Key takeaways
- The workshop drawing details individual geometry for shop fabrication of parts.
- The erection drawing defines spatial referencing, connections and stability on the construction site.
- The civil engineer must give formal approval before any cutting or machining begins.
- The checking and approval period must imperatively be included in the contractual schedule.
Distinguishing the workshop drawing from the erection drawing by operational use
Confusing workshop drawings and erection drawings inevitably leads to installation errors or delays on the construction site. The workshop drawing is a manufacturing document intended for machinists, metalworkers and welders in the shop. It represents each steel component in isolation or as a welded sub-assembly. Conversely, the erection drawing constitutes the setting-out and assembly tool for the erection foreman. Attempting to erect a steel framework solely using cutting lists or workshop sheets creates unnecessary information overload for erection teams while omitting orientation marks and lifting sequences.
| Analysis criterion | Workshop drawing (fabrication) | Erection drawing (construction site) |
|---|---|---|
| Main subject | Individual component, welded base plate, finished sub-assembly | Complete framework, spatial reference marks, site connections |
| Dimensioning and tolerances | Fabrication dimensions to the millimetre, machining tolerances | Finished levels, grid lines, setting-out dimensions and erection tolerances |
| Fastening details | Shop weld throats, stud drillings, chamfers | Site bolting, tightening class, splice welds |
| Additional information | Bill of materials, unit weight, surface treatment | Lifting sequence, slinging points, safety measures and temporary propping |
The workshop drawing contains all instructions required to turn raw sections into components ready for assembly: cutting, notching, drilling, chamfering, weld edge preparation and precise positioning of stiffeners. Required surface treatments, such as hot-dip galvanising or the application of an anti-corrosion primer, also appear on it. The erection drawing, for its part, covers the general setting-out of the works in relation to surveyor grid lines and interfaces with the structural work. It assigns a unique, unambiguous erection mark to each beam, column or angle, refers to site-bolted connection nodes and specifies required tightening torques.
Securing the engineer's approval and locking in review periods
Under no circumstances may the contractor start cutting sections or welding plates without having obtained formal approval from the civil engineer responsible for the structure. This check does not relieve the steel fabricator of their own dimensional verifications, but it certifies that the design office validates force transmission, bolt diameters and layouts, connection plate thicknesses and the compliance of selected sections with structural calculation assumptions. Starting fabrication based on unapproved drawings exposes the company to scrapping tonnes of steel if modifications to structural nodes occur in the meantime.
- Preparation and internal self-checkingThe internal technical office models the steelwork, generates parts lists and checks geometric consistency against architectural drawings and site surveys of as-built masonry.
- Official submittal for approvalTransmission of general layout drawings, connection details and connection calculation notes to site management and the civil engineer, accompanied by a transmittal sheet stating the revision index.
- Examination and return of approval by the consultantThe civil engineer reviews the documents and returns them endorsed with a precise status: 'Approved for construction', 'Approved with comments' or 'To be corrected and resubmitted'.
- Workshop fabrication orderClearance of any minor comments by the technical office and formal release of drawings stamped 'Approved for construction' to machining and assembly stations.
The technical validation cycle must be explicitly quantified in the project's contractual schedule. In Swiss steel construction practice, this engineer review period generally ranges between ten and fifteen working days from receipt of a complete package. If this time slot is not ring-fenced in the master schedule, the steel fabricator is caught between the delivery deadline imposed on the construction site and a package held up by the consultants. Planning ahead is all the more critical when procurement involves special steel grades requiring rolling or heat treatment lead times.
Technical content and completeness: from individual part to assembled structure
Confusing workshop drawings and erection drawings on a steel construction site directly exposes teams to setting-out errors, or even major structural risks. The workshop drawing is the manufacturing instruction intended for shop operatives. It covers each component individually or as a welded sub-assembly, with millimetric precision tailored to machine processing. In contrast, the erection drawing is addressed exclusively to erectors on the construction site and details the arrangement of the overall framework within the building's reference grid.
| Technical criterion | Workshop drawing (fabrication) | Erection drawing (construction site) |
|---|---|---|
| Main subject | Individual components (plates, gussets) and welded sub-assemblies. | Complete assembled framework, structural grids and axis marks. |
| Assembly information | Weld throat thicknesses, bevels, shop welding symbols, exact hole drilling. | Bolt classes, tightening torques, washers, site continuity welds. |
| Dimensional data | Cutting lengths, notches, hole patterns, machine fabrication tolerances. | Finished levels, grid lines, setting-out dimensions, verticality tolerances. |
| Handling and safety | Shop lifting points, lifting tap holes on heavy components. | Total element weight, centre of gravity, erection sequence, slinging areas. |
| External interfaces | Holes for secondary fixings, cast-in sockets. | Holding-down plates, concrete grouting pockets, temporary lifelines. |
The workshop drawing provides no information on how components connect to foundations or existing masonry. Using a cutting drawing in a mobile elevating work platform forces the team leader to extrapolate non-existent general dimensions, increasing the risk of reversing symmetrical sections or omitting crucial stiffeners. The erection drawing, meanwhile, shows every alphanumeric mark stamped onto profiles in the shop to establish an unambiguous erection sequence.
Approval cycles and locking in validation periods in the schedule
The transmission of execution documents follows a strict contractual procedure prior to any steel cutting or deployment of lifting crews. In accordance with French-speaking Swiss construction practice and the SIA 118 framework, the steel fabricator prepares drawings based on formwork drawings and load take-downs provided by the design office. The civil engineer responsible for structural safety must imperatively approve the drawings before workshop production is released.
- Issue of execution packageThe steel company's technical office transmits erection drawings and connection details under provisional 'Approved for review' status to site management and the engineer.
- Review and exchange periodThe civil engineer verifies connection compliance, site weld capacities and force transmission at supports. This review phase generally requires ten to fifteen working days.
- Return with approvalThe package is returned endorsed 'Approved for construction', 'Approved for construction with comments' or 'To be corrected and resubmitted'. Only this approval releases shop production.
- Distribution to operational teamsThe project manager distributes workshop drawings to fabrication workstations and transmits approved erection drawings to the site foreman and crane erector.
Starting fabrication of a framework without the engineer's formal approval directly engages the company's liability if a load transfer requires a web stiffener or a change in high-strength bolt diameter. On a legal level, art. 365 CO stipulates that if materials supplied by the client or any other circumstance jeopardises the regular or timely completion of the work, the contractor must immediately inform the client. Furthermore, under art. 229 CP, whoever intentionally disregards the recognised rules of the trade while directing or carrying out a construction project, and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of people, is liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty.
Managing approval disputes and execution stoppages
On a structural steel construction site, the line between workshop drawing and erection drawing becomes critical the moment an approval delay occurs. The workshop drawing serves exclusively for cutting, machining, notching and welding components in the shop. The erection drawing is used by the foreman for setting out base plates, spatial referencing, temporary connections and final torquing. Sending a team to site with workshop drawings causes immediate assembly errors, lack of tightening torques and complete loss of structural stability sequencing.
When the civil engineer delays returning workshop drawings stamped 'approved for construction', shop fabrication must not start. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), non-performance or delay may lead to claims for contractual damages. If the contractual review period—generally set between ten and fifteen working days in the master schedule—is exceeded, site management must be formally notified by written notice of the impending suspension of shop fabrication.
Should a geometric discrepancy be found during installation on concrete foundations, the contractor immediately checks the dimensions on the approved erection drawing against the setting-out tolerances. If the error stems from an inconsistency between the engineer's calculation notes and the formwork drawings, the steel fabricator exercises their duty to notify without improvising thermal cutting or hole slotting on site. Connection alterations on site require written approval from the engineer, otherwise node load-bearing capacity may be compromised.
- Record in the site diary the exact date workshop drawings were transmitted to the engineer.
- Issue formal notice of review delay from the very first working day following the end of the schedule allowance.
- Categorically refuse structural lifting based on workshop sheets that have not been compiled into a general layout drawing.
- Demand formal approval of the erection drawing including residual loads in temporary props.
Frequently asked questions
Can workshop drawings be used on the construction site to carry out erection?
No. Workshop drawings detail the unit fabrication of sections, drilling, notching and welding in the shop. They contain neither the spatial reference marks for the complete structure, nor the stability sequence, erection clearances or specified tightening torques. Working on the construction site without the general erection drawing exposes erectors to reversing symmetrical components and risks steel frame collapse.
What drawing approval period should be entered into the master execution schedule?
The standard review period granted to the civil engineer is ten to fifteen working days per submittal package. This checking time must be explicitly shown in the master schedule as a hold point prior to ordering special steel grades and starting workshop fabrication. Shortening this contractual period without the engineer's written agreement transfers the financial risk of machining modifications directly onto the steel fabrication shop.
Who must approve the erection drawing before lifting begins?
The erection drawing must imperatively receive 'approved for construction' status from the civil engineer responsible for the structural calculations before lifting operations begin. This approval certifies the compliance of site connections, erection sequencing and load transfer to permanent anchorages. The engineer pays particular attention to transient stability phases, temporary bracing and reactions on masonry or concrete supports.
What should be done if the civil engineer returns drawings marked 'approved with comments'?
The shop must hold production of parts affected by the comments until the details are rectified. The steel fabricator's technical office incorporates the annotations into the digital model, issues a new drawing revision and resubmits the fabrication sheets for the modified items. Fabricating subject to comments is done solely at the company's risk if revisions affect end-plate thicknesses or the number of preloaded bolts.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for construction work
