Key takeaways
- A technical reservation must imperatively specify its grid axis mark, its measurement, and the target component.
- Acceptance of the work according to standard SIA 118 transfers the duty of care risks for the steel frame.
- The agreed remedy period takes into account the full procurement and surface treatment cycle.
- Financial retention guarantees completion and cannot block the entire final account for the package.
Formulating actionable reservations during the acceptance record
During the joint inspection tour of a structural frame or load-bearing metal façade, drafting vagueness is the main source of disputes stalling site closure. A vague annotation such as "rework weld finishes" or "paint touch-ups" arbitrarily shifts the burden of proof to the workshop and prevents any formal clearance. The metalwork contractor must insist that each item is linked to an identifiable part, measured by a reliable mechanical inspection method, and backed by the contract acceptance criteria.
| Raw finding on the construction site | Technical wording required in the record | Evidence tool or document | Consequence for clearance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Damaged paint on columns | Paint chip of approx. 35 cm² on outer flange of HEB 240 column, axis C-3, level +1 | Dry film thickness gauge (residual film measurement) | Local brush touch-up according to manufacturer's technical data sheet |
| Non-compliant bolting | M24 HR bolts not tightened to specified torque on cross-member node T12, grid line 4 | Calibrated torque wrench (torque log) | Controlled tightening to nominal value under joint inspection record |
| Beam not straight | Residual deflection measured at 18 mm at mid-span of IPE 400 girder (axis 2 between B and C) | Optical laser level and 3 m straightedge | Check against project allowable tolerances |
| Ugly weld on roof | Local 3 mm excess weld metal on fillet weld of bracing gusset GV-08 | Weld gauge and visual inspection | Gentle grinding without notching base metal and cold galvanising |
Formal notification in the minutes marks the starting point of the remediation obligation. When the parties record defects that do not impair the safe use of the structure, acceptance of the work is declared with reservations. The transfer of risks takes place for the sections accepted without dispute, relieving the steelwork contractor of the duty of care for subsequent mechanical damage caused by other trades.
Intervention periods, financial retention, and interface with the account
Entering a reservation requires the joint agreement of a realistic remediation schedule. In steel construction, remediation cannot be improvised on the spot: manufacturing a splice plate, reworking a profile in the shop, or applying a multi-coat anti-corrosion system requires incompressible procurement, machining, and curing times. The agreed deadline recorded in the minutes must incorporate these technical constraints as well as the availability of aerial work platforms or service scaffolding.
- Workshop or on-site repair qualificationDetermine whether the intervention requires heavy lifting equipment or simple manual work using calibrated power tools.
- Validation of the repair sheetSubmit the working method for grinding, weld plugging, or fastener replacement to the structural engineer before taking any action.
- Execution and convening for clearance inspectionCarry out the intervention within the agreed period and summon site management in writing to formally record the resolution of the open item.
- Signing of the reservation clearance formHave the written final clearance certificate initialled, which is mandatory to trigger payment of the withheld balance.
Financially, the retention applied by the client must not exceed the foreseeable cost of the work required to eliminate the recorded defects. Withholding ten per cent of the total contract sum for three anti-rust paint touch-ups is contrary to industry practice. If penalties or delays from other trades are invoked, the Code of Obligations (CO) governs default and non-performance, notably art. 102 CO on formal notice through reminder by the creditor and art. 107 CO, which allows setting an appropriate time limit to perform the obligation.
Managing retention on invoices and releasing the bank guarantee for performance directly interface with final invoicing. For the detailed breakdown of the final account, calculation of metal price revisions, and the issue of partial payment orders, refer to the financial management guidelines developed in the tenders section.
Technical qualification of reservations on the frame and connections
During the joint inspection record according to standard SIA 118, entering a vague note such as "paintwork to be reviewed" or "bolts to be checked" precludes any subsequent formal clearance. For the steelwork contractor, every reservation recorded in the acceptance record must include a geographical designation on the layout drawing, a specific component (haunch, base plate, stiffener, chord), and a value measured by a calibrated instrument (coating thickness gauge, torque wrench, or straightedge).
The distinction between a cosmetic anti-corrosion touch-up and a structural non-conformity directly determines the site schedule. While a topcoat scratched during cladding work is handled by localized sanding followed by a compatible repair system, a tightening defect on a preloaded bolted connection requires a documented procedure with residual torque checking or fastener replacement.
| Element and grid mark | Measured joint finding | Remedial technical action | Execution period |
|---|---|---|---|
| HEB 240 column, Axis B3, level +3.40 m | Dry film thickness measured at 65 µm versus 120 µm specified on exterior face | Degreasing, local de-nibbing, and reapplication of a polyurethane finish coat | 10 working days |
| IPE 360 beam, bay C2-C3 | Paint chip with incipient superficial oxidation over 400 mm of bottom flange | Mechanical cleaning grade St 3, zinc epoxy primer, then topcoat | 5 working days |
| End plate, frame joint D4 | Residual gap of 3.5 mm under plate after preloading, absence of solid packing | Supply and insertion of machined steel tapered shims, re-tightening | 15 working days |
| Roof purlin cleat, Axis 2-E | 2 M16 bolts non-compliant with the property class specified on shop drawings | Removal, supply, and installation of compliant bolting with chamfered washers | 5 working days |
Remediation period, joint clearance, and release of retention
Setting a realistic execution period for the clearance of reservations relies on access availability and coating application conditions. If the structural work or finishing trades have dismantled the standing scaffolding or if ambient temperatures drop below resin curing thresholds, the agreed timeframe must integrate these access and building physics constraints.
The sole function of the financial retention applied at acceptance of the work under standard SIA 118 is to guarantee performance of the remediation work recorded in the minutes. It can under no circumstances serve as leverage to negotiate uncommissioned additional work. The retained amount must remain strictly proportionate to the estimated actual cost of workshop or on-site assembly touch-ups.
- Notice of completion of interventionThe foreman or site manager notifies site management in writing of the completion of touch-ups, backed by dimensional check sheets and painting reports.
- Visual and metrological clearance inspectionJoint visit to the areas identified during initial acceptance. Each item in the reservation schedule is signed off jointly on the spot.
- Preparation of the final clearance recordDrafting of the document certifying the elimination of reported defects, formally releasing the contractor from liability for the remedied elements.
- Forwarding to the final accountThe reservation clearance deed enables the immediate release of the financial retention money or the return of the equivalent bank guarantee.
Managing acceptance disputes and administrative closure
When site management refuses to sign the minutes or makes general complaints about the framework, the site manager must neutralise the risk of financial hold-up. An undetermined entry such as "non-compliant structure" or "finishes to be reviewed" does not constitute an admissible reservation. Under standard SIA 118, the work is inspected jointly, and the results are recorded mutually. If a disagreement persists during the visit, the contractor demands the immediate entry of their own technical comments directly into the record or notifies their objection by registered mail.
In the event of a real and quantified defect (bolts not tightened to torque, lack of fillet welds of required throat thickness, or anti-corrosion paint thickness defects measured by micrometer), the company carries out the remediation within the agreed remedy period. If this deadline is not met by the steelwork contractor, the Code of Obligations (CO) provides the rules applicable to default. Art. 107 CO provides that the other party may set an appropriate time limit to perform; upon its expiry, they may waive performance and claim damages or withdraw from the contract. The client may then hire a third party at the defaulting contractor's expense.
The financial retention applied to interim statements cannot exceed the objective cost of the necessary remediation work. It in no way constitutes an arbitrary lump-sum penalty. As soon as the reservation clearance record is signed, the steelwork contractor submits their final account including approved addenda and definitive measured quantities. A detailed analysis of final account items and invoicing rules is available in the tenders section.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if site management refuses to sign the metalwork acceptance record?
According to standard SIA 118, the inspection is carried out jointly. If site management refuses to formalise the document, the site manager immediately drafts a detailed record on site, supported by photographs and dimensional surveys. They serve this document by registered post with acknowledgement of receipt, requesting a formal position within a fortnight. Continued silence constitutes acceptance of the work without apparent reservations.
How do you contest a reservation concerning the alignment of a steel column?
A contestation relies exclusively on verifiable geometric measurements. The contractor uses a theodolite or a laser level to check out-of-plumbness against allowable erection tolerances. If the measured deviation remains within the project's contractual thresholds, the site manager submits the joint inspection record to demand the outright cancellation of the reservation entered during the visit.
Can retention money be withheld for a minor aesthetic reservation?
No. The retained amount must be strictly proportionate to the actual cost of the repair needed to clear the defect. For a simple scratch on visible frame lacquer, retention is limited to a painter's quote for localized spray or brush touch-up. Withholding an advance payment in full or retaining five per cent on this ground is unjustified.
Who validates the final clearance of reservations after on-site remediation?
Clearance requires a formal joint inspection record with site management. The contractor notifies the consultants in writing upon completion of the repairs, specifying the items addressed according to the original table. An addendum to the acceptance record, countersigned by both parties, certifies the removal of the reservations and immediately triggers the release of funds retained on the account for the work.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for construction work (procedure for acceptance of the work and recording of defects)
- CO art. 107Default in bilateral contracts: setting an appropriate time limit to perform and options available to the creditor upon expiry of the time limit
