Key takeaways
- Legionella multiplies massively in lukewarm water systems between 25 °C and 45 °C.
- Storing domestic hot water in the storage tank requires a minimum setpoint of 60 °C.
- The water temperature at the loop return must never fall below 55 °C.
- Unlooped terminal branches must be flushed or limited to a strict maximum volume.
The critical growth range and the four sanitary control points
Preventing Legionella (Legionella pneumophila) requires rigorous control of the thermal behaviour of the sanitary system. The danger zone lies precisely in a lukewarm range, between 25 °C and 45 °C, where bacterial growth within the biofilm is exponential. Below 20 °C the bacterium is dormant; above 55 °C its reproduction stops; from 60 °C it is destroyed within a few minutes. The installer's task is to eliminate any permanently lukewarm zone in the distribution system.
Domestic hot water must be kept at a sufficient temperature from its preparation to the draw-off points to prevent Legionella from multiplying, while avoiding the risk of scalding at the draw-off points.
Standard SIA 385/1 and SSIGE W3 guidelines
To validate the compliance of an installation at commissioning, the plumber must fit sensors and carry out joint measurements at four key points of the circuit: the water heater storage volume, the main distribution flow, the foot of each circulation return riser and the furthest draw-off point.
| Measuring point | Minimum temperature | Sanitary function | Action in case of deviation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domestic hot water storage tank | 60 °C | Bacterial destruction in the stored volume | Raise the control setpoint on the tank |
| DHW distribution flow | 60 °C | Compensation of in-line heat losses | Check the thermostatic mixing valve |
| Loop return (main collector) | 55 °C | Keeping the whole loop outside the risk zone | Rebalance the thermal control valves |
| Most unfavourable draw-off point | 50 °C (after flow) | Guarantee of hygiene at the point of use | Flush the dead leg or insulate the branch |
On domestic water heaters, the temperature is taken via a thermowell immersed directly in the lower third of the tank, the zone most exposed to cold water inflows. Contact thermometers on copper or stainless steel pipes must be insulated together with the pipe so that the ambient air of the boiler room does not distort the reading by several degrees.
The domestic circulation loop: the mandatory 55 °C threshold at the return
The purpose of the domestic hot water (DHW) circulation loop is to ensure continuous circulation of the fluid in order to prevent stagnant water from cooling down. According to SIA 385/1, the permissible temperature loss over the whole circulation path must not exceed 5 K. With a flow set at 60 °C, the water returning to the loop return collector must show at least 55 °C. If the temperature drops to 53 °C or 50 °C, the system moves into a range favourable to recolonisation by biofilm.
- Checking the circulation pump flowCheck that the domestic circulation pump delivers the speed and differential pressure required to overcome hydraulic pressure losses and maintain the heat-carrying flow.
- Adjusting the thermal balancing valvesAdjust the thermostatic control valves located at the foot of each riser. These components automatically reduce the flow as soon as 57 °C is reached, in order to redirect the flow to under-supplied risers.
- Differential temperature measurementRead the temperature with an immersion thermometer on the main flow and on each riser return after three hours of stabilised operation without draw-off.
- Checking the terminal dead legsMeasure the volume of the branches connecting the looped riser to the draw-off point. According to the SSIGE W3 guidelines, the volume contained between the loop and the tap must not exceed 3 litres of water.
Finally, the quality of the thermal insulation on the distribution and return pipes determines the stability of the system. Slab penetrations and passages through service shafts must keep their insulating sleeve without any discontinuity, otherwise thermal bridges are created that abruptly lower the return temperature below the regulatory threshold of 55 °C.
Hot water storage and distribution: maintaining the temperature regimes prescribed by SIA 385/1
To prevent Legionella colonisation without relying on an occasional thermal shock, which is often illusory, internal plumbing installations must permanently apply strict temperature regimes. SIA 385/1 defines the target values to be met throughout the domestic hot water (DHW) system. The DHW storage tank is the first line of defence: the stored water must be kept at a continuous minimum temperature of 60 °C over the full height of the tank, thus avoiding the formation of lukewarm lower layers that favour bacterial growth.
The temperature at the distribution flow, immediately downstream of the heater or of the main sanitary mixing valve, must guarantee a constant 60 °C. The permissible temperature drop along the most unfavourable path of the looped distribution must not exceed 5 K. This means that the water temperature must under no circumstances fall below the 55 °C threshold when it completes its transit in the risers or circulation collectors. The SSIGE guidelines remind us that this thermal requirement applies 24 hours a day, prohibiting night-time shutdowns of the circulation pumps, which were formerly tolerated for energy-saving reasons.
| Sanitary control point | Minimum temperature | Maximum permissible deviation | Risk in case of non-compliance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Domestic hot water storage tank | 60 °C continuous | 0 K (no cold stratification) | Growth in the sump or bottom of the tank |
| Main DHW distribution flow | 60 °C in stabilised operation | - 1 K at peak use | Insufficient supply to the risers |
| Foot of each circulation riser | 55 °C permanent | 0 K below the 55 °C threshold | Creation of a lukewarm volume in the riser |
| Main loop return collector | 55 °C before connection to the water heater | - 0 K | Overall balancing fault and contamination |
| Terminal draw-off points (after running the water) | 50 °C (or 60 °C without mixer) | Reached in 10 to 15 seconds | Prolonged stagnation between 25 °C and 45 °C |
Hydraulic balancing and acceptance measurement of the domestic circulation loop
Achieving a uniform loop return of 55 °C throughout a multi-occupancy building depends entirely on the quality of the hydraulic balancing. Without dynamic regulating components, hot water systematically takes the riser closest to the boiler room or technical room. This short circuit causes the distant risers to cool down, and they inevitably fall into the Legionella incubation zone, between 25 °C and 45 °C. The plumber must install thermostatic balancing valves at the foot of each circulation return riser. These components automatically modulate their flow according to the measured temperature, throttling the hot circuits to supply the coldest sections.
- Visual inspection and checking of the insulation classEnsure the continuity of the insulation on the flow and return pipes of the loop, in accordance with the requirements of SIA 385/1. Pipe hangers, valve bodies and flanges must be insulated without thermal bridges to avoid localised heat losses that cause the return to fall below 55 °C.
- Complete air venting of the circulation circuitRemove residual air through the automatic air vents placed at the high points of each riser. An air pocket blocks circulation, whether by gravity or by pump, creating a cold dead section that cannot be detected at the main collector.
- Reading contact temperatures on risersCarry out the measurements with a calibrated surface-contact thermometer or immersion probe. Measure the fluid at each return balancing valve after at least two hours of continuous operation without major draw-off on the system.
- Flow check at the furthest tapsOpen fully the draw-off valve at the furthest point of an unlooped branch. Check that the hot water flows at its regulatory setpoint temperature within a maximum of 10 to 15 seconds, confirming that the volume of stagnant water in the branch does not exceed 3 litres.
Acceptance of a sanitary installation requires a joint measurement report recording the temperatures taken at the four key points: tank outlet, main flow, foot of each circulation riser and inlet of the circulation collector into the water heater. The plumber thus validates the compliance of the installation with Swiss good practice and guarantees that no hydraulic dead zone remains in the floor distributions.
Corrective actions in case of low temperature at the loop return
When the temperature measured at the main loop return falls below the mandatory 55 °C threshold required by SIA 385/1 and the SSIGE guidelines, the plumber must act methodically on the distribution system. If the domestic hot water flow does guarantee 60 °C at the outlet of the distributor or storage tank, the excessive temperature drop comes from unbalanced flows, a break in the insulation or unwanted water mixing at a draw-off point.
- Methodical measurement riser by riserRead the temperature of each individual return with a calibrated contact thermometer, positioned on the bare metal pipe upstream of the control valve. Any riser showing less than 55 °C indicates an insufficient volume flow in relation to the actual heat losses of the service shaft.
- Checking the thermal control valvesExamine the automatic circulation regulators located at the foot or head of the riser. Limescale and sludge frequently jam cartridge thermostatic elements in the throttled position. Dismantle, clean or replace the faulty thermostatic element before resuming the initial setting.
- Locating stagnant sectionsInspect all branches leading to terminal fixtures. Oversized individual branches or unconnected stub pipes act as heat sinks. Remove any dead leg and shorten the terminal connections to the strict minimum in order to respect the permissible volumes without a loop.
- Insulation auditCheck the thermal continuity of the insulation along the whole route. Sleeves interrupted at fire-rated wall penetrations, uninsulated metal clamps and bare valves are major thermal bridges that cool the circulating water considerably.
If a bacteriological analysis result indicates contamination, the SSIGE guidelines provide for a temporary thermal disinfection at 70 °C on the distribution, with systematic flushing at all draw-off points that have first been secured against scalding. This emergency remediation never replaces the mechanical restoration of the circulation loop: only the permanent maintenance of 55 °C guarantees the hygiene of the drinking water.
Frequently asked questions
Why can't you simply raise the water heater setpoint to compensate for a loop return that is too cold?
Raising hot water production above 60 °C masks a hydraulic balancing fault without correcting it. This practice drastically accelerates scaling of the storage tank and heat exchangers, increases energy consumption and heightens the risk of scalding at the taps. SIA 385/1 prescribes correcting the losses by adjusting the flow of the disadvantaged risers via the control valves, rather than overheating the storage to compensate for a faulty system.
What difference is tolerated between the flow and loop return temperatures?
SIA 385/1 and the SSIGE guidelines impose a maximum temperature difference of 5 kelvins between the distribution flow and the domestic circulation return. For a flow set at 60 °C, the return to the storage tank must never fall below 55 °C. A difference greater than 5 K proves that the circulation pump flow is insufficient or that the heat losses of poorly insulated pipes are excessive.
From what distance or volume must a hot water pipe be connected to the loop?
According to the SSIGE guidelines and SIA 385/1, a hot water pipe without circulation must not contain more than 3 litres of water between the loop and the furthest draw-off point. As soon as the volume of the piping exceeds this threshold, or the waiting time at the tap exceeds the comfort requirements, the plumber must extend the circulation loop or fit a self-regulating heating tape kept at temperature.
How do you check the temperature of a circulation riser without draining or drilling the pipe?
The measurement is taken with a fast contact thermometer fitted with a surface probe or a thermal clamp. The installer temporarily opens the insulating shell, carefully cleans the surface of the metal pipe to remove any oxidation, applies thermal paste and fixes the sensor firmly. The stabilised value is read after two minutes of continuous circulation, before closing the insulation tightly again to avoid any residual heat loss.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 385/1Domestic hot water installations in buildings - General principles and requirements
- SSIGE W3Guidelines for drinking water installations
