Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 232Renovation: diagnostics and remediation of existing structuresChapter 2 of 10 in the section

Old wiring with degraded insulation: recognising it, measuring it and refusing to reuse it

Faced with conductors under textile braiding or impregnated paper, the installation electrician cannot improvise any makeshift repair. You will learn to identify this historic wiring, to confirm its dielectric failure by insulation measurement, to justify a categorical technical refusal to reuse it and to formalise in writing the mandatory notice addressed to the owner of the installation.

Key takeaways

  • Hardened or crumbling textile braiding signals an irreversible failure of the conductor's insulating sheath.
  • Any mechanical handling of an old conductor causes its protective material to burst apart immediately.
  • An insulation measurement at a standardised test voltage confirms the dielectric breakdown before any connection is made.
  • The written notice of defect relieves the installer of liability by recording the obligation of complete replacement.

Observing the crumbling and validating the dielectric breakdown with the measuring instrument

In buildings erected before the 1960s in French-speaking Switzerland, installations frequently contain old-generation conductors with a vulcanised rubber sheath under a cotton braid impregnated with wax or bitumen, sometimes laid in threaded metal conduits of the Bergmann type. Over time, the heat dissipated by the Joule effect and continuous contact with oxygen cause the elastomers to lose their plasticisers. The rubber becomes brittle as glass, while the outer braid disintegrates into dark dust as soon as a junction box is opened.

The tactile test on the construction site is unambiguous: moderate pressure between thumb and forefinger on the conductor produces distinct cracking, followed by fragments of insulation falling away and leaving the bare copper exposed. As soon as this visual and mechanical finding is made, the conductor is considered unfit for use. No taping or sleeving can restore a dielectric barrier that complies with the recognised technical rules.

  1. Isolation and disconnectionSwitch off the supply upstream, lock out the circuit against any unintended re-energising and verify the absence of voltage with a calibrated two-pole voltage tester.
  2. Isolating the conductorsFree the ends without bending them excessively, taking care to separate the phases, the neutral and the surrounding metal parts.
  3. Insulation measurement at 500 VApply the standardised DC voltage between live conductors, then between each live conductor and earth or the metal conduit, using a verified installation insulation tester.
  4. Recording the measured valuesRead the displayed insulation resistance. On degraded insulation, the reading often falls below the acceptable threshold of 1 megaohm, sometimes dropping to negligible residual values.

Refusing the connection and documenting the replacement obligation with the client

The installation electrician is responsible for the compliance of the circuits he alters or works on. The discovery of wires insulated with degraded fabric prohibits any connection to a modern distribution board or new equipment. By knowingly agreeing to reconnect a bare or friable wire, the professional takes full responsibility for the resulting defects, in particular the risks of a dead short circuit, electric shock by indirect contact or a switchboard fire.

Course of action depending on the condition of the existing insulating sheath
Visual and mechanical conditionInsulation tester resultTechnical decision of the site foreman
Cotton braid intact but dry, no loss of materialAbove 1 MΩ when dryProvisional retention provided it is not handled; replacement to be planned.
Cracked insulation, loss of material in the test bendBelow 1 MΩ or unstableFormal refusal of reuse, section taken out of service and locked out.
Bare copper visible in the box or conduitDead short circuit or critical leakageAbsolute prohibition on re-energising, mandatory removal and complete rewiring.

Under art. 365 CO, the contractor informs the client if a circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work. Art. 229 CP punishes anyone who, intentionally or through negligence, infringes the recognised rules of the trade when carrying out construction work and thereby endangers the life or physical integrity of persons. The discovery of a dilapidated conduit requires a technical stop to the connection and a detailed letter of notice.

Removal of degraded conductors and constraints of historic conduits

The finding of friable textile or vulcanised rubber insulation prohibits any re-energising. Attempting to use degraded conductors as pull wires for the replacement exposes the electrician to mechanical breakage inside the conduit. Under pulling force, the cotton braiding tears off, the dry rubber flakes away and the bare annealed copper conductor risks jamming against an internal burr of the metal tube.

Behaviour when removing old conductors depending on the type of existing conduit
Type of period conduitLikely internal conditionRisk when removing the wiresTechnical measure on the construction site
Bergmann tube (stapled sheet metal and bituminised cardboard)Decomposed cardboard, residual moisture, sharp burrsTearing of the textile insulation, pull wire jammingPrior industrial vacuuming, neutral vegetable lubricant, flexible nylon rod
Heavy threaded steel tubeIncomplete deburring at the couplings, rustSevering of copper strands, short-circuit arc if kept liveMulti-conductor check for absence of voltage, use of a polished steel fish tape
Embedded lead conduitLocalised crushing under masonry, white oxidationReduced cross-section preventing the passage of three modern conductorsProbing with a mechanical gauge; abandon and chase out if the usable diameter is insufficient

To extract the wires without damaging the network of embedded conduits, the team injects a pulling lubricant compatible with modern plastics and free of solvents. Pulling is carried out by two fitters: one guides the conductors at the entry of the flush box without sharp bends, while the second applies a moderate linear force at the other end. If a break occurs mid-run, a transmitter-receiver cable locator makes it possible to pinpoint the blockage precisely before considering a destructive opening of the masonry.

Rewiring, permanent lock-out and formalising the duty to notify

When the insulation crumbles and the owner refuses the quote for rewiring, the installation electrician may under no circumstances reconnect the appliances or control devices. Leaving live an installation whose insulating sheath is falling to dust exposes the occupants to a fire caused by an arcing fault or to fatal indirect contact. Art. 229 CP punishes anyone who infringes the rules of the building trade and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons.

  1. 1. Physical disconnection of the circuit concernedDisconnect the offending circuit at the downstream terminals of the overcurrent protective device in the distribution board. Isolate the ends of the textile conductors with sealed end caps or closed spring terminals.
  2. 2. Mechanical lock-out and signageLock out the control device with a locking device or a lock-out padlock. Affix a rigid danger tag stating that energising is prohibited.
  3. 3. Joint insulation measurementApply a DC test voltage of 500 V between phases, neutral and earth. Record the collapsed insulation value on the measurement report to substantiate the technical impossibility of connection.
  4. 4. Drafting the written duty to notifySend the client a detailed notice stating the proven danger, the impossibility of incurring the company's liability and the list of the sections taken out of service.

Sending this notice meets the contractor's contractual obligations. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if a circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work, the contractor informs the client. The report states the exact location of the de-energised parts and recalls that the operator remains liable if he attempts an unauthorised re-energising without prior repair by personnel holding a federal installation licence.

Handling disputes and formal refusal to re-commission

On renovation construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland, the discovery of old wires under tarred textile braiding or crumbling vulcanised rubber frequently leads to friction with the client. When the latter refuses complete replacement of the lines in order to limit masonry costs or preserve historic woodwork, the installation electrician must under no circumstances give in. Re-energising conductors whose sheath crumbles at the slightest bend exposes the building to a manifest risk of short circuit, dead insulation fault and fire starting in wall cavities.

  1. Lock-out and blocking of the linePhysically disconnect the disputed conductors at the distribution board or in the junction box. Fit a lock-out padlock on the branch circuit breaker and place insulated protective terminals on each unconnected conductor.
  2. Drafting the joint measurement reportDraw up a report recording the value measured with the insulation ohmmeter at the standardised test voltage, together with clear photographs showing the crumbling of the braid and the exposed copper core.
  3. Sending the formal safety notificationSend a written report to the owner without delay by registered letter. This document certifies the prohibition on energising the dilapidated circuit, states the non-compliance with the NIBT and recalls the need for complete rewiring.

If the old network runs through metal conduits with a bituminous sleeve or asbestos boards, the electrician stops any attempt at mechanical pulling to avoid the release of harmful dust. The remediation of the contaminated conduits is then a matter for a specialist company before any new halogen-free conductors are installed. If the owner insists on forced re-energising of a dilapidated section, calling on an inspector from an accredited inspection body allows the dangerousness of the installation to be officially recorded, thereby protecting the installer and clarifying the technical dispute.

Frequently asked questions

Can a crumbling fabric wire be covered with heat-shrink sleeving to avoid replacing it?

Adding heat-shrink sleeving to a conductor whose textile insulation is falling to dust is non-compliant practice. This makeshift solution masks the problem at the visible end, but in no way guarantees the dielectric condition of the wire inside the conduit, where friction has also degraded the material. As soon as crumbling is observed during handling, complete replacement of the conductor by pulling in a new line is always required.

Does an insulation measurement above 1 MΩ allow a crumbling textile wire to be kept?

No. A satisfactory insulation measurement at the moment of testing only indicates the absence of conductive contact at rest, under stable humidity conditions. If the insulation crumbles to the touch, its mechanical strength is destroyed. The slightest vibration, settling of a structural element or later movement of equipment will cause the sheath to collapse and create a dangerous insulation fault. The visual and mechanical check takes precedence over a momentarily favourable measurement.

What should I do if the client demands in writing that I reconnect despite my warning of danger?

You must formally refuse the connection. A waiver signed by the client has no exonerating value in the event of an accident or electrical incident if the professional knowingly connected an installation that does not comply with the recognised rules of the trade. The approach is to lock out the disputed circuit de-energised at the board, fit insulating terminals and record the technical refusal in a written report sent to the client.

How should I act if the old conduit will not let the new conductors through?

When the old sheet-metal or lead tube is crushed or blocked, never force it, as this risks damaging the new insulation. If the line cannot be removed with a suitable lubricant, the conduit must be abandoned. The passage should then be blocked off, the technical impossibility recorded in the construction site report and the client offered a new route under surface-mounted trunking or through a compliant masonry chase.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365subject matter and ground: contractor's liability and informing the client in case of circumstances jeopardising execution of the work
  • CP art. 229infringement of the rules of the building trade

In the same section