Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 232Schematics, sizing and circuit protectionChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Surge protector: when it is needed, where it goes and what it does not protect

Installing a surge protector guarantees nothing if upstream-downstream coordination and connection rules are neglected. This chapter details the selection of surge protective devices under the NIBT, their methodical placement in the electrical cabinet and absolute control of wiring lengths. You will know how to avoid the pitfall of the cable that is too long, which destroys the surge protector's effectiveness against steep wave fronts.

Key takeaways

  • The NIBT requires the lightning risk to be assessed according to the supply and the presence of an external lightning conductor.
  • Type 1 absorbs the impact energy while Type 2 clips the surge for the connected equipment.
  • The sum of the connection lengths must never exceed the strict limit of fifty centimetres.
  • Beyond ten metres of final circuit line, the wave rebuilds and requires a Type 3 surge protector.

NIBT requirements and methodical coordination of Type 1, 2 and 3 surge protectors

In Switzerland, the NIBT standard prescribes the systematic assessment of the risk of atmospheric transient overvoltage for any new or converted building. Installing a surge protector becomes mandatory where the structure has an external lightning protection system (lightning conductor), where it is supplied by an overhead network in an exposed area, or where an interruption of service affects safety equipment or causes critical operating losses. Without a lightning conductor and with an underground service entry, the analysis is based on the calculated risk level according to the NIBT guidelines. In current practice in French-speaking Switzerland, the electrical installer routinely fits a Type 2 surge protector at the service entry point to protect the equipment against switching surges from the network operator and indirect lightning strikes.

Characteristics and installation hierarchy of low-voltage surge protectors
Technical parameterType 1 (Spark gap / Varistor)Type 2 (Varistor)Type 3 (Fine terminal filter)
Test surge wave10/350 µs (impulse current)8/20 µs (induced current)1.2/50 µs - 8/20 µs (combined wave)
Location in the structureMain service entry / main distribution boardSecondary distribution boardAs close as possible to the sensitive equipment
Protection level (Up)Less than or equal to 2.5 kVLess than or equal to 1.5 kVLess than or equal to 1.0 kV
Main protective roleDischarge of direct currentLimitation of surge voltagesFine protection of electronics

Effective protection of the installation and equipment depends absolutely on a coordinated energy cascade. Installing a Type 2 or 3 device without an upstream energy stage leads to thermal explosion of the varistor during a direct strike. Conversely, installing a Type 1 surge protector alone leaves a residual voltage above 2.5 kV, incompatible with the dielectric strength of common electronic boards, set at 1.5 kV by the NIBT for terminal equipment. Coordination between two stages requires a decoupling impedance, obtained either by a minimum length of 10 to 15 metres of phase conductor between the boards, or by using combined Type 1+2 cartridges certified by the manufacturer to operate without an intermediate inductance.

The 50 centimetre rule and the real limits of cabinet protection

The physics of steep wave fronts tolerates no imprecision in installation. When a standardised 8/20 µs impulse is discharged, the steepness of the current front generates a non-negligible inductive voltage drop across each connecting conductor, according to the equation U = L · (di/dt). A copper conductor in a cabinet has a self-inductance of about 1 µH per metre. For a discharge current of 10 kA, each centimetre of wire generates approximately 10 to 15 V extra. If the total link between the phase, the surge protector, its disconnecting circuit breaker and the earth bar reaches 1 metre instead of 50 centimetres, the voltage applied to the installation increases by more than 600 V, destroying the whole benefit of the protection level Up shown on the cartridge.

  1. Install the module directly at the head of the cabinetFix the surge protector on the first DIN rail immediately next to the main switch or input isolator, without routing through secondary wiring ducts.
  2. Use the V connectionBring the supply conductor directly to the upstream double terminals of the surge protector, then continue to the busbar, so that the branch tap is physically eliminated.
  3. Run the PE link in a straight lineConnect the earth terminal of the surge protector directly to the main equipotential bonding bar of the cabinet with a copper conductor of at least 6 mm² for a Type 2 or 16 mm² for a Type 1.

The electrical installer must clearly identify what the board surge protector does not protect. The device in no way prevents overvoltages induced by electromagnetic coupling in final circuits forming large spatial loops inside the building. Moreover, beyond 10 metres of cable between the protected board and the equipment, an oscillation and wave reflection phenomenon at the open end can double the peak voltage applied across the appliance terminals. Finally, a low-voltage surge protector provides no protection against direct surges passing through the metallic masses of the building or the communication networks if these do not have a compliant equipotential bonding.

Effective protection distance and resonance along final circuits

The action of a surge protector at the main distribution board is not uniform across the whole building. As soon as the supply line leaves the cabinet, the characteristic impedance of the cable changes the propagation of the residual surge wave. At the point of use, the equipment presents an input impedance far higher than the surge impedance of the cable. This impedance mismatch creates a reflected wave that superimposes on the incident wave, causing a sudden local rise in voltage across the appliance terminals.

When the cable run between the cabinet surge protector and the terminal equipment exceeds 10 metres, the oscillation phenomenon can double the peak voltage experienced by the equipment. Even if the Type 2 surge protector maintains an effective protection level Up of 1.5 kV at the board outlet, reflection at the end of the line raises this value to nearly 3 kV. However, for single-phase 230 V equipment in overvoltage category II according to the NIBT, the rated impulse withstand voltage is set at 2.5 kV. Electronic boards and power supply units then suffer irreversible dielectric breakdown. In an extended building, each remote sub-board therefore requires a coordinated Type 2 surge protector, supplemented by a Type 3 as close as possible to the sensitive loads.

Behaviour of the transient overvoltage and devices prescribed according to distance
Link lengthWave phenomenon observedStress on the equipmentNIBT installation measure
Less than 10 mResidual wave damped without measurable reflectionPeak voltage kept below the Up levelProtection by the Type 2 cabinet surge protector
From 10 m to 30 mOnset of oscillation and progressive resonancePeak voltage between 1.5 and 1.8 times UpFitting a Type 2 surge protector in the sub-board
More than 30 mTotal reflection with potential doubling of UpPeak voltage exceeding the 2.5 kV withstandType 3 terminal surge protector in direct proximity

To retain real effectiveness, the connection of the protective conductor to the terminal surge protector must avoid any inductive loop. The electrical installer inserts the Type 3 surge protector directly on the equipment terminals or in the adjacent flush-mounting box. The local equipotential bonding connects the metal casing, the PE protective conductor and the earth terminal of the surge protector with a conductor of appropriate cross-section, no longer than 20 centimetres, in order to eliminate any parasitic inductive overvoltage.

Physical limits, withstand of temporary overvoltages and disconnection

A metal-oxide varistor or gas spark-gap surge protector is sized to discharge brief transient impulse currents, measured in microseconds (10/350 µs waveform for a direct lightning strike or 8/20 µs for network switching and indirect effects). It is totally incapable of dissipating a temporary overvoltage at mains frequency (TOV), lasting from a few tens of milliseconds to several hours. These disturbances often result from a neutral break on the low-voltage network, a faulty source changeover or a transformer fault.

The coordination of the overcurrent protective device placed upstream of the surge protector determines the overall safety of the distribution board. Manufacturers define a maximum rating for the backup fuse (blade fuses or gG cartridges, commonly 63 A to 125 A). Where the upstream main circuit breaker has a rating less than or equal to this value, direct supply of the surge protector is permitted. On the other hand, if the general protection exceeds the prescribed threshold, or if the operator refuses any interruption of the general supply when a module fails in short circuit at end of life, the installer must fit a dedicated circuit breaker or sub-fuses, sized to tolerate the discharge of lightning current without nuisance tripping.

Monitoring of the device forms part of the verification duties set by the ordinance on low-voltage electrical installations (OIBT). Visual checking of the mechanical disconnection indicator (green in normal state, red when the thermal disconnector has tripped) validates the integrity of each pole. During the 500 V DC insulation measurement carried out at final inspection, the electrician must systematically withdraw the cartridges or operate their dedicated isolator. Leaving the varistors inserted diverts direct current to earth, falsifies the insulation measurement and prematurely degrades the components. The inspection and compliance of the device are noted in the safety report.

Handling failures and non-compliances in overvoltage protection

In the field, the failure of a surge protector chain usually shows after a nearby lightning strike or a severe switching surge. If sensitive downstream equipment has been damaged although the cabinet contains a protective device, the electrical installer must immediately audit the physical layout of the board before blaming the component itself.

The first step is to measure the developed geometric length of the connecting conductors between the busbars, the surge protector, its possible upstream decoupling fuse and the main earth bar. If this cumulative distance exceeds fifty centimetres, the inductive voltage drop generated by the steepness of the impulse current explains the ineffectiveness of the device. The terminal equipment has simply taken the residual voltage plus the inductive potential drop of the conductors.

  1. Visual check and disconnectionCheck the mechanical indicators of the cartridges. A red indicator signals a varistor out of service after absorbing thermal energy. If the internal disconnecting device has opened, isolate the module and check the condition of the dedicated upstream overcurrent protective device.
  2. Insulation check of the installationBefore replacing the cartridges, the pluggable modules must be withdrawn to carry out the 500 V insulation measurement, otherwise the value will be falsified or the remaining spark gaps and varistors permanently damaged.
  3. Restoration and re-layoutReplace the cartridges with strictly equivalent references in maximum continuous operating voltage Uc and protection level Up. Reduce the wiring links by a direct V routing or a tap onto the double terminals of the device.

Where the condition of the existing cabinet or the layout of the network operator's equipment makes it impossible to comply with the short-connection rule, or where the environment required a Type 1 coordination that does not exist, the installer reports the situation. Under art. 365 CO, if a circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor informs the client. This technical step formalises the physical limit of the protections in place.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the circuit breaker or fuse dedicated to the surge protector trip without a storm?

This case often reveals end of life of the varistor caused by repeated temporary overvoltages on the network. The component suffers a growing leakage current leading to thermal runaway. If the internal thermal disconnector does not separate the element in time, the upstream fuse blows to break the short circuit to earth. Replace the faulty cartridge immediately.

Can a Type 2 surge protector be installed away from the main board?

Not for the head of the installation. The main Type 2 goes as close as possible to the supply entry point, immediately after the main switch. Placing a surge protector in the middle of the distribution without upstream coordination lets the surge wave into the cabinet, creating inductive couplings on all neighbouring circuits and cancelling the effectiveness of the building's overall protection.

What should be done if the connection length exceeds 50 centimetres in the cabinet?

The connection method must be changed. If a direct run to the PE bar is impossible, use the feed-through or V connection technique: the phase and neutral enter directly on the double terminals of the surge protector before supplying the rest of the board. The tap length thus becomes strictly zero, removing the additional inductive overvoltage.

Does a surge protector protect against a break in the neutral conductor?

Absolutely not. A neutral break generates a temporary overvoltage at mains frequency reaching 400 V on single-phase loads. A standard surge protector is sized to discharge brief transient impulses of a few microseconds. Subjected to 400 V continuously, the component goes into permanent conduction, heats up violently and destroys itself if its thermal disconnector does not isolate it instantly.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365materials and land: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the materials he supplies; if the materials supplied by the client or the land designated by him are found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).

In the same section