Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 232Installation: conduits, distribution boards and switchgearChapter 4 of 10 in the section

Tightening connections: prescribed torque, re-tightening and the resulting heating

This chapter details the methods for tightening electrical connections in cabinets and distribution boards. You will learn to apply the prescribed torques using calibrated torque tools, to manage conductor creep through systematic re-tightening after commissioning, and to verify the thermal compliance of joints by infrared thermography.

Key takeaways

  • An under-tightened or over-tightened connection is the main cause of electrical fires in buildings.
  • The torque screwdriver guarantees the exact contact pressure defined by the switchgear manufacturer.
  • Re-tightening compensates for the mechanical settling and creep of copper under nominal load.
  • Thermal camera inspection makes it possible to detect abnormal contact resistances under load immediately.

Apply the prescribed torque with a torque screwdriver to eliminate fire risks

In secondary and main distribution boards, the failure of a screwed connection is the predominant origin of incidents caused by electric arcs or slow heating. An insufficiently tightened screw creates a reduced contact surface between the terminal clamp and the conductor core. This reduction of the conducting cross-section produces a localised contact resistance. According to the Joule effect, the power dissipated as heat increases in proportion to the square of the current flowing. Conversely, over-tightening without a control tool deforms the clamping cage, crushes the copper strands excessively to the point of partial breakage, or strips the screw threads, resulting in an irreversible loss of elastic pressure.

Tightening by feel, carried out with a standard slotted or Phillips screwdriver, can in no case meet the tolerances required by manufacturers of modular or power switchgear. The use of an adjustable, certified torque screwdriver is the only way to ensure the conformity of the work. The target values vary considerably depending on the size of the switching device, the conductor material and the drive profile, whether slotted, Pozidriv or combined Pozidriv-slot screws (a profile often referred to as PlusMinus or SL/PZ).

Orders of magnitude of prescribed torques according to the switchgear and the connected cross-section
Type of switchgearConnection cross-sectionIndicative tightening torqueScrewdriver profile required
Control terminals / relays0.5 mm² to 1.5 mm²0.5 to 0.8 NmFine slot or Pozidriv 1
Modular circuit breaker 10 A to 20 A1.5 mm² to 4 mm²1.8 to 2.5 NmCombined SL/PZ 1 or 2
Circuit breaker / switch 32 A to 63 A6 mm² to 16 mm²2.8 to 3.5 NmCombined SL/PZ 2 or hexagon
Main switch 100 A to 160 A25 mm² to 70 mm²5.0 to 9.0 NmHexagon torque wrench

Handling the tool requires controlled movements. The operator seats the bit fully at the bottom of the drive recess to avoid any slipping that could damage the steel of the screw or the adjacent plastic insulation. The torque must be applied smoothly, without jerking, until the torque mechanism releases cleanly (mechanical clutch release or audible signal). Effort must stop at the click: continuing beyond this point introduces an uncontrolled parasitic torque.

Organising re-tightening after loading and verifying the thermal performance of the installation

The initial making of the connection does not guarantee the definitive stability of the connection over time. Under the combined action of the mechanical pressure exerted by the terminal and the thermal cycles alternating load and rest, copper undergoes plastic settling and creep. This molecular rearrangement reduces the effective clamping force. In new or heavily modified installations, re-tightening after loading is essential to neutralise this structural loosening.

  1. Running-in period under loadLet the board operate under a significant real load (ideally at least 40 to 50 % of the nominal current of the main feeders) for 24 to 72 hours, allowing the materials to go through their first thermal expansions.
  2. Isolation and mechanical re-tighteningAfter safely de-energising the distribution, re-apply the torque screwdriver set to the original prescribed torque on each power terminal, busbar connection and final outgoing feeder. Any angular movement of the screw confirms the actual settling of the cable.
  3. Visual quality-assurance markingApply an indelible witness line of varnish or a coloured seal linking the screw head to the body of the device to document the check and to detect visually any later loosening.

Once the cabinet has been re-energised and loaded, thermographic inspection by infrared is the non-destructive validation method par excellence. Carried out with a calibrated thermal camera, this direct visual inspection of the bare conductors and terminals identifies thermal anomalies invisible to the naked eye. Measurements must be taken with the front covers removed, in strict compliance with the safety measures against electric arcs and accidental direct contact.

Critical differential temperature rise (ΔT)
Difference in temperature measured between a suspect connection and an adjacent connection of the same phase carrying a comparable current. A temperature difference above 5 kelvins (K) requires close monitoring, while exceeding 15 K requires immediate shutdown and complete rework of the termination.

During the infrared scan, the installer records in the technical report the ambient temperature of the cabinet, the actual current measured with a clamp meter at the time of capture, and the emissivity used (generally 0.95 for PVC insulation and oxidised copper). This thermal inspection protocol provides essential traceability for the as-built file and guarantees the long-term integrity of the electrical distribution board in accordance with the safety requirements in force.

Infrared thermography inspection protocol for connections under load

Localised heating at the terminals of a switchgear assembly comes directly from the contact resistance caused by deficient tightening or by mechanical creep of the copper. While the torque screwdriver guarantees initial compliance with the torque prescribed by the manufacturer, infrared thermography inspection is the reference non-destructive method for validating the thermal behaviour of joints in real operation.

A thermographic campaign delivers usable results only if the installation is operating under stabilised conditions. Taking a measurement on a board with no load or a negligible load systematically masks developing hot spots, because heat dissipation by the Joule effect remains proportional to the square of the current. The front covers and protective casings must be removed in strict compliance with the safety measures for work in the vicinity of bare live parts, in order to eliminate any absorbing or reflecting barrier that would distort the optical measurement of the camera.

Evaluation grid for temperature differences on electrical terminals and connections
Relative temperature difference (ΔT)Presumed diagnosisRisk levelCorrective measure required
1 K to 10 KDeveloping fault or slight load imbalanceLowMonitoring at the next periodic inspection
11 K to 30 KProven contact resistance, insufficient torque or creepMediumRe-tightening with a torque screwdriver within 15 days
31 K to 50 KSevere degradation of the connection point, onset of carbonisationCriticalIntervention within 24 to 48 hours with replacement of the conductor termination
> 50 KImminent failure of the connection, major thermal arcingFire hazardEmergency trip-out, replacement of the terminal and the cable

Thermal interpretation requires systematically comparing the three phases of the same three-pole feeder supplying a balanced load. A temperature difference recorded between two phases carrying the same current unambiguously reveals a mechanical or metallurgical anomaly at the contact point, regardless of the ambient temperature of the cabinet.

Organising re-tightening, locking seals and the intervention report

The durability of a connection depends on the mechanical stabilisation of the assembly. After the first thermal cycles of expansion and contraction following commissioning, methodical re-tightening is required on power terminal blocks, circuit breaker terminals and floor distribution blocks. This operation does not consist of blindly tightening the screws, but of rigorously re-applying the prescribed nominal torque using calibrated tools, failing which the copper strands will be crushed and the cross-section may break.

  1. Isolation and securing of the boardDisconnect the installation from the voltage sources, lock the switching devices against re-closing and verify the actual absence of voltage on all connection terminals in accordance with the five safety rules.
  2. Torque check and mechanical readjustmentEngage the torque screwdriver fitted with the appropriate drive profile (Pozidriv, slot or combined Plus/Minus) and check the torque without jerking. If the screw turns before the mechanism releases, thermal loosening is confirmed.
  3. Marking and visual sealingApply an indelible witness line of varnish straddling the screw head and the device housing. This visual mark makes it possible to identify immediately, during later inspections, any tampering or accidental unscrewing.
  4. Drawing up the self-inspection recordRecord each torque value applied, the reference of the tool used and the date of the check on the internal inspection sheet attached to the cabinet diagram.

Systematically including the tightening record and the thermograms in the technical file of the work gives the installer formal proof of compliance. When the safety report (RS) is handed over after the acceptance measurements, this documentary follow-up protects both the client against latent incidents and the executing company against warranty claims.

Emergency intervention protocol for overheating, tightening damage and responsibilities

The detection of a loose connection, abnormal overheating during thermographic inspection or a damaged terminal cage constitutes a technical emergency on the construction site. A poorly tightened terminal causes a localised contact resistance that releases destructive heat energy, the leading cause of fires starting in distribution boards. Faced with this proven malfunction, the electrical installer cannot limit themselves to one extra turn of the screw: the securing and rework procedure must follow a methodical approach to restore conformity.

  1. Isolation and securing of the boardSwitch off the supply upstream, lock the switching device against any inadvertent re-closing and verify the absence of voltage according to the five safety rules recognised by the NIBT. Put up barriers if neighbouring live parts remain energised.
  2. Damage diagnosis and cutting back the copperAssess the extent of the damage to the conductor and the terminal. Copper that is blued, charred or has undergone mechanical creep has lost its conductivity and its rigidity. Cut off the damaged end until a bright, non-oxidised core is reached, strip to the exact length and crimp a new ferrule for flexible conductor.
  3. Replacement of switchgear without exceptionNever attempt to repair a damaged thread, nor to keep in service a fuse or a circuit breaker whose thermoplastic housing has yellowed or been heated. Remove the damaged device and install a new component of strictly equivalent type.
  4. Torque tightening and locking sealMake the connection with a calibrated torque screwdriver, rigorously applying the torque defined by the manufacturer. Apply an indelible locking line of varnish between the screw head and the housing, then schedule a thermal camera check under full nominal load.

Each correction is the subject of a technical intervention report added to the final file of the installation. The electrician records in it the circuit reference, the exact torque applied in newton-metres, the reference of the replaced equipment and the thermograms before and after the work. This rigorous traceability guarantees compliance during the final verification before the handover of the safety report required by the OIBT.

Frequently asked questions

What should be done if the thread of a terminal strips during tightening with a torque screwdriver?

When the thread of a circuit breaker or terminal block gives way before the prescribed torque is reached, the device is irreversibly unusable. It is strictly forbidden to insert a larger screw or to wedge the cage. The complete switchgear must be replaced immediately. The installer isolates the circuit, removes the damaged component and fits a new device, applying the manufacturer's torque. The conductor must also be inspected to check that it has not been sheared.

Why is it not enough simply to re-tighten a connection that has been significantly overheated?

Excessive heating alters the molecular structure of the copper, causing annealing that makes it lose its mechanical elasticity. The metal oxidises at the surface, drastically increasing the contact resistance. Simply re-tightening oxidised or crept copper will reproduce the hot spot shortly afterwards. It is mandatory to isolate the installation, cut off the browned section of cable, strip a sound section, fit a new wiring ferrule and replace the thermally damaged switchgear.

From what temperature difference does a hot spot detected with the infrared camera become critical?

According to maintenance practice on electrical boards in Switzerland, a temperature delta of 5 to 15 K compared with adjacent phases under identical load is an anomaly to be scheduled for re-tightening. Beyond 30 K of temperature rise, or when the absolute temperature exceeds the withstand limit of the insulation (often 70 °C for ordinary PVC), the situation requires immediate shutdown, isolation and complete rework of the connection concerned.

What calibration interval is required for torque tools used in the workshop and on the construction site?

A torque screwdriver or wrench must be checked and recalibrated periodically, in principle every twelve months or after 5,000 releases, in accordance with the recommendations of precision-tool manufacturers. Any tool that has been dropped from head height or has suffered a violent impact on the construction site must be withdrawn from service immediately and checked on a calibration bench. The calibration certificate must be recorded in the quality file of the electrical installation company.

Texts and standards cited

  • CPviolation of the rules of the art of construction: any person who, while directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally infringes the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons is liable to a custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty; if through negligence, up to three years or a monetary penalty.

In the same section