Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 250Drainage: stack, primary ventilation and sound insulationChapter 4 of 10 in the section

The water seal: height, evaporation in an empty dwelling and diaphragm trap

After three weeks without any water supply, a cellar floor trap loses its odour-tight seal. This chapter details the evaporation kinetics, the water seal requirements under the SN EN 12056 standard, and the technical top-up solutions. You will also learn the practical limits of mechanical diaphragm traps.

Key takeaways

  • The SN EN 12056 standard prescribes a minimum water seal height of fifty millimetres.
  • The dry, ventilated air of a basement evaporates the volume of water in three weeks without any supply.
  • Connecting a regularly used appliance is the most reliable top-up method.
  • The diaphragm trap blocks the passage of odour but is vulnerable to fouling and loaded wastewater.

Loss of water seal by evaporation: standard requirements and the reality of basements

In the basements of residential or office buildings, floor traps installed in cellars, plant rooms or laundry rooms regularly stop fulfilling their function as a barrier against drain gases. The problem does not always come from dynamic loss of seal caused by suction on the stack, but from the simple gradual disappearance of the water through natural evaporation. When the room is not regularly sprayed or washed down with plenty of water, the liquid volume decreases every day until it opens a direct path for foul air from the public sewer or the buried drain.

For gravity drainage systems inside buildings, the minimum water seal height of traps for sanitary appliances and floor traps must be 50 mm in order to guarantee an effective hydraulic barrier against the penetration of sewer gases.

SN EN 12056-2

A 50 mm water column in a standard trap cup of 100 mm diameter represents a volume of between 0.25 and 0.4 litre of residual water. In a temperate cellar, the average evaporation rate varies between 1.5 and 2.5 mm per twenty-four-hour period. This rate increases markedly if the room has natural ventilation forced through a basement light well or mechanical air movement. At 2 mm lost per day, the water seal falls below the critical dip-tube threshold in less than twenty days. From the third week, the hydraulic plug is broken and foul air rises freely into the room.

Residual water seal
Vertical height measured between the lowest point of the trap's dip tube and the upper level of the outlet weir. It is the thickness of water that hermetically isolates the room atmosphere from the air in the pipes.

Topping up the water trap or fitting a diaphragm: trade-offs and limits of use

To remedy drying out without forcing the user to pour a bucket of water manually every fortnight, several technical provisions exist. The most robust from a hygiene standpoint consists of connecting, along the route of the drop pipe or directly upstream of the floor trap, the discharge of a frequently used appliance, for example the waste of a laundry-room sink or the overflow of a controlled supply. This arrangement renews the water seal at every use, eliminating any risk of prolonged stagnation.

A second alternative consists of integrating an automatic top-up dispenser connected to the drinking water network. This accessory injects a few centilitres of water each time it detects a drop in distribution pressure in the building. However, this solution requires a drinking water connection with a compliant non-return device to prevent any risk of contamination, which increases the installation cost and the need for annual maintenance.

Comparison of solutions against floor trap drying out
DeviceOperating principleAdvantagesLimits and weak points
Conventional trap with top-upSupply of regular wastewater upstreamAbsolute reliability, no moving mechanical partsRequires an active sanitary appliance nearby
Flap or float trapFloating ball blocking the passage when dryPrevents odour passage after evaporationSensitive to limescale and greasy deposits
Silicone diaphragm trapElastomer lip closed at rest, open under flowWorks without any water, compact sizeRisk of sticking or blockage by solid residues
Top-up deviceAutomatic injection from the sanitary networkGuarantees a permanent water seal of 50 mmHigher cost and mechanical monitoring required

The diaphragm trap is an attractive answer for cellars without a water point nearby: at rest, two silicone lips remain pinched together by their elasticity and prevent gases from rising, even if the bottom of the trap is completely dry. As soon as a flow arrives, the weight of the water column parts the lips and drains towards the pipe. Under art. 364 CO, the installer carries out the work in accordance with the rules of the trade; he must therefore take into account the operating constraints of the materials he installs.

Diagnosis of passive loss of seal and remedies by hydraulic top-up

In plant rooms, basement laundry rooms or private cellars, the complete drying out of a floor trap within three weeks is a common defect. Under the combined effect of low humidity during the heating season, the total absence of water supply and slight pneumatic pressure drops created by airlocks or the thermal draught of service shafts, the water film evaporates at an average rate of 1.5 to 2.5 millimetres per day. Once the water seal is broken, the drain pipe acts as a direct chimney, driving decomposition gases from the main network into the building.

The SN EN 12056 standard sets a minimum water seal height of 50 mm for appliance traps and floor gullies. However, this theoretical dimension does not guarantee that the seal will last in an unoccupied room. A height of 50 mm in a standard bowl of 100 mm diameter represents a volume of approximately 0.4 litre of water. Faced with continuous evaporation without compensating draw-off, this residual volume is irreversibly exhausted before the monthly visit of the operator or owner.

  1. Connecting a permanent auxiliary dischargeThe most robust method consists of diverting the discharge of a domestic water heater safety valve or the waste of a water softener to the floor trap. Each heating or regeneration cycle injects a few decilitres of fresh water, maintaining the level without human intervention or any additional mechanism.
  2. Installing a timed top-up injectorWhere no water-producing sanitary appliance is nearby, fitting a drinking water branch equipped with a safety disconnector and a programmed flush valve guarantees a calibrated supply. The dispenser injects a defined volume once a week, compensating for evaporation without risk of overconsumption.
  3. Fitting a floating anti-evaporation sealFor existing bowls embedded in the slab where no clean water supply is accessible, inserting a float or plunging-ball cartridge into the trap cup limits the water-air exchange surface. The float descends with the residual water level and presses its O-ring against the outlet funnel as soon as the water seal becomes critical.

Diaphragm traps and dry flaps: principles, fouling and limits of installation

The mechanical silicone diaphragm trap or dry flap appears an attractive alternative on paper: it replaces or supplements the conventional water seal with elastomer lips that part under the weight of the discharged water and close hermetically as soon as the flow stops. This technical solution blocks odours even when the water reserve is completely dry. However, its installation on Swiss construction sites is subject to strict rules because of its mechanical vulnerability.

Comparison of anti-odour devices for floor traps in dry rooms
DeviceSeal maintained without water supplySensitivity to foulingRecommended location
Standard 50 mm water sealNone (fails within 2 to 4 weeks)None (simple settling)Rooms washed down with a hose or with an active water point
Deep water seal (80 to 100 mm)Medium (maintained 6 to 8 weeks)Low (deposits can be removed by cleaning)Cellars with periodic access, meter rooms
Automatic mechanical top-upTotal and continuousLow (clean water renewed)Basements of rental buildings, boiler rooms
Combined trap with water seal and silicone diaphragmHigh (watertight diaphragm as back-up)Very high (solid particles, fibres)Closed plant rooms, storerooms without heavy sweeping

The silicone diaphragm does not tolerate suspended matter. In a cellar or storage room, the discharged water often comes from floor washing and carries fine sand, concrete dust, cleaning fibres and hair. These impurities become wedged between the elastomer lips. A grain of sand of 0.5 millimetre or a clump of fibres is enough to prevent the dry flap from closing tightly. With the water seal evaporated, the air gap left by the slightly open lip immediately lets hydrogen sulphide rise.

From a regulatory standpoint, the exclusive use of a mechanical device without a liquid water seal is not accepted in place of a trap complying with the SN EN 12056 standard on the main stacks. The silicone diaphragm must always be integrated as an additional anti-evaporation safeguard, inserted inside a traditional hydraulic trap cup, and not as a single dry flap without a water surface.

Odour disputes and trap drying out: remedial protocol

The complete drying out of a cellar trap after three weeks of vacancy is a recurring defect at handover of the works. Faced with complaints about drain odours rising, the plumber must rule out dynamic suction before blaming natural evaporation. A visual check with a torch makes it possible to verify the state of the water surface and measure the residual height. If the hydraulic trap is completely empty with no recent discharge on the drop stack, low humidity and the ventilation of the room alone are at fault. The systematic replacement with a dry fitting or a silicone diaphragm cartridge is not the universal answer.

Decision matrix for recurrent drying out of a floor trap
Room configurationPriority solutionFallback solutionFormal contraindication
Plant room with water pointConnection of a regular discharge (water softener)Trap with increased water sealPermanent blocking of the grate
Private cellar without water supplyTimed automatic re-priming deviceDry flap with mechanical diaphragmDrain oil or volatile liquid
Intermittently used communal laundry roomStandard water seal maintained by protocolRemovable silicone diaphragm for cleaningFloor trap without strainer basket

When the client requires a definitive intervention, the installation of a dry-flap trap must be subject to precise written reservations. The silicone diaphragm compensates for the loss of the liquid plug but proves vulnerable to solid residues, textile fibres and limescale. In a cellar housing a washing machine or a wash basin, deposits end up blocking the sealing lip in a slightly open position, restoring the direct passage of sewer gases.

The lasting remedy consists of favouring a regular water supply by gravity tapping from a drain-off or a sanitary valve, or of installing an automatic top-up connected to the distribution network. If the lack of supply forces the fitting of a diaphragm, it must remain accessible without tools for the mandatory quarterly cleaning recorded in the installation's maintenance log.

Frequently asked questions

What is the minimum water seal prescribed for an indoor floor trap?

According to the SN EN 12056 standard, the minimum water seal height for standard sanitary appliances is set at fifty millimetres. For yard or floor traps subject to strong negative pressure or rapid evaporation, professional guidelines recommend a water seal of at least seventy millimetres in order to delay complete loss of prime during prolonged absence of flow.

Why must the silicone diaphragm not be fitted on all traps?

The flexible diaphragm requires the passage of clean water to keep its seal. If the discharged water contains sand, sweeping dust or hair, the particles lodge in the elastic slit. The lip stays stuck in the open position, letting network gases rise. Moreover, it does not withstand high back-pressures in the event of accidental surcharging.

How can a cellar trap be topped up in a fully passive way?

The most reliable method consists of directing the discharge from a water heater safety valve, the overflow of a water softener unit or the regular condensate of a technical appliance to the floor trap. Each operating cycle thus reintroduces a few decilitres of fresh water into the cup, keeping the level above the dip tube without human intervention or any electrical mechanism.

How can evaporation be distinguished from dynamic loss of seal?

Dynamic loss of seal occurs during the massive discharge of an appliance located upstream on the same stack, creating a negative pressure that abruptly sucks out the water seal within seconds with an audible gurgling. Drying out by evaporation takes place slowly and silently over several weeks, under the combined action of dry ambient air and the natural draught of the drainage stack.

Texts and standards cited

  • SN EN 12056Gravity drainage systems inside buildings: general design principles and hydraulic water seal requirements.

In the same section