Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 215Steel: grades, sections and execution classesChapter 2 of 10 in the section

Execution class EXC2 or EXC3: requirements for workshop and testing

This chapter details the practical differences between classes EXC2 and EXC3 for structural steelwork in Switzerland. You will learn how to identify constraints on your welders right from the call for tenders stage, schedule the intervention of a certified external inspector and secure the documentary traceability of steels without disrupting the workshop manufacturing workflow.

Key takeaways

  • Class EXC3 imposes systematic operator qualifications and welding procedure specifications.
  • Switching to EXC3 multiplies volumetric non-destructive testing on structural nodes.
  • Documentary traceability in EXC3 requires a 3.1 certificate linked directly to each cut component.
  • Anticipating the execution class prevents testing cost overruns and critical delays during erection.

Workshop and assembly: what switching to EXC3 changes for the fabrication team

In Swiss tenders for structural steelwork or load-bearing composite facades, the specifications set the execution class in accordance with standard SN EN 1090. The standard class for administrative or industrial buildings remains EXC2. As soon as the civil engineer specifies class EXC3—generally for structures subject to fatigue, overhead cranes, nodes under dynamic loading or heavily loaded buildings open to the public—the workshop organisation changes scale.

Comparison of workshop requirements according to standard SN EN 1090
Workshop criterionExecution class EXC2Execution class EXC3
Welding coordinationBasic or specific technical knowledge depending on steel gradesComprehensive technical knowledge required for the coordinator
Welder qualificationValid certificates according to welder qualification standardsSystematic certificates with range of approval covering the joint
Welding procedure specification (WPS)Mandatory for common processes, simplified validationMandatory with qualification by prior procedure test (WPQR)
Thermal cutting and edgesStandard dimensional and geometrical tolerancesStrict inspection of surface hardening and grinding of cut edges

Regarding the required welder qualification, EXC2 allows qualified personnel to be assigned to typical joints without necessarily requiring a welding procedure qualification test for every geometrical variation. In EXC3, every butt or fillet weld on a primary structural member must rely on a rigorously qualified procedure. If your workshop assembles heavy rolled sections or welded plate girders, the welder cannot work without their personal certificate specifically covering the steel grade, the welding position (for instance vertical-up PF or overhead PE) and the joint bevel type.

Managing workshop workflows also requires attention to the preparation of cut parts. In EXC3, notching, plasma cutting or flame cutting operations require systematic grinding of thermally cut faces to remove the heat-affected zone and bring the steel hardness below the thresholds tolerated by standard SN EN 1090. Sharp edges intended to receive corrosion protection must imperatively have a minimum corner radius of two millimetres.

Non-destructive testing and documentary management: the rigour required on the construction site

The extent of non-destructive testing constitutes the most visible financial and operational difference between the two classes. In class EXC2, 100% visual inspection is the baseline rule, supplemented by a sampling rate of complementary testing (magnetic particle, penetrant, ultrasonic testing) often limited to a few percent on fillet or butt welds. In EXC3, the extent of non-destructive testing increases considerably and systematically applies to full-penetration joints as well as structural continuity splices.

  1. Systematic visual testing (VT)Performed on all weld runs by the welder and signed off by the welding coordinator before any other examination.
  2. Surface testing (MT or PT)Application of magnetic particle or penetrant testing to a high proportion of fillet and butt welds according to the inspection plan.
  3. Volumetric testing (UT)Ultrasonic detection of internal defects on full-penetration welds, executed by a certified Level 2 independent inspector.
  4. Documentary archivingInclusion of inspection records in the technical project file with formal approval from the engineer.

Documentary traceability in EXC3 allows no break in the chain. In EXC2, batch traceability is sufficient most of the time, supported by a 2.2 or 3.1 inspection certificate depending on the steel grade. In EXC3, the standard requires full traceability of each individual component: each cut section piece, each gusset or node plate must bear its original marking transferred by mechanical engraving, traceable transfer or indelible labelling, linked directly to the specific 3.1 mill test certificate of the heat.

When delivering bundles to the Swiss construction site, the contractor submits the complete execution file including the declaration of performance, material certificates, procedure qualifications and all NDT reports. Article 365 CO points out that if the material supplied by the client or any circumstance compromises the proper execution of the works, the contractor must immediately inform the client. A delay in qualifying a welding procedure or the late discovery of an EXC3 requirement blocks acceptances and brings the erection of the steel frame to a standstill.

Welding coordination and workshop skills: the operational dividing line

The shift between execution class EXC2 and class EXC3 according to SN EN 1090 fundamentally alters the technical and supervisory chain within the steel fabrication workshop. In EXC2, which covers the majority of standard steel structures for industrial sheds or commercial buildings, the requirements regarding welding coordination remain proportionate. A coordinator possessing basic or specific technical knowledge is generally sufficient to approve welding procedure specifications and monitor routine production.

As soon as the civil engineer specifies EXC3—a frequent scenario for structures subject to fatigue, road bridges, footbridges under high dynamic loads, or primary load-bearing members made of thick welded plate girders—personnel qualifications permit no compromise. Welding coordination must be undertaken by a specialist holding comprehensive technical knowledge, certified by a recognised International Welding Engineer or Welding Technologist diploma. This coordinator must demonstrate formal authority over the workshop to qualify welding procedures and authorise assembly operations.

Comparative workshop and competence requirements according to execution class
SN EN 1090 criterionExecution class EXC2Execution class EXC3
Welding coordinationBasic or specific technical knowledge depending on steel gradesComprehensive technical knowledge required for the majority of structural steels
Welder qualificationUp-to-date certificates for each process, position and material groupMandatory certificates with strict six-month validity monitoring and regular testing
Welding specifications (WPS)WPS prepared on the basis of standard or test-qualified welding proceduresWPS strictly qualified by complete welding procedure qualification (WPQR)
Tacking and fit-upTack welds performed by qualified welders with the same filler metal requirementsTack welds strictly governed by dedicated WPS; systematic removal or controlled grinding

For workshop fitters and welders, the required welder qualification remains legally modelled on the same practical testing standards. However, the scope covered by each individual certificate must be rigorously aligned with the actual joints specified in the order. In EXC3, using fine-grain steels or heavy thicknesses necessitates qualifications for operators welding with preheat monitored by contact pyrometer or temperature-indicating crayons, with zero deviation tolerated on interpass temperature.

Scope of testing, traceability chain and financial repercussion

The direct budgetary impact of switching from EXC2 to EXC3 is concentrated on the extent of non-destructive testing and the administrative management of steels. Whereas in EXC2 100% visual inspection is supplemented by surface or volumetric non-destructive testing targeted at reduced percentages (often 5% to 10% of stressed butt joints), class EXC3 mandates extensive non-destructive testing coverage, frequently reaching 20% to 100% depending on joint type, consequence class and stress level defined by the engineer.

These ultrasonic, magnetic particle or liquid penetrant examinations must be performed by certified Level 2 inspectors in accordance with the qualification standard for non-destructive testing personnel, generally commissioned from independent third-party bodies. Quarantining parts in workshop assembly areas to allow inspectors to intervene, waiting for components to cool down and awaiting inspection records slows down the fabrication flow and ties up workshop floor space.

Documentary traceability is the second decisive factor. In class EXC2, traceability of rolled products by production batch remains the generally accepted standard, supported by 3.1 mill inspection certificates. In class EXC3, traceability must be individual for each major structural component. Every beam section, node plate or welded gusset must retain its physical identification, hard-stamped or engraved, linked to the exact cast heat number recorded in the project file.

The contractor entering into a works contract assesses, prior to entering into the contract, the measures necessary to ensure occupational safety and health protection, as provided for in art. 3 OTConst. In handling heavy sections and manipulating complex elements under continuous non-destructive testing, this planning duty governs the safe layout of welding stations, temporary storage areas and lifting equipment tailored to inspection rhythms.

Managing execution non-conformities and contractual arbitration

On a construction site involving structural steelwork or a composite facade framework, reclassifying a structure late from execution class EXC2 to execution class EXC3 disrupts the production line. If the initial technical description or the civil engineer's drawings impose EXC3 requirements retrospectively after the bid was calculated based on EXC2 standards, the workshop faces an immediate impasse. Welder qualifications, welding procedure specifications and the non-destructive testing plan no longer meet acceptance criteria.

The contractor must then apply the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO). Art. 365 CO provides that if any circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the works, the contractor must inform the client. As soon as a discrepancy is identified between the class prescribed in the contract and the requirements demanded during fabrication supervision, a written notice must be sent to the site management before starting any cutting or assembly of structural steel sections.

  • Halt fabrication of the disputed components to prevent destructive rework in the workshop.
  • Audit available material certificates to verify compliance with the required documentary traceability.
  • Check the validity of welder qualification certificates for the actual project positions and thicknesses.
  • Request a formal addendum covering the additional cost of supplementary non-destructive testing and the involvement of the welding coordinator.

When internal defects are detected during penetrant or ultrasonic testing, the workshop manager logs the flaw in a non-conformance report. Air-arc gouging or grinding of the defective weld must be followed by a revised procedure validated by the welding coordinator, followed by re-testing via NDT recorded in the final inspection report.

Frequently asked questions

Can welders qualified for EXC2 be used to fabricate an EXC3 classified component?

No. Standard SN EN 1090 mandates that welders must be qualified for the processes, material groups and joint positions according to applicable standards. In EXC3, personnel qualification requirements and supervision by a welding coordinator holding comprehensive technical knowledge are strictly mandatory. An expired certificate or one not suited to the joint leads to immediate rejection of the parts during workshop documentation verification.

What is the practical difference in non-destructive testing extent between EXC2 and EXC3?

In class EXC2, non-destructive testing includes 100% visual inspection and a limited sampling of volumetric or surface testing on butt welds. In EXC3, the inspection plan enforces a significantly greater extent: magnetic particle, penetrant or ultrasonic testing systematically covers a high proportion of primary welds, increasing the time required from a certified external inspector.

How should steel traceability be verified for cut sections in EXC3?

Documentary traceability in EXC3 requires individual tracking from the steel mill's 3.1 inspection certificate down to the final erected member. Each cut section piece must receive indelible marking transferring the heat number and the cut mark. Any hard stamping or marking must appear on the fabrication drawing and in the workshop register, whereas in EXC2 batch traceability is generally sufficient.

What is the expected financial impact when moving contractually from EXC2 to EXC3?

The cost increase stems from procedure requalification, time spent on supervision by the welding coordinator, increased engagement of non-destructive testing bodies and the administrative processing of certificates. This additional cost is typically around 10% to 25% on the fabrication portion of structural steel frames. For detailed pricing and bill of quantities itemisations, refer to the tenders section.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied; if materials supplied by the client or ground designated by the client are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the works, the contractor must immediately notify the client, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3)
  • SN EN 1090Execution of steel structures and aluminium structures - Technical requirements for steel structures

In the same section