Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 215Connections: bolting, welding and inspectionChapter 4 of 10 in the section

Welding defects: undercut, lack of penetration, porosity, and what can be repaired

On structural steelwork construction sites, commissioning an inspection body for non-destructive testing without prior verification unnecessarily burdens budgets. This chapter teaches you to read a weld bead with the naked eye using a welding gauge, to distinguish permissible surface defects from critical internal flaws, and to perform weld repairs in accordance with the recognised rules of the art.

Key takeaways

  • A methodical visual examination eliminates obvious rejections before the intervention of a certified external inspector.
  • The undercut of a fillet weld reduces the effective thickness and weakens the throat under cyclic loading.
  • Lack of penetration remains invisible on the surface and requires ultrasonic or radiographic testing.
  • Every repair requires careful grinding down to sound metal without overheating the heat-affected zone.

Diagnose geometric and surface defects with workshop instruments

Visual inspection forms the first acceptance barrier for welded joints in steel construction according to standard SN EN 1090. Before calling in a certified technician for magnetic particle or penetrant testing, the site foreman must systematically inspect each fillet weld and each butt joint splice. Raking light of at least 350 lux, a magnifying glass of moderate magnification, a steel rule, and a dial or vernier welding gauge are sufficient to spot the majority of geometric non-conformities.

Classification of defects visible upon direct examination and measurement methods
Defect designationManufacturing causeMechanical consequenceVerification tool
Lateral undercutTravel speed too fast or excessive arc voltageStress concentration and crack initiation at the weld toeUndercut depth gauge
Root fillet undercutIncorrect torch angle or improperly set currentDirect weakening of the design throat thicknessSliding fillet weld gauge
Isolated surface porosityShielding gas failure or contaminated steel surfaceMinor loss of cross-section, risk of gas pocket clusteringLinen tester and calibrated rule
Porosity clusterDraught on construction site during MAG weldingMassive open surface porosity precluding acceptanceDirect visual examination without instruments
Excessive reinforcementWeaving speed too slow during capping passesToe blend angle too steep causing a notch effectMulti-purpose angle gauge

An undercut is a longitudinal groove melted into the base metal along the toe of the weld that is not filled by weld metal. On a plate girder or a haunch connection under bending moment, this groove creates an acute notch. Depending on the execution class defined by standard SN EN 1090, the permissible depth of an undercut generally allows no more than half a millimetre, provided that the transition to the plate remains smooth. Beyond that, fatigue crack initiation is virtually certain.

Solid inclusions, such as slag inclusions in manual metal arc or submerged arc welding, often appear on the surface as surface irregularities and discontinuous grooves. If the welder applies a fill pass without scrupulously removing the slag crust using a chisel or a die grinder, the defect becomes internal and compromises the structural integrity of the joint.

Address internal lack of penetration and regulate permissible repairs

Unlike undercuts or surface gas cavities, lack of penetration and lack of fusion usually remain invisible to the naked eye. This defect occurs when the molten metal does not fuse with the root of the bevel or leaves a continuous void between the two joined parts. A full penetration weld inspected solely from above can display a flawless appearance while the root face features a fatal discontinuity defect.

Lack of penetration
Absence of complete fusion of the deposited metal at the root of a bevelled joint or lack of penetration of the fillet weld beyond the theoretical contact line of the steel parts.

To detect these internal anomalies before the issuance of non-destructive testing inspection reports, the steel fabricator plans ultrasonic or radiographic testing according to the requirements of standard SN EN 1090. Calling upon an external inspection body represents a high direct cost: commissioning an ultrasonic testing campaign on parts already exhibiting obvious visual defects leads to a doubling of inspection call-out invoices.

  1. Locating and delimiting the defective areaLocate the extent of the defect using penetrant testing or thermal chalk, allowing an overcut run-out of at least 20 mm on either side of the undercut or porosity cluster.
  2. Mechanical excavation by gouging or grindingOpen a flared U-groove using an angle grinder fitted with a grinding disc of appropriate thickness. Cold chipping is prohibited to prevent closing the lips of an eventual crack.
  3. Verification of bright, sound base metalEnsure via a quick dye penetrant check or visual inspection under good lighting that the slag inclusion or lack of fusion has completely vanished at the bottom of the groove.
  4. Preheating and weld deposit according to the welding procedure specificationRebuild the bead in successive narrow stringer passes, observing the steel preheat temperature to prevent local hardening and cold cracking.
  5. Dressing and transitional blendingGrind down the weld repair reinforcement to restore the nominal joint profile without gouging into the adjacent structural steel plates.

Structural steel requires absolute rigour during repair phases. Using an angle grinder with a thin slitting disc to carve a narrow slot is a frequent error on the construction site: it promotes lack of fusion during the subsequent pass due to insufficient torch access. By maintaining a groove geometry with an included angle of at least 60 degrees, the welder ensures perfect wetting of the filler metal and avoids the occurrence of new blowholes.

Filter defects with the naked eye and magnifying glass before non-destructive testing

Calling in an external inspection body to carry out dye penetrant, magnetic particle, or ultrasonic testing on an uninspected weld bead represents a pointless expense if the steel fabricator has not first eliminated the imperfections detectable without heavy equipment. Methodical visual inspection allows the elimination of the majority of surface anomalies that would lead to the immediate rejection of the connection node under standard SN EN 1090-2.

Direct observation of a weld bead requires thorough descaling, mechanical wire-brushing of the heat-affected zone, and raking light of at least 500 lux. With the naked eye and using a rule or a moderate-magnification lens, the foreman primarily checks for undercut. This undercut groove is situated along the fusion boundary between the base metal and the deposited weld metal, often caused by excessive travel speed, overly high arc voltage, or an incorrect MAG torch angle. Lack of throat thickness and continuous undercuts create stress notch crack initiators under dynamic loading.

Surface anomalies observable during visual inspection and common acceptance limits
Defect typeCause on construction site or in workshopDirect visibilityImmediate intervention criterion
Continuous undercutArc voltage too high, incorrect torch angleYes, distinct groove along the fusion lineRepair required if the depth cuts into the base metal beyond class tolerances
Surface-breaking porosity (pinhole)Shielding gas blown away by wind, greasy steelYes, craters or pinholes visible with a pocket microscopeRejected as soon as clusters are present or if diameter exceeds contractual limits
Root lack of penetrationTight bevel preparation, root face too thickNo (except welding on backing strips or accessible reverse side)Surface inspection ineffective; requires ultrasonic or radiographic testing
Slag inclusionInsufficient cleaning between passes (process 111)No when trapped in sub-surface passesVisually detectable only during intermediate grinding

Surface porosities and poorly filled stop craters indicate a breakdown of the weld pool. On an outdoor construction site in French-speaking Switzerland, draughts disrupting the shielding gas on a solid wire process constitute the leading cause of porosity clusters. If the metal displays tiny isolated cavities with a diameter below the limits set by the execution class of standard SN EN 1090-2, the component remains acceptable. Conversely, aligned or clustered porosities require immediate rectification.

Acceptable repair methodology and mechanical limits

Not every non-conformity justifies scrapping a built-up welded beam or column. An acceptable weld repair is based on a strict sequence: precise identification of the defective volume, mechanical removal by light grinding or gouging, and rebuilding of the bead in accordance with a qualified welding procedure specification.

  1. Defect excavationRemove the anomaly using an angle grinder fitted with a roughing disc or by air-arc gouging if the defect extends deep. The groove must have flared sidewalls with a minimum bevel angle of 20° to 30° to ensure adequate wetting of the repair pass, without sharp corners or notch roots.
  2. Excavation checkInspect the bottom of the excavation groove with a quick dye penetrant or local magnetic test to ensure the complete elimination of the crack, porosity cluster, or slag track before depositing any new weld metal.
  3. Preheating and weld depositApply preheating in accordance with the steel grade (particularly for heavy thicknesses in S355) to prevent local martensite hardening. Perform the repair using compatible filler metal, striking and terminating the arc on sound zones or run-on/run-off tabs.
  4. Finishing and re-inspectionGrind the weld repair cap to blend its profile smoothly into the original geometry. Submit the repaired area to complete visual inspection and the non-destructive testing specified in the initial inspection plan.

The contractor shall take the organisational measures required to ensure execution according to recognised rules of the art. Art. 364 CO sets out the contractor's duties regarding diligence and liability in the direction of the works. When structural steel presents extensive inclusions or internal lack of penetration confirmed by NDT, full grooving of the bevel remains the only technically acceptable approach to restore the static capacity of the joint.

Management of weld non-conformities and repair arbitration

On structural steelwork or a composite facade load-bearing frame, late detection of imperfections jeopardises the delivery schedule. When prior visual inspection reveals excessive undercuts, porosity clusters, or root lack of penetration, the intervention of a certified external inspector without preparation exposes the workshop to formal rejection. Before commissioning expensive non-destructive testing by magnetic particle or ultrasonic methods, the site foreman must determine the mechanical feasibility of an acceptable weld repair according to standard SN EN 1090.

  1. Mechanical excavationEliminate the defect (porosity, slag inclusion, or sharp undercut) by careful grinding with an abrasive wheel or by air-arc gouging for heavy sections, creating a flared groove with smooth sidewalls.
  2. Intermediate inspectionVerify the total removal of the discontinuity by colour contrast penetrant testing or magnetic particle testing before striking any new arc.
  3. Thermal rebuildingPreheat the area according to the instructions of the welding procedure specification (repair WPS), then deposit the filler passes while ensuring regular thermal monitoring.
  4. FinishingGrind the excess reinforcement flush and re-establish a smooth transition without creating a new mechanical notch.

If the volume of steel removed by grinding exceeds structural tolerances or if a lack of penetration spans a rigid node without access to the back, local repair is prohibited. The contractor must record the non-conformity in a technical query submitted to the civil engineer responsible for the structural design. Where execution deviates from the works requirements, the client may exercise its rights under art. 368 CO. Art. 229 CP applies in the event of an infringement of the rules of the art endangering the life or physical integrity of persons. An undocumented repair directly incurs the civil liability and criminal liability of the erection supervisors.

Frequently asked questions

Can an undercut along a flange edge be repaired by simply welding over it?

No. Overwelding directly over an undercut without preparation traps oxide inclusions and exacerbates the notch effect under tensile stress. An acceptable repair requires gentle transitional grinding to blend the groove into the base metal, or edge gouging followed by strict preheating before depositing the reinforcement bead in accordance with a WPS qualified under standard SN EN 1090.

What is the tolerance for surface porosity prior to liquid penetrant testing?

Standard SN EN 1090 refers to manufacturing quality levels where surface-breaking pores or porosity clusters are prohibited on structural joints. Before ordering billable penetrant testing, any porosity visible to the naked eye must be removed with a workshop grinder. The presence of a single open cavity results in the immediate rejection of the non-destructive testing report.

How should a lack of penetration discovered after welding on a closed hollow section be treated?

On a hollow section without internal access, root lack of penetration cannot be repaired from the reverse side. The contractor must gouge the weld out across its entire depth by grinding or milling back to the original bevel. If this excavation excessively weakens the load-bearing cross-section, prior approval from the civil engineer is required before executing the new weld.

How many successive repairs are permitted on the same weld bead?

As a rule, the technical specifications of standard SN EN 1090 restrict interventions to two local repairs in the same spot. Each heating and cooling cycle alters the heat-affected zone of the steel, increases hardness, and embrittles the crystalline structure. Beyond two unsuccessful excavations, the affected section of the structural element must be cut out and replaced.

Texts and standards cited

  • SN EN 1090Execution of steel structures and aluminium structures - Technical requirements for steel structures
  • CO art. 368rights of the client in case of defects in the work: rejection, price reduction, rectification, damages; any clause agreed upon in advance that limits or excludes the right to the rectification of defects is null and void if the defect relates to a construction (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026).
  • CP art. 229infringement of the rules of the art of construction: anyone who, when directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally breaches the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons shall be liable to a custodial sentence not exceeding five years or a monetary penalty; if through negligence, to a custodial sentence not exceeding three years or a monetary penalty.

In the same section