Key takeaways
- The grade defines the minimum nominal yield strength considered in the structural design.
- An S235 section and an S355 section are visually indistinguishable without their original marking.
- Standard SIA 263 sets out calculation rules that strictly prohibit any underestimation of resistance.
- Any change of grade during fabrication requires formal approval from the responsible engineer.
Two geometrically identical sections separated by 120 megapascals
On a structural steel construction site or in the bays of a fabrication workshop, two HEA 200 beams of the same length have strictly the same geometry, the same linear mass, and the same rolled surface finish. Yet one may be made of S235 steel and the other of S355 steel. The letter S designates a structural steel. The number that follows indicates the guaranteed minimum nominal yield strength, denoted fy, measured for small to moderate material thicknesses, expressed in newtons per square millimetre or megapascals.
- Yield strength (fy)
- Maximum stress that a steel can withstand without undergoing permanent plastic deformation. Beyond this threshold, the metal no longer returns to its initial shape once unloaded.
Between S235 steel and S355 steel, the difference in elastic load-bearing capacity exceeds 50%. In the design verifications required by SIA 263 (Steel Structures), the engineer dimensions the cross-sections of columns, main girders, or truss chords to resist bending, shear, and axial compression stresses. Using S235 for a member designed in S355 drastically reduces the safety margin against global buckling, lateral-torsional buckling, or yielding under maximum imposed loads.
| Characteristic | Grade S235 | Grade S355 |
|---|---|---|
| Nominal yield strength fy (t ≤ 16 mm) | 235 N/mm² | 355 N/mm² |
| Nominal tensile strength fu | 360 to 510 N/mm² | 470 to 630 N/mm² |
| Minimum elongation at fracture | 26% | 22% |
| Typical application in industrial halls | Light purlins, sag bars, secondary angles | Load-bearing columns, main portal beams, primary girders |
Marking verification, document concordance, and prohibition of substitution
Since no workshop visual test can distinguish these steels, traceability relies on the physical marking of the steel sections and mill certificates. Upon unloading at the workshop or on the construction site, the receiving team checks the rolling mill label, cold stamping, or indelible inkjet marking applied to the web or the inner face of the flanges. These markings state the mill name, the exact grade with its impact sub-grade (for example JR, J0, or J2), the cast number, and the profile number.
- Inspection upon bar deliveryCompare the physical labelling on the sections with the delivery note and the corresponding mill inspection certificate.
- Traceability transfer during cuttingTransfer the marking by engraving or indelible paint onto each cut length before any grinding or shot blasting.
- Concordance with workshop drawingsCheck the cut mark and the specified grade on the bill of materials before beginning tacking and welding of end plates.
The prohibition against substituting one steel for another without written approval is an absolute structural safety rule. If a section specified in S355 is missing during the cutting phase, the workshop manager or foreman may under no circumstances replace it with an identical-geometry section taken from S235 stock. Such a modification reduces the element's resistance by more than a third and exposes the structure to progressive or sudden failure. A steel fabricator noticing a discrepancy or shortage must report the situation to the appointed engineering consultancy.
Replacing S235 steel with S355 without consultation also creates specific problems. Although stronger in tension and simple bending, S355 steel has a chemical composition higher in carbon equivalent, which hardens the heat-affected zone during welding and may require a preheat temperature or suitable filler metals to prevent cold cracking. Moreover, preloaded high-strength bolted connections or connection plates designed to dissipate energy through controlled deformation risk altering the overall failure mechanism calculated by the engineer. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the material it supplies. Finally, art. 229 CP penalises anyone who violates the recognised rules of the building trade and thereby endangers the life of persons.
Mechanical behaviour and design impacts according to SIA 263
In a roof frame or primary structure, arbitrarily substituting an S355 steel with S235 alters the structural equilibrium defined by the civil engineering consultancy. Although both grades share a similar density and a longitudinal modulus of elasticity of approximately 210,000 MPa, the sizing of rolled sections depends directly on their nominal yield strength. The engineer utilises this capacity to reduce member cross-sections or resist bending and compression stresses without reaching the plastic range under ultimate load.
Under the design rules of SIA 263, cross-sectional resistance and member stability against lateral-torsional buckling or flexural buckling rely on this guaranteed yield strength. Lowering the limit to 235 N/mm² on a beam designed in S355 without thickening the flanges or adjusting the plastic section modulus leads to exceeding allowable stresses as early as commissioning. Conversely, substituting S235 with S355 without recalculation creates other structural risks: the overall stiffness of the member against deflection remains unchanged, while ductile failure or seismic behaviour is altered if the connections were not designed to develop yielding in the stronger section.
| Technical characteristic | Grade S235 | Grade S355 | Direct impact on execution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nominal yield strength (t ≤ 16 mm) | 235 N/mm² | 355 N/mm² | Sizing of cross-sections under bending moment and axial force |
| Ultimate tensile strength Rm | 360 to 510 N/mm² | 470 to 630 N/mm² | Design of ultimate resistance for bolted and welded connections |
| Modulus of elasticity E | ~ 210,000 N/mm² | ~ 210,000 N/mm² | Identical deflections and deformations for the same geometry |
| Weldability and carbon equivalent (CEV) | Very high, low CEV | Demanding, higher CEV | Adaptation of filler metals and thermal control of welds |
| Susceptibility to elastic buckling | Moderate (section often more massive) | High (thinner walls for equal loads) | Requires stiffeners and increased flatness checks |
Workshop management, offcut traceability, and execution responsibility
In the storage area and at cutting stations, the main risk lies in confusing two bare bars of identical geometric cross-section (IPE, HEA, HEM, or hollow sections) whose initial rolling mark was lost during previous cuts. The steel fabrication workshop must enforce a rigorous marking transfer system by cold stamping or standard indelible marker as soon as an offcut is returned to the buffer stock. Any section whose origin cannot be certified by its mill certificate and cast number must be immediately downgraded and kept away from main load-bearing components.
When the engineer exceptionally approves a grade adjustment, they must issue an updated and validated calculation note and amend the workshop execution drawings. This contractual modification directly engages the contractor's obligations: under art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the material supplied. Using a lower grade without written approval exposes the structure to structural failure and the contractor to a complete replacement of the non-compliant member.
- Inspection upon bar receiptVerify concordance between the delivery note, 3.1 mill certificates, and markings stamped or labelled on the sections before any unloading.
- Systematic marking transferTransfer the grade (S235 or S355) and cast number onto each cut length before physical separation from the parent bar.
- Quarantine of doubtful itemsIsolate any offcut or section lacking legible marking in a dedicated quarantine area, prohibiting its use for primary structure.
- Approval of alterationsForward any procurement constraint to the site management and await the civil engineer's written endorsement before cutting an alternative grade.
Grade non-conformity: stop-work procedure and crisis management
Discovering an S235 section installed instead of a specified S355 on a construction site or during fabrication constitutes a critical structural non-conformity. The steel fabricator can neither conceal the substitution nor attempt to justify retaining the component alone. For an identical geometry, the member has a load-bearing capacity deficit of approximately one third, directly endangering user safety.
- Erection shutdown and taggingAs soon as the error is identified via the label, cold stamping, or material certificate, immediately halt assembly work in the affected zone. Mark the component with a red industrial marker and physically quarantine unerected bars to prevent any unintended handling.
- Formal notice to site management and the engineerImmediately send written notice detailing the non-conformity: component mark on the general arrangement drawing, delivered grade, specified grade, and cast number. In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor informs the client of any circumstance compromising the proper execution of the works.
- Verification calculation under SIA 263Only the appointed civil engineer is qualified to recalculate the member under SIA 263. If the section operates at a very low stress ratio or if the serviceability limit state (deflection) strictly governs the design, a formal signed deviation may be granted.
- Approved replacement or strengtheningWithout written authorisation from the engineer, completely remove the non-compliant member. If strengthening with welded plates is approved, apply a strict welding procedure specification, inspected before re-applying loads.
Frequently asked questions
Can S355 be substituted with S235 by increasing member thickness?
No. Even if overall inertia appears to offset the lower yield strength, altering a member's geometric section changes load paths, self-weights, and the behaviour of bolted or welded connections. According to SIA 263, any dimensional or material change requires formal verification by the civil engineering consultancy responsible for the structural steel design.
Is a 3.1 material certificate sufficient if the marking on the beam is erased?
No. A 3.1 mill certificate only guarantees conformity if it is formally linked to the physical product. Without cold-stamped marking, a mill label, or internal cutting traceability demonstrating the cast number, the steel is deemed unidentifiable. The workshop must quarantine the beam and order destructive metallurgical testing or downgrade it to non-structural use.
Does the modulus of elasticity vary between S235 and S355?
No, the longitudinal modulus of elasticity remains identical for both grades, at approximately 210,000 megapascals. If a beam is sized solely to meet an allowable deflection criterion under live loads, S355 will deflect no less than S235 for the same geometric section. However, S355 provides significantly higher plastic resistance and yield strength.
What should be done if a subcontractor delivers S235 instead of the specified S355?
Reject the delivery upon receipt on the construction site by noting the discrepancy on the delivery note and in the site log. Stop the erection of the affected members to prevent irreversible assembly. The contractor immediately notifies the supplier of the failure and refers the matter to the site management to decide on re-fabrication lead times or required expert assessments.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 263Steel structures: design, ultimate and serviceability limit states, choice of structural grades
- CO art. 365Material and ground: obligation of the contractor to notify the client of any circumstance compromising proper execution
- CP art. 229Violation of the recognised rules of the building trade: endangering life or physical integrity while directing or executing construction works
