Key takeaways
- The impedance measurement at the end of the line determines the minimum prospective fault current.
- The calculated current must exceed the magnetic tripping threshold of the installed protective device.
- The NIBT requires automatic disconnection within 0.4 second for socket-outlets.
- An insufficient current requires changing the curve, lowering the rating or increasing the cross-section.
The impedance measurement validates magnetic tripping within the prescribed time
On a construction site subject to the NIBT rules, verifying automatic disconnection of supply in a TN system relies on mastering the phase-to-protective-conductor loop impedance, denoted Zs. This quantity expresses the total resistance and reactance encountered by the fault current from the secondary winding of the distribution transformer, through the supply line, the main switchboard, the circuit breaker and the phase conductor to the equipment, and then the complete return via the PE or PEN protective conductor. Taking this measurement at the furthest point of each final circuit is the only technical way to establish the worst-case situation of the installation.
- Prospective fault current (Ik)
- Theoretical value of the current that flows during a bolted short circuit between a phase conductor and earth or the protective conductor, obtained by dividing the nominal phase voltage by the measured loop impedance.
The test instrument applies a brief voltage drop or injects a calibrated pulse train to measure this impedance without tripping the upstream residual current devices. The instrument displays two inseparable data simultaneously: the impedance Zs in ohms and the prospective short-circuit current in amperes or kiloamperes, calculated directly using the relation Ik equals U zero divided by Zs, with a reference voltage of two hundred and thirty volts. This prospective fault current represents the minimum energy flow that will pass through the disconnecting device at the instant the metal enclosure of an appliance comes into contact with the phase.
To meet the requirement of disconnection within 0.4 second, the miniature circuit breaker cannot operate in its slow thermal range. The prospective fault current must reach the instantaneous range, that is, the electromagnetic tripping threshold of the device. If the actual short-circuit current remains confined to the thermal overload zone of the circuit breaker, disconnection will take several seconds, or even several tens of seconds. During this interval, the accessible metal casing remains at a potential that is dangerous for the user, and the heating of PVC-insulated conductors can destroy embedded conduits.
Interpreting the prospective current and adapting the protection at the switchboard
Analysis in the field requires a direct comparison between the prospective fault current displayed by the instrument and the instantaneous operating current of the protective device, denoted Ia. For a standard miniature circuit breaker, the value of Ia depends strictly on its standardised tripping curve. A sixteen-ampere circuit breaker with a B curve trips instantaneously between three and five times its rated current, i.e. a guaranteed disconnection threshold of eighty amperes. The same sixteen-ampere rating with a C curve requires between five and ten times the rated current, which raises the guaranteed magnetic tripping threshold to one hundred and sixty amperes.
| Rated current | Curve B (5 x In) | Curve C (10 x In) | Curve D (20 x In) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 A | 50 A | 100 A | 200 A |
| 13 A | 65 A | 130 A | 260 A |
| 16 A | 80 A | 160 A | 320 A |
| 20 A | 100 A | 200 A | 400 A |
When the measurement at the furthest socket-outlet shows a loop impedance of one point sixty ohms, the short-circuit current calculated by the instrument comes to one hundred and forty-three amperes. If this circuit is protected by a sixteen-ampere C-curve distribution circuit breaker, the protection does not meet the requirements of the NIBT: one hundred and forty-three amperes is below the one hundred and sixty amperes needed to ensure magnetic tripping. Disconnection within 0.4 second is absolutely not guaranteed.
- Replacement with a B curveReplace the C-curve circuit breaker with a B-curve model of the same rating if no high-inrush load justifies it, lowering the required threshold from 160 to 80 amperes.
- Lowering the rated currentReduce the rating to 13 amperes or even 10 amperes on a C curve, bringing the instantaneous disconnection requirement below the measured short-circuit value.
- Increasing the conductor cross-sectionInstall conductors of larger cross-section to reduce the line's resistance per unit length when the assigned rated current must absolutely be maintained.
Any non-conformity found during this metrological verification engages the installer's responsibility before the safety report is issued. Recording an impedance value without comparing the resulting fault current with the magnetic threshold of the upstream device is a major technical fault. If the distributor or the independent inspection body finds a rating unsuited to the measured loop, immediate rectification will be required at the expense of the contracting company.
Diagnosing an excessive loop: from field finding to magnetic threshold
On the construction site, loop impedance is always measured at the furthest point of use of each final circuit. The calibrated measuring instrument passes a calibrated load pulse between the live conductor and the protective conductor (PE) to evaluate the total fault impedance ($Z_s$). This quantity includes the internal resistance of the network operator's transformer, the main connecting cable, the busbars of the switchboard and all the wiring of the circuit concerned. At the nominal phase voltage of 230 V, the multifunction tester instantly calculates the prospective short-circuit current ($I_k$). This direct physical check allows the installation electrician to certify that the energy released during a bolted fault will trip the magnetic release of the disconnecting device without delay, in accordance with the fast-clearing requirements set out in the NIBT.
- Prospective short-circuit current ($I_k$)
- Electric current that would flow in the circuit concerned if a short circuit of negligible impedance occurred between a live conductor and an exposed metal part or the protective conductor.
| Disconnecting device | Magnetic threshold ($I_a$) | Minimum fault current ($I_{k,\min}$) | Maximum loop impedance ($Z_{s,\max}$) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Circuit breaker B10 | 3 to 5 × In | 50 A | 4.60 Ω |
| Circuit breaker B13 | 3 to 5 × In | 65 A | 3.54 Ω |
| Circuit breaker B16 | 3 to 5 × In | 80 A | 2.88 Ω |
| Circuit breaker C10 | 5 to 10 × In | 100 A | 2.30 Ω |
| Circuit breaker C13 | 5 to 10 × In | 130 A | 1.77 Ω |
| Circuit breaker C16 | 5 to 10 × In | 160 A | 1.44 Ω |
As soon as the measured impedance exceeds the permissible limit, the prospective current $I_k$ falls below the threshold required for instantaneous tripping. If a measurement gives a value of 1.95 Ω on a socket-outlet protected by a C16 circuit breaker, the calculated current reaches only 118 A, whereas electromagnetic tripping requires at least 160 A. The device will then react only through its thermal bimetal, leaving a dangerous potential on the exposed metal parts for several seconds. Faced with a non-compliant result, the team leader first looks for connection faults: a loosely tightened terminal screw in a junction box, oxidation on the contacts of a socket-outlet or an undersized earth conductor in an intermediate connection.
Correcting ratings, alternative solutions and the safety report
When the high impedance results from the actual length of the route or from irreversible installation constraints, the installer must correct the protection at the distribution board. The most direct action is to review the rated current or the response curve of the miniature circuit breaker. If the power of the connected appliances allows it, replacing a C16 circuit breaker with a C13 or C10 model immediately reduces the required short-circuit current. Likewise, switching from a C curve to a B curve halves the magnetic threshold: for a 16 A circuit, the instantaneous tripping current falls from 160 A to 80 A. The permissible loop impedance is then raised to 2.88 Ω, which makes the installation compliant without pulling in new conductors.
If the load requires keeping a 16 A circuit breaker on a C curve to absorb inrush currents and re-pulling larger-section wires (from 1.5 mm² to 2.5 mm²) is impossible in the existing conduits, adding a residual current device (RCD) with a maximum sensitivity of 30 mA offers a compliant alternative. According to the NIBT requirements for TN earthing systems, the RCD is an approved compensatory measure: it ensures automatic disconnection as soon as an earth insulation fault occurs, guaranteeing the protection of persons independently of the operation of the magnetic release.
All the corrected final measurements must be documented precisely in the test protocol included in the safety report (RaSi). This official document specifies for each circuit the protective rating installed, the curve selected, the measured impedance $Z_s$ and the prospective current $I_k$. This technical information, passed on to the owner and the network operator, forms the as-built file required at the acceptance inspection or the periodic inspections provided for by the OIBT. At the same time, the installer updates the single-line diagram displayed on the switchboard door to ensure absolute consistency between the equipment in place and the technical documentation.
Site arbitration: persistent loop non-conformity and making safe
In the field, the fault loop measurement ($Z_s$ or $Z_{L-PE}$) taken at the end of the circuit immediately determines the compliance of the installation. If the measured impedance is excessive, the prospective fault current ($I_k$) calculated by the installation tester falls below the magnetic tripping threshold of the protective device. In a TN network, the NIBT requires a maximum disconnection time of 0.4 second for final circuits up to 63 A supplying socket-outlets or mobile equipment. If the minimum short-circuit current does not reach the instantaneous threshold, disconnection falls back on the thermal bimetal, which reacts within several seconds. The protective conductor then heats up dangerously and the touch voltage persists on the exposed metal parts.
- Check the physical connectionsHunt down parasitic contact resistances. Check the tightness at the switchboard terminals, inspect the spring or screw terminals in the junction boxes and measure the continuity of the PE conductor. A loosely tightened terminal distorts the measurement.
- Adapt the tripping curveReplace a C-curve circuit breaker with a B curve when the inrush currents of the load allow it. For a 16 A rating, the minimum magnetic threshold required drops immediately from 160 A to 80 A, restoring compliance without changing the cable.
- Lower the rated currentReplace the protective device with a lower rating, for example by going from 16 A to 13 A or 10 A. This proportional reduction lowers the prospective fault current needed to guarantee the fast disconnection required by the standard.
- Add residual current protectionAdd a residual current device if the line cross-section cannot be increased in the existing conduit. In a TN system, the RCD ensures opening within a fraction of a second in the event of an insulation fault, even with a high loop impedance.
In the event of a technical impasse or if the client refuses to modify the contractual ratings, the circuit must remain locked out and padlocked at the main switchboard. The installer records the actual values and the calculation showing the shortfall in the initial measurement protocol. Art. 365 CO requires the contractor to inform the client immediately of any circumstance compromising the proper execution of the work. This written notification relieves the installer of liability and blocks the issue of the safety report as long as the installation presents a risk of electric shock.
Frequently asked questions
Why measure the loop impedance at the furthest point rather than at the switchboard outgoing way?
Measuring at the furthest piece of equipment captures the total resistance of the phase and protective conductors. The longer the line, the higher the loop Zs and the lower the prospective short-circuit current. Validating compliance at the worst-case point mathematically guarantees that any insulation fault occurring upstream will generate a higher current, tripping the disconnecting device in an even shorter time than that required by the NIBT.
What should be done if the measured prospective fault current is borderline relative to the magnetic threshold?
When the measured value is close to the theoretical threshold, the temperature correction factor must be applied. Under the effect of the short circuit, the heating of the copper conductors increases their resistance by about 20%. If the safety margin is zero when cold, the circuit breaker will not disconnect within the prescribed time during a real fault. It is then advisable to switch to a B curve or to reduce the rated current of the protective circuit breaker.
Does a 30 mA residual current circuit breaker remove the need to check the fault loop impedance?
No, the measurement remains essential even where an RCD is present. While the RCD protects persons against indirect contact by disconnecting in less than 0.4 second, the phase-neutral loop impedance must also be measured to verify the breaking capacity and the clearing of bolted short circuits by the circuit breaker. In addition, the measurement validates the mechanical continuity of the PE conductor and the absence of a broken link between the exposed conductive part and the switchboard.
Why is an abnormally low loop impedance sometimes found on an old socket-outlet?
An abnormally low impedance on an old installation often signals uncontrolled parallel earth paths. The earth conductor may be in direct contact with a metal water pipe, a reinforced-concrete reinforcement or a metal sheath. This fortuitous earthing distorts the reading by masking a break in the main PE conductor. A point-to-point continuity check with the supply off makes it possible to separate the real PE from parasitic metallic connections.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365materials and land: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the materials he supplies; if the materials supplied by the client or the land designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3)
