Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat demand and sizing of the heat generationChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Back-up heating: bivalence point, resistance heater hours and winter bill

After this chapter, you will be able to set the bivalence temperature of a heat pump precisely in accordance with SIA 384/2. You will master the controller settings that prevent the electric heating element from switching on unintentionally. Finally, you will be able to audit the energy meters and hour counters at the end of the first winter.

Key takeaways

  • SIA 384/2 is the basis for setting the bivalence point temperature rigorously.
  • A bivalence point set too high calls on the electric resistance heater from the first cool nights.
  • The controller must delay and lock out the electric stage above the temperature threshold defined in the design.
  • Reading the thermal kWh and the back-up hours together validates consumption after the winter.

Setting the bivalence point to SIA 384/2 and limiting the electric stage

In an air/water heat pump installation operating in mono-energetic mode, the capacity sizing is based on the heat load calculated to SIA 384/2. The thermodynamic generator covers the entire heat loss down to a pivotal outdoor temperature: the bivalence point. Below this threshold, the drop in the machine's output and the simultaneous rise in the building's demand make it necessary to add a back-up heat source, in the form of an electric resistance heater immersed in the buffer tank or integrated into the indoor hydraulic module.

Bivalence point
The precise outdoor temperature at which the useful heating capacity delivered by the heat pump falls below the overall heat demand of the building calculated to SIA 384/2.

A bivalence point set between -3 °C and -5 °C on the Swiss Plateau allows the heat pump to provide on its own 95 % to 98 % of the annual heating work. The electric back-up heating element only steps in for the few remaining cold peaks. If, on the other hand, the bivalence point drifts towards +2 °C or +3 °C because of an error in the load calculation or excessive caution when selecting the unit, the electric resistance heater takes over a huge share of the seasonal kilowatt-hours. The heating installer must then correct the programming on the heating controller to avoid this drift.

Effect of the bivalence point on annual thermodynamic coverage
Bivalence temperature selectedShare of heat supplied by the heat pumpShare of heat supplied by the resistance heaterOperating mode observed
-5 °C to -7 °C98 % to 99 %1 % to 2 %Optimal mono-energetic
-2 °C to -4 °C95 % to 97 %3 % to 5 %Accepted standard in lowland areas
0 °C to +2 °C82 % to 88 %12 % to 18 %Critical undersizing
+4 °C and aboveLess than 75 %More than 25 %Severe tariff drift

Measuring operating hours and checking the meter after the first winter

The contractor is liable for the proper performance of the work under art. 364 CO by ensuring settings consistent with the design data. The on-site check takes place during the operating visit at the end of the first winter. The check is not based on the user's impressions but on measured values: the hour counter of the back-up stage on the controller, the electricity meter dedicated to the boiler room and the heat meter installed on the hydraulic distribution.

  1. Reading the hour counters and energy metersExtract from the controller the operating hours of the compressor and the operating hours of the electric back-up. At the same time, read the electrical power sub-meter and the heat meter of the primary circuit.
  2. Calculating the back-up hours ratioDivide the operating time of the resistance heater by the total heating hours. Over a full season in lowland areas, the time the electric back-up is engaged must not exceed 2 % to 5 % of the total hours.
  3. Checking the actual seasonal coefficient of performanceDivide the total thermal energy fed into the network by the electrical energy consumed by the machine and its resistance heater. An actual seasonal value below 2.8 at low temperature reveals abnormal back-up consumption.
  4. Correcting hysteresis settings and thermal lockoutIf the back-up hour counter shows excessive hours, adjust the heating curve, extend the enabling delay of the electric stage and lock out the back-up permanently above the set bivalence temperature.

Diagnosing faulty switch-on of the electric stage

On an air-water heat pump installation in service, winter overconsumption rarely stems from an outright compressor failure. In most cases encountered on construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland, the cause lies in inadequate control settings that call on the electric back-up stage well before the physical limits of the machine are reached. When the outdoor temperature crosses the theoretical bivalence point defined during the design to SIA 384/2, the back-up resistance heater must come into play only gradually to cover the capacity shortfall, never to compensate for a flow fault or an incorrect setpoint.

To isolate the cause of abnormal use of the electric heating elements, the foreman or commissioning technician must compare the actual hydraulic parameters with the generator's output curves. A heating curve set with too steep a slope creates a flow temperature demand that the heat pump cannot meet on its own at low outdoor temperatures. The system then switches prematurely to the electric element to try to bridge the gap, destroying the installation's seasonal coefficient of performance.

Recurrent causes of unintended switch-on of the electric back-up
Symptom observedHydraulic or thermal originCorrection on the controller or the network
Back-up active in mild weather (> +3 °C)Outdoor sensor badly exposed or not calibratedRewire the sensor on the north façade and calibrate the measurement offset
Resistance heater switched on during defrostsInsufficient buffer volume or excessive draw-off flowAdjust the back-up lockout delay during the reversal cycle
High resistance heater hours in the mid-seasonHeating flow setpoint set too high (unsuitable weather-compensated curve)Lower the slope of the heating curve and open the zone valves
All stages switching on simultaneouslyPower staging delay deactivatedProgramme an offset of 20 to 30 minutes between each electric step

Annual verification protocol and recalibration against the meter

The operating review drawn up at the end of the first heating period is the only arbiter for the installer and the client. SIA 384/2 allows hot-water heating installations to be sized by setting strict calculation bases for heat losses and for the maximum permissible energy share attributable to the electric back-up. This check cannot be improvised from the building's overall electricity bill, but relies on the joint reading of the heat energy meters and the dedicated electrical sub-meters.

  1. Reading the energy meters and hour countersAt the end of April, read the index of the electrical sub-meter dedicated to the back-up, the electrical index of the compressor, the quantity of thermal megawatt-hours fed into the distribution network, and the hour counter of each resistance heater stage.
  2. Calculating the electric assistance ratioDivide the electrical energy consumed by the resistance heater by the sum of the electrical energy consumed by the heat pump and its back-up. This ratio must remain below the contractual and technical threshold set during the thermal design.
  3. Checking the back-up operating hoursCompare the cumulative hours of the electric resistance heater with the local climate data for the past season. On the French-speaking Swiss lowlands (Geneva, Vaud, Fribourg), a total exceeding 150 to 200 hours for an average winter indicates a bivalence point set too high or an ineffective software lockout.
  4. Adjusting the bivalence setpoint and limiting the back-upLower the outdoor temperature at which the back-up is enabled on the controller if the compressor still has modulation reserve at low temperature. If necessary, lock out the maximum stage of the resistance heater with the installer code to limit the instantaneous power drawn from the grid.

When the client reports abnormal overconsumption, notice of defects under art. 367 CO requires a rigorous check of the technical parameters from delivery or formal notice. By systematically recording the ratio between back-up operating hours and total output from the first heating season, the installer demonstrates that the installation is compliant or corrects the settings before the drift causes lasting financial loss.

Handling consumption drift and remedies in the event of excessive back-up use

When a winter electricity bill soars after the first heating season, the confrontation between the installer and the operator almost always centres on undersizing of the machine or a control malfunction. The analysis cannot be improvised on the basis of impressions: it requires the immediate extraction of the controller's history in order to correlate the operating hours of the electric back-up with the curve of actual outdoor temperatures and the heat load calculated to SIA 384/2.

  1. Reading the meters and operating ratiosRead the active energy index of the meter dedicated to the heat pump and that of the specific sub-meter of the electric heating element. Calculate the ratio of resistance heater hours to compressor running hours: a value above 5 % in the climate of the French-speaking Swiss Plateau indicates a hydraulic anomaly or an incorrect switch-on threshold.
  2. Software repositioning of the bivalence pointIf the back-up enabling parameter has been left at the factory value of +2 °C, recalibrate it to the design value determined by SIA 384/2, typically between -3 °C and -6 °C. Increase the back-up validation delay to at least 60 minutes to filter out defrost cycles without making unnecessary demands on the grid.
  3. Checking the flow rate and the heating curveCheck the volumetric flow rate of the primary circulator using an ultrasonic flowmeter or by measuring the delta T between flow and return. A heating curve that is too steep pushes the setpoint beyond the operating limits of the refrigerant in mild weather, forcing artificial electric back-up.

From a legal standpoint, if the overconsumption results from a proven error in the settings or a wiring fault in the outdoor sensor, the work is defective. Under art. 367 CO, the client examines the state of the work as soon as is practicable and notifies the contractor of any defects. In practice, the heating engineer corrects the settings, documents the recommissioning in a record signed by both parties and schedules a new meter check within thirty days.

Frequently asked questions

How can a high ratio of back-up hours be justified after a particularly harsh winter?

The local weather data from the reference station should be extracted and the actual heat demand recalculated to SIA 384/2. If daily temperatures stayed well below the design base temperature for an extended period, the use of the direct back-up is normal. If, however, this ratio exceeds 5 % of the total annual time without exceptional cold, the bivalence point setting or the heating curve remains the cause.

Can the back-up resistance heater be completely disabled to avoid unpleasant surprises on the bill?

Physically or digitally locking out the electric stage exposes the installation to a loss of comfort during frost peaks or during repeated defrost cycles of an air-water machine. During these cycle reversal phases, the back-up compensates for the drop in buffer tank temperature to protect the evaporator against freezing. Good practice is to lock out the back-up above the calculated bivalence point while keeping it technically available as a safety measure.

What is the normal share of energy consumed by a back-up immersion heater over a season?

In an installation designed to the recognised rules of the trade in French-speaking Switzerland, the electric back-up of a correctly sized heat pump must not cover more than 2 % to 5 % of the thermal kilowatt-hours distributed per year. Beyond this threshold measured at the meter, the installation drifts towards purely resistive operation, which destroys the overall seasonal coefficient of performance and creates a direct additional cost for the client.

What should be checked first if the resistance heater switches on when the outdoor temperature is mild?

Check the value read by the outdoor sensor on the controller display to rule out an ohmic calibration fault or spurious thermal influence from the building. Then examine the boost delay: a room setpoint raised abruptly by several degrees can trigger the back-up in advance if the deviation differential is too narrow. Finally, check that there is no latent compressor fault code that has switched the machine to emergency operation.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 384/2Heat demand for building heating and sizing of the thermal output
  • CO art. 367Inspection of the work and notice of defects by the client

In the same section