Key takeaways
- Spray fireproofing provides a cost-effective solution for structural steel intended to remain hidden.
- Board encasement ensures crisp edges and a paint-ready finish in visible areas.
- The required thickness varies depending on the section factor of the steel profile and the target fire resistance.
- Early coordination with the heating, ventilation, and electrical trade avoids costly remediation on the construction site.
Spray fireproofing and board encasement: performance, thicknesses, and visual appearances
To ensure the fire resistance of a steel structure (requirements R30 to R120 or higher), the steel fabricator has three main systems available: intumescent paint, spray fireproofing, and board encasement. When intumescent paint reaches its technical or financial limits due to a very unfavourable section factor (slender sections or thin webs), resorting to a thick insulating cladding becomes unavoidable. The choice between spray fireproofing and boards radically alters member clearance dimensions, the building's final appearance, and site work scheduling.
| Protection system | Average thickness (R60-R90) | Surface finish | Preferred application area |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spray fireproofing (mineral wool) | 15 to 45 mm | Rough, fibrous, uneven | Plenums, plant rooms, basements |
| Board encasement | 12 to 35 mm | Smooth, crisp edges, ready to paint | Offices, public areas, visible zones |
| Intumescent paint | 0.5 to 2.5 mm | Smooth, conforms to profile geometry | Exposed architectural steelwork |
Spray fireproofing consists of mineral wool mixed with hydraulic binders or gypsum-vermiculite blends. It is applied by pneumatic spraying directly onto blasted and primed steel. Its primary advantage lies in its low application cost and its ability to conform to complex geometries without cutting. Conversely, its raw appearance is very fibrous and irregular. It is prohibited in habitable spaces without a suspended ceiling because it retains dust and exhibits low resistance to mechanical impact.
Board encasement utilises rigid panels of calcium silicate, glass-fibre reinforced gypsum, or compressed rock wool. The boards are assembled around the steel section by screwing, stapling, or onto an independent galvanised secondary frame. This system completely conceals the section behind a rectangular box with perfect edges. It directly provides a surface ready for plastering and interior painting, offering a clean aesthetic that integrates seamlessly into the architecture.
Construction site coordination, building services integration, and interface management
The choice of protection method directly impacts the management of the construction site and the scheduling of finishing trades. In accordance with general planning principles set out in the construction work safety ordinance, the structural fire protection must be sequenced to avoid any subsequent damage by other trades.
- Substrate preparation and fixingsFit suspension brackets, HVAC ductwork inserts, and cable trays to the bare or primed steel before applying fire protection.
- Application of protectionApply spray fireproofing in an environment protected from frost and draughts, or install board encasement ensuring continuity of joint seals.
- Routing of pipes and ductworkInstall building services maintaining a minimum clearance from the installed protection to avoid any aggressive contact or compression.
- Interface inspection and remediationVisually inspect the entire treatment and immediately repair anchor areas or accidental impact damage before closing ceilings.
Interventions by plumbing, heating, and ventilation trades require rigorous coordination. When services pass through an encased or sprayed steel beam, pipe penetrations must feature dedicated firestop sleeves. Spray fireproofing damaged by the subsequent installation of a ventilation duct loses all certified performance if remediation is not carried out according to the manufacturer's protocol.
From an overall financial perspective, spray fireproofing offers the lowest square-metre cost for raw application, but often necessitates the addition of a suspended ceiling to hide its appearance. Board encasement represents a higher initial investment in labour, but combines the roles of fire protection and finished lining, thereby saving secondary plastering work. The economic assessment must therefore consider the complete interior finish build-up.
Comparative performance and thickness constraints
Passive fire protection of steel structures relies on three primary methods: intumescent paint, spray fireproofing based on mineral wool or cementitious binders, and rigid board encasement (calcium silicate or reinforced gypsum). When the required rating reaches R60, R90 or even R120, the choice of system dictates not only the final overall dimensions around the steel member, but also the overall execution cost.
| Assessment criterion | Spray fireproofing (wet/fibrous) | Board encasement | Intumescent paint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical thickness (R90) | 25 to 40 mm | 15 to 30 mm | 1.5 to 4 mm |
| Surface finish | Raw, fibrous, granular (concealable finish) | Smooth, ready to paint or taped joints | Smooth, retains profile geometry |
| Clearance impact | Substantial member build-up (loss of headroom/clearance) | Crisp rectangular encasement, fixed dimensions | Low build-up, profile geometry preserved |
| Application | Wet spray application, significant overspray | Dry installation on framework or direct screwing | Application by airless spray or roller |
Coordination with building services and impact on the construction site
Scheduling fire protection works requires strict coordination between building services (HVAC, electrical) and the structural steelwork contractor. Spray fireproofing generates substantial dust and wet overspray, requiring execution prior to running any building services. Conversely, board encasement is often carried out after running secondary services to close the shafts, but requires clear access around the profile.
- Spray fireproofing: Requires a bare construction site, masking of adjacent areas, and adequate ambient temperature. Hangers for building services must be fixed to the structure prior to spraying.
- Board encasement: Requires rigorous detailing of thermal bridges and service penetrations through the protective box, in accordance with VKF directives.
- Temporary protection: The steel must receive an anti-corrosion primer compatible with the spray material or the board edge adhesive.
In accordance with CFST Directive 6508 and the general prevention rules of art. 82 LAA, safeguarding workers' health requires the wearing of personal protective equipment during spraying or board cutting operations generating mineral dust. Construction site logistics must anticipate the disposal of offcuts or overspray waste in compliance with on-site sorting requirements specified by the Waste Prevention and Disposal Ordinance (OLED).
Management of non-conformities and remediation on the construction site
When fibrous spray or board encasement suffers premature damage or poor workmanship, the site manager's responsiveness governs cost control. Damage caused by building services trades (electrical, plumbing, ventilation) to already applied fire protection represents the most frequent dispute on load-bearing steel structures. If a subcontractor damages the sprayed blanket or removes a reinforced gypsum board to route a duct without making good the packing, the integrity of the R30 to R120 fire resistance is immediately compromised. Under art. 365 CO, the contractor must immediately notify the client of any circumstances jeopardising the proper or timely execution of the works. For remediation, spray fireproofing touch-ups require a compact spray machine or manual patching with lightweight mortar according to manufacturer recommendations, whereas replacing damaged boards requires strict compliance with screw centres and intumescent mastic joint treatment.
Another critical issue involves non-compliance with specified thicknesses or insufficient adhesion to steel profiles. The absence of a suitable bonding primer on hot-dip galvanised steelwork causes widespread debonding of sprayed mortar. In the event of non-compliant thickness measurements with a pin gauge, applying a second coat requires checking the intercoat interval and the cohesion of the first coat. In accordance with the principles of CO, the client may exercise rights in the event of defects in the work, requiring the steel fabricator to conduct rigorous quality control on substrate acceptance before commencing fire protection works.
To prevent these hold-ups, the foreman records each treated area in the site daily log supported by photos, measuring the thickness in millimetres, ambient temperature, and relative humidity during application. Establishing clear interface milestones prohibits any subsequent drilling or fixing by electricians and heating engineers without written approval. Once the protection is approved, applying durable labelling to each insulated load-bearing member specifies the fire resistance rating achieved and the type of product applied, ensuring traceability during future alterations of the building.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if a services trade punctures a calcium silicate board encasement?
The installer must seal the penetration in accordance with the standard detail from the protection system supplier. The opening reduces the fire resistance of the steel structure. The steel fabricator must require the use of a certified firestop mortar or intumescent mastic to restore the continuity of the EI system. Remediation must be recorded in an intervention report dated and signed by the relevant site manager.
Can fibrous spray fireproofing remain exposed in an unheated plant room?
Sprayed fibrous fireproofing may remain visible in a plant room, provided it is not subject to water splashing, high-velocity air streams, or repeated mechanical impacts. In exposed areas or unheated spaces prone to condensation, a hydrophobic surface hardener must be applied, or a cementitious sprayed mortar preferred. Otherwise, rigid encasement is required to ensure durable fire protection.
How is the thickness of sprayed mortar on a steel beam correctly measured?
Measurement is performed using a calibrated needle gauge, pushed perpendicularly until contact with the steel. Samples are taken according to a grid defined by VKF guidelines, measuring the web and flanges of the HEA or IPE profile. The average measured thickness must reach the nominal value calculated from the U/A section factor, without any single point showing a deficit exceeding the permitted tolerance.
What is the acceptable flatness tolerance for a fire-resistant board encasement?
For reinforced gypsum or calcium silicate board encasement intended to remain exposed, flatness requirements are defined by standard SIA 414. The permitted deviation under a 2-metre straight edge is generally 3 millimetres for a high-quality finish. If boards receive only a mist coat of paint without full surface skimming, joint lips must not exceed 1 millimetre to avoid casting shadows under raking light.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365Defective material or site, or circumstances jeopardising the proper execution of the work: duty to inform the client immediately
- COClient rights in the event of defects in the work: rejection, price reduction, rectification, damages
- SIA 414Tolerances in building construction
