Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 232Schematics, sizing and circuit protectionChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Selectivity: making the right protective device trip, not the one upstream

By the end of this chapter, you will be able to size and verify the total or partial selectivity of a low-voltage electrical installation. You will be able to apply the rating ratios required between distribution levels, coordinate thermal-magnetic curves according to manufacturers' data and arrange residual current devices so that a fault at a final circuit does not trip the whole building.

Key takeaways

  • Rigorous grading of ratings prevents nuisance tripping of the overcurrent protective device located upstream.
  • Current-based and time-based selectivity ensure that only the final circuit trips in the event of a short circuit.
  • The manufacturer's selectivity table certifies the actual dynamic withstand beyond theoretical calculations.
  • Residual current selectivity requires a sensitivity ratio of at least three and a selective time delay.

Coordinating ratings and tripping curves to contain the fault

When a short circuit occurs at a socket outlet in a dwelling, only the final distribution protective device must open the circuit. If the service connection circuit breaker or the main upstream overcurrent protective device trips at the same time as, or before, the local device, the installation has a grading fault. This malfunction deprives the whole building of power, compromising the safety of occupants and the continuity of operation of common services. The NIBT requires that the operating characteristics of the disconnecting devices be coordinated so that only the device protecting the faulty part interrupts the supply.

Total selectivity
Situation in which, for any fault current value up to the ultimate breaking capacity of the downstream device, only the device located immediately upstream of the fault opens, keeping the rest of the distribution live.

For slow overloads, thermal selectivity relies on the difference between nominal ratings. With gG-type fuses in cascade, the rule of thumb proven in Switzerland requires a rating ratio of at least 1.6 between upstream and downstream. Thus, a 63 A main fuse effectively protects a circuit protected by a fuse of 40 A or less. When a line circuit breaker is combined upstream with a distribution circuit breaker downstream, the overlap of the inverse-time tripping curves determines the thermal selectivity limit.

Usual grading ratios for overcurrent protective devices in low voltage
Upstream deviceDownstream deviceMinimum recommended ratioBehaviour under high short-circuit current
gG fusegG fuseRating ratio 1:1.6Total selectivity guaranteed by the Joule integrals
Circuit breaker, curve CCircuit breaker, curve BRating ratio 1:2 to 1:2.5Partial selectivity limited to the upstream magnetic threshold
gG fuseCircuit breaker, curve B or CgG fuse 2 standard sizes higherExcellent limitation, subject to I²t verification
Adjustable circuit breakerModular circuit breakerZone time delay requiredDepends on the setting of the upstream instantaneous release

In a bolted short circuit, the instantaneous current frequently exceeds the magnetic threshold of the upstream device. Current-based selectivity becomes insufficient as soon as the prospective current passes through both magnetic releases at the same time. To overcome this limit, the project manager and the installer must consult the selectivity table of the switchgear manufacturer. These reference documents give the selectivity limit value in kiloamperes, established by physical laboratory tests in accordance with the corresponding product standards.

Ensuring residual current selectivity by grading sensitivities and time

The widespread use of residual current devices (RCDs) to protect persons against indirect and direct contact requires the same rigour for residual current selectivity. An earth leakage current caused by the start-up of a heating element or by a crushed appliance cable must never trip the main RCD of the floor board or of the main service entrance. Residual current selectivity cannot be improvised: it requires the strict combination of two cumulative criteria, one current-based and the other time-based.

  1. Ratio of rated fault currentsThe rated residual current IΔn of the upstream device must be equal to or greater than three times that of the downstream device. For a final circuit protected at 30 mA, the upstream RCD must have a minimum sensitivity of 100 mA, with 300 mA being the usual standard in buildings.
  2. Time offset of the opening thresholdsThe upstream device must be of the time-delayed or selective type, identified by the symbol S. The non-response time of the upstream RCD must remain strictly longer than the total breaking time, arc included, of the downstream residual current circuit breaker.
  3. Checking permanent leakage currentsUse a leakage clamp meter to measure the residual capacitive currents of the installation, so that a permanent load upstream does not artificially lower the effective tripping threshold of the main device.

A 300 mA instantaneous RCD placed upstream of a 30 mA instantaneous combined residual current circuit breaker provides no selectivity on a bolted earth insulation fault. In a bolted phase-to-earth fault above 500 mA, both mechanisms trip without any time offset, causing both devices to open indiscriminately. Using a type S RCD upstream guarantees a minimum non-tripping time of 130 milliseconds at its rated current, giving the downstream 30 mA module the time needed to extinguish the arc in less than 40 milliseconds.

Grading of protective devices: from the main overcurrent protective device to the final circuits

In a multi-occupancy residential or office building, nuisance tripping of the upstream disconnecting device following a bolted fault on a lighting or socket circuit is a major technical design defect. In the event of a short circuit in a bedroom or kitchen, the energy released must be cleared by the protective device located immediately upstream of the load, without triggering the apartment board circuit breaker, the circuit breaker of the main distribution board (MDB), and even less the fuses of the building's service entrance enclosure.

To ensure total selectivity in the overload zone (thermal tripping), compliance with a geometric rating ratio between levels is the first requirement. With industrial high-rupturing-capacity (HRC) blade fuses or Diazed-type cartridges installed in cascade, a rated current ratio of at least 1.6 between upstream and downstream prevents pre-arcing of the upstream cartridge. However, as soon as the protection involves modular line circuit breakers (MCB) or moulded-case circuit breakers (MCCB), this simple arithmetic rule becomes void in the face of high instantaneous short-circuit currents.

  1. Level 1: General service entrance enclosureInstallation of NH-size HRC fuses in accordance with the directives of the distribution network operator (DNO). These devices provide robust delayed breaking and absorb the short-circuit energy without failing under the normal inrush currents of the building.
  2. Level 2: Main distribution board (MDB) and risersInstallation of outgoing circuits protected by fuse-type overcurrent protective devices or by moulded-case circuit breakers fitted with electronic time-delayed releases (intentional short-time delay, time-based selectivity of 50 to 100 ms).
  3. Level 3: Dwelling distribution boards (DB)Supply via an isolating switch or main circuit breaker rated so as not to interfere with the thermal and magnetic tolerance band of the 10 A, 13 A or 16 A distribution circuit breakers feeding the final circuits.

Manufacturers' selectivity tables and residual current coordination

To rigorously validate selectivity between two line circuit breakers in the high-current range, empirical calculation is prohibited by the NIBT. The installation electrician must refer to the selectivity table of the manufacturer of the installed equipment. These tables, established after destructive tests in a high-power laboratory, define for each combination of devices the selectivity limit expressed in kiloamperes (kA) or confirm total selectivity (symbol T) up to the rated breaking capacity (Icu).

Example of a selectivity matrix between an upstream distribution circuit breaker and downstream distribution circuit breakers
Upstream device (MDB / riser)Upstream ratingDownstream device (bedroom circuit)Downstream ratingSelectivity limit (Is)
Electronic moulded-case circuit breaker (MCCB)160 A (100 ms delay)Modular circuit breaker, curve B13 A / 10 kAT (Total up to 10 kA)
Thermal-magnetic moulded-case circuit breaker63 A (instantaneous)Modular circuit breaker, curve C16 A / 6 kA1.8 kA (Partial)
HRC blade fuse (gG)63 AModular circuit breaker, curve B13 A / 10 kAT (Total up to 10 kA)
Modular circuit breaker, curve C32 A / 10 kAModular circuit breaker, curve B10 A / 6 kA0.6 kA (Partial)

Coordination of residual current selectivity follows a combined logic of current sensitivity and time delay. A phase-to-earth insulation fault on a household appliance must never trip the residual current device (RCD) placed upstream of the metering group or on the supply of the riser. The NIBT requires flawless discrimination to guarantee that voltage is maintained for essential services and neighbouring apartments.

During the final checks preceding the safety report (RSi), the installation electrician verifies the value of the prospective short-circuit current at the point closest to the distribution board. If this measured value exceeds the limit Is given in the manufacturer's selectivity table for the chosen pair of devices, the installation has a non-conformity regarding continuity of service: the rating or the technology of the upstream device must be revised before final commissioning.

Diagnosis and correction of a non-selective cascade after an incident

When a bolted short circuit at a bedroom socket causes the main switch to open or blows the upstream riser fuses, the installation shows a loss of selectivity. This operating defect paralyses all occupants for a localised incident. In renovation or during major troubleshooting, the installation electrician cannot simply reset the tripped device without analysing the breaking chain.

  1. Survey of the devices in cascadeNote the nominal ratings, the rated breaking capacities ($I_{cn}$) and the tripping curves (B, C or D) of each level, from the main overcurrent protective device to the final distribution circuit breaker.
  2. Checking against the manufacturer's selectivity tableAlways consult the selectivity table of the switchgear manufacturer. Two circuit breakers with graded ratings guarantee only partial selectivity if the prospective short-circuit current at the fault point exceeds the rated selectivity limit ($I_s$).
  3. Correcting the rating ratios between levelsRestore a sufficient rating ratio. For gG HRC fuses, observe the classic ratio of at least 1:1.6 between successive levels to guarantee full energy selectivity.
  4. Bringing residual current protection into complianceReplace any instantaneous RCD placed upstream of final circuits already protected at 30 mA with a delayed selective RCD (type S), with a minimum sensitivity of 300 mA.

If the distributor or the client's representative requires unsuitable existing protective devices to be retained, art. 365 CO requires the contractor to report immediately, in writing, these anomalies that compromise operational safety. The work ends with a tripping test using an installation tester and the mandatory update of the board diagrams required by the NIBT.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a bolted short circuit in a bedroom make the upstream device trip?

In a bolted short circuit close to the board, the inrush current reaches several kiloamperes, instantly acting on the magnetic releases of both circuit breakers. If the breaking energy of the downstream device does not clear the arc before the tripping threshold of the upstream circuit breaker is reached, both open simultaneously. Selectivity was only partial.

How can strict residual current selectivity be ensured between two levels?

Two cumulative criteria are mandatory: grading of sensitivities and time delay. The upstream RCD must have a sensitivity at least three times higher than that of the downstream RCD (for example 300 mA upstream for 30 mA downstream) and must be of the selective type (marked S), providing a minimum time delay of about 40 milliseconds.

Can different brands be mixed to design a selective cascade?

This is technically prohibited for short-circuit selectivity. Selectivity and back-up (cascading) tables are established by manufacturers' tests in accordance with switchgear standards. When brands are mixed, no table guarantees the selectivity limit; the installer then has only overload selectivity, exposing the installation to upstream tripping.

What rating ratio should be applied between gG fuse cartridges?

To guarantee total selectivity between two gG-type fuse overcurrent protective devices in series, the proven rule of thumb requires a nominal ratio of 1 to 1.6 between the downstream rating and the upstream rating (for example a 63 A upstream fuse for a 40 A downstream fuse).

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365material and site: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must immediately inform the client, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).

In the same section