Key takeaways
- The passage of a plug of water in the stack creates a strong negative pressure that sucks out the water seal below.
- SN EN 12056 prescribes a stack extended to open air without any reduction in cross-section.
- Loss of a trap seal removes the airtight barrier and lets toxic decomposition gases in.
- The roof outlet must be strictly positioned outside any blockage zone and away from air intakes.
Understanding the piston effect and the negative pressure that empties traps
When a sanitary appliance such as a WC is operated on the fifth floor, the flush releases an instantaneous volume of six to nine litres. This mass of liquid does not fall as one compact, homogeneous block: it accelerates, clings to the inner walls of the pipe through friction and quickly turns into an annular cylinder of water or an intermittent hydraulic piston. As it moves at high speed down the soil stack, this column of water drags along the air present in the pipework through a powerful ejection effect.
- Trap seal loss
- Partial or total loss of the protective water seal held in the trap of a sanitary appliance, caused by a drop in pressure in the drainage pipe, allowing gas emissions from the public sewer or the septic tank to spread freely into occupied rooms.
This forced displacement of air creates a partial vacuum upstream of the falling mass. If no outside air instantly compensates for the gas volume expelled downwards, the negative pressure spreads directly into the horizontal branches on the lower floors. The trap of the washbasin or WC pan on the ground floor then undergoes a critical pressure difference: the atmospheric pressure in the room pushes the water in the trap towards the pipe, drawing out the water seal in a fraction of a second with a characteristic gurgling sound.
- Plug formation and hydraulic accelerationThe released water reaches its terminal velocity over the first metres of vertical fall, creating a massive air draw at the top and pushing air downwards.
- Negative pressure induced in the stackWithout air coming from the roof, the internal pressure collapses below the atmospheric pressure of the building, drawing in the fluid masses connected to the pipe.
- Breakdown of the protective water sealA fifty-millimetre water seal cannot withstand air suction: it is drawn into the stack, opening a direct path for sewer gases.
Installation rules and roof outlet according to SN EN 12056
To neutralise these critical pressure fluctuations, SN EN 12056 requires every wastewater stack to be extended vertically to open air. This primary ventilation stack turns the gravity system into a balanced circuit in which air enters freely at exactly the rate of the flows, without ever stressing the water-seal barriers of the appliances. The golden rule is to maintain the nominal diameter of the stack over its entire ventilation length: reducing a one-hundred-millimetre pipe to DN 70 under the roof space restricts the air flow and cancels the effectiveness of the system.
| Ventilation method | Mechanical principle | Limits of use | Installation requirement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary ventilation | Direct extension of the stack to open air at roof level | Requires a watertight roof penetration | Keep the full nominal diameter up to the outlet |
| Secondary ventilation | Parallel air pipe connected to the branches | Extra cost for ducting and increased pipe length | Essential for very tall stacks |
| Air admittance valve | Diaphragm valve that opens only under negative pressure | Relieves no positive pressure and has a limited service life | Not permitted for venting the single main stack of the building |
The roof outlet requires close coordination with the sheet-metal work. The stack must extend above the roof covering by at least fifty centimetres to prevent blockage by the snow layers common on the Swiss Plateau and in the Pre-Alps. In addition, a minimum distance of two metres must be kept from any openable roof window or fresh-air intake to prevent hydrogen sulphide or methane from being recirculated into ventilated spaces. The end opening is left open or protected by a simple anti-intrusion wire-mesh cap, without a fine insect screen that could ice up under the effect of foul air saturated with moisture.
Diagnosing trap seal loss: identifying negative pressure and load defects
On a renovation site or when commissioning a residential building, the finding of foul odours coming back up on the ground floor almost always points to a broken water seal. When a resident flushes a WC on the fifth floor, the released volume of water forms a hydraulic plug that descends at high speed in the soil stack. Without a sufficient and immediate air supply from the top, this liquid mass acts like the plunger of a syringe: it pushes the air downstream and creates a powerful negative pressure upstream. This sudden suction pulls on the water seals of appliances on the lower floors, emptying the traps of walk-in showers and washbasins all at once.
Trap seal loss is not due to a failure of the sanitary appliance itself, but to a pressure imbalance in the drainage network. SN EN 12056 sets the flow calculation rules to prevent pressure variations from exceeding a strict range capable of tearing the water out of the trap. As soon as the negative pressure exceeds the strength of the water column held in the trap bowl, foul air passes through the trap with a characteristic loud gurgling. This phenomenon is often accompanied by the opposite effect at the stack base: compression of the air forces soiled water out of the lowest trap if the connection to the buried collector has too sharp a bend or a constriction.
- Suction noises and gurgling in the waste outlets when a neighbouring appliance discharges.
- Complete and recurrent drying out of the shallow traps of shower trays connected to the same stack.
- Intermittent sewer smells coinciding with peak hours of sanitary use in the building.
- Partial blockage of the roof terminal caused by winter frost, a bird's nest or an unsuitable strainer.
Restoring airflow: continuous sizing and supplementary valves
To guarantee the integrity of the water seals, the primary ventilation at roof level must absolutely keep the full nominal diameter of the soil stack over its entire vertical run. If the stack is sized DN 100 to collect soil water, the section passing through the roof space and the ventilation sleeve in the sheet-metal work must show the same DN 100 internal diameter without any narrowing. Furthermore, the layout in the roof space must rule out sharp 90-degree bends in favour of two 45-degree bends, in order to limit the airflow pressure losses that slow the intake of fresh atmospheric air during peak loads.
| Technical device | Negative pressure compensation | Positive pressure relief | Compliant application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full primary ventilation terminating at roof level | Excellent, unlimited outside air flow | Ensured naturally by thermal draught | Mandatory basic solution for every main stack |
| Parallel secondary ventilation | Optimal on very tall stacks | Full, thanks to relief loops on the floors | Tower buildings or high appliance density |
| Diaphragm air admittance valve at stack head | Good, opens under slight negative pressure | None, the valve remains airtight against indoor air | Tolerated in renovation if a roof outlet is impossible |
| Individual air valve under washbasin | Local, for the connected appliance | None, does not protect the main stack | Supplementary fix on an overly long branch connection |
The use of an air admittance valve (diaphragm negative-pressure valve) is a derogation solution when passing through flat roofs or historic sheet-metal work proves technically unfeasible. This mechanical component opens under the effect of suction to admit ambient air and closes by gravity as soon as equilibrium is restored. However, the valve in no case allows positive pressures generated by compression at the stack base to be relieved, nor does it provide general ventilation of the public network. Moreover, it must always remain installed in a heated, ventilated and accessible space so that the flexible diaphragm can be checked and replaced without destroying the duct walls.
Resolving odour problems and clearing defects after handover
The appearance of sewer odours and suction noises on the ground floor whenever an appliance discharges on the fifth floor signals a major airflow defect. This trap seal loss results directly from the negative pressure created by a wastewater stack forming a liquid piston with no compensating air supply at the top. When the water seal is siphoned out, foul air from the pipes enters the occupied rooms freely. Resolving this problem requires a methodical technical analysis before any demolition work is undertaken in the service shafts.
- Measuring pressure variations and inspecting the pipeConnect a differential manometer to the waste of a sanitary appliance on the lowest level to record the dynamic negative pressure during simultaneous flushing. Pass an endoscopic inspection camera down from the roof to detect a crushed pipe, a limescale plug or a non-compliant reduction in cross-section.
- Checking the primary ventilation outlet at roof levelPhysically check on the roof that the stack terminates in open air with no clogged mesh, no reducing sleeve and at a proper distance from openings. The absence of an extension at full diameter to the outside air is the main cause of violent air draws on the lower floors.
- Correcting the layout and restoring airflow capacityReplace the defective sections to restore the full nominal diameter of the soil stack, in strict compliance with SN EN 12056. If an architectural constraint prevents reworking the roof outlet, install a parallel vent pipe or a certified diaphragm air admittance valve in a heated and accessible room.
When clearing defects with the client or the site management, the test protocol consists of triggering the flush on the fifth floor while monitoring the stability of the water surface in the ground-floor trap. SN EN 12056 requires a minimum residual water seal after discharge in order to validate the technical acceptance of the installation and certify odour tightness.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a trap empty when a toilet is flushed several floors higher up?
When a large quantity of water descends along a vertical stack, it forms a ring of water or a liquid piston that descends at high speed. This flow drags along the air above it and compresses the air below. If the stack is not open to the air at roof level, a strong negative pressure forms upstream of the piston, sucking out the protective water in the traps of the lower floors and releasing bad odours.
Can the diameter of the primary ventilation be reduced compared with that of the stack?
No. SN EN 12056 prescribes that the primary ventilation keeps a nominal diameter strictly identical to that of the soil stack up to its roof outlet. Reducing the diameter, for example going from a stack of one hundred and ten millimetres diameter to an outlet of seventy-five millimetres, chokes the incoming air flow. During a sudden discharge, the airflow pressure loss generates the negative pressure responsible for trap seal loss on the traps connected to the network.
Can a diaphragm air admittance valve completely replace a roof outlet?
In a multi-storey building, at least one main stack must terminate in open air at roof level to ensure the discharge of gases and the general ventilation of the public sewer network. Diaphragm air admittance valves only work on air intake and cannot expel positive pressures. They are only a supplementary solution on secondary stacks or in renovations where no watertight penetration is possible.
What is the minimum water seal height required to block drain gases?
According to the sanitary rules and SN EN 12056, the standard water seal of a household or sanitary appliance trap must be at least fifty millimetres deep. After the passage of the negative-pressure wave caused by the discharge from upper floors, the installation must retain a sufficient residual height to form an airtight barrier against drain gases. A loss of level of more than twenty-five millimetres requires a review of the ventilation system.
Texts and standards cited
- SN EN 12056Gravity drainage systems inside buildings - Engineering rules and sizing of the ventilation of soil stacks
