Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 250Water hygiene: legionella, temperatures and stagnationChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Taking and reading a water analysis: sampling point, method and follow-up actions

This chapter details the procedure for taking domestic water samples from an internal distribution installation. You will learn how to choose a representative sampling point, how to distinguish the first-draw analysis from the analysis after flushing in order to locate a microbial proliferation precisely, and how to interpret laboratory results in order to initiate the appropriate sanitary corrective measures in line with the SSIGE guidelines.

Key takeaways

  • The immediate sample targets terminal contamination of the fittings and connecting hoses.
  • The sample taken after prolonged flushing assesses the bacteriological quality of the riser or the circulation loop.
  • Disinfecting the draw-off outlet by flaming or with alcohol before sampling avoids distorting the analytical results.
  • Exceeded thresholds require intensive flushing, thermal shock or targeted chemical disinfection.

Distinguishing the first draw from the stabilised sample to locate the contamination

In the field, the classic mistake is to purge a pipe at length before filling the analysis bottle when a health concern arises. This systematic purging flushes out the water that has stagnated in the tap, the aerator and the supply pipework. The laboratory then receives water freshly drawn from the main riser, which masks the localised fouling of the last metres of pipe. To make a reliable diagnosis and target the remedial works, the plumber applies a rigorous method combining two distinct types of samples.

First-draw (immediate) sample
Sampling of the first litre of water drawn when the fitting is opened after a minimum period of inactivity of four hours, without prior disinfection of the outlet or flushing, intended to assess contamination of the terminal zone.
Stabilised sample (after flushing)
Sampling carried out after removing the flow straighteners, disinfecting the outlet and letting the water run until a constant temperature is reached, intended to characterise the water of the main distribution network.
  1. Immediate sample (bottle A)Gently open the valve or mixer to the mixed or hot water position depending on the test being carried out. Immediately fill a sterile bottle containing sodium thiosulphate (chlorine neutraliser) to capture the volume stagnant in the hose, the ceramic cartridge and the aerators.
  2. Removal and disinfection of the outletAlways remove any scaled aerators, shower heads or flow regulators. Carefully disinfect the neck of the tap by flaming (for bare metal fittings) or with 70 % ethanol spray with a contact time of two minutes.
  3. Stabilised thermal purge (bottle B)Reopen the hot water at nominal flow. Measure the temperature with an immersion probe thermometer until the value remains strictly stable for at least one minute, then take the second sterile sample without touching the rim of the container.

Selecting representative points and planning corrective measures

The SSIGE guidelines require a precise mapping of the sanitary network in order to position the hygiene checks. A single sample on the ground floor provides no guarantee for the whole building. The plumber must sample at the critical locations: immediately at the outlet of the domestic hot water heater, on the circulation loop return before the connection to the storage tank, at the hydraulically most remote draw-off point, and on little-used dead-leg branches presenting a risk of prolonged stagnation.

Cross-interpretation of Legionella bacteriological analysis results
Immediate sample (A)Stabilised sample (B)Probable location of the sourcePlumber's corrective action
Positive (> 1 000 CFU/l)Negative (< 1 000 CFU/l)Fitting, aerator, terminal hoseDescaling, local chemical disinfection or replacement of the terminal components.
Negative (< 1 000 CFU/l)Positive (> 1 000 CFU/l)Riser, circulation loop, storage tankComplete purge, hydraulic balancing of the loop, temporary thermal shock of the network.
Positive (> 1 000 CFU/l)Positive (> 1 000 CFU/l)Overall contamination of the sanitary distributionGeneral thermal or chemical remediation, temperature checks and removal of dead legs.

When the results reveal contamination of the riser or the loop, the first sanitary measure consists of tracking down and physically eliminating dead legs: disconnected sections of former appliances, stub lengths exceeding three times the internal diameter, or unused bypasses. The plumber then checks the operating temperatures required by the SSIGE guidelines: mixed or hot water must reach at least 60 °C at the distribution outlet and must not fall below 55 °C throughout the circulation loop.

Field sampling protocol and SSIGE sampling methodology

In internal sanitary installations, sampling carried out blindly or without a standardised method completely distorts the diagnosis. Filling a bottle after purging the pipe for several minutes masks the local fouling of a fitting or the bacterial growth in a floor connection. Conversely, taking only the first trickle of water without checking the riser makes it impossible to know whether the contamination originates in the circulation loop or at the terminal fitting. The SSIGE directive W3/E3 and the Swiss drinking water hygiene recommendations require a fractionated approach, the only one capable of distinguishing a point problem from a general drift of the distribution network.

  1. Preparing the equipment and labellingAlways use sterile sampling bottles supplied by the accredited laboratory, pre-conditioned with sodium thiosulphate to neutralise any residue of oxidising disinfectant. Prepare a calibrated immersion probe thermometer, a bottle of methylated spirit or 70 % ethanol with sterile swabs, and a tracking sheet stating the point number, the exact time and the condition of the draw-off fitting.
  2. Immediate first-draw sample (Volume A)Gently open the valve or mixer to the hot water position, without removing the flow regulator or disinfecting the outlet. Immediately collect the first litre of water (or the fraction of 250 to 500 millilitres requested by the laboratory) at moderate flow to avoid aerosolisation. Measure the instantaneous temperature as soon as filling is complete. This volume reflects the sanitary condition of the flow straightener, the hose and the terminal dead leg.
  3. Conditioning of the draw-off pointRemove the aerator, shower head or flow straightener with an open-ended spanner without scratching the fitting. Clean the outlet, remove any visible limescale deposits, then disinfect the spout by flaming (metal fitting with no visible plastic seal) or by careful swabbing with a pad soaked in 70 % alcohol, observing a contact time of at least two minutes.
  4. Sample after stabilised flushing (Volume B)Reopen the hot water at constant flow. Let the water run until a strictly stabilised temperature is obtained on the immersion thermometer, measured for at least thirty consecutive seconds (generally after two to three minutes of purging). Fill the second sterile bottle, avoiding any contact between the neck and the draw-off spout. This volume characterises the water circulating in the riser or the distribution pipe.
Technical comparison of the two types of domestic water sample
Sample typeOperating protocolHydraulic target representedOrigin of a non-conformity
Immediate first draw (Volume A)Bottle filled as soon as the fitting is opened, without prior purging, disinfection or removal of accessories.Volume stagnant in the fitting, the shower hose, the aerator and the terminal pipework (length less than 3 metres).Scaling of the aerator, biofilm in the EPDM/silicone hose, prolonged stagnation in the room, faulty thermostatic mixer.
After stabilised flushing (Volume B)Accessories removed, spout disinfected by flame or alcohol, active purge until perfect thermal stabilisation.Upstream collective network: circulation loop, distribution risers, heat exchanger or DHW cylinder on the sanitary side.DHW flow temperature below 60 °C, loop return below 55 °C, hydraulic balancing fault, dead leg on the main pipe.

Interpretation of laboratory results and sanitary corrective actions

Microbiological analysis reports are read in colony-forming units per litre (CFU/l). The guidelines of the Swiss Gas and Water Industry Association (SSIGE) and the federal ordinances on drinking water set precise alert levels for Legionella pneumophila. The plumber working on site must cross-check the bacteriological results of volumes A and B with his operating temperature readings in order to target the faulty component without carrying out unnecessary work.

When the laboratory finds a concentration below 1 000 CFU/l, the installation is within the tolerance range, but routine monitoring is required if the value approaches this level. Between 1 000 and 10 000 CFU/l, the intervention level requires an immediate review of the hydraulic operation. Above 10 000 CFU/l, the installation presents an acute health hazard: the operator must prohibit use of the unsecured showers and the plumber starts remediation immediately.

Decision matrix and technical follow-up according to the analysis pairs
Result Volume A (first draw)Result Volume B (stabilised)Sanitary diagnosisImmediate corrective measures (CFC 250)
> 1 000 CFU/l< 1 000 CFU/lContamination strictly localised at the periphery.Replacement of hoses and shower heads with smooth anti-biofilm models. Replacement or descaling of the aerators. Flushing of rarely used water points.
< 1 000 CFU/l> 1 000 CFU/lContamination of the upstream distribution network, terminal fittings clean.Checking the non-return valves, verifying the flow rates of the static or thermal loop balancing valves, removal of blind sections identified in the service shaft.
> 1 000 CFU/l> 1 000 CFU/lOverall systemic contamination of the DHW network.Temporary fitting of 0.2 µm terminal filters on the showers. Thermal disinfection of the network at 70 °C at each draw-off point for at least 3 minutes. Checking that 60 °C is maintained at the storage tank outlet.

Managing an analytical non-conformity and remediating the network

When the results from an accredited laboratory reveal that the reference values set by the ordinance on drinking water and on the water of publicly accessible bathing and shower facilities, or by the SSIGE guidelines, have been exceeded, the plumber must intervene without improvising. The first task consists of cross-checking the two bottles taken: the immediate first-draw sample and the sample after prolonged flushing until the temperature stabilises. This comparison determines the source of proliferation and dictates the exact nature of the remedial works.

Diagnosis of the location of the contamination and immediate corrective measures
First-draw resultResult after flushingLocation of the problemPlumbing technical action
Positive (exceeded)Compliant (below threshold)Fitting, aerator, hose or terminal dead legDescaling, disinfection or replacement of the terminal components; purging of dead legs.
Compliant (below threshold)Positive (exceeded)Riser, circulation loop or storage tankRegulation of loop returns, general hydraulic flushing and balancing.
Positive (exceeded)Positive (exceeded)Overall systemic contamination of the distributionGlobal disinfection of the network, review of temperatures and rework of stagnant routes.
  1. Emergency securingAs soon as a critical concentration is notified, shut off the draw-off points at risk of aerosols, in particular shower heads, or fit the outlets with watertight sterilising terminal filters.
  2. Targeted curative treatmentIf the contamination is general, carry out a flush with domestic hot water in accordance with SSIGE directive W3, maintaining the required temperature at each draw-off point, or carry out an authorised chemical disinfection.
  3. Effectiveness checkCarry out a new sampling campaign no earlier than forty-eight hours after the remediation, again observing the double sampling in order to verify lasting eradication of the biofilm.

Every remediation measure must be recorded in the building's sanitary operating log. If anomalies persist despite purges and thermal shocks, the plumber must physically audit the uninsulated pipe sections, the temperature drops on the circulation returns and the unconnected stub pipes. Mechanical elimination of dead legs remains the only definitive guarantee against bacterial recolonisation of drinking water networks.

Frequently asked questions

Why does taking a sample of mixed water at the shower outlet distort the diagnosis?

Sampling the mixed water directly masks the exact origin of the bacteria by blending cold and hot water. Moreover, the mixer cartridge, the hose and the shower head often harbour an independent biofilm. To target the faulty component in accordance with the SSIGE guidelines, the shower head must be removed and the raw mixed water sampled separately, then the domestic hot water alone at the upstream supply connection after thermal stabilisation.

What must be done immediately if the water analysis reveals a critical level of Legionella pneumophila?

The plumber must notify the operations manager so that access to the showers concerned is immediately prohibited, or have 0.2 micrometre antibacterial terminal filters installed on the outlets. The distribution temperatures must then be checked in accordance with SSIGE directive W3, the circulation loop surveyed, and a thermal shock or systematic disinfection of the entire contaminated network organised, followed by an analytical check.

Should the pipes be purged before taking a domestic water sample?

No, not before the first sample has been taken. According to the SSIGE protocols, the very first one-litre draw taken without prior flushing represents the stagnant water contained in the fitting and the terminal connection, where the biofilm is concentrated. Only after this bottling is the tap purged until a constant temperature is reached in order to take the second sample, representative of the water circulating in the riser.

What are the risks of a poorly executed thermal disinfection on a sanitary installation?

An uncontrolled rise in temperature exposes users to severe scalding at draw-off points not fitted with safety thermostatic mixers. On the equipment side, repeated thermal shocks above seventy degrees damage synthetic seals, accelerate scaling of heat exchangers and cause sudden expansions that generate leaks on pressed or soldered fittings. The intervention requires a written protocol and rigorous monitoring.

Texts and standards cited

  • directive SSIGE W3Guidelines for drinking water installations
  • OPBDOrdinance on drinking water and on the water of publicly accessible bathing and shower facilities

In the same section