the discharge to the lower part of the exchanger and the return to the upper part to facilitate the evacuation of carbon dioxide.
  3. Injection of the product and monitored circulationInject the diluted acid solution (generally dosed between 5 and 10 % according to the manufacturer's recommendations). Circulate it, reversing the flow every ten minutes. Check the pH of the bath: a pH that rises quickly towards 5 or 6 indicates that the acid is being consumed by the scale; add reagent until the pH stabilises durably below 2, a sign that the reaction has ended.
  4. Draining and neutralisation of the effluentDischarge the spent solution into a treatment tank. Neutralise the acidity using a basic agent (sodium bicarbonate or carbonate) until a pH between 6.5 and 8.5 is reached before any discharge to the sewer, in accordance with local water protection rules.
  5. Intensive flushing with mains waterConnect the cold drinking water supply and flush at full flow to waste into the wastewater drain. Continue running water until the pH and conductivity measured at the drain point are strictly identical to the values of the water entering from the public network.

Scaling kinetics and periodic diagnosis of domestic hot water exchangers

In a drinking water distribution installation, the formation of calcium carbonate accelerates as soon as the contact temperature exceeds 55 °C. In French-speaking Switzerland, networks supplied by aquifers or karst springs frequently show a hardness between 25 and 35 °fH. The passage of cold water through a heat exchanger — whether a tube bundle immersed in a water heater or an external plate exchanger for instantaneous production — causes degassing of the dissolved carbon dioxide. This phenomenon breaks the calco-carbonic equilibrium and leads to massive precipitation of calcite on the metal exchange surfaces.

The thermal resistance of limescale is about thirty times greater than that of stainless steel and four hundred times greater than that of copper. A two-millimetre crust thermally insulates the exchange walls: to maintain the domestic hot water setpoint of 60 °C required for bacteriological prevention, the installer observes a drift in the temperature difference between the heating fluid and the drinking water. This abnormal rise in the return temperature, or the inability to supply the peak domestic flow rate, is the first indicator of a clogged exchanger.

Drift indicators and inspection intervals according to water hardness
Water hardness (°fH)Scaling ratePermissible pressure lossVisual inspection interval
Less than 15 °fH (soft water)Very low precipitation below 65 °CIncrease of less than 100 mbarEvery 3 to 5 years
15 to 25 °fH (moderately hard water)Regular deposit on heated areasIncrease of 100 to 250 mbarEvery 2 years
25 to 35 °fH (hard water)Rapid scaling of narrow channelsIncrease of 250 to 500 mbarEvery year
More than 35 °fH (very hard water)Severe clogging within a few monthsExceedance of more than 500 mbarEvery 6 to 12 months

Checking the scaling condition does not rely solely on temperature and pressure loss measurements. On storage cylinders fitted with a manhole or inspection flange, removing the cover allows direct visual inspection of the tank bottom and the tube bundle. The sanitary installer observes there the thickness of the adherent deposits as well as the volume of powdery scale that has fallen to the lower part. On brazed plate exchangers, direct visual inspection being impossible without destructive dismantling, the check is carried out using differential pressure gauges installed on the sanitary test points to measure the hydraulic restriction of the circuit.

Targeted chemical descaling, action time and sanitary neutralisation protocol

Curative descaling of a domestic hot water exchanger requires a rigorous selection of the chemistry to dissolve calcium carbonate without degrading the constituent metals or the brazed joints. The use of hydrochloric acid is strictly prohibited on domestic hot water exchangers: chloride ions cause sudden, perforating crevice corrosion on austenitic stainless steels and attack copper or nickel brazing. Sanitary fitters must use formulations based on phosphoric acid, citric acid or sulfamic acid containing corrosion inhibitors approved for contact with drinking water.

  1. Hydraulic isolation and drainingClose the upstream and downstream isolating valves of the drinking water circuit. Lock out the make-up supply. Drain the entire volume of domestic water contained in the exchanger or coil to the floor drain via a reinforced hose.
  2. Connection of the descaling unitConnect an acid circulation pump to the service connections, creating an independent closed circuit. Respect a circulation direction opposite to the normal hydraulic flow in order to mechanically loosen the scale plates under the effect of the counter-current.
  3. Injection of the descaler and monitoring of degassingInject the diluted acid solution in accordance with the manufacturer's technical requirements. Leave the vent of the descaling tank open to release the carbon dioxide generated by the chemical reaction. Reverse the flow direction every ten minutes using the reversing valve.
  4. Saturation check and exposure timeMaintain circulation for 40 to 90 minutes depending on the measured thickness of the deposit. Check the pH of the solution regularly: a rapid rise of the pH above 2 indicates exhaustion of the acid, requiring readjustment. As soon as degassing stops and the pH stabilises, descaling is complete; prolonging the operation would needlessly corrode sound metal.
  5. Neutralisation and high-pressure sanitary flushingDrain the spent acid solution into a retention tank and introduce an alkaline neutralising solution to deactivate the acid residues. Then flush the exchanger with mains drinking water, at full flow and open discharge, until a pH strictly identical to that of the building's supply water is obtained.

After sanitary flushing, systematic replacement of the food-grade elastomer flat gaskets on the connection flanges is required to avoid any leak resulting from the chemical and mechanical stresses of the acid cycle. Repressurisation is carried out gradually, with the vent valves open, to evacuate air pockets before the system is brought back up to temperature. An intervention sheet recording the volume of scale removed, the type of acid used and the final pH values is then appended to the building's sanitary maintenance log.

Descaling incidents: action to take in the event of perforation or acid contamination

Chemical attack on a stainless steel plate exchanger or on the coil of an enamelled cylinder carries a major technical risk: revealing pre-existing under-deposit corrosion. Scale frequently masks deep crevice pitting on the steel or areas of enamel detachment. When the acid solution dissolves the carbonate crust, the weakened wall gives way. On an external exchanger, the perforation of an internal plate causes the primary heating fluid to pass directly into the drinking water network, in formal contradiction with the requirements of the SSIGE W3 guideline.

In the event of a sudden pressure drop in the heating circuit or an abnormal rise in domestic water pressure accompanied by discolouration of the water at the vent, close the primary and secondary isolating valves without delay. The appliance must be immediately locked out and drained. If the exchanger is a brazed plate model, it must be replaced completely without delay. On a dismantlable model, release the tie rods from the frame, locate the perforated plate precisely and always replace it, renewing all the original elastomer gaskets.

If the measurement indicates acidic residual water after the first flushing cycle, do not reopen the domestic water network. Re-inject into the calorifier an alkaline neutralising solution based on sodium bicarbonate or carbonate, then circulate in a closed loop for fifteen minutes. When the pH is perfectly stabilised between seven and eight, drain the effluents to the discharge in accordance with the requirements of the water protection legislation. Carry out a final flush at high flow until every trace of foam has completely disappeared.

Frequently asked questions

How can you tell whether a plate heat exchanger is scaled up without dismantling it?

Monitor the temperature difference between the primary flow and the domestic hot water outlet, as well as the hydraulic pressure loss on the pressure gauges. As the thickness of limescale increases, heat exchange collapses: the secondary temperature struggles to reach its setpoint of sixty degrees while the primary return remains abnormally hot. A drop in flow at the draw-off point confirms the progressive blockage of the passage channels between the stainless steel plates.

Why prefer sulfamic acid to hydrochloric acid for a stainless steel exchanger?

Hydrochloric acid violently attacks the passive layer of the austenitic stainless steels commonly used in domestic plate exchangers. Chloride ions cause pitting corrosion and stress cracking, making the plates porous within a few minutes of exposure. Inhibited sulfamic acid dissolves calcium carbonate effectively while preserving the integrity of the stainless steel, of the copper- or nickel-brazed joints, and of the sealing gaskets.

How often should the bottom of a domestic storage cylinder be inspected?

Visual inspection through the manhole is carried out every two to four years depending on the hardness of the distributed water. In a limescale area exceeding twenty-five French degrees, inspect the tank every two years. This inspection makes it possible to remove the limescale sludge settled at the bottom, to check the condition of the enamel lining and to measure the wear of the magnesium sacrificial anode before perforating corrosion attacks the steel.

What should be done with acidic effluents from chemical cleaning on the construction site?

It is strictly forbidden to drain an acid solution directly into the building's drainage system. The effluents must be collected in the tank of the descaling pump, then neutralised by the gradual addition of a base such as sodium carbonate until a pH between six and a half and eight and a half is obtained. This neutralised discharge may then be released to the wastewater system in accordance with cantonal environmental guidelines.

Texts and standards cited

  • SSIGE W3Guidelines for drinking water installations

In the same section