Key takeaways
- Indelible marking before removal guarantees exact matching with as-built drawings.
- Inspection of drilled holes tracks down ovalisation, fracture initiation and corrosion.
- Weld beads must undergo a visual examination and penetrant testing.
- The absence of a material certificate requires destructive testing in an accredited laboratory to requalify the grade.
Organising the removal, marking each section and inspecting existing joints
Dismantling a steel structure to give it a second life cannot be improvised like simple demolition. The operation demands the same rigour as the initial erection. Before loosening a single bolt or deploying lifting equipment, the site manager draws up a precise dismantling plan. Each load-bearing element (columns, beams, purlins, sag bars and bracings) receives a unique mark, recorded on the as-built drawings of the structure. This marking is carried out by physical marking directly on the steel. Adhesive labels or chalk lines that disappear in bad weather are prohibited; the team uses an indelible industrial marker pen resistant to ultraviolet rays, backed up if necessary by a cold punch stamp placed on a neutral zone of the section.
The removal of bolted joints requires particular care. The use of a cutting torch to cut bolts or sever splice plates is strictly prohibited if the parts are to be reused. Joints must be undone mechanically using an impact wrench or torque wrench. As soon as the node is freed, the foreman meticulously inspects the bolt clearance holes. A hole that has undergone excessive stress often exhibits ovalisation through bearing deformation of the inner wall or radial micro-cracks initiated by the bolt threads. If the hole geometry deviates from allowable tolerances, the net cross-section of the component is impaired, precluding its direct reuse without workshop rework.
Joints welded on the construction site or in the workshop also require systematic verification. Heat-affected zones are particularly susceptible to ageing, fatigue and crevice corrosion beneath aged paint. After thorough cleaning of rust deposits and protective coatings by wire brushing or local mechanical stripping, a visual inspection detects undercuts, cracks or lack of fusion. Where the component has sustained cyclic loads, non-destructive testing by penetrant testing or magnetic particle inspection allows the integrity of the bead to be certified before any reloading.
| Component | Critical checkpoint | Consequence for reuse |
|---|---|---|
| Bolt holes | Ovalisation, burrs, edge micro-cracks | Reaming to a larger diameter or rejection of the component |
| End plates and gussets | Buckling, out-of-plane distortion, corrosion | Cold straightening under a press or replacement of the plate |
| Weld beads | Crater cracks, undercuts, pitting | Complete gouging out and remaking of the bead in the workshop |
| Section webs and flanges | Local buckling, mechanical notches | Cropping damaged zones or downgrading |
Restoring steel traceability and validating grades through laboratory testing
The main technical hurdle in reusing steel sections lies in the loss of documentary traceability. Without a mill certificate guaranteeing chemical composition and yield strength, the civil engineer responsible for the new structure cannot validate calculation notes according to structural steelwork standards. The contractor must therefore reconstruct the material history or have the steel qualified through a recognised testing campaign. Examining the archives of the existing structure (original drawings, period approval sheets) constitutes the first step, complemented by searching for any embossed rolling marks on the webs of the girders indicating the producer and the rolling era.
When all documentation is missing, the metal must undergo specimen sampling for mechanical and chemical analyses by an accredited testing laboratory. The sampling of test pieces is performed by coring or waterjet cutting in low-stress zones, generally flange overlengths or section ends. Tensile tests allow the actual yield strength, ultimate tensile strength and elongation at fracture to be established precisely. These data make it possible to link the legacy steel to current standardised grades, adopting a safe characteristic value.
- Carbon equivalent value (CEV)
- Index calculated from the chemical composition of the steel reflecting its weldability. A high value imposes strict precautions, such as systematic preheating prior to any thermal joining operation.
Spectrometric analysis of the chemical composition proves essential for ruling on the weldability of the reused steel. The analysis determines the percentages of carbon, manganese, silicon, phosphorus and sulphur to calculate the carbon equivalent value. If very old steels display high levels of impurities or poor impact energy in Charpy impact tests, their welding on the new construction site will be ruled out. In this scenario, the engineer reorients the project design towards exclusively bolted joints, thus avoiding any risk of cold cracking.
Geometric diagnosis of sections and qualification of holes
The careful dismantling of a steel skeleton requires immediate examination as soon as it is set down on the ground. Prior to any workshop reconditioning, each element undergoes dimensional inspection to detect potential residual deformations resulting from past service or disconnection forces. Permanent beam deflections, flange twisting and local web buckling adjacent to bearings are measured using a straightedge and an alignment string line.
| Area examined | Target defect | Immediate sorting criterion | Remedial action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compression flanges | Local buckling or ripple | Deformation visible under 2 m straightedge | Cropping the deformed area or downgrading |
| Web adjacent to haunches | Lateral-torsional buckling or residual web distortion | Deviation exceeding rolling tolerances | Cold straightening prohibited without analysis, cutting required |
| Bolted connections | Hole ovalisation, edge burring | Residual clearance exceeding nominal hole clearance | Reaming to larger diameter or strengthening with cover plate |
| Contact faces | Laminar rust under end plate | Wall thickness loss measurable with micrometer | Grit blasting followed by a new web thickness survey |
The condition of the holes determines the feasibility of reuse without heavy remachining. Holes accommodating preloaded bolting undergo friction stresses that may have work-hardened or distorted the edges of the original hole. Torn edges, edges gouged by cutting torches during prior modifications or distorted by excessive shear prevent the correct transmission of forces in the future project. Any non-circular hole must be reamed to the next standard diameter if the residual edge and pitch distances still allow it.
Weld requalification protocols and grade validation
The absence of original mill certificates (such as attestations under applicable standards) requires recreating the metallurgical history of the material. Weldability directly depends on the carbon equivalent of the legacy steel. Sampling from offcuts or by coring in neutral parts of the load-bearing elements allows spectrometric analysis to be carried out in an accredited laboratory, complemented by tensile and impact tests at standard temperature.
- Mechanical stripping of retained weldsComplete removal of old paint layers and rust by localised grit blasting or aggressive wire brushing back to white metal on all original workshop welds.
- Surface non-destructive testingLiquid penetrant testing or magnetic particle inspection of fillet welds connecting end plates and stiffeners to identify fatigue flaws and underbead cracking.
- Metallographic test specimen samplingMechanical cutting of a specimen from a lightly stressed zone to characterise the actual yield strength, tensile strength and chemical composition by optical emission spectrometry.
- Assignment of a guaranteed strength classIn the event of scatter in the test results, the steel structure is assigned a conservative lower-bound yield strength to enable safe redesign by the engineering office.
The handling of elements during dismantling and sorting operations must safeguard the physical integrity of personnel. In accordance with OTConst art. 17, measures must be taken so that workers are not endangered by the collapse of building components or falling objects and materials. Disconnection operations are conducted only after secure slinging of each member onto suitable lifting equipment.
Managing discrepancies during dismantling and requalifying reuse steel
In the field, removal frequently reveals major discrepancies: deformed connection plates, pronounced hole ovalisation under the effect of past shear, legacy torch cuts or the complete absence of original marking. When the actual condition diverges from reuse assumptions, the team leader halts the requalification of the component. The contractor exercises the duty to notify provided for in art. 365 CO by reporting in writing to the site management the defects observed on the components supplied for the new structure.
- Recording and isolating damaged componentsEach section exhibiting delamination, cracked weld beads or damaged tapped holes is marked with an indelible red cross. The component is immediately removed from the sorting flow to prevent any confusion with items validated in the reuse catalogue.
- Survey of degraded geometriesThe foreman records in the log the exact location, actual diameter of altered holes and cross-sectional losses due to corrosion. This survey is forwarded to the civil engineer responsible for reuse for recalculation of allowable loads or definition of required cut-outs.
- Testing campaign for sections without traceabilityIf the material certificate is missing and the cold stamped mark is illegible, the steel is presumed non-compliant for structural use. Specimen samples are then taken from the neutral ends of the members to characterise the grade through tensile and impact tests and chemical analysis by spectrometry.
In the event of rejection of a batch of steel that is excessively corroded or exhibits uncertain weldability, the enterprise applies the sorting requirements set out in the Waste Ordinance. Elements disqualified for the load-bearing frame are redirected to material recycling in a steelworks according to OLED, without compromising the safety requirements of the new structure.
Frequently asked questions
How can the grade of a steel beam be identified without any material certificate?
Without an original certificate or embossed rolling mark, the engineer requires a destructive campaign. The steel fabricator takes a test piece from the end of the section, outside the critical joint zone. An accredited testing laboratory carries out optical emission spectrometry to determine the carbon equivalent and chemical composition, complemented by a tensile test to measure the actual yield strength of the steel.
What should be done when a bolt hole is ovalised or exhibits edge cracks?
A hole that is ovalised under stress or cracked rules out direct reuse of the connection node. Two technical solutions are applicable after approval by the engineer: reaming the hole to the next diameter up if minimum edge distances remain compliant, or cropping the damaged end of the member to weld a new end plate of appropriate thickness in the workshop.
How can dismantled sections be durably marked on the deconstruction site?
Marking with chalk or plain marker is prohibited because it washes off in bad weather or during grit blasting. Each component receives a unique identifier recorded on the marking plan before removal. A riveted metal plate or cold punch marking is applied at mid-span of the web, supplemented by a barcode or a sealed tear-proof label.
Can dismantled high-strength bolting assemblies be reused?
The reuse of preloaded bolts is strictly prohibited. During initial tightening to controlled torque, the bolt undergoes irreversible plastic elongation that degrades its future load-bearing capacity. Fastener sets (bolts, nuts, bevelled washers) must systematically be scrapped for material recycling and replaced with new certified bolting during rebuilding.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365material and site: the contractor is liable for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he immediately notifies the client thereof, under penalty of bearing the consequences (para. 3).
- OTConst art. 17protection against collapse of building components or falling objects and materials: at workstations and passageways, measures must be taken so that workers are not endangered.
