Key takeaways
- The cutting process governs the surface hardness and geometric roughness of the steel cut edge.
- Standard SN EN 1090 imposes strict edge tolerances and hardness limits.
- The heat-affected zone requires systematic grinding on high-yield-strength steels.
- Oxygen laser cutting produces an oxide layer detrimental to weld bead soundness.
Edge behaviour according to process: oxy-fuel, plasma and laser beam
In structural steel workshops, cutting sections to length and cutting out gusset plates, base plates or webs for plate girders rely on three distinct thermal technologies. Each applies its own thermal cycle that alters the crystal structure of the metal over a given depth, generating a heat-affected zone (HAZ). Oxy-fuel cutting relies on the exothermic combustion of iron in a jet of pure oxygen after preheating with an oxy-acetylene or oxy-propane flame. Reserved for common heavy thicknesses above 20 mm, this process produces a deep HAZ, often exceeding 2 mm, marked by drag lines and residual iron mill scale on the cut face.
Plasma cutting uses a constricted electric arc enveloped in a plasma-forming gas to melt the steel instantly and expel the molten pool at high velocity. Highly efficient on thicknesses from 5 mm to 30 mm, plasma produces a natural bevel on the cut edge. The severe cooling cycle, accelerated by the surrounding mass of the plate, induces pronounced surface hardening. The surface frequently exhibits adhering dross on the underside as well as carburisation or nitriding of the edge depending on the assist gas selected, which complicates subsequent welding operations without edge preparation.
Laser cutting, whether using a CO2 or fibre source, concentrates exceptional power density on a millimetric impact point. It ensures remarkable squareness and very low roughness on thin and medium plates up to 20 mm or 25 mm. When oxygen is used as the assist gas, a thin film of iron oxide adheres mechanically to the edge. If the cut is performed under high-pressure nitrogen, the cut edge remains clean and oxide-free, with an extremely narrow heat-affected zone, often under 0.3 mm, limiting surface self-hardening on standard base grades.
| Process | Usual thicknesses (S235 to S355) | Typical HAZ depth | Appearance and recurring edge defects |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oxy-fuel cutting | 20 mm to 150 mm and more | 1.5 mm to 3.0 mm | Pronounced drag lines, adhering mill scale, slag dross on the underside. |
| Plasma cutting | 5 mm to 35 mm | 0.8 mm to 1.8 mm | Bevel angle (out-of-square defect), hardened edge, expulsion dross. |
| Laser cutting (O2 / N2) | 1 mm to 25 mm | 0.2 mm to 0.6 mm | Vertical, clean cut edge, reactive oxide film (under O2) or clean, bright cut edge (under N2). |
SN EN 1090 requirements and essential workshop dressing before welding
Standard SN EN 1090 governs the execution of steel structures and specifies stringent requirements regarding the geometric and metallurgical condition of thermally cut surfaces. Depending on the execution class required for the structure (generally EXC2 for standard commercial and industrial buildings, or EXC3 for dynamic or heavily loaded structures), free cut faces or those intended to be welded must comply with limit values for average roughness and perpendicularity tolerance. In addition, surface hardness after cutting must not exceed strict metallurgical thresholds, in order to prevent the critical risk of cold cracking under the weld bead during assembly of load-bearing elements.
- Visual and dimensional inspection of the cut edgeCheck for the absence of piercing craters, gouges or angular deviations exceeding the geometric tolerances of the specified execution class.
- Mechanical deburring and descalingRemove oxy-fuel slag or plasma dross using a pneumatic chisel or an angle grinder fitted with a suitable grit abrasive disc.
- Removal of the laser oxide layerCompletely remove the ferrous oxide film resulting from oxygen laser cutting by vigorous mechanical wire-brushing or light disc grinding to bare metal, preventing porosity outgassing in the molten pool.
- Bevelling and weld edge preparationDress the V, single-bevel or U preparations indicated on the workshop drawings by grinding or milling, ensuring that the entire residual hardened zone is fully eliminated.
The organisation of this workshop dressing work directly engages the responsibility of the fabrication teams. Occupational safety regulations require dust extraction for grinding and hearing protection against grinding noise levels. The site foreman ensures that no joint is tack-welded onto a surface still bearing traces of mill scale or thermal microcracks. A properly dressed face guarantees uniform root penetration, eliminates the risk of oxide inclusions and ensures compliance of the final non-destructive testing report.
Heat-affected zone and edge metallurgy according to process
Thermal cutting of structural steel locally alters the crystal structure of the parent metal over a depth proportional to the heat input. This heat-affected zone exhibits increased surface hardness as a result of the rapid thermal cycle combining localized heating and immediate cooling by conduction into the bulk of the part. In structural steelwork and load-bearing facades, standard SN EN 1090 strictly governs the hardness of these cut edges in order to prevent any risk of brittle fracture or underbead cracking during subsequent assembly stages.
| Cutting process | Typical HAZ thickness | Bevel angle and perpendicularity | Surface finish and burrs |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oxy-fuel cutting | Around 1.5 to 3.0 mm | Low bevel angle, moderate angular tolerance | Pronounced cut kerfs, adhering scale and slag |
| High-definition plasma | Around 0.5 to 1.5 mm | Visible bevel on heavy thicknesses | Moderate slag on underside, nitrogen oxide deposits |
| Laser beam (nitrogen/oxygen) | Around 0.1 to 0.4 mm | Almost strictly square cut edge | Smooth cut edge, thin oxide film under oxygen cutting |
On high-yield-strength steels of grades S355 or S460, oxy-fuel cutting demands heightened vigilance. The very high heat input generates local hardening that routinely exceeds permissible values without subsequent grinding. Conversely, nitrogen laser cutting preserves the material's impact toughness by restricting martensitic transformation to a micrometric fringe, ensuring excellent edge ductility without impairing fatigue strength under dynamic loading.
Workshop protocols: bevel preparation and dressing before welding
Directly incorporating thermally cut components into a structural frame node without mechanical preparation exposes the structure to severe non-conformities during non-destructive testing. For execution classes EXC2 and EXC3 commonly specified on commercial and industrial buildings in Switzerland, the workshop must implement a rigorous machining or grinding sequence to remove hardened zones and true up fit-up geometries.
- Deburring and slag removalSystematic descaling with a pneumatic chisel or snagging wheel to remove all cut dross along the bottom edge, preventing parasitic thermal bridging during tacking.
- Geometric check of bevel angleVerification of cut edge squareness with an angle gauge. In the event of an angular deviation induced by the plasma torch, a fit-up dressing is carried out using a portable beveller or a 40-grit abrasive disc.
- Removal of the hardened layerGrinding of at least 0.5 mm on an oxy-fuel or plasma cut edge intended to receive a highly stressed butt weld, in order to return to sound, thermally unaltered parent metal.
- Rounding of sharp edgesSystematic edge breaking to a radius of at least 2 mm using a pneumatic edge milling tool to guarantee the nominal thickness of the paint or galvanised coating in accordance with standard SN EN 1090.
When preparing single-V or single-bevel edge preparations by thermal cutting in the workshop, preheating the plate may be mandatory to limit the thermal gradient on thick sections. The operator must maintain a uniform root opening free from cutting notches that could cause lack of root penetration in the weld. In the event of accidental gouge defects caused by a deflected torch start, weld buttering is only permitted after complete removal of the crack by light grinding and liquid penetrant inspection.
Cutting non-conformities: managing defects and workshop dressing
On structural steel members, an out-of-tolerance cut edge directly compromises welded or bolted connections. When geometry, surface finish or surface hardness do not meet the specified requirements for the structure, the workshop manager must immediately record the non-conformance prior to any fabrication.
- Deep gouges or notching from oxy-fuel cutting: eliminate tears by light grinding in the longitudinal direction. If the depth of the defect encroaches upon the cross-section beyond manufacturing tolerances, carry out weld buttering according to a qualified welding procedure specification (WPS), followed by complete flush grinding.
- Excessive plasma bevel angle: redress edge squareness using a portable milling machine or snagging grinder to restore the required weld root face and bevel angle, monitoring component root opening during tacking.
- Presence of mill scale or vitrified oxides from laser: systematically strip the residual oxide film by mechanical brushing with a rotary steel wire brush or by spot blast-cleaning, in order to prevent porosity or blowholes under the bead.
- Surface hardening of the heat-affected zone: for heavily stressed structural steel grades, remove excess material by mechanical machining or grinding to eliminate the hardened fringe, particularly if non-destructive testing by penetrant testing or magnetic particle testing is required.
According to art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the regular or timely execution of the work, the contractor must immediately inform the client. If cut components exhibit supply defects or irreversible thermal distortion incompatible with the required execution class, formal notice must be issued prior to any assembly operation.
Frequently asked questions
How can mill scale produced by oxygen laser cutting be effectively eliminated before welding?
The iron oxide layer generated by oxygen laser cutting forms a hard film that contaminates the weld pool and creates porosity beneath the bead. The workshop must use an angle grinder equipped with a semi-rigid abrasive disc or a rotary hardened steel wire brush. Simple manual wire-brushing is insufficient: the metal must be stripped completely back to bare, bright steel across the entire surface of the joint area.
Can an oxy-fuel hardened edge be left as cut on a structural member?
No, an oxy-fuel cut face on heavy thickness develops local hardening that increases the risk of underbead cracking during welding. The workshop must grind or plane the edge to remove the hardened fringe of the heat-affected zone. This step prevents cold cracking in the welded joint. For unpainted, welded elements, the edge must also be rounded to ensure the required anti-corrosion adhesion.
How can an edge preparation whose angle has drifted during workshop plasma cutting be rectified?
The plasma process can induce an unintended bevel angle due to nozzle wear or incorrect torch settings. To re-establish the angle and root face required by the welding procedure, the operator redresses the face using a portable mechanical beveller or guided grinding. If the dressing reduces the length of the metal component too extensively, qualified weld buildup followed by machining becomes mandatory.
What measures should be taken in the workshop if a cut plate exhibits global thermal distortion?
The thermal energy transferred by oxy-fuel or plasma cutting concentrates internal shrinkage stresses that distort flat bars and thin gusset plates. The metal fabricator straightens the members on a mechanical straightening bench using a hydraulic press or performs localized flame shrinking with a torch. Heat input must remain strictly controlled to preserve the yield strength and impact toughness specified for the structural frame.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is liable for the sound quality of the materials supplied; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the regular or timely execution of the work, the contractor must immediately inform the client, failing which the contractor will bear the consequences (para. 3)
