Key takeaways
- Standard rolled sections reach their geometric and economic limits as soon as the span exceeds fifteen metres.
- Plate girders allow moment of inertia to be optimised by varying flange and web thicknesses.
- Fabricating a plate girder entails longer lead times for plate rolling and workshop assembly.
- Resorting to heavy-thickness welding triggers a stringent non-destructive testing plan in the workshop.
Identify the limits of rolled sections and switch to plate girders
In the daily practice of industrial halls and administrative buildings in French-speaking Switzerland, hot-rolled sections (HEA, HEB, HEM, or IPE series) are the initial design choice. This standard component offers an obvious economic advantage: it comes straight out of the European rolling mill, features consistent standardised mechanical properties, and arrives on the drilling bench without heavy workshop welding operations.
When clear spans exceed the threshold of 15 to 18 metres, or when massive point loads are transferred from upper-floor columns, deflection and bending moment constraints dictate the cross-sections. The civil engineer then runs up against the physical limits of industrial catalogues. An HEB 1000 or HEM 1000 section represents considerable mass per unit length for a moment of inertia that is no longer distributed optimally along the span.
- Plate girder (PRS)
- Load-bearing steel element formed by welding cut heavy plates (flanges and web), custom-sized to resist mechanical forces without superfluous material.
Switching to a plate girder becomes essential as soon as the required moment of inertia exceeds the capacity of commercial sections, or when headroom limits demand an asymmetrical or tapered cross-section (haunched profile). Standard SIA 263 governs the design of these elements, notably incorporating the risk of web buckling when its slenderness becomes high, which requires adding welded transverse or longitudinal stiffeners.
| Criterion | Standard rolled section | Plate girder (PRS) |
|---|---|---|
| Typical spans | Up to 15 - 18 m | Over 18 m or heavy loads |
| Section depth | Fixed, limited to 1000-1100 mm | Unconstrained, typically 800 to 2500 mm |
| Material distribution | Uniform, dictated by catalogue | Optimised (varying thicknesses) |
| Workshop labour | Low (cutting, drilling, end fittings) | Very high (flame cutting, bevelling, welding) |
| Non-destructive testing | Limited to end connections | Systematic on continuous welds |
Manage lead times and increased quality controls
Opting for a plate girder profoundly alters the supply chain and the critical path of the erection schedule. While a standard rolled section in S355J2 steel is often available from stock at regional stockists within 2 to 3 weeks, heavy plates intended for plate girder flanges require specific mill orders, especially for thicknesses exceeding 40 or 50 millimetres with through-thickness properties against lamellar tearing (Z25 or Z35 qualities according to standard SIA 263).
- Cutting and bevel preparationFlanges and web are cut by oxy-fuel or plasma cutting, then edges are ground to remove mill scale and heat-affected hard zones before fit-up.
- Tack welding and clampingPositioning on assembly bench or turning rolls with anti-distortion jigs to prevent thermal shrinkage during continuous welding.
- Assembly weldingExecution of longitudinal full-penetration or fillet welds using submerged arc welding or gas-shielded welding with preheating if thickness requires it.
- Thermal or mechanical straighteningStraightening using a press or flame heating to compensate for residual camber and flange warping.
- Non-destructive testing (NDT)Systematic visual inspection, supplemented by dye penetrant, magnetic particle, and ultrasonic testing of welds under tension depending on execution class.
The workshop quality control plan becomes considerably heavier. The welds joining the flanges to the web along the entire length of the beam are subjected to direct shear and tensile stresses. Depending on the execution classes defined during design (typically EXC2 or EXC3 on long-span structures), non-destructive testing is no longer limited to visual inspection. Engaging certified inspectors to carry out magnetic particle testing on fillet welds and ultrasonic testing on full-penetration flange splices is mandatory.
The design and execution of welded built-up elements must take into account residual stresses, risks of local instability from buckling, and any anisotropy of heavy flat products subjected to through-thickness tensile stresses.
norme SIA 263
Workshop design and fabrication: switching to plate girders
As soon as the spans exceed the usual dimensions of commercial rolled sections or load paths require asymmetrical moments of inertia, the workshop must fabricate plate girders (PRS). Unlike rolled sections produced directly from rolling mills with standardised root fillets, a plate girder is assembled from heavy plates cut by oxy-fuel or high-definition plasma cutting. This geometric freedom requires sizing sections in accordance with standard SIA 263, integrating the behaviour of thin-walled elements under local instability phenomena.
| Criterion | Hot-rolled section (IPE, HEA, HEM) | Plate girder (PRS) |
|---|---|---|
| Section depth | Limited by current steel mill catalogues (often ≤ 1000 mm) | Unconstrained, typically 800 mm to over 2500 mm per structural calculation |
| Wall thickness | Web-to-flange ratio imposed by rolling standards | Independent optimisation of web and flange thicknesses |
| Buckling behaviour | Generally stocky walls (Class 1 or 2 according to standard SIA 263) | Slender webs often requiring transverse stiffeners |
| Workshop preparation | Direct sawing, drilling, and notching | Plate cutting, edge preparation, tacking, and continuous welding |
| Material continuity | Monolithic cross-section without assembly weld seams | Heat-affected zones (HAZ) along fillet or butt welds |
Choosing a plate girder also allows a variable moment of inertia along the span: the web can be tapered to match the bending moment diagram precisely, thereby reducing the self-weight of the structure. However, reducing web thickness increases its susceptibility to buckling under shear or compressive stress, which requires systematically placing welded vertical or longitudinal stiffeners at supports and under concentrated loads.
Quality assurance plan, non-destructive testing, and schedule impact
Resorting to plate girders profoundly alters the logistics and documentation chain of the steel construction company. Procuring certified steel plates requires 3.1 material certificates, supplemented where necessary by low-temperature impact tests or resistance to lamellar tearing (Z-quality). Mill lead times increase compared to bars stocked by Swiss stockists.
- Systematic visual inspection (VT) of all weld seams to detect undercut, root grooves, or grooves before any surface treatment.
- Surface testing by dye penetrant (PT) or magnetic particle inspection (MT) on weld start/stop areas and stiffener-to-flange intersections.
- Volumetric testing by ultrasonic testing (UT) on butt welds of tension flanges and full-penetration connections subject to fatigue.
- Comprehensive dimensional check prior to shot blasting: camber, sweep, flange squareness, and neutral axis straightness.
All these requirements must be incorporated into the inspection and test plan (ITP) approved by the structural engineer before material processing. On the construction site, the site supervisor ensures delivery dates are coordinated with mobile cranes, as built-up elements often represent heavy, bulky loads whose direct offloading onto permanent supports avoids critical temporary storage on the ground.
Non-conformities on plate girders and delay management: action procedure
On a structural steel construction site, geometric deviation or an internal defect in a plate girder immediately halts the erection line. Unlike a commercial rolled section that can be replaced from stockist inventories, a defective plate girder requires a structured technical response to avoid shutting down mobile cranes.
- Joint dimensional check: measuring residual camber, web buckling, and flange misalignment against standard SIA 263 tolerances.
- Clearing any doubts through non-destructive testing: magnetic particle or dye penetrant inspection for weld surface cracks, ultrasonics for separations at the web-flange junction.
- Written notification to site management if the contractual deadline is threatened, pursuant to the general mechanism of art. 365 CO al. 3 in the event of disruptive circumstances.
- Drafting a non-conformance report sent to the civil engineer responsible for the structure, accompanied by a design check calculation note if thermal or mechanical remediation is considered.
When the defect stems from plate delamination across the thickness (lamellar tearing under welding stresses), flame straightening is strictly prohibited. The workshop must proceed with air-arc gouging of the defective weld or full replacement of the section using plate with enhanced through-thickness properties. If the member arrives warped on the construction site, mechanical jacking requires prior authorisation from the structural engineer to avoid altering the design residual stresses.
If scrapping the member requires total remake in the fabrication plant, plate procurement lead times and submerged arc welding time will cause a delay of several weeks. The site foreman immediately reorganises the erection sequence to maintain site access for other trades, while the site supervisor formalises the situation pursuant to the rules on default of the debtor specified in art. 102 CO.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if a plate girder arrives with non-compliant negative camber upon delivery?
Measure the actual camber using a laser level or optical surveyor's level at three points. Compare these values to the approved fabrication drawings in accordance with standard SIA 263. If the deviation exceeds fabrication tolerances, halt unloading and alert the civil engineer. Workshop heat straightening may be approved under a written method statement, but forcing the piece on the construction site using splice connections is prohibited.
How should one react if blowholes or cracks appear after on-site welding?
Ban uncontrolled grinding without traceability. Cordon off the area and notify the non-destructive testing technician to map the extent of the defect using dye penetrant or magnetic particle testing. The workshop or erection crew proceeds with mechanical or thermal gouging of the crack down to sound metal. Rewelding must strictly comply with the qualified welding procedure specification, with preheat monitored using a pyrometer.
Can a plate girder web be cut on site to let building services pass through?
No opening is permitted without formal approval from the engineering consultancy. The web of a plate girder is optimised to the thinnest thickness to minimise self-weight, making it susceptible to local buckling. Any unplanned core drilling requires structural calculations checking residual shear and entails adding welded stiffeners around the penetration under strict execution control.
How can a site delay caused by waiting for ultrasonic testing results be justified?
Volumetric non-destructive testing is an integral part of the quality assurance plan defined in the construction contract. To prevent disputes, record the inspection body's working duration and analysis time in the daily construction site report. Promptly issue a written notice to site management detailing the impact on the critical path and the actual erection date.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 263Swiss standard for steel construction: structural design, section stability, and fabrication tolerances.
- CO art. 102Default of the debtor: the debtor is placed in default by reminder of the creditor; where a day has been fixed for performance by agreement or by valid notice, the debtor is in default automatically upon expiry of that day.
- CO art. 365Material and site conditions: if any circumstance arises which threatens the correct or timely performance of the work, the contractor must inform the employer immediately, failing which the contractor shall bear the consequences (al. 3).
