Key takeaways
- Transverse and longitudinal shrinkage inevitably modifies the initial geometry of assembled steel sections.
- Standard SIA 263 requires strict compliance with the geometric tolerances of the finished structure.
- The alternating sequence of weld runs balances heat input to limit overall distortion of the sub-assembly.
- Clamping that is too rigid blocks distortion but induces high internal residual stresses.
Shrinkage phenomena and requirements according to standard SIA 263
During a welding operation, the localised heat input causes expansion of the steel, followed by significant contraction upon cooling. A component that is perfectly straight before assembly displays angular and axial distortions if these movements are not anticipated. Standard SIA 263 sets the dimensional framework and requires steel structures to comply with execution geometric tolerances once the welds have cooled.
- Transverse and longitudinal shrinkage
- Transverse shrinkage corresponds to the contraction of the metal perpendicular to the axis of the weld bead, drawing the components closer together or pinching them. Longitudinal shrinkage acts parallel to the pass and results in shortening or buckling of the assembled member.
| Type of shrinkage | Observed effect | Workshop preventive measure |
|---|---|---|
| Transverse shrinkage | Closing of the angle of a V-butt preparation | Angular pre-setting opposite the bevel |
| Longitudinal shrinkage | Shortening of the welded beam | Cutting allowance integrated during fabrication |
| Angular shrinkage | Misalignment or twisting of flanges | Symmetrical welding sequence or clamps |
Prevention methods: alternating sequence and control of clamping
To prevent the distortion of a built-up section or a load-bearing facade joint, the welder must not execute a continuous weld run from start to finish without interruption. Using an alternating sequence of weld runs (backstep method or symmetrical welding) allows heat input to be evenly distributed and balances contraction stresses.
- Pre-setting or angular positioningPre-set the component at an angle equal to the calculated distortion so that it pulls back square under the effect of shrinkage.
- Setting up mechanical clampingFasten the sub-assembly to a welding platen using clamps or tie rods to mechanically restrain displacement during welding.
- Execution of alternating and symmetrical weld runsDeposit the passes by alternating sides of the neutral axis in order to counter contraction forces against each other.
On the construction site, site management and the foreman ensure compliance with the welding execution plan. The on-site safety coordinator checks the application of the provisions of the ordonnance sur la sécurité et la protection de la santé des travailleurs dans les travaux de construction (art. 5 OTConst) regarding construction site organisation and personnel qualifications during heavy assembly operations.
Behaviour of welded joints and distortion management
During the cooling of the weld pool, steel undergoes unavoidable thermal shrinkage. If the steel section is not guided or restrained following a strict methodology, this physical phenomenon leads to an overall geometric distortion of the component. A member that is perfectly straight during setting out loses its alignment from the very first weld run.
- Transverse and longitudinal shrinkage
- Transverse shrinkage corresponds to the narrowing of the joint perpendicular to the weld axis, whereas longitudinal shrinkage acts parallel to the weld bead, causing buckling or bowing of long components.
To comply with the execution requirements for steel structures defined by standard SIA 263, the steel fabricator must compensate for these dimensional variations before and during welding. Planning the workshop assembly process requires anticipating the residual deflection generated by each pass.
| Type of shrinkage | Observed effect on the component | Workshop corrective action |
|---|---|---|
| Transverse shrinkage | Drawing together of the two parts at the bevel, reduction of the root opening. | Rigid tack welding with prior wedging and initial over-gapping of the preparation. |
| Longitudinal shrinkage | Bowing of the section (camber effect) on the side of the weld line. | Alternating welding using discontinuous segments and reverse pre-setting. |
| Angular shrinkage | Closing of the angle formed by the plates following successive V-passes. | Angular pre-balancing of the parts before tack welding. |
Sequence of weld runs, clamping and residual stresses
To limit overall distortion without excessively locking the natural expansion of the steel, the workshop supervisor implements an alternating sequence of weld runs. Symmetrical welding relative to the neutral axis of the section balances thermal stresses. The backstep technique distributes the heat input evenly across the entire length of the component.
- Mechanical pre-settingApply a counter-camber to the section using a hydraulic jack prior to welding in order to anticipate the pulling force of the weld bead.
- Symmetrical and alternating weldingExecute the passes by systematically alternating opposite sides relative to the neutral axis of the component.
- Controlled release and dimensional checkLoosen the clamping elements after complete cooling and verify alignment using optical instruments.
The organisation of the construction site and the safety of erectors remain subject to general directives. The employer specifically ensures the organisation of prevention at workstations in accordance with art. 82 LAA and provides appropriate equipment according to OPA. The site supervisor scrupulously checks the flatness of the assemblies before any delivery to the installation construction site.
Management of non-conformities and on-site flame straightening methods
When a steel section undergoes angular distortion or a longitudinal deflection that does not comply with the requirements of standard SIA 263 following welding operations, suitable corrective measures must be applied prior to any structural erection. Controlling transverse and longitudinal shrinkage proves critical when assembling clamped components, as mechanically preventing dimensional changes generates significant internal residual stresses within the weld bead and the heat-affected zone.
- Geometric assessment and distortion checkMeasure deviations in alignment, squareness and deflection on the section using straightedges or optical levels. Compare the readings against the manufacturing tolerances defined by standard SIA 263.
- Flame straightening (thermal shrinkage heating)Apply localised heating in triangles or lines using an oxyacetylene torch on the side opposite the distortion. The temperature of the metal must be strictly maintained within the range recommended for the steel grade to avoid any alteration of the metallurgical structure.
- Cold mechanical straighteningCorrect deflection using a site hydraulic press or a jack, applying progressive forces distributed over hardwood or aluminium packing to prevent marking the steel surface.
- Notification to the client and duty to notifyIn the event of an anomaly related to the anchor base or material supplied by the client that would prevent the execution of a compliant joint, the contractor immediately notifies the client in accordance with CO.
In the event of major defects resulting from an inadequate welding sequence or poorly designed clamping, the client may assert rights arising from the warranty for defects according to CO. Prevention is based on the meticulous preparation of the welding sequence in the workshop, the use of initial pre-settings and the methodical alternation of weld passes.
Frequently asked questions
How can a steel section distorted by weld bead shrinkage be corrected?
The preferred method is flame straightening using an oxyacetylene torch. By applying triangular heating zones on the side opposite the weld, the metal expands locally and then contracts upon cooling, bringing the component back within tolerance. Mechanical straightening with a hydraulic press provides an effective alternative if the section allows it without risk of cracking.
Why can rigid clamping of a component cause cracks?
Clamping physically prevents the natural transverse and longitudinal shrinkage of molten metal during solidification. Being unable to distort geometrically, the joint builds up very high residual tensile stresses within the weld bead and the heat-affected zone. If these stresses exceed the ultimate tensile strength of the metal upon cooling, cracks appear in the weld.
What is the purpose of an alternating sequence of weld runs?
The alternating sequence balances the distribution of heat input on either side of the section's neutral axis. By alternating passes on different faces or parts of the component, the shrinkage forces generated by each weld bead oppose and cancel each other out. This drastically reduces the overall distortion of the assembled steel sub-assembly.
What should be done if the supporting structure has defects that affect the welding of the facade?
If the concrete or steel support provided by the client proves to be non-compliant or out of tolerance, the steel fabricator must immediately issue a written notice of defect to the client. Under CO, the contractor is required to report any compromised circumstance to protect against liability for subsequent alignment defects.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 263Steel structures - Design and execution of joints and tolerances
- COImmediate notice to the client in the event of defects in material or site
- CORights of the client in the event of defective execution of the work
