Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 232Schematics, sizing and circuit protectionChapter 3 of 10 in the section

Circuit-breaker curve: B, C or D depending on what is supplied

When a protective device trips unexpectedly as a machine is switched on, the installer must make a precise diagnosis. You will learn to analyse the inrush peak of an inductive load, to select the appropriate magnetic curve according to the NIBT rules and to rule out blindly increasing the rated current, which jeopardises short-circuit breaking.

Key takeaways

  • The inrush current of a motor reaches six to ten times its nominal operating current.
  • The B curve trips on short-circuit from three to five times the rated current of the circuit-breaker.
  • Switching to a C or D curve absorbs the switch-on peak without changing the conductor cross-section.
  • Increasing the rated current instead of changing the curve compromises the protection of persons and cables.

Understanding tripping at start-up and characterising the tripping curves

On a commercial or industrial construction site, direct switching-on of a motor-driven machine often causes a type B thermal-magnetic circuit-breaker to open immediately. This phenomenon does not indicate an insulation fault or a continuous thermal overload, but the instantaneous response of the magnetic release. On energising, the stationary rotor and the build-up of the inductive flux generate a transient inrush current that peaks at between 6 and 10 times the nominal current for a few tens of milliseconds. A B curve, calibrated to react between 3 and 5 times the rated current In, systematically interprets this wave as a bolted short-circuit.

Magnetic inrush current
Transient current peak drawn by an inductive or capacitive load when it is energised, characterised by a peak amplitude and a time constant before stabilising at nominal operation.
Magnetic tripping thresholds according to the product standard for circuit-breakers
Curve typeMinimum magnetic thresholdMaximum magnetic thresholdTypical building applications
B curve3 x In5 x InVery long lines, purely final distribution circuits, heaters without inrush
C curve5 x In10 x InGeneral use, standard socket outlets, standard compressors, motors with soft start
D curve10 x In20 x InMotors with high direct-start torque, LV/LV transformers, large fans

The thermal behaviour remains strictly identical from one curve to another: the bimetal protects the cable against slow overloads with the same time tolerances. In contrast, the magnetic system of the C curve tolerates the peak of a conventional asynchronous motor without tripping. For loads with a very high starting inrush, such as a workshop circular saw or a high-inertia industrial dust extractor, the D curve moves the instantaneous tripping threshold up to 10 to 20 times In, allowing the wave to pass without unwanted tripping.

The oversizing trap and loop checks according to the NIBT

When a B13 circuit-breaker trips on connecting a motor-pump set, the most frequent field error is to replace the device with a B20 or B25 that happens to be in the van. This practice is a major non-conformity with respect to the NIBT rules. Increasing the rated current In without recalculating the cross-section destroys the thermal coordination of the line: a 1.5 mm² or 2.5 mm² cable is exposed to a permanent overload that the circuit-breaker allows but that is destructive for the conductor insulation, creating a direct fire risk in partitions or cable trays.

The second pitfall concerns the protection of persons against indirect contact by automatic disconnection of the supply, and the disconnection within the prescribed time of the minimum short-circuit current at the end of the line. Switching to a higher curve requires a larger short-circuit current Ik to operate the electromagnet. The electrician must measure the phase-PE loop impedance at the furthest point of the line using a verified installation tester. If the loop has too high a resistance because of excessive wiring length, the prospective short-circuit current will not reach the upper magnetic threshold of a D curve.

  1. Checking the rating plateRead off the nominal operating current and the starting factor of the motor to identify the real inrush peak.
  2. Keeping the rating suited to the cableMaintain a rated current In less than or equal to the current-carrying capacity Iz of the installed conductor according to its installation method.
  3. Substituting the tripping curveReplace the device with a circuit-breaker of the same rated current but of C or D curve according to the magnetisation requirement.
  4. Measuring the minimum short-circuit currentCheck at the end of the line that the minimum fault current Ik trips the circuit-breaker within the time required by the NIBT.

If calculation or measurement proves that the short-circuit current at the far end is insufficient to instantly reach the threshold of a D curve, the installer must not persist with this solution. The correction then requires either increasing the line cross-section to reduce the loop resistance, or inserting an electronic soft starter that will shave off the inrush peak, making the use of a C curve fully compatible with the overall safety of the installation.

Choice of curve according to load dynamics and limitation of inrush current

The behaviour of a load when it is energised dictates the choice of the modular protective device. When a three-phase or single-phase asynchronous motor starts direct-on-line, the inrush current instantly reaches six to eight times its rated current for a duration of between a few tenths of a second and several seconds. A B curve, whose magnetic release reacts from 3 to 5 times the nominal current, perceives this transient peak as a bolted short-circuit and causes the circuit to open unintentionally. Systematically replacing it with a C curve (magnetic threshold of 5 to 10 times In) solves the great majority of start-ups of construction-site compressors, mitre saws or light hoists without compromising the thermal safety of the cable.

For loads with high mechanical inertia or a very high initial reluctance — such as large isolating transformers, motors starting under heavy load or certain transformerless power supplies — switching to a D curve (magnetic threshold between 10 and 14 times In, depending on manufacturers' ranges) becomes indispensable. The NIBT requires this magnetic threshold to be adjusted so that it remains strictly matched to the normal starting regime without requiring an artificial increase of the nominal rated current.

Suitability of tripping curves according to loads and usual magnetic thresholds
CurveMagnetic threshold rangeRecommended load typesConstraint on line length
B curve3 to 5 × InPurely resistive heating, heaters, final lighting distribution lines without inductive ballastTolerates the longest line lengths while guaranteeing instantaneous disconnection.
C curve5 to 10 × InGeneral building applications: small motors, standard refrigeration units, workshop socket outlets, grouped fluorescent or LED lightingIntermediate maximum length; reference standard in Swiss residential and commercial installations.
D curve10 to 14 × InLV/LV transformers, high-inertia motors, direct-start industrial compressors, welding setsVery limited cable length; requires a particularly low loop impedance.

Besides the choice of the miniature circuit-breaker itself, the electrician-installer must consider limiting the inrush current at the source when the line has a restrictive cross-section. Fitting a static soft starter, a conventional star-delta changeover or a transient damping resistor reduces the energising peak to less than three times the nominal current. This technical approach avoids imposing on the upstream distribution a D-curve circuit-breaker that would needlessly saturate the fast-tripping capacity of the main board.

On-site inspection protocols and the thermal derating trap

The selection of the curve does not change the characteristic of the thermal bimetal in any way: whether type B, C or D, a 16 A device provides identical protection against slow overloads. The recurring trap is to increase the rated current of the circuit-breaker (for example fitting a 25 A circuit-breaker in place of a 16 A to get past the starting peak) instead of simply changing the curve. This wrong reflex exposes the cable to prolonged undetected heating, the permissible thermal capacity of the cable insulation (generally 70 °C for PVC or 90 °C for XLPE) being exceeded before the circuit-breaker opens the pole.

Before official commissioning and issue of the safety report (RSI), the metrological test protocol requires absolute validation of automatic disconnection at the point furthest from the load. The electrician measures the phase-PE fault loop impedance using a calibrated installation tester. The measured prospective short-circuit current must imperatively be higher than the minimum magnetic tripping current of the installed circuit-breaker, i.e. at least the product of the rated current and the upper factor of the curve.

  1. Recording the load dataIdentify on the motor rating plate the rated operating current, the power factor and the estimated ratio of the starting current (Ia/In).
  2. Joint selection of rating and curveDetermine the rated current from the cable cross-section and installation method, then choose the B, C or D curve able to absorb the transient current without opening the circuit.
  3. Final loop impedance measurementConnect the installation tester to the motor terminal block and measure the loop impedance to ensure that the prospective short-circuit current trips the magnetic release within the time prescribed by the NIBT.
  4. Recording in the measurement protocolEnter in the test protocol the value in ohms, the calculated fault current, and the reference of the curve selected in the distribution board.

Decision procedure in case of persistent tripping at start-up

On a construction site in French-speaking Switzerland, unwanted tripping of a motor as soon as it is switched on often reveals a mismatch between the dynamic behaviour of the load and the magnetic profile of the disconnecting device. When the circuit-breaker trips systematically despite resetting, the electrician-installer must on no account replace the protective device with a higher rated current. This practice creates an immediate fire risk through inadmissible heating of the cables or removes the automatic disconnection required in the event of a short-circuit at the end of the line.

  1. Recording the actual values and the rating plateCheck the supply voltage, the rated current and the power factor on the motor rating plate. Measure the actual peak at switch-on with a clamp meter equipped with an inrush-current capture function over a minimum period of 100 milliseconds.
  2. Checking the loop impedance before substitutionMeasure the phase-PE loop impedance at the motor connection box using an installation tester. Confirm that the prospective short-circuit current guarantees instantaneous tripping of the intended circuit-breaker according to the NIBT requirements.
  3. Adapting the curve or fitting a soft starterIf the loop calculation confirms the safety of persons, replace the B-curve circuit-breaker with a model of the same rating in C curve (magnetic threshold between 5 and 10 times the rated current) or in D curve (magnetic threshold between 10 and 20 times the rated current). If the loop impedance is too high, keep the protection and fit a soft starter or a drive to limit the peak at the source.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a compressor trip a B16 circuit-breaker when its running current is only 10 A?

A B-curve circuit-breaker reacts magnetically from 3 to 5 times its rated current, i.e. between 48 and 80 A. On direct start under load, an asynchronous motor generates a transient inrush current reaching 6 to 8 times its rated current, i.e. 60 to 80 A for several tens of milliseconds. This pulse instantly trips the magnetic release of the circuit-breaker without there being a continuous thermal overload.

Can a B16 circuit-breaker be replaced by a B25 to avoid unwanted trips of a machine?

No, this modification is a major technical fault. Increasing the rated current of a line sized for 16 A exposes the 2.5 mm² cable to destructive overloads that the 25 A circuit-breaker will no longer detect in time. The solution complying with the NIBT rules is to keep the rated current of 16 A while adopting a C or D curve, or to fit a soft-start system.

What constraint does fitting a D-curve circuit-breaker on a very long line impose?

The D curve requires a minimum short-circuit current equivalent to 10 to 20 times the rated current to trip instantaneously on its magnetic part. On a long line, the resistance of the conductors lowers the prospective short-circuit current at the point of use. If this value falls below the upper magnetic threshold, the tripping time exceeds the limits set by the NIBT, creating a fatal risk through touch voltage.

What documentary checks and measurements must the electrician record after changing the curve of a motor feeder?

The installer records the measurement of the phase-PE loop impedance at the load, the calculated minimum short-circuit current and the compliance of the automatic disconnection time. He updates the board labelling and the single-line distribution diagram. The results are entered in the preliminary measurement protocol before signing the safety report provided for by the OIBT, certifying that no risk of overheating or electric shock remains.

Texts and standards cited

  • CP art. 229breach of the rules of the building trade: anyone who, in directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally breaches the rules of the trade and knowingly endangers the life or limb of persons is liable to a custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty; if through negligence, up to three years or a monetary penalty.

In the same section