Key takeaways
- A thermographic survey is always carried out with the installation delivering at least forty per cent load.
- A difference of more than fifteen kelvins requires targeted action at the next shutdown.
- Insufficient mechanical tightening is the main cause of temperature rise through contact resistance.
- The inspection interval varies from one to three years depending on the operating requirements of the building.
Measurement conditions under load and classification of temperature differences
A conductor or a switching device does not heat up instantaneously to the point of causing a fire. The degradation process usually extends over several weeks, even several months. An abnormal contact resistance produces heat dissipation according to Ohm's law, proportional to the square of the current flowing through the connection. Detecting this anomaly with a thermal camera before the insulation carbonises, however, requires one strict condition: the installation must be examined during a phase of active operation. Carrying out a thermographic campaign on a main distribution board whose outgoing circuits are unloaded or under-loaded is a waste of technical effort, because the heat flow dissipated is undetectable by the bolometric sensor.
To obtain a usable analysis, the load must reach at least 40 % to 50 % of the rated current of the circuits inspected. The measurement is carried out with covers or front panels open, in strict compliance with the safety measures for work in the vicinity of live bare parts, wearing the required personal protective equipment. The assessment is based on the temperature difference, denoted Delta T, measured between the suspect area and a healthy reference phase carrying an identical current, or relative to the ambient temperature of the enclosure.
| Temperature difference (Delta T) | Severity level | Effect on the equipment | Recommended action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 to 5 K | Low / monitor | Incipient overheating without damage | Record the currents and note in the report for follow-up |
| 5 to 15 K | Medium / to be planned | Premature thermal ageing of the insulation | Torque check and cleaning at the next maintenance |
| 15 to 30 K | High / urgent | Clear degradation of plastics and oxidation of the copper | Intervention scheduled at short notice, remake the connection |
| > 30 K | Critical / immediate | Risk of electric arc, melting or fire outbreak | Shed load or isolate without delay, replace the component |
Interpreting the thermal image requires careful setting of the camera parameters, in particular emissivity. A bare polished copper conductor or a silver-plated aluminium connection pad has a very low emissivity, causing parasitic reflections from the surroundings. To make the measurement reliable on these shiny metals, the practitioner aims in priority at the adjacent PVC insulating sheaths or resin terminals, or applies vinyl tape of known emissivity (close to 0.95) in order to quantify the real value of the temperature rise.
Origin of hot spots, mechanical correction and campaign intervals
Field experience on installations inspected according to the NIBT shows that an overwhelming majority of the hot spots found result from a failure of mechanical tightening. The succession of thermal cycles of expansion and contraction of the copper, combined with vibrations induced by the mains frequency or by nearby electromechanical equipment, causes screw terminals to loosen progressively. This phenomenon is accompanied by surface oxidation of the metal at the contact point, increasing the interface resistance. More rarely, the overheating results from an undersized conductor, from broken strands in a flexible conductor that has been poorly crimped, or from a blatant load imbalance between the phases.
- Recording and assessmentPhotograph the thermogram together with the real view of the switchboard, measure the current of each phase with a clamp multimeter and calculate the exact Delta T.
- Secure isolationSwitch off the supply to the switchboard or the targeted outgoing circuit, and verify the absence of voltage according to the five safety rules before any manual intervention.
- Inspection and restorationDismantle the suspect connection, clean the oxidised metal surfaces, replace the ferrules or the annealed conductors, then re-tighten with a screwdriver or torque wrench to the torque prescribed by the switchgear manufacturer.
- Check measurement under loadRe-energise the circuit, wait for thermal stabilisation under a representative load and confirm that the residual Delta T has definitively disappeared.
The employer ensures that the general technical prevention rules adapted to the hazards of electric current are applied, in accordance with art. 82 LAA, by providing the personnel involved with arc-flash face shields and insulating gloves when opening front panels under voltage. As regards intervals, although the OIBT sets the legal periodic inspections of installations at intervals of one, five, ten or twenty years depending on the use of the premises, infrared thermography is a predictive maintenance tool that follows a tighter schedule.
Each campaign must be documented in a structured technical report recording the thermal images, the measured currents, the reference ambient temperature and the immediate or deferred corrective actions. This document, included in the review file of the electrical switchboard, guarantees the traceability required by the operators of the building and demonstrates full control of the risk of fires of electrical origin.
Measurement protocol under load and interpretation of temperature differences
Infrared thermography applied to low-voltage switchgear assemblies anticipates the thermal failure of components well before an arc or visible carbonisation appears. Since the Joule effect is proportional to the square of the current ($P = R \cdot I^2$), a contact resistance anomaly remains undetectable if the installation does not deliver sufficient current at the time of scanning. A measurement under representative load requires the switchboard to operate at at least 40 % of its rated current, the ideal being above 70 % during the real operating peaks of the building (machines in production or maximum office activity). Examining a cabinet under low load without first recording the currents with clamp meters risks a false negative: a defective terminal carrying 5 A will appear cold, but will cause destructive damage as soon as a power demand reaches 63 A.
| Temperature difference (ΔT) | Anomaly level | Effect on the equipment | Time to intervene |
|---|---|---|---|
| ΔT < 10 K | Minor overheating | Initial drift, insulation withstand maintained | To be recorded and monitored at the next inspection |
| 10 K ≤ ΔT < 30 K | Significant difference | Degradation of the insulation, oxidation of the contacts | Planned intervention within one month with load check |
| ΔT ≥ 30 K | Critical difference | Imminent risk of arcing or fire outbreak | Immediate de-loading and repair before re-energising |
The operator must set up the thermal camera rigorously. While PVC insulating sheaths and painted front panels show an emissivity close to 0.95, bare copper pads or tinned aluminium busbars have a very low emissivity (often below 0.30), creating misleading parasitic reflections from neighbouring elements. A significant temperature difference is not judged on an absolute raw value, but by differential comparison between phases on a symmetrical outgoing circuit, or relative to the internal ambient air outside the convective flow. As these operations are carried out with doors open and under voltage, wearing personal protective equipment against electric arcs is required in accordance with art. 3 OPA, which requires the employer to take the protective measures that meet the recognised rules of safety engineering.
Dealing with mechanical loosening and inspection schedule
On low-voltage distribution and control installations, the most frequent cause of overheating remains the progressive loosening of screwed mechanical connections. This unavoidable phenomenon results from the permanent electrodynamic micro-vibrations induced by the 50 Hz frequency, from the repeated mechanical shocks of power contactors and above all from the slow plastic creep of copper under the effect of thermal expansion-cooling cycles. When the initial tightening is carried out without a suitable ferrule or without strict control of the recommended torque, the connection bears only on tiny surface micro-asperities. Over time, mechanical relaxation lowers the contact pressure, the interface resistance rises, releases additional heat and accelerates thermal runaway. The systematic use of periodically calibrated torque tools is the only reliable technical safeguard against this progressive mechanical degradation.
To maintain the safety of the installation over time and prevent any risk of fire, the installer-electrician must formalise a proposed inspection interval according to the criticality of the site, consistent with the OIBT inspection regimes and the fire protection directives of the AEAI:
- Annual inspection: essential for main boards (TGBT) of industrial sites, craft workshops, premises at risk of fire and large premises open to the public.
- Two-yearly inspection: recommended for office sub-distribution boards, administrative centres and commercial areas without flammable dust.
- Five-yearly inspection: aligned with the OIBT interval for light commercial premises and common installations of residential buildings.
- Acceptance inspection after works: carried out two to three months after commissioning, when the stabilised load regime reveals any initial tightening defects.
The file handed to the client contains each thermogram paired with a visible-light photograph, with the measured currents and a list of the corrective actions required. For a set of cabinets in an office building, the cost of a thermographic campaign is usually of the order of CHF 600 to 1,200 depending on the size of the installation, a modest amount compared with the cost of an unplanned shutdown or a major loss.
Handling a critical thermal anomaly and making safe
Discovering abnormal overheating during a thermographic inspection requires an immediate decision proportionate to the gradient recorded. When a temperature difference exceeds 40 K relative to a reference conductor under equivalent load, or when the absolute temperature at the terminals of a device exceeds the rated limit of the insulation (generally 70 °C for standard PVC), the risk of material degradation and electric arc is imminent. The person involved cannot postpone the corrective measure.
- Load shedding and isolation of the lineThe team leader immediately carries out targeted load shedding of the outgoing circuit concerned to interrupt the Joule effect. If the overheating is on the main busbar or the main switch, a shutdown coordinated with the site operator is required immediately in accordance with the safety rules for work on de-energised installations.
- Joint inspection record and notice to the ownerIn accordance with CO, the contractor notifies the client or their representative of any circumstance jeopardising the work. The electrician writes an intervention report stating the time-stamped infrared image, the maximum temperature measured, the current recorded with the clamp meter and the visible damage to the switchgear.
- Mechanical restoration and post-intervention checkSimply re-tightening a screw on a blued or oxidised terminal is not enough. Copper that is work-hardened or annealed by heat loses its elastic properties. The overheated section of conductor must be cut off, the terminal or circuit breaker replaced, and the tightening carried out with a torque screwdriver to the torque specified by the manufacturer.
To comply with art. 82 LAA, the employer applies all necessary prevention measures during diagnostic work under voltage, in particular the wearing of arc-flash protective visors and insulating gloves. If the fault has caused partial melting or a degradation of the breaking capacity, the final return to service is subject to a final check recorded in the operating file of the distribution board.
Frequently asked questions
What minimum load rate must be used for the thermography of a switchboard?
Infrared thermography is only meaningful if the circuit operates at at least 30 % of its rated current, the ideal being to reach or exceed 50 %. Since the Joule effect varies with the square of the current, a measurement taken on a busbar or a circuit breaker under low load completely masks a faulty contact. In the case of low load, the main loads must be switched on deliberately before carrying out the thermal scan.
From what temperature difference is a hot spot considered critical?
Between 5 and 10 K difference relative to a neighbouring phase carrying an identical load, the developing defect requires monitoring at the next maintenance. Between 10 and 30 K, the overheating indicates a marked contact resistance that requires a planned intervention shortly. Beyond 30 K of differential, or if the absolute temperature exceeds the thermal class of the insulation, the anomaly becomes critical and justifies prompt isolation for mechanical repair.
Why is tightening the main cause of the overheating observed?
Alternating cycles of heating and cooling cause differential expansion between the steel screw and the copper or aluminium conductor. Without elastic compensation, this dynamic induces settling of the material and then progressive loosening. The reduction of the useful contact area increases the local electrical resistance, which intensifies the heat release by the Joule effect and accelerates the degradation until the insulation is burnt.
What thermographic inspection interval should be proposed to clients?
For industrial, commercial or craft low-voltage main boards under heavy use, an annual campaign is the recommended frequency. In small office or residential assemblies, an inspection every three to five years is generally sufficient, often coordinated with the deadlines of the periodic inspection within the meaning of the OIBT. Any significant addition of power or major modification of the switchboard must systematically be followed by an acceptance thermography.
Texts and standards cited
- COmaterial and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must notify the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
- LAA art. 82general prevention rules: to prevent occupational accidents and diseases, the employer takes all the measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that the state of the art makes it possible to apply and that are adapted to the given conditions; the workers assist him (in particular by using personal protective equipment).
